This mini-review article summarizes the available technologies for the recycling of heavy metals (HMs) in municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash (FA). Recovery technologies included thermal separation (TS), chemical extraction (CE), bioleaching, and electrochemical processes. The reaction conditions of various methods, the efficiency of recovering HMs from MSWI FA and the difficulties and solutions in the process of technical development were studied. Evaluation of each process has also been done to determine the best HM recycling method and future challenges. Results showed that while bioleaching had minimal environmental impact, the process was time-consuming. TS and CE were the most mature technologies, but the former process was not cost-effective. Overall, it has the greatest economic potential to recover metals by CE with scrubber liquid produced by a wet air pollution control system. An electrochemical process or solvent extraction could then be applied to recover HMs from the enriched leachate. Ongoing development of TS and bioleaching technologies could reduce the treatment cost or time.
AlorroRDHiroyoshiNItoM, et al (2009) Recovery of heavy metals from MSW molten fly ash by CIP method. Hydrometallurgy97: 8–14.
2.
ArenaU (2012) Process and technological aspects of municipal solid waste gasification: A review. Waste Management32: 625–639.
3.
BartonRGClarkWDSeekerWR (1990) Fate of metals in waste combustion systems. Combustion Science and Technology74: 327–342.
4.
BoeschMEVadenboCSanerD, et al (2014) An LCA model for waste incineration enhanced with new technologies for metal recovery and application to the case of Switzerland. Waste Management34: 378–89.
5.
BoseckerK (1997) Bioleaching: Metal solubilization by microorganisms. FEMS Microbiology Reviews20: 591–604.
6.
BosshardPPBachofenRBrandlH (1996) Metal leaching of fly ash from municipal waste incineration byAspergillus niger. Environmental Science & Technology30: 3066–3070.
7.
BrandlHFaramarziMA (2006) Microbe–metal-interactions for the biotechnological treatment of metal-containing solid waste. China Particuology4: 93–97.
8.
BredbergKKarlssonHTHolstO (2004) Reduction of vanadium(V) with Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans and Acidithiobacillus thiooxidans. Bioresource Technology92: 93–96.
9.
BrombacherCBachofenRBrandlH (1997) Biohydrometallurgical processing of solids: A patent review. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology48: 577–587.
10.
ChanCJiaCQGraydonJW, et al (1996) The behaviour of selected heavy metals in MSW incineration electrostatic precipitator ash during roasting with chlorination agents. Journal of Hazardous Materials50: 1–13.
11.
ChanCCYKirkDW (1999) Behaviour of metals under the conditions of roasting MSW incinerator fly ash with chlorinating agents. Journal of Hazardous Materials64: 75–89.
12.
ChenGF (1992) Heavy Metal Metallurgy. Beijing: Metallurgical Industry Press.
13.
ChenWKirkelundGMJensenPE, et al (2018) Electrodialytic extraction of Cr from water-washed MSWI fly ash by changing pH and redox conditions. Waste Management71: 215–223.
14.
ChimenosJMFernándezAICervantesA, et al (2005) Optimizing the APC residue washing process to minimize the release of chloride and heavy metals. Waste Management25: 686–693.
15.
CoxABryanCG (2017) Insights into heap bioleaching at the agglomerate-scale. Solid State Phenomena262: 185–188.
16.
DontrirosSLikitlersuangSJanjaroenD (2020) Mechanisms of chloride and sulfate removal from municipal-solid-waste-incineration fly ash (MSWI FA): Effect of acid–base solutions. Waste Management101: 44–53.
17.
EckeHSakanakuraHMatsutoT, et al (2000) State-of-the-art treatment processes for municipal solid waste incineration residues in Japan. Waste Management & Research18: 41–51.
FanCWangBZhangT (2018) Review on cement stabilization/solidification of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash. Advances in Materials Science and Engineering2018: 1–7.
20.
