Full-scale experimental study on fire suppression performance of a designed water mist system for rescue station of long railway tunnel

Abstract

Rescue stations have been newly designed in some super-long mountain railway tunnels of China such as over 30 km long, as a new type of strategic counteract design for fire accident in tunnels. Water mist fire suppression systems are needed to be installed in such rescue stations to control the train fire. However, there is no design engineering experience for it. In this article, a full-scale experimental facility was built to study the fire suppression performance of water mist system in such railway tunnel rescue station. A series of full-scale tests was preliminarily conducted considering the fire position was on top of, inside, and under the train carriage with gasoline pool fire and wood crib fire used as fire sources. A design of water mist suppression system for such a fire scenario was presented, and its performance was tested. Experimental data on temperature, CO concentration, and radiation flux were collected and analyzed. The results showed that the water mist system could control fires, cool the air temperature in the rescue station, and strongly reduce the radiant heat flux in the vicinity of the fire source under various ventilation conditions. However, the visibility of the rescue station was much deteriorated after the injection of water mist, so that emergency lights and evacuation lights are necessary for personnel evacuation. The changes of fire extinguishing time with longitudinal ventilation velocities showed that longitudinal ventilation could provide both favorable and unfavorable conditions for water mist fire extinguishment. So, to achieve efficient fire suppression performance of water mist system, attention might be paid to the controls of tunnel ventilation system in the event of a fire in a railway tunnel rescue station. The design of the water mist system and the full-scale experimental data on the fire suppression performance presented in this article may serve as a reference for such engineering applications.

Keywords

Railway tunnel rescue station water mist system fire suppression performance temperature CO concentration radiation flux

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

. Studies on thermal physics of smoke movement in tunnel fires. PhD Dissertation, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui, China, 2006.

Haack

. Current safety issues in traffic tunnels. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2002; 17: 117–127.

Vuilleumier

Weatherill

Crausaz

. Safety aspects of railway and road tunnel: example of the Lötschberg railway tunnel and Mont-Blanc road tunnel. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2002; 17: 153–158.

Kirkland

. The fire in the channel tunnel. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2002; 17: 129–132.

Mashimo

. State of the road tunnel safety technology in Japan. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2002; 17: 145–152.

Leitner

. The fire catastrophe in the Tauern Tunnel: experience and conclusions for the Austrian guidelines. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2001; 16: 217–223.

Grant

Brenton

Drysdale

. Fire suppression by water sprays. Prog Energy Combust Sci 2000; 26: 79–130.

Liu

Kim

. A review of water mist fire suppression systems—fundamental studies. J Fire Prot Eng 2000; 10: 32–50.

Mawhinney

Richardson

. A review of water mist fire suppression research and development, 1996. Fire Technol 1997; 33: 54–90.

10.

Liu

Kim

. A review of water mist fire suppression technology. Part II—application studies. J Fire Prot Eng 2001; 11: 16–42.

11.

Kim

Ryou

. An experimental and numerical study on fire suppression using a water mist in an enclosure. Build Environ 2003; 38: 1309–1316.

12.

Liu

Carpenter

Kim

. Cooling characteristics of hot oil pool by water mist during fire suppression. Fire Saf J 2008; 43: 269–281.

13.

Liu

Peng

. Experimental study on burning rates of square/rectangular gasoline and methanol pool fires under longitudinal air flow in a wind tunnel. J Hazard Mater 2009; 169: 972–979.

14.

Carvel

Beard

Jowitt

. The influence of longitudinal ventilation systems on fires in tunnels. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2001; 16: 3–21.

15.

Carvel

Beard

Jowitt

. Variation of heat release rate with forced longitudinal ventilation for vehicle fires in tunnels. Fire Saf J 2001; 36: 569–596.

16.

Chatris

Quintela

Folch

. Experimental study of burning rate in hydrocarbon pool fires. Combust Flame 2001; 126: 1373–1383.

17.

Liu

. A wind tunnel experimental study on burning rate enhancement behavior of gasoline pool fires by cross air flow. Combust Flame 2011; 158: 586–591.

18.

Fong

Yang

. Modeling fire-induced smoke spread and carbon monoxide transportation in a long channel: fire dynamics simulator comparisons with measured data. J Hazard Mater 2007; 140: 293–298.

19.

Chow

Yuan

. Tracking a ceiling jet front for hot smoke tests in tunnels. J Fire Sci 2007; 25: 99–108.

