Decentralized waste sorting and composting can divert almost two-thirds of household waste from landfill. However, national rates of composting and recycling remain low in many parts of the globe. This review critically evaluates the design and efficacy of behaviour-change interventions to influence households to sort and compost organic waste. The systematic literature search yielded 3595 titles and abstracts which were reviewed and resulted in 14 unique interventions. The social marketing benchmark criteria are utilized to critically examine the design of these interventions. Synthesized results indicate a need for customized interventions that are co-designed with users and tailored to address their specific needs and challenges. Interventions with four or more social marketing elements produced positive behavioural outcomes, albeit with varying impact. This review highlights gaps in the design of waste management interventions and provides suggestions for future practices.
AbergHDahlmanSShanahanH, et al. (1996) Towards sound environmental behaviour: Exploring household participation in waste management. Journal of Consumer Policy19: 45–67.
2.
AndreasenAR (2002) Marketing social marketing in the social change marketplace. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing21: 3–13.
3.
ArliDDietrichTTkaczynskiA, et al. (2017) Indonesian healthy living intentions: Segmentation study insights. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing22: e1574.
4.
AshtonWManchandaR (2018) Using previous social marketing efforts to assess a new program. Journal of Social Marketing8: 202–219.
5.
BasilDBasilMLavackA, et al. (2019) Toward developing an environmental efficacy construct. Journal of Social Marketing10: 1–17.
BenchMLWoodardRHarderMK, et al. (2005) Waste minimisation: Home digestion trials of biodegradable waste. Resources, Conservation and Recycling45: 84–94.
8.
BernstadA (2014) Household food waste separation behavior and the importance of convenience. Waste Management34: 1317–1323.
9.
BernstadAJansenJLAspegrenH (2012) Local strategies for efficient management of solid household waste – The full-scale Augustenborg experiment. Waste Management & Research30: 200–212.
10.
BernstadAla Cour JansenJAspegrenA (2013) Door-stepping as a strategy for improved food waste recycling behaviour – Evaluation of a full-scale experiment. Resources, Conservation and Recycling73: 94–103.
11.
BoonrodKTowprayoonSBonnetS, et al. (2015) Enhancing organic waste separation at the source behavior: A case study of the application of motivation mechanisms in communities in Thailand. Resources, Conservation and Recycling95: 77–90.
12.
BortoletoAPKurisuKHHanakiK (2012) Model development for household waste prevention behaviour. Waste Management32: 2195–2207.
13.
BuyucekNKubackiKRundle-ThieleS, et al. (2016) A systematic review of stakeholder involvement in social marketing interventions. Australasian Marketing Journal24: 8–19.
14.
CarinsJERundle-ThieleSR (2014) Eating for the better: A social marketing review (2000–2012). Public Health Nutrition17: 1628–1639.
15.
ChammasGKayedSAl ShamiA, et al. (2020) Transdisciplinary interventions for environmental sustainability. Waste Management107: 159–171.
16.
ChristieBWallerV (2019) Community learnings through residential composting in apartment buildings. Journal of Environmental Education50: 97–112.
DahlSEagleLLowD (2015) Integrated marketing communications and social marketing. Journal of Social Marketing5: 226–240.
19.
DavidPRundle-ThieleS (2019) Rethinking behaviour change: A dynamic approach in social marketing. Journal of Social Marketing9: 252–268.
20.
DavisRCampbellRHildonZ, et al. (2015) Theories of behaviour and behaviour change across the social and behavioural sciences: A scoping review. Health Psychology Review9: 323–344.
21.
DibbS (2017) Changing times for social marketing segmentation. In: DietrichTRundle-ThieleSKubackiK (eds) Segmentation in Social Marketing: Process, Methods and Application. Singapore: Springer.
22.
DietrichT (2017) Segmentation in social marketing: Five steps to success. In: DietrichTRundle-ThieleSKubackiK (eds) Segmentation in Social Marketing: Process, Methods and Application. Singapore: Springer, 77–92.
23.
DietrichTRundle-ThieleSKubackiK (eds) (2017a) Segmentation in Social Marketing: Process, Methods and Application. Singapore: Springer.
24.
DietrichTRundle-ThieleSSchusterL, et al. (2016) Co-designing social marketing programs. Journal of Social Marketing6: 41–61.
25.
DietrichTTrischlerJSchusterL, et al. (2017b) Co-designing services with vulnerable consumers. Journal of Service Theory and Practice27: 663–688.
26.
DiGiacomoAWuDWLLenkicP, et al. (2018) Convenience improves composting and recycling rates in high-density residential buildings. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management61: 309–331.
27.
DomeganCCollinsKSteadM, et al. (2013) Value co-creation in social marketing: Functional or fanciful?Journal of Social Marketing3: 239– 256.
28.
DooleyJAJonesSCIversonD (2012) Web 2.0: An assessment of social marketing principles. Journal of Social Marketing2: 207–221.
29.
FrenchJ (2017) The importance of segmentation in social marketing strategy. In: DietrichTRundle-ThieleSKubackiK (eds) Segmentation in Social Marketing: Process, Methods and Application. Singapore: Springer, 25–40.
