Long-Term Planning for Solid Waste Management

Abstract

The continuing provision of an efficient, reliable and cost-effective service for solid waste management requires the preparation of a sound long-range plan. It is suggested here that such a plan is one which has been chosen by local politicians from a short list of alternative plans, each of which has been evaluated in depth. An examination of the few plans currently available in the U.K. suggests that this ideal is far from being achieved.

This article critically examines each of the steps involved in producing a sound plan. Some of the political issues which underpin the planning process are addressed, while existing computer models to assist the evaluation of plans are examined and found wanting. A new approach is introduced, in which the waste manager himself (or herself) uses the computer "interactively", interjecting his skill and judgement as required, with the aim of shortlisting for further study several interestingly different plans, each having a similar cost.

Keywords

Planning municipal solid waste management industrial and commercial waste modelling economic analysis uncertainty sensitivity analysis interactive model decision support system U.K.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bonczek, R.H. , Holsapple, C.W. & Whinston, A.B. (1984), Developments in decision support systems. In Advances in Computers, Vol. 23 ( M. C. Yovits , Ed.), pp. 141-175. Academic Press, Orlando.

Chapman, R.E. & Berman, E.B. (1983), The Resource Recovery Planning Model: A New Tool for Solid Waste Management, National Bureau of Standards Special Publications 657. National Bureau of Standards, U.S. GPO, Washington D.C.

U.K. Department of the Environment (1976), Guideline for the Preparation of a Waste Disposal Plan, Waste Management Paper No. 3. HMSO, London.

Foster, B.A. , Shovlar, P.A. & Fitzpatrick, A.J. (1984), Waste Management Planning—An Application of Decision Support Techniques, Report No. CSS 156. Computer Systems & Sciences Division, Harwell Laboratory, Oxon OX11 ORA, U.K.

Lords Hansard (1984), Control of Pollution Act 1974: Authorities' waste disposal plans. Lords Hansard, 1244, 966, 15 March 1984. HMSO, London.

Pearce, F. (1984), Broken promises at the Department of the Environment , New Scientist, 101, 16.

Rushbrook, P.E. (1984a), Estimating Waste Management Costs for Pre-Design and Preliminary Design Purposes, Harwell report No. AERE-R11406. HMSO, London.

Rushbrook, P.E. (1984b), The Technological Economics of the Collection and Disposal to Landfill of Municipal Refuse in the United Kingdom. PhD Thesis, Stirling University, U.K.

Wilson, D.C. (1977a), Strategy evaluation in the planning of waste management to land—a critical review of the literature, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 1, 205-217.

10.

Wilson, D.C. (1977b), Modelling as an Aid to Solid Waste Management Planning—a State of the Art Report, Harwell report AERE-R 8769. HMSO, London.

11.

Wilson, D.C. (1978), The economics of resource recovery from solid waste, Engineering and Process Economics, 3, 35-39.

12.

Wilson, D.C. (1979a), The uncertain costs of waste disposal and resource recovery, Resource Recovery and Conservation, 4, 261-299.

13.

Wilson, D.C. (1979b), The efficiency of resource recovery from solid waste, Resource Recovery and Conservation, 4, 161-188.

14.

Wilson, D.C. (1981), Waste Management—Planning, Evaluation, Technology . Oxford University Press, Oxford , U.K.

15.

Wilson, D.C. (1982a), The definition of special wastes, Chemistry and Industry (London), 17 April 1982, 253-259.

16.

Wilson, D.C. (1982b), Management of hazardous waste, Chemistry in Britain, 18, 720-729.