FengSYangHWangW (2015) Improved chalcopyrite bioleaching by Acidithiobacillus sp. via direct step-wise regulation of microbial community structure. Bioresource Technology192: 75–82.
21.
FerreiraCJensenPOttosenL, et al (2005) Removal of selected heavy metals from MSW fly ash by the electrodialytic process. Engineering Geology77: 339–347.
22.
FerreiraCDJensenPOttosenL, et al (2008) Preliminary treatment of MSW fly ash as a way of improving electrodialytic remediation. Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part A43: 837–843.
23.
FunariVBragaRBokhariSNH, et al (2015) Solid residues from Italian municipal solid waste incinerators: A source for “critical” raw materials. Waste Management45: 206–216.
24.
FunariVGomesHICappellettiM, et al (2019) Optimization routes for the bioleaching of MSWI fly and bottom ashes using microorganisms collected from a natural system. Waste and Biomass Valorization10: 3833–3842.
25.
FunariVMäkinenJSalminenJ, et al (2017) Metal removal from Municipal Solid Waste Incineration fly ash: A comparison between chemical leaching and bioleaching. Waste Management60: 397–406.
26.
GaddGM (2000) Bioremedial potential of microbial mechanisms of metal mobilization and immobilization. Current Opinion in Biotechnology11: 271–279.
27.
GaoXJiBYanD, et al (2017) A full-scale study on thermal degradation of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans in municipal solid waste incinerator fly ash and its secondary air pollution control in China. Waste Management & Research35: 437–443.
28.
GuTRastegarSOMousaviSM, et al (2018) Advances in bioleaching for recovery of metals and bioremediation of fuel ash and sewage sludge. Bioresource Technology261: 428–440.
29.
HongKTokunagaSKajiuchiT (2000a) Extraction of heavy metals from MSW incinerator fly ashes by chelating agents. Journal of Hazardous Materials75: 57–73.
30.
HongKJTokunagaSIshigamiY, et al (2000b) Extraction of heavy metals from MSW incinerator fly ash using saponins. Chemosphere41: 345–352.
31.
HoornwegDBhada-TataP (2012) What a Waste: A Global Review of Solid Waste Management. Washington, DC: World Bank.
32.
HuHLiuHZhangQ, et al (2016) Sintering characteristics of CaO-rich municipal solid waste incineration fly ash through the addition of Si/Al-rich ash residues. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management18: 340–347.
33.
HuHLuoGLiuH, et al (2013) Fate of chromium during thermal treatment of municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute34: 2795–2801.
34.
HuangKInoueKHaradaH, et al (2011) Leaching of heavy metals by citric acid from fly ash generated in municipal waste incineration plants. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management13: 118–126.
35.
HuangTLiuLZhouL, et al (2018a) Operating optimization for the heavy metal removal from the municipal solid waste incineration fly ashes in the three-dimensional electrokinetics. Chemosphere204: 294–302.
36.
HuangTZhouLLiuL, et al (2018b) Ultrasound-enhanced electrokinetic remediation for removal of Zn, Pb, Cu and Cd in municipal solid waste incineration fly ashes. Waste Management75: 226–235.
37.
HuangTZhouLTaoJ, et al (2018c) Cylindrical electrolyser enhanced electrokinetic remediation of municipal solid waste incineration fly ashes. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 301: 12097.
38.
HuangTYChiuehPTLoSL (2017) Life-cycle environmental and cost impacts of reusing fly ash. Resources, Conservation and Recycling123: 255–260.
39.
IshigakiTNakanishiATatedaM, et al (2005) Bioleaching of metal from municipal waste incineration fly ash using a mixed culture of sulfur-oxidizing and iron-oxidizing bacteria. Chemosphere60: 1087–1094.
40.
JadhavUUBiswalBKChenZ, et al (2018) Leaching of metals from incineration bottom ash using organic acid. Journal of Sustainable Metallurgy4: 115–125.
41.
