Job Satisfaction Among Early Labor Force Participants: Unexpected Outcomes in Public and Private Sector Comparisons

Abstract

This study presents a systematic investigation of the level of job satisfaction among a national cross-section of early labor force participants in the public and private employment sectors in the late 1980s. While the conventional wisdom would suggest that there is a "crisis" in the level of job satisfaction among public sector employees—due to extensive "bureaucrat bashing" and the alienative internal dynamics of working within overly rigid and rule-bound organizations—the findings presented here suggest that public sector employees manifest sig nificantly higher levels of job satisfaction than their private sector counterparts. After control ling for a variety of background, personal, and situational factors, the higher level of public sector job satisfaction remains. The empirical evidence utilized in this study is from the National Longitudinal Survey's Youth Cohort.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aldrich, J. and F. Nelson. (1984). Linear Probability, Logit, and Probit Models Beverly Hills, Calif.: Sage Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences.

Andrisani, P. (1978). "Job Satisfaction Among Working Women." Signs 3(Spring): 588-607

. Barton, A. (1980). "A Diagnosis of Bureaucratic Maladies," in Carol Weiss and Allen Barton eds. Making Bureaucracies Work Beverly Hills and London: Sage Publications.

Benms, W. and P. Slater. (1964). "Democracy is Inevitable." Harvard Business Review (March-Apnl) : 51-59

. Blackburn, J.W. and W. Bruce. (1989). "Rethinking Concepts of Job Satisfaction: The Case of Nebraska Municipal Clerks." Review of Public Personnel Administration 10(Fall): 11-28

. Bose, C. (1985). Jobs and Gender A Study of Occupational Prestige New York: Praeger.

Buchanan, B. (1974). "Government Managers, Business Executives, and Organizational Commitment." Public Administration Review 34(July-August): 339-347

. Cascio, W. (1982). Costing Human Resources The Financial Impact of Behavior Organizations New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.

Converse, P. , J. Dotson , W. Hoag and W. McGee III. (1980). American Social Attitudes Data Sourcebook, 1947-1978 Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

10.

Cummings, T.E. and E.S. Molloy. (1977). Improving Productivity and The Quality of Worklife New York: Praeger Publishers.

11.

Daley, D. (1988). "Performance Appraisal in a Public Agency: Multiple Measurements Supporting Common Conclusions." Review of Public Personnel Administration 9(Fall): 17-27.

12.

Davis, L. (1971). "Job Satisfaction Research: The Post-Industrial View." Industrial Relations 10: 179-193

13.

. Denhardt, R. (1981). In the Shadow of Organizations Lawrence, Kansas: Regents Press of Kansas.

14.

Farazmand, A. (1989). "Crisis in the U.S. Administrative State." Administrator and Society 21(August): 173-199

15.

. Fox, S. ( 1989). "Intergenerational Differences, Merit Pay and Loyalty." Review of Public Personnel Administration 9(Spring): 15-27

16.

. Freeman, R.B. (1978). "Job Satisfaction as an Economic Variable." American Economic Review 68(May): 135-141

17.

. Goodsell, C. (1985). The Case for Bureaucracy Chatham, New Jersey: Chatham House Publishers, Inc.

18.

Gortner, H. , J. Mahler and J.B. Nicholson. (1987). Organizational Theory: A Public Perspective Chicago, Ill.: The Dorsey Press.

19.

Greiner, J. , H. Hatry , M. Koss , A. Millar , and J. Woodward. (1981) Productivity and Motivation A Review of State and Local Government Initiatives Washington, D.C .: The Urban Institute Press.

20.

Hackman, J.R. and G. Oldham. (1975). "Development of the Job Diagnostic Survey." Journal of Applied Psychology 60(April): 159-170

21.

. Hamilton, R. and J. Wright. (1986). The State of the Masses New York: Aldme Publishing Co.

22.

Hammer, E. and D.V. Tassell. (1983). "On Public vs. Private Sector Motivation: Have the Stereotypes Been Debunked?" Public Personnel Management 12(Fall): 282-289

23.

. Hanushek, E. and J. Jackson. (1977). Statistical Methods for Social Scientists New York: Academic Press.

24.

