Biological Studies of Combustion Atmospheres

Abstract

There is evidence supported by statistical information from fire deaths that many fire fatalities occur as a result of incapacitation of the victims by the toxic products given off during the early stages of fires, thereby preventing escape from the fire, rather than from direct exposure to heat or other factors. As an essential part of understanding these problems, a study has been made of the mechanisms of incapacitation resulting from exposures to atmospheres of ther mal decomposition products from polymeric materials. Under conditions ap proved by the Home Office Inspector, individual cynomolgus monkeys were ex posed to atmospheres increasing in separate experiments from very low smoke concentrations until early signs of physiological effects were detected. Measure ments were made of two kinds of physiological parameters: vital signs (respira tion, electrocardiography and respiratory blood gases) and parameters indicating effects on the nervous system (electroencephalography, auditory evoked poten tials, nerve conduction velocity). The atmospheres generated were designed to study the effects of hypoxia, hypercapnia, carbon monoxide, hydrogen cyanide and thermal decomposition products from wood, polyacrylonitrile, polyurethane foam, polypropylene, polystyrene and nylon produced under pyrolytic or ox idative conditions at a range of temperatures. The main findings were that the composition and hence the toxicity of the products from individual materials could vary considerably depending upon the different conditions of temperature and degree of oxygenation under which they were decomposed. However, despite the great complexity in chemical composition of the test atmospheres, the basic toxic effects on the animals were relatively simple, and for each in dividual atmosphere the toxicity was always dominated by one of these factors; carbon monoxide, hydrogen cyanide, or irritants. The role of each of these fac tors in causing incapacitation in real fires is discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

W.D. Woolley and P.J. Fardell , "Basic Aspects of Combustion Toxicology," Conference on Smoke and Toxic Gases from Burning Plastics, London, 6-7 January 1982. QMC Industrial Research Ltd., London, p. 8/1-8/47.

Fire Safety Journal Vol. 5 ( 1982) p. 29.

W.A. Harland and R.A. Anderson , "Causes of Death in Fires," Conference on Smoke and Toxic Gases from Burning Plastics, London, 6-7 January 1982. QMC Industrial Research Ltd., London. p. 15/1-15/19.

E.P. Radford , International Symposium on Physiological and Toxicological Aspects of Combustion Products. University of Utah. (1974).

S.E. Chandler and R. Baldwin , "Furniture and Furnishings in the Home, Some Fire Statistics" Fire Mater . Vol. 1 (1976) p. 76.

U.K. Fire Statistics, London, Home Office, published annually (1979).

W.D. Woolley and P.J. Fardell , "The Prediction of Combustion Products," Fire Research Vol. 1 (1977) p. 11.

G. Kimmerle , "Aspects and Methodology for the Evaluation of Toxicological Parameters During Fire Exposure," JFF/Combustion Toxicology Vol. 1 (1974) p. 4.

W.A. Harland and W.D. Woolley , "Fire Fatality Study," University of Glasgow. Building Research Establishment Information Paper IP 18/79. (1979).

10.

J.H. Petajan , K.J. Voorhees , S.C. Packham , R.C. Baldwin , I.N. Einhorn , M.L. Grunnet , B.G. Dinger and M.M. Birky , "Extreme Toxicity from Combustion Products of a Fire-Retarded Polyurethane Foam" Science , Vol. 187 p. 742 (1975).

11.

H.J. Klimisch , "Concept and Experience with the Standardisation of Test Methods According to DIN 54 436 for Determining the Relative Acute Inhalation Toxicity of Thermal Decomposition Products," Conference on Smoke and Toxic Gases from Burning Polymers, London 6-7 January 1982. p. 9/1-9/30.

12.

D.A. Purser , P. Grimshaw and K.R. Berrill , "The Role of Hydrogen Cyanide in the Acute Toxicity of the Pyrolysis Products of Polyacrylonitrile," In Press.

13.

W.D. Woolley , S.A. Ames and P.J. Fardell , "Chemical Aspects of Combustion Toxicology of Fires," Fire Mater . Vol. 3 (1979) p. 110.

14.

W.D. Woolley , "Nitrogen-Containing Products from the Thermal Decomposition of Flexible Polyurethane Foam," Br. Polym. J. Vol. 4, p. 27.

15.

J.F. Nunn , Applied Respiratory Physiology, Butterworth , 1969. p. 156.

16.

W.D. Woolley , P.J. Fardell and I.G. Buckland , "The Thermal Decomposition Products of Rigid Polyurethane Foams under Laboratory Conditions," Fire Research Station, Fire Research Note No. 1039 .

17.

D.A. Purser and P. Grimshaw , "The Incapacitative Effects of Exposure to the Thermal Decomposition Products of Polyurethane Foams," Interflam '82 Conference, Guildford, 30 March-1 April 1982. Fire Mater. In Press.

18.

R.D. Lynch, on the Non-Existence of Synergism Between Inhaled Hydrogen Cyanide and Carbon Monoxide. Fire res. Station, Fire Res. Note 1035. Borehamwood (1975).

19.

B.R. Pitt , E.P. Radford , G.H. Gurtner and R.J. Traystman , "Interaction of Carbon Monoxide and Cyanide on the Cerebral Circulation and Metabolism," Arch. Environ. Hlth. Vol. 34 (5) (1979 ) p. 354.

20.

E.A. Higgins , V. Fiorca , A.A. Thomas and H.V. Davis , "Acute Toxicity of Brief Exposures to HF, HC1, NO2 and HCN With and Without CO," Fire Technology, Vol. 8 (1972) p. 120.

21.

R.D. Stewart , J.E. Peterson , E.D. Baretta , H.C. Dodd and A.A. Herrmann , "Experimental Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide," Arch. Environ. Hlth. Vol. 21 (1970) p. 154.

22.

R.D. Stewart , "The Effects of Carbon Monoxide on Man," JFF/Combustion Toxicology Vol. 1 (1974) p. 167.

23.

J.E. Peterson and R.D. Stewart , "Predicting the Carboxyhaemoglobin Levels Resulting from Carbon Monoxide Exposures," J. app. PhysioL Vol. 39 (1975 ) p. 633.

24.

J.B. Brierley , A.W. Brown and J. Calverley , "Cyanide Intoxication in the Rat: Physiological and Neuropathological Aspects," J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiat. Vol. 39 ( 1976) p. 129.

25.

D.G. Clark , S. Buch , J.E. Doe , H. Frith and D.H. Pullinger , "Bronchopulmonary Function: Report on the Main Working Party," Pharmac. Ther. Vol. 5 (1979) p. 149.

26.

N.I. Sax , Dangerous Properties of Industrial Materials 4th Edition, Van Norstran Reinhold Co., 1975.