FujihiraHKubackiKRontoR, et al. (2015) Social marketing physical activity interventions among adults 60 years and older: A systematic review. Social Marketing Quarterly21: 214–229.
32.
GeislarS (2017) The new norms of food waste at the curb: Evidence-based policy tools to address benefits and barriers. Waste Management68: 571–580.
33.
GillanDALelandLSJrDaviesAM, et al. (2004) Reducing curbside waste volumes by promoting household composting. Journal of Environmental Systems30: 317–332.
34.
GomezALoarREngland KramerA (2018) The impact of market segmentation and social marketing on uptake of preventive programmes: The example of voluntary medical male circumcision. A literature review. Gates Open Research2: 68.
35.
GrayDBeanB (2011) Can social marketing segmentation initiatives be used to increase household electricity conservation?Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing23: 269–305.
36.
GreenKMCrawfordBAWilliamsonKA, et al. (2019) A meta-analysis of social marketing campaigns to improve global conservation outcomes. Social Marketing Quarterly25: 69–87.
37.
HinsleyAVerissimoDRobertsDL (2015) Heterogeneity in consumer preferences for orchids in international trade and the potential for the use of market research methods to study demand for wildlife. Biological Conservation190: 80–86.
HurleyEDietrichTRundle-ThieleS (2019) A systematic review of parent based programs to prevent or reduce alcohol consumption in adolescents. BMC Public Health19: 1451.
40.
JessonJ (2009) Household waste recycling behavior: A market segmentation model. Social Marketing Quarterly15: 25–38.
41.
JonesSKeaneASt JohnF, et al. (2019) Audience segmentation to improve targeting of conservation interventions for hunters. Conservation Biology33: 895–905.
42.
KarkaniasCPerkoulidisGMoussiopoulosN (2016) Sustainable management of household biodegradable waste: Lessons from home composting programmes. Waste and Biomass Valorization7: 659–665.
43.
KazaSYaoLBhada-TataP, et al. (2018) What a waste 2.0: A global snapshot of solid waste management to 2050. In: Urban Development Series. Washington, DC: World Bank.
44.
KellermeyerLHarnkeBKnightS (2018) Covidence and Rayyan. Journal of the Medical Library Association106: 580–583.
45.
KemperJBallantineP (2019) Targeting the structural environment at multiple social levels for systemic change. Journal of Social Marketing10: 38–53.
46.
KimJRundle-ThieleSKnoxK (2019) Systematic literature review of best practice in food waste reduction programs. Journal of Social Marketing9: 447–466.
47.
KimJRundle-ThieleSKnoxK, et al. (2020a) Outcome evaluation of an empirical study: Food waste social marketing pilot. Social Marketing Quarterly26: 1524500420918690.
48.
KimJRundle-ThieleSKnoxK, et al. (2020b) Consumer perspectives on household food waste reduction campaigns. Journal of Cleaner Production243: 118608.
49.
KitunenARundle-ThieleSKadirM, et al. (2019) Learning what our target audiences think and do: Extending segmentation to all four bases. BMC Public Health19: 382.
KrepsGL (1996) Promoting a consumer orientation to health care and health promotion. Journal of Health Psychology1: 41–48.
52.
KubackiKRundle-ThieleS (2017) Formative Research in Social Marketing: Innovative Methods to Gain Consumer Insights. Singapore: Springer
53.
KubackiKRundle-ThieleSLahtinenV, et al. (2015) A systematic review assessing the extent of social marketing principle use in interventions targeting children (2000–2014). Young Consumers16: 141–158.
54.
LahtinenV (2018) Assessing the effectiveness of the marketing mix in social marketing. PhD Thesis, Griffith University, Australia.
55.
LeeN (2017) How and why segmentation improves ROI. In: In: DietrichTRundle-ThieleSKubackiK (eds) Segmentation in Social Marketing: Process, Methods and Application. Singapore: Springer, 61–74.
56.
LefebvreRC (2012) Transformative social marketing: Co-creating the social marketing discipline and brand. Journal of Social Marketing2: 118–129.
57.
LiCJHuangYYHarderMK (2017) Incentives for food waste diversion: Exploration of a long term successful Chinese city residential scheme. Journal of Cleaner Production156: 491–499.
58.
LiQZengFMeiH, et al. (2019) Roles of motivation, opportunity, ability, and trust in the willingness of farmers to adopt green fertilization techniques. Sustainability11: 6902.
59.
LiberatiAAltmanDGTetzlaffJ, et al. (2009) The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: Explanation and elaboration. BMJ339: b2700.
60.
ManomaiviboolPSrivichaiMUnrojP, et al. (2018) Chiang Rai zero waste: Participatory action research to promote source separation in rural areas. Resources, Conservation & Recycling136: 142–152.
61.
MbuligweSEKassengaGRKasevaME, et al. (2002) Potential and constraints of composting domestic solid waste in developing countries: Findings from a pilot study in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Resources, Conservation & Recycling36: 45–59.
MetcalfALAngleJWPhelanCN, et al. (2018) More “bank” for the buck: Microtargeting and normative appeals to increase social marketing efficiency. Social Marketing Quarterly25: 26–39.