Hays, S.W. and N.P. Lovrich. (1989). "ROPPA Call for Manuscripts." Review of Public Personnel Administration 9(Summer): 88

25.

. Heffron, L. (1989). Organization Theory and Public Organizations Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.

26.

Herzberg, F. (1966). Work and the Nature of Man Cleveland: World Publishing Company.

27.

Hummel, R. (1977). The Bureaucratic Experience New York: St. Martin's Press.

28.

Inglehart, R. (1990). Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.

29.

Janka, K. (1977). People, Performance Results Washington, D.C.: National Trammg and Development Service Press.

30.

Kalleberg, A. (1977). "Work Values and Job Rewards: A Theory of Job Satisfaction." American Sociological Review 42(February): 124-143

31.

. Kaplan, R. and C. Tausky. (1987). "Humanism in Organizations: A Cntical Appraisal," In Dean Yarwood, ed. Public Administration New York: Longman.

32.

Katzell, R. and D. Yankelovich. (1975a). Work, Productivity, and Job Satisfaction An Evaluation of Policy-Related Research New York: The Psychological Corporation.

33.

_. ( 1975b). "Improving Productivity and Job Satisfaction Organizational Dynamics 4(Summer): 69-80

34.

. Klembaum, D. and L. Kupper. (1978). Applied Regression Analysis and Other Multivariate Methods Massachusetts: Duxbury Press.

35.

Koehn, H.E. (1983). "The Postindustrial Worker." Public Personnel Management 12(Fall): 244-248

36.

. Larson, J.S. (1989). "Employee Participation in Federal Management." Public Personnel Management 18(Winter): 404-414

37.

. Lovrich, N.P. (1987). "Ment Pay and Motivation in the Public Workforce: Beyond Technique to More Basic Considerations." Review of Public Personnel Administration 7(Spring): 54-71

38.

. McGregor, D. (1960). The Human Side of Enterprise New York: McGraw Hill

39.

Morse, N. and R. Weiss. (1955). "The Functioning and Meaning of Work and the Job." American Sociological Review 20: 191-198

40.

. Niskanen, W. (1975). "Bureaucrats and Politicians." Journal of Law and Economics 18(December): 617-643.

41.

Ostrom, V. (1974). The Intellectual Crisis in American Public Administration University, Alabama: The University of Alabama Press.

42.

Park, C. , N.P. Lovrich and B.S. Steel. (1989). "Postmaterialist Values in the Postindustrial Workplace: A Test of Inglehart's Theory of Value Change in the Context of U.S./Korean Comparisons." Public Administration Quarterly 13(Summer): 273-292

43.

. Ramey, H. (1979a). "Perceptions of Incentives in Business and Government: Implications for Civil Service Reform." Public Administration Review 36(September-October): 440-448

44.

. . ( 1979b). "Reward Expectations, Role Perceptions, and Job Satisfaction Among Government and Business Managers: Indications of Commonalities and Differences." Academy of Management Proceedings 357-61

45.

. Srivastva, S. , P. Salipante , T. Cummings , W. Notz , J. Bigelow and J. Waters. (1975). Job Satisfaction and Productivity An Evaluation of Policy Related Research on Productivity, Industrial Organization and Job Satisfaction Cleveland, Ohio: Case Western Reserve University.

46.

Steel, B.S. and N.P. Lovrich. (1987). "Comparable Worth: The Problematic Politicization of a Public Personnel Issue." Public Personnel Management 16(Spring): 23-36

47.

. Thayer, F. (1981). An End to Hierarchy and Competition: Administration in the Post Affluent World, 2nd edition. New York: Franklin Watts.

48.

Troy, L. (1988). "Public Sector Unionism: The Rising Power Center of Organized Labor." Government Union Review 9(Summer): 1-35

49.

. Waldo, D. (1980). The Enterprise of Public Administration Novato, California: Chandler and Sharp Publishers.

50.

Weiss, C. (1980). "Efforts at Bureaucratic Reform: What Have We Learned?" in Carol Weiss and Allen Barton eds. Making Bureaucracies Work Beverly Hills and London: Sage Publications.

51.

Zupan, L.L. (1986). "Gender-Related Differences in Correction Officer's Attitudes and Perceptions." Journal of Criminal Justice 14(Spring): 349-361.