JadhavUUHochengH (2015) Analysis of metal bioleaching from thermal power plant fly ash by Aspergillus niger 34770 culture supernatant and reduction of phytotoxicity during the process. Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology175: 870–881.
42.
JakobAStuckiSKuhnP (1995) Evaporation of heavy-metals during the heat treatment of municipal solid-waste incinerator fly-ash. Environmental Science & Technology29: 2429–2436.
43.
JosephASnellingsRVan den HeedeP, et al (2018) The use of municipal solid waste incineration ash in various building materials: A Belgian point of view. Materials11: 141.
44.
Karlfeldt FedjeKEkbergCSkarnemarkG, et al (2010) Removal of hazardous metals from MSW fly ash—An evaluation of ash leaching methods. Journal of Hazardous Materials173: 310–317.
45.
KatsuuraHInoueTHiraokaM, et al (1996) Full-scale plant study on fly ash treatment by the acid extraction process. Waste Management16: 491–499.
46.
KitamuraHSawadaTShimaokaT, et al (2016) Geochemically structural characteristics of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash particles and mineralogical surface conversions by chelate treatment. Environmental Science and Pollution Research23: 734–743.
47.
KonishiYMatsuiMFujiwaraH, et al (2003) Zinc leaching from fly ash in municipal waste incineration by thermophilic archaean Acidianus brierleyi growing on elemental sulfur. Separation Science and Technology38: 4117–4130.
48.
KrebsWBachofenRBrandlH (2001) Growth stimulation of sulfur oxidizing bacteria for optimization of metal leaching efficiency of fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration. Hydrometallurgy59: 283–290.
49.
KrebsWBrombacherCBosshardPP, et al (1997) Microbial recovery of metals from solids. FEMS Microbiology Reviews20: 605–617.
50.
KuboňováLLangováŠNowakB, et al (2013) Thermal and hydrometallurgical recovery methods of heavy metals from municipal solid waste fly ash. Waste Management33: 2322–2327.
51.
KurashimaKMatsudaKKumagaiS, et al (2019) A combined kinetic and thermodynamic approach for interpreting the complex interactions during chloride volatilization of heavy metals in municipal solid waste fly ash. Waste Management87: 204–217.
52.
LaneDJSippulaOKoponenH, et al (2020) Volatilisation of major, minor, and trace elements during thermal processing of fly ashes from waste- and wood-fired power plants in oxidising and reducing gas atmospheres. Waste Management102: 698–709.
53.
LatorreMCortésMPTravisanyD, et al (2016) The bioleaching potential of a bacterial consortium. Bioresource Technology218: 659–666.
54.
LedererJTrinkelVFellnerJ (2017) Wide-scale utilization of MSWI fly ashes in cement production and its impact on average heavy metal contents in cements: The case of Austria. Waste Management60: 247–258.
55.
LeeJPandeyBD (2012) Bio-processing of solid wastes and secondary resources for metal extraction – A review. Waste Management32: 3–18.
56.
LimaATRodriguesPCMexiaJT (2010) Heavy metal migration during electroremediation of fly ash from different wastes—Modelling. Journal of Hazardous Materials175: 366–371.
57.
LiuJChenJHuangL (2015) Heavy metal removal from MSS fly ash by thermal and chlorination treatments. Scientific Reports5: 17270.
58.
LoginovaEProskurninMBrouwersHJH (2019) Municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash composition analysis: A case study of combined chelatant-based washing treatment efficiency. Journal of Environmental Management235: 480–488.
59.
MahieuxPYAubertJECyrM, et al (2010) Quantitative mineralogical composition of complex mineral wastes – Contribution of the Rietveld method. Waste Management30: 378–388.
60.
MäkinenJSaloMSoiniJ, et al (2019) Laboratory scale investigations on heap (bio)leaching of municipal solid waste incineration bottom ash. Minerals9: 290.
61.
MishraDRheeY (2010) Current research trends of microbiological leaching for metal recovery from industrial wastes. In: Méndez-VilasA (ed.) Current Research, Technology and Education Topics in Applied Microbiology and Microbial Biotechnology. Spain: Formatex, 1289–1292.