NsimbePMendozaHWafulaST, et al. (2018) Factors associated with composting of solid waste at household level in Masaka municipality, Central Uganda. Journal of Environmental & Public Health2018: 1–7.
70.
PalijonAHaraYMurakamiA, et al. (2017) Biowaste reuse through composting: The response of Barangay Holy Spirit in Quezon City, Philippines, to solid-waste management. In YokohariMMurakamiAHaraY, et al (eds) Sustainable Landscape Planning in Selected Urban Regions. Tokyo: Springer, pp. 227–236.
71.
PanaretouVMalamisDPapadaskalopoulouC, et al. (2017) Implementation and evaluation of an integrated management scheme for MSW in selected communities in Tinos Island, Greece. Waste and Biomass Valorization8: 1597–1616.
72.
ParkinsonJSchusterLRussell-BennettR (2016) Insights into the complexity of behaviours: The MOAB framework. Journal of Social Marketing6: 412–427.
73.
PearsonDPereraA (2018) Reducing food waste: A practitioner guide identifying requirements for an Integrated social marketing communication campaign. Social Marketing Quarterly24: 45–57.
74.
PhillipsonLGordonRTelentaJ, et al. (2016) A review of current practices to increase Chlamydia screening in the community: A consumer-centred social marketing perspective. Health Expectations19: 5–25.
75.
PoortingaWDarntonA (2016) Segmenting for sustainability: The development of a sustainability segmentation model from a Welsh sample. Journal of Environmental Psychology45: 221–232.
76.
PurcellMMagetteWL (2011) Targeted intervention strategies to optimise diversion of BMW in the Dublin, Ireland region. Waste Management31: 2180–2189.
77.
Rundle-ThieleS (2009) Bridging the gap between claimed and actual behaviour: The role of observational research. Qualitative Market Research12: 295–306.
78.
Rundle-ThieleSDavidPWillmottT, et al. (2019a) Social marketing theory development goals: An agenda to drive change. Journal of Marketing Management35: 160–181.
79.
Rundle-ThieleSPangBKnoxK, et al. (2019b) Generating new directions for reducing dog and koala interactions: A social marketing formative research study. Australian Journal of Environmental Management26: 173–187.
80.
SaundersSBarringtonDSridharanS (2015) Redefining social marketing: Beyond behavioural change. Journal of Social Marketing5: 160–168.
81.
SchusterLKubackiKRundle-ThieleS (2016) Community-based social marketing: Effects on social norms. Journal of Social Marketing6: 193–210.
82.
SequeiraVChandrashekarJS (2015) Solid waste management in Mangaluru City – A case study. International Journal of Innovation and Applied Studies10: 420–427.
83.
SharpVGiorgiSWilsonDC (2010) Delivery and impact of household waste prevention intervention campaigns (at the local level). Waste Management & Research28: 256–268.
84.
ShawkySKubackiKDietrichT, et al. (2019) Using social media to create engagement: A social marketing review. Journal of Social Marketing9: 204–224.
85.
SmithSRJasimS (2009) Small-scale home composting of biodegradable household waste: Overview of key results from a 3-year research programme in West London. Waste Management & Research27: 941–950.
86.
SternPC (2020) A reexamination on how behavioral interventions can promote household action to limit climate change. Nature Communications11: 918.
TkaczynskiARundle-ThieleS (2013) Understanding what really motivates attendance: A music festival segmentation study. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing30: 610–623.
89.
TkaczynskiARundle-ThieleS (2019) Is destination marketing missing the mark? A Fraser Coast segmentation analysis. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management12: 12–14.
90.
TkaczynskiARundle-ThieleSRPrebensenNK (2016) To segment or not? That is the question. Journal of Vacation Marketing24: 16–28.
91.
TrischlerJDietrichTRundle-ThieleS (2019) Co-design: From expert- to user-driven ideas in public service design. Public Management Review21: 1595–1619.
92.
TruongVDSaundersSGDongXD (2019) Systems social marketing: A critical appraisal. Journal of Social Marketing9: 180–203.
93.
VarottoASpagnolliA (2017) Psychological strategies to promote household recycling: A systematic review with meta-analysis of validated field interventions. Journal of Environmental Psychology51: 168–188.
94.
VeríssimoD (2019) The past, present, and future of using social marketing to conserve biodiversity. Social Marketing Quarterly25: 3–8.
95.
WestRGodinhoCABohlenLC, et al. (2019) Development of a formal system for representing behaviour-change theoriesNature Human Behaviour3: 526–536.
96.
WilliamsIDKellyJ (2003) Green waste collection and the public’s recycling behaviour in the Borough of Wyre, England. Resources, Conservation and Recycling38: 139–159.
97.
WoodM (2016) Midstream social marketing and the co-creation of public services. Journal of Social Marketing6: 277–293.
98.
WoodM (2019) Resilience research and social marketing: The route to sustainable behaviour change. Journal of Social Marketing9: 77–93.
99.
WoodardRHarderMKBenchM, et al. (2001) Evaluating