20.

Tang

Yang

. Longitudinal distributions of CO concentration and difference with temperature field in a tunnel fire smoke flow. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 2010; 53: 2844–2855.

21.

Peng

Huo

. Critical wind velocity for arresting upwind gas and smoke dispersion induced by near wall fire in a road tunnel. J Hazard Mater 2008; 150: 68–75.

22.

Huo

Chow

. Studies on buoyancy-driven back-layering in tunnel fires. Exp Therm Fluid Sci 2008; 32: 1468–1483.

23.

Huo

Yang

. Full scale experiments on studying smoke spread in a road tunnel. In: Fire safety science—Proceedings of the eighth international symposium, International Association for Fire Safety Science (IAFSS), Beijing, China, 18-23 September, 2005, pp.1437–1448.

24.

Huo

Peng

. On the maximum smoke temperature under ceiling in tunnel fires. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2006; 21: 650–655.

25.

Barkar

MZA

. Control of smoke flow in tunnel fires using longitudinal ventilation systems—a study of the critical velocity. Fire Saf J 2000; 35: 363–390.

26.

Oka

Atkinson

. Control of smoke flow in tunnel fires. Fire Saf J 1995; 25: 305–322.

27.

Vauquelin

. Influence of tunnel width on longitudinal smoke control. Fire Saf J 2006; 41: 420–426.

28.

Aralt

Nilsen

. Automatic fire detection in road traffic tunnels. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol 2009; 24: 75–83.

29.

Han

Lee

. Flame and smoke detection method for early real-time detection of a tunnel fire. Fire Saf J 2009; 44: 951–961.

30.

Lemaire

Kenyon

. Large scale fire tests in the second benelux tunnel. Fire Technol 2006; 42: 329–350.

31.

Carsten

. Full scale tunnel fire tests of VID fire-kill low pressure water mist tunnel fire protection system in Runehamar test tunnel. In: Fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17-19th March, 2010, pp.585–589.

32.

Mawhinney

Ingason

. Approval testing of a HI-FOG water mist system for protection of highway transport tunnels for heavy goods vehicles. Report No. HAI-5022-010-2, 2006. Hughes Associates Inc., Maryland, USA.

33.

Stefan

. Road tunnel protection by water mist systems—implementation of full scale fire test results into a real project. In: World tunnel congress 2008—underground facilities for better environment and safety, Central Board of Irrigation & Power, India, 22-24 September, 2008, pp.1942–1948.

34.

Guigas

Wetzig

Bouteloup

. Dynamic fire spreading and water mist tests for the A86 East Tunnel. In: Proceedings of the 5th international conference on tunnel fires, London, 25-27 October, 2004, pp.261–270.

35.

Markku

. Tunnel fire protection water mist concept for road and railway tunnels, http://www.sfs.au.com/library/Tunnel_fire_protection-Water_mist_concept.pdf , (accessed June, 2011).

36.

Starke

. Fire suppression in road tunnel fires by a water mist system—results of the SOLIT project. In: Fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden, Germany, 17-19 March, 2010, pp.311–321.

37.

Ingason

. Model scale tunnel tests with water spray. Fire Saf J 2008; 43: 512–528.

38.

Yuan

Lazzara

. The effects of ventilation and preborn time on water mist extinguishing of diesel fuel pool fires. J Fire Sci 2004; 22: 379–404.

39.

Hart

Ren

Edwards

. Numerical simulation of water mist suppression of tunnel-fire scenarios. In: Third international conference on CFD in the mineral and process industries, CSIRO, Melbourne, Australia, 10-12 December, 2003, pp.35–40.

40.

Nmira

Consalvi

Kaiss

. A numerical study of water mist mitigation of tunnel fires. Fire Saf J 2009; 44: 198–211.

41.

Huo

Wang

. Experimental and numerical studies on longitudinal smoke temperature distribution upstream and downstream from the fire in a road tunnel. J Fire Sci 2007; 25: 23–43.

42.

Yang

Liu

. Study on the relationship between the exposed area of wood crib and its heat release rate. Fire Sci Technol 2010; 29: 13–15.

43.

Wang

Liao

Yao

. Preliminary study on the interaction of water mist with pool fires. J Fire Sci 2001; 19: 45–61.

44.

Prasad

Kailasanath

. Simulation of water mist suppression of small scale methanol liquid pool fires. Fire Saf J 1999; 33: 185–212.