62.
NagibSInoueK (2000) Recovery of lead and zinc from fly ash generated from municipal incineration plants by means of acid and/or alkaline leaching. Hydrometallurgy56: 269–292.
63.
NarayanaT (2009) Municipal solid waste management in India: From waste disposal to recovery of resources?Waste Management29: 1163–1166.
National Cooperative Highway Research Program Report 577 (2007) Guidelines for the selection of snow and ice control materials to mitigate environmental impacts. Available at: https://www.nap.edu/read/23178/chapter/1 (accessed 30 November 2020).
67.
NiPLiHZhaoY, et al (2017) Relation between leaching characteristics of heavy metals and physical properties of fly ashes from typical municipal solid waste incinerators. Environmental Technology38: 2105–2118.
68.
NowakBAschenbrennerPWinterF (2013) Heavy metal removal from sewage sludge ash and municipal solid waste fly ash—A comparison. Fuel Processing Technology105: 195–201.
69.
NowakBFrías RochaSAschenbrennerP, et al (2012) Heavy metal removal from MSW fly ash by means of chlorination and thermal treatment: Influence of the chloride type. Chemical Engineering Journal179: 178–185.
70.
NowakBPesslAAschenbrennerP, et al (2010) Heavy metal removal from municipal solid waste fly ash by chlorination and thermal treatment. Journal of Hazardous Materials179: 323–331.
71.
OkadaTTojoYTanakaN, et al (2007) Recovery of zinc and lead from fly ash from ash-melting and gasification-melting processes of MSW – Comparison and applicability of chemical leaching methods. Waste Management27: 69–80.
72.
OkadaTTomikawaH (2013) Effects of chemical composition of fly ash on efficiency of metal separation in ash-melting of municipal solid waste. Waste Management33: 605–614.
73.
OkadaTTomikawaH (2016) Efficiencies of metal separation and recovery in ash-melting of municipal solid waste under non-oxidative atmospheres with different reducing abilities. Journal of Environmental Management166: 147–155.
74.
PanYWuZZhouJ, et al (2013) Chemical characteristics and risk assessment of typical municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash in China. Journal of Hazardous Materials261: 269–276.
75.
PandaSAkcilAMishraS, et al (2017) Synergistic effect of biogenic Fe3+ coupled to S degrees oxidation on simultaneous bioleaching of Cu, Co, Zn and As from hazardous Pyrite Ash Waste. Journal of Hazardous Materials325: 59–70.
76.
PedersenAJ (2002) Evaluation of assisting agents for electrodialytic removal of Cd, Pb, Zn, Cu and Cr from MSWI fly ash. Journal of Hazardous Materials95: 185–198.
77.
PollmannKKutschkeSMatysS, et al (2018) Bio-recycling of metals: Recycling of technical products using biological applications. Biotechnology Advances36: 1048–1062.
78.
PooleDArgentBBSharifiVN, et al (2008) Prediction of the distribution of alkali and trace elements between the condensed and gaseous phases in a municipal solid waste incinerator. Fuel87: 1318–1333.
79.
PurgarAWinterFBlasenbauerD, et al (2016) Main drivers for integrating zinc recovery from fly ashes into the Viennese waste incineration cluster. Fuel Processing Technology141: 243–248.
80.
QinDGaoSWangL, et al (2017) Three-dimensional carbon nanofiber derived from bacterial cellulose for use in a Nafion matrix on a glassy carbon electrode for simultaneous voltammetric determination of trace levels of Cd(II) and Pb(II). Microchimica Acta184: 2759–2766.
81.
QuinaMJBontempiEBogushA, et al (2018) Technologies for the management of MSW incineration ashes from gas cleaning: New perspectives on recovery of secondary raw materials and circular economy. Science of the Total Environment635: 526–542.
82.
