The Toxicity Equivalency Factor Scheme Applied To Municipal Incinerator Pcdd/Pcdf Emissions When Specific Congener Information Is Lacking

Abstract

The 2,3,7,8-TCDD Toxicity EQuivalents (TEQ) approach provides a useful method for estimating the environmental risk of polychlorodibenzodioxin and polychlorodibenzofuran complex mixtures, thus making it possible to express their toxicological significance with only one number. Generally the conversion of the concentration units into those of TEQ requires an isomer-specific analysis and the appropriate Toxicity Equivalency Factors (TEF). In this paper we propose a "theoretical" model for estimating TEQ values of PCDD + PCDF mixtures which, starting from the experimental value of the PCDD + PCDF concentration (μg Nm^-3) and the theoretical value of PCDD and PCDF fingerprints in the emissions from municipal incinerators, to make an estimate of the global toxicity in terms of ng TEQ Nm^-3. The TEQ values estimated for a number of samples are in good agreement with those calculated from the isomer and congener experimental data. Given the investment and running costs plus the time and the analytical complexity in determining the congeners and single isomer concentrations, it seems that the proposed "theoretical" model is a reasonable tool for estimating the exposure hazard related to a complex mixture of PCDD/PCDFs emitted from municipal solid waste (MSW) incinerators. Another objective of this paper is to explore the consistency between scientific knowledge and the authority regulatory guidelines. This work shows that the Italian national emission standard (4 μg Nm^-3) for the total PCDD + PCDF concentration is higher than the international target of 0.1 ng TEQ Nm^-3. We suggest a value of 1 μg Nm^-3 for TCDD + TCDF concentration if Italian regulators want to add a further constraint.

Keywords

Polychlorodibenzodioxins (PCDDs)polychlorodibenzofurans (PCDFs)municipal solid waste (MSW)incinerators toxicity equivalency factors (TEF)toxicity equivalents (TEQ)health risks.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chiu et al. 1987; Brenner et al. 1985; Sussman & Hahn pers. comm.; AA.VV. 1986; Gizzi et al. 1982; De Frè' 1986; Ozvacic et al. 1984; Oehme et al. 1986. Labels (a)-(p) indicate different runs in the references and link Tables 6 and 7 with fig. 2.

Aa. Vv. (1986) Background information with respect to dioxin issues associated with incineration of municipal solid waste. WHO Working Group on Risk to Health of Dioxins, Napoli, Italy.

Ahlborg, U.G. (1989) Nordic risk assessment of PCDDs and PCDFs. Chemosphere 19, 603-608.

Bagnati, R. , Benfenati, E. , Mariani, G. , Fanelli, R. , Chiesa, G. , Moro, G. & Pitea, D. (1990) The combustion of municipal solid waste and PCDDs and PCDFs emissions. On the real scale thermal behavior of PCDD and PCDF in flue gas and fly ash. Chemosphere 20, 1907-1914.

Batt, S.C. & Peterson, P.J. (1988) Risk assessment techniques for carcinogenic compounds. In Risk Assessment of Chemicals in the Environment ( M. L. Richardson , ed.). London, U.K.: The Royal Society of Chemistry, p. 153.

Bergström, J.G.T. & Warman, K. (1987) Production and characterization of trace organic emissions in Sweden. Waste Management & Research 5, 395-401.

Brenner, K.S. , Dorn, I.H. & Herrmann, K. (1986) Dioxin analysis in stack emissions, slags and the wash water circuit during high-temperature incineration of chlorine-containing industrial waste. Chemosphere 15, 1193-1199.

California Air Resources Board (1986) Public hearing to consider adoption of a regulator amendment identifying chlorinated dioxins and dibenzofurans as a toxic air contaminant. Staff Report, June. California, U.S.A.

Ccms-Nato (1988a) International toxicity equivalency factor (I- TEF) method of risk assessment for complex mixtures of dioxins and related compounds. Pilot study on international exchange on dioxins and related compounds. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), Committee on the Challenges of Modern Society (CCMS) . Report Number 176.

10.

Ccms-Nato (1988b) Scientific basis for the international toxicity equivalency factor (I-TEF) method of risk assessment for complex mixtures of dioxins and related compounds. Pilot study on international exchange on dioxins and related compounds. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), Committee on the Challenges of Modern Society (CCMS). Report Number 178.

11.

Clementi, S. , Cruciani, G. & Curti, G. (1986) Some applications of partial least-squares method . Analytica Chimica Acta 191, 149-160.

12.

Chiu, C. , Halman, R. , Lanoy, M. & Lao, R.C. (1987) Refined analytical procedures to detect and measure PCDD/PCDF, PAH, PCB, CB, and CP in environmental samples. Chemosphere 16, 1619-1624.

13.

