Quantification of Zinc Hydroxystannate** and Stannate** Synergies in Halogen-containing Flame-retardant Polymeric Formulations

Abstract

Zinc stannate and hydroxystannate are used as synergists in fire-retardant systems in conjunction with halogenated species where their behavior is generally considered to be similar to antimony-containing synergists while offering the additional properties of smoke suppression and relative nontoxicity. The literature most often compares relative synergistic behaviors qualitatively but this article determines such behavior quantitatively using Lewin’s synergistic effectiveness parameter, E_S, calculated from sample limiting oxygen index (LOI) data. Flame-retardant formulations comprising zinc stannate (ZS), zinc hydroxystannate (ZHS), or antimony III oxide (ATO) in combination with selected and polymer-compatible bromine-containing flame retardants were formulated in commercial grades of poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC)), thermoset polyester resin, and polyamide 6. PVC formulations simulated both commercial cable and plastisol applications and comprised either a phthalate or aryl phosphate ester as plasticizer in combination with selected synergists. All formulations were subjected to flammability testing using LOI, UL94 (vertical sample mode), and cone calorimetric (including smoke analysis) methods. For all PVC/synergist combinations containing the phthalate plasticizer, synergy was evident with 2.0 > ES > 1.0 and a relative effectiveness order ATO > ZHS > ZS. Zinc borate present as a cosynergist also has a quantifiable, positive effect. In the presence of the phosphate ester plasticizer, the reverse order is observed with marginal levels of synergy being evident (1.2 > ES > 1.0). In polyester resin formulations, ATO and ZHS exhibit similar levels of synergy when present with dibromoneopentyl diglycol with the former being superior when decabromodiphenyl ether is the flame retardant. However, in all polyamide 6 formulations, the highest levels of synergistic effectiveness are observed (ES ≥ 5.0) with ZS. Maximum values of ES correspond to a molar ratio of Sn/Br<0.3 suggesting the formation of SnBr2 and SnBr4 as the effective flame-retarding species.

Keywords

zinc stannate zinc hydroxystannate Flamtard S Flamtard H zinc borate antimony III oxide poly(vinyl chloride)polyester polyamide 6 bromine flame retardant synergy synergistic effectivity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chaplin, D. and Brown, S.C. ( 1990). Flamtard - A New Range of Flame and Smoke Retardants , In: Flame Retardants’ 90, Interscience Communications, London, pp. 114-125.

Cusack, P.A. ( 1991). Tin Chemicals as Flame Retardants, In: Lewin, M. and Kirshenbaum, G. (eds), Recent Advances in Flame Retardancy of Polymeric Materials, Vol. 2, pp. 75-82, Business Communications Inc, Norwalk, CT, USA.

Cusack, P.A. and Hornsby, P. (1999). Zinc Stannate-coated Filler: Novel Flame Retardant Materials and Smoke Suppressants for Polymeric Materials, J. Vinyl Additive Technol., 5(1): 21-30.

Cusack, P.A. and Cross, M. (2002). Environmentally-friendly Tin Based Fire Retardants, In: Flame Retardants 2002, pp. 83-88, Interscience Communications, London.

Horrocks, A.R. , Smart, G. , Price, D. and Kandola, B. (2009). Zinc Stannates as Alternative Synergists in Selected Flame Retardant Systems, J. Fire Sci. (in press).

Troitzsch, J. ( 2003). Plastics Flammability Handbook, 3rd edn, pp. 532- 535, Carl Hanser Verlag, Munich, Germany.

Astm 2863-00. Standard Test Method for Measuring the Minimum Oxygen Concentration to Support Candle-like Combustion of Plastics (Oxygen Index).

Lewin, M. and Weil, E.D. ( 2001). Mechanisms and Modes of Action in Flame Retardancy of Polymers, In: Horrocks, A.R. and Price, D. (eds), Fire Retardant Materials, p. 39, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge .

Nazaré, S. , Kandola, B. and Horrocks, A.R. (2008). Smoke, CO and CO2 Measurements and Evaluation Using Different Fire Testing Techniques for Flame Retardant Unsaturated Polyester Resin Formulations, J. Fire Sci., 26: 215-242.

10.

Hirschler, M.M. (1993). An Attachment for Use with the NBS Smoke Density Chamber for Measurement of Smoke Obscuration at Different Orientations, Fire Mater., 17: 173-183.

11.

Scudamore, M.J. , Briggs, P.J. and Prager, F.H. (1991). Cone Calorimetry - A Review of Tests Carried Out on Plastics for the Association of Plastic Manufacturers in Europe, Fire Mater., 15(2): 65-84.

12.

Horrocks, A.R. , Tunc, M. and Price, D. (1987). The Burning Behaviour of Textiles and its Assessment by Oxygen-index Methods, Textile Prog., 18(1-3): 1-205.

13.

Chaplin, D. ( 1994). Fire Retardant Compositions, US Patent 5,338,791.

14.

Shen, K.K. ( 2006). Overview of Flame Retardancy and Smoke Suppression of Flexible PVC, In: Proceedings SPE Vinyltech Conference , Atlanta, 18 October.

15.

Pitts, J.J. ( 1973). Inorganic Fire Retardants and their Mode of Action, In: Kuryla, W.C. and Papa, A.J. (eds), Flame Retardancy of Polymeric Materials, Vol. 1, Chap. 2, p. 181, Marcel Dekker, New York.

16.

17.

Petsom, A. , Roengsumran, S. , Ariyaphattanakul, A. and Sangvanich, P. ( 2003). An Oxygen Index Evaluation of Flammability for Zinc Hydroxystannate and Zinc Stannate as Synergistic Flame Retardants for ABS Copolymer, Polym . Degrad. Stab., 80: 17-23.

18.

Jung, H.C. , Kim, W.N. , Lee, C.R. , Suh, K.S. and Kim, S.R. ( 1998). Properties of Flame-retarding Blends of Polycarbonate and Poly(Acrylonitrile-Butadiene-Styrene), J. Polym. Eng. , 18(1/2): 115-130.

19.

Levchik, S.V. and Weil, E.D. (2000). Combustion and Fire Retardancy of Aliphatic Nylons, Polym. Int., 49(10): 1033-1076.

20.

Weil, E.D. ( 1973). Additivity, Synergism and Antagonism in Flame Retardancy , In: Kuryla, W.C. and Papa, A.J. (eds), Flame Retardancy of Polymeric Materials, Vol. 3, pp. 185-243, Marcel Dekker, New York.

21.

Hastie, J.R. (1973). Molecular Basis of Flame Inhibition, J. Res. Nat. Bur. Standards, 77A(6): 733.

22.

Kicko-Walczak, E. (2004). Studies on the Mechanisms of Thermal Decomposition of Unsaturated Polyester Resins with Reduced Flammability, Polym. Polym. Comp., 12: 127-134.