QuinaMJBordadoJCQuinta-FerreiraRM (2008) Treatment and use of air pollution control residues from MSW incineration: An overview. Waste Management28: 2097–2121.
83.
RaclavskáHCorsaroAHartmann-KovalS, et al (2017) Enrichment and distribution of 24 elements within the sub-sieve particle size distribution ranges of fly ash from wastes incinerator plants. Journal of Environmental Management203: 1169–1177.
84.
RamanathanTTingY (2016) Alkaline bioleaching of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash by autochthonous extremophiles. Chemosphere160: 54–61.
85.
RasoulniaPMousaviSMRastegarSO, et al (2016) Fungal leaching of valuable metals from a power plant residual ash using Penicillium simplicissimum: Evaluation of thermal pretreatment and different bioleaching methods. Waste Management52: 309–317.
86.
RumbleJ (2020) CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 101st edn. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
87.
SabbasTPolettiniAPomiR, et al (2003) Management of municipal solid waste incineration residues. Waste Management23: 61–88.
88.
SandWGehrkeTJozsaP, et al (2001) (Bio)chemistry of bacterial leaching—Direct vs. indirect bioleaching. Hydrometallurgy59: 159–175.
89.
SchinnerFBurgstallerW (1989) Extraction of zinc from industrial waste by a Penicillium sp. Applied and Environmental Microbiology55: 1153–1156.
90.
SchlumbergerSSchusterMRingmannS, et al (2007) Recovery of high purity zinc from filter ash produced during the thermal treatment of waste and inerting of residual materials. Waste Management & Research25: 547–555.
91.
SenguptaBSenguptaRSubrahmanyamN (2006) Copper extraction into emulsion liquid membranes using LIX 984N-C®. Hydrometallurgy81: 67–73.
SongJSunYJinL (2017) PESTEL analysis of the development of the waste-to-energy incineration industry in China. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews80: 276–289.
94.
SørumLFrandsenFJHustadJE (2003) On the fate of heavy metals in municipal solid waste combustion Part I: Devolatilisation of heavy metals on the grate. Fuel82: 2273–2283.
95.
TangJSteenariB (2015) Solvent extraction separation of copper and zinc from MSWI fly ash leachates. Waste Management44: 147–154.
96.
TangJSteenariB (2016) Leaching optimization of municipal solid waste incineration ash for resource recovery: A case study of Cu, Zn, Pb and Cd. Waste Management48: 315–322.
97.
TangJSuMWuQ, et al (2019) Highly efficient recovery and clean-up of four heavy metals from MSWI fly ash by integrating leaching, selective extraction and adsorption. Journal of Cleaner Production234: 139–149.
98.
TangJSuMZhangH, et al (2018) Assessment of copper and zinc recovery from MSWI fly ash in Guangzhou based on a hydrometallurgical process. Waste Management76: 225–233.
99.
TaoHLeiTShiG, et al (2014) Removal of heavy metals from fly ash leachate using combined bioelectrochemical systems and electrolysis. Journal of Hazardous Materials264: 1–7.
100.
WangHFanXWangY, et al (2018) Comparative leaching of six toxic metals from raw and chemically stabilized MSWI fly ash using citric acid. Journal of Environmental Management208: 15–23.
101.
WangQYangJWangQ, et al (2009) Effects of water-washing pretreatment on bioleaching of heavy metals from municipal solid waste incinerator fly ash. Journal of Hazardous Materials162: 812–818.
102.
WangYPanYZhangL, et al (2015) Can washing-pretreatment eliminate the health risk of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash reuse?Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety111: 177–184.
103.
WeibelGEggenbergerUKulikDA, et al (2018) Extraction of heavy metals from MSWI fly ash using hydrochloric acid and sodium chloride solution. Waste Management76: 457–471.
104.
WeibelGEggenbergerUSchlumbergerS, et al (2017) Chemical associations and mobilization of heavy metals in fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration. Waste Management62: 147–159.
105.