Cruciani, G. , Clementi, S. , Lasagni, M. , Todeschini, R. & Pitea, D. (1990) Response surface models for the post-combustor efficiency in a pilot plant of MSW. In 10th International Meeting Dioxin'90, Short papers (O. Hutzinger & H. Fiedler, eds), vol. 3, 49. Bayreuth, Germany: Ecoinforma Press.

14.

De Frè (1986) Dioxin levels in the emissions of Belgian municipal incinerators. Chemosphere 15, 1255-1260.

15.

Eadon, G. , Kaminsky, L. , Silkworth, J. , Aldous, K. , Hilker, D. , O'Keefe, P. , Smith, R. , Gierthy, J. , Hawley, J. , Kim, N. & Decaprio, A. (1986) Calculation of 2,3,7,8-TCDD equivalent concentrations of complex environmental contaminant mixtures. Environmental Health and Perspective 70, 221-227.

16.

Gizzi, F. , Reginato, R. , Benfenati, E. & Fanelli, R. (1982) Polychloro dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDD) and polychlorodibenzofurans (PCDF) in emissions from an urban incinerator. 1. Average and peaks. Chemosphere 11, 577-583.

17.

Goldstein, J.A. & Safe, S. (1989) Mechanism of action and structure activity relationships for the chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and related compounds. In Halogenated Byphenyls, Terphenyls, Naphthalenes, Dibenzodioxins and related product ( R. D. Kimbrough & A. A. Jensen eds) Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier Science Publishers.

18.

Grant, D.L. (1977) Proceedings on the 12th annual workshop on pesticide residue analysis, p. 251. Winnipeg, Canada.

19.

Hagenmaier, H. , Brunner, H. , Haag, R. , Kraft, M. & Lützke, K. (1987) Problems associated with the measurement of PCDD and PCDF emissions from waste incineration plants. Waste Management & Research 5, 239-250.

20.

Kutz, F.W. , Barnes, D.G. , Bottimore, D.P. , Greim, H. & Bretthauer, E.W. (1990a) The international toxicity equivalency factor (I-TEF) method of risk assessment for complex mixtures of dioxins and related compounds. Chemosphere 20, 751-757.

21.

Kutz, F.W. , Barnes, D.G. , Bottimore, D.P. & Bretthauer, E.W. (1990b) The toxicity equivalency factor (TEF) method: decision criteria for determining applicability. In 10th International Meeting Dioxin'90, Short Papers (O. Hutzinger & H. Fiedler, eds), vol. 1, p. 325. Bayreuth, Germany: Ecoinforma Press.

22.

Lasagni, M. , Rovida, C. , Di Cosmo, O. & Pitea, D. (1990) Kinetic aspects from the laboratory simulation of the formation and destruction of PCDD/PCDF in fly ash from municipal waste incinerators. In 10th International Meeting Dioxin'90 , Short Papers (O. Hutzinger & H. Fiedler, eds), vol. 3, p. 115. Bayreuth , Germany: Ecoinforma Press.

23.

Lipsky, D. (1989) Assessment of potential health hazards associated with PCDD and PCDF emissions from a municipal waste combustor. In The Risk Assessment of Environmental Hazards ( D. J. Paustenbach , ed.). New York, U.S.A.: J. Wiley & Sons, p. 631.

24.

McKone, T.E. & Kastenberg, W.E. (1986) Application of multimedia pollutant transport models to risk analysis. In Pollutants in a Multimedia Environment ( Y. Cohen , ed.). New York, U.S.A.: Plenum Press, p. 167.

25.

Ministero dell'Ambiente (1990) Linee guida per il contenimento delle emissioni inquinanti dagli impianti industriali e per la fissazione dei valori minimi di emissione (Italian Ministry of the Environment guidelines for the control of the toxic emissions from industrial plants and for the minimum emission values permitted), D.M. 12 luglio 1990, Supplemento Ordinario alla Gazzetta Ufficiale della Repubblica Italiana n. 176 del 30 luglio 1990.

26.

Mukerjee, D. & Cleverly, D.H. (1987) Risk from exposure to polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans emitted from municipal incinerators. Waste Management & Research 5, 269-283.

27.

Oehme, M. , Mano, S. & Mikalsen, A. (1986) Formation and presence of polyhalogenated and polycyclic compounds in the emissions of waste incinerators. Norwegian Institute for Air Research, Report NILU TR 5/86, N-8327.

28.

Ontario Ministry of the Environment (1982) Chlorinated Dioxins and Chlorinated Dibenzofurans. Ambient Air Guidelines . Health Studies Service, Ministry of Labor, 16 December. Ontario: Canada.

29.