WuHTingY (2006) Metal extraction from municipal solid waste (MSW) incinerator fly ash—Chemical leaching and fungal bioleaching. Enzyme and Microbial Technology38: 839–847.
106.
XieKHuHXuS, et al (2020) Fate of heavy metals during molten salts thermal treatment of municipal solid waste incineration fly ashes. Waste Management103: 334–341.
107.
XuTRamanathanTTingY (2014) Bioleaching of incineration fly ash by Aspergillus niger – Precipitation of metallic salt crystals and morphological alteration of the fungus. Biotechnology Reports3: 8–14.
108.
XuTTingY (2004) Optimisation on bioleaching of incinerator fly ash by Aspergillus niger – Use of central composite design. Enzyme and Microbial Technology35: 444–454.
109.
XuTTingY (2009) Fungal bioleaching of incineration fly ash: Metal extraction and modeling growth kinetics. Enzyme and Microbial Technology44: 323–328.
110.
YakubuYZhouJShuZ, et al (2018) Potential application of pre-treated municipal solid waste incineration fly ash as cement supplement. Environmental Science and Pollution Research25: 16167–16176.
111.
YangGCCTsaiC (1998) A study on heavy metal extractability and subsequent recovery by electrolysis for a municipal incinerator fly ash. Journal of Hazardous Materials58: 103–120.
112.
YangJWangQWangQ, et al (2008) Comparisons of one-step and two-step bioleaching for heavy metals removed from municipal solid waste incineration fly ash. Environmental Engineering Science25: 783–789.
113.
YangJWangQWangQ, et al (2009) Heavy metals extraction from municipal solid waste incineration fly ash using adapted metal tolerant Aspergillus niger. Bioresource Technology100: 254–260.
114.
YangRLiaoWLinC (2013) Feasibility of lead and copper recovery from MSWI fly ash by combining acid leaching and electrodeposition treatment. Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy32: 1074–1081.
115.
YangZTianSJiR, et al (2017) Effect of water-washing on the co-removal of chlorine and heavy metals in air pollution control residue from MSW incineration. Waste Management68: 221–231.
116.
YinKAhamedALisakG (2018) Environmental perspectives of recycling various combustion ashes in cement production – A review. Waste Management78: 401–416.
117.
YuJQiaoYJinL, et al (2015a) Removal of toxic and alkali/alkaline earth metals during co-thermal treatment of two types of MSWI fly ashes in China. Waste Management46: 287–297.
118.
YuJQiaoYSunL, et al (2015b) Detoxification of ashes from a fluidized bed waste incinerator. Chemosphere134: 346–354.
119.
YuJSunLMaC, et al (2016) Mechanism on heavy metals vaporization from municipal solid waste fly ash by MgCl2⋅6H2O. Waste Management49: 124–130.
120.
ZhangFItohH (2006a) A novel process utilizing subcritical water and nitrilotriacetic acid to extract hazardous elements from MSW incinerator fly ash. Science of the Total Environment369: 273–279.
121.
ZhangFItohH (2006b) Extraction of metals from municipal solid waste incinerator fly ash by hydrothermal process. Journal of Hazardous Materials136: 663–670.
122.
ZhangYHuangTHuangX, et al (2017) Study on electro-kinetic remediation of heavy metals in municipal solid waste incineration fly ash with a three-dimensional electrode. RSC Advances7: 27846–27852.
123.
ZhangYKasaiE (2004) Effect of chlorine on the vaporization behavior of zinc and lead during high temperature treatment of dust and fly ash. ISIJ International44: 1457–1468.
124.
ZhaoKHuYTianY, et al (2020a) Chlorine removal from MSWI fly ash by thermal treatment: Effects of iron/aluminum additives. Journal of Environmental Sciences88: 112–121.
125.
ZhaoPJingMFengL, et al (2020b) The heavy metal leaching property and cementitious material preparation by treating municipal solid waste incineration fly ash through the molten salt process. Waste Management & Research38: 27–34.