Ozvacic, V. , Wong, G. , Tosine, H. , Clement, R. , Osborne, J. & Thorndyke, S. (1984) Determination of chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins, chlorinated dibenzofurans, chlorinated byphenyls and chlorophenols in air emissions and other process streams at Swaru in Hamilton. In Ontario Ministry of Environment, Report No. ARB-02-ETRD. Ontario, Canada.

30.

Pallesen, L. (1987) Statistical assessment of PCDD and PCDF emission data. Waste Management & Research 5, 367-379.

31.

Pitea, D. , Bonati, L. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. & Chiesa, G. (1989a) The combustion of municipal solid wastes and PCDD and PCDF emissions. Part. 1 PCDD and PCDF in MSW. Chemosphere 18, 1457-1464.

32.

Pitea, D. , Lasagni, M. , Bonati, L. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. & Chiesa, G. (1989b) The combustion of municipal solid wastes and PCDD and PCDF emissions. Part 2. PCDD and PCDF in stack gases. Chemosphere 18, 1465-1474.

33.

Pitea, D. , Cosentino, U. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. & Chiesa, G. (1989c) The combustion of municipal solid wastes and PCDD and PCDF emissions. Part 3. PCDD and PCDF in fly ash, Chemosphere , 18, 1475-1483.

34.

Pitea, D. , Todeschini, R. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Bonati, L. & Chiesa, G. (1989d) The combustion of municipal solid waste: PCDD and PCDF in MSW and in emissions. A chemometric approach. Chemosphere 19, 751-757.

35.

Pitea, D. , Di Prima, M. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. , Comolli, P. & Chiesa, G. (1989e) PCDD and PCDF in emissions from the combustion of MSW in a pilot plant. Chemosphere 19, 417-422.

36.

Pitea, D. , Bonati, L. , Cosentino, U. , Lasagni, M. & Moro, G. (1989f) A selected bibliography on PCDD and PCDF formation . Toxicological and Environmental Chemistry 22, 239-261.

37.

Pitea, D. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. , Clementi, S. , Cruciani, G. & Chiesa, G. (1990) Response surface models for the formation of PCDD and PCDF in a pilot plant combustion of MSW. Chemosphere 20, 1973-1979.

38.

Pitea, D. , Lasagni, M. , Moro, G. , Todeschini, R. , Cruciani, G. , Clementi, S. & Chiesa, G. (1991) PCDD and PCDF from the combustion of MSW in a pilot plant. In Ecological Physical Chemistry. Proceedings of an International Workshop, 8-12 November 1990, Siena, Italy (C. Rossi & E. Tiezzi, eds). Amsterdam, The Netherlands, Elsevier Science Publishers, p. 419.

39.

Regione Lombardia (1986) Linee guida per i requisiti tecnici ed i limiti di emissioni dagli impianti di incenerimento di rifiuti solidi urbani ed assimilabili (Technical requirements and emission standard guidelines for municipal solid waste incinerator plants). In Smaltimento dei rifiuti, Supplemento a Ecologia Ambiente ( Regione Lombardia , ed.). Milan , Italy, p. 194.

40.

Safe, S.H. (1986) Comparative toxicology and mechanism of action of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans. Annual Review of Pharmacology and Toxicology 26, 371-399.

41.

Swiss Federal Office for Environmental Protection (Bundesamt Für Umweltschutz, Bern) (1982) Environmental pollution due to dioxins and furans from chemical rubbish incineration plant . Schriften reihe Umweltschutz, No. 5. Switzerland, Bern.

42.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) ( 1987) Interim Procedures for Estimating Risks Associated with Exposures to Mixtures of Chlorinated Dibenzo-p-dioxins and -Dibenzofurans (CDDs and CDFs). EPA/625/3-87/012. Washington, DC, U.S.A.: USEPA.

43.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) ( 1989) Interim Procedures for Estimating Risks Associated with Exposures to Mixtures of Chlorinated Dibenzo-p-dioxins and -Dibenzofurans (CDDs and CDFs) and 1989 Update. EPA/625/3-89/016. Washington, DC: USEPA.

44.

Wold, S. (1978) Cross-validatory estimation of the number of components in factor and principal component model. Technometrics 20, 397-405.

45.

Wold, S. , Albano, C. , Dunn III, W.J. , Edlung, U. , Esbensen, K. , Geladi, P. , Helberg, S. , Johanson, E. , Lindberg, W. & Sjöstrom, M. (1984) Multivariate data analysis in chemistry. In Chemometrics ( B. R. Kowalski , ed.). Dordrecht, Germany: Reidel, p. 17.

46.

Wold, S. , Sjöström, M. , Carlson, R. , Lundstedt, T. , Hellberg, S. , Skagerberg, B. , Wikström, C. & Ohman, J. (1986) Multivariate design. Analytica Chimica Acta 191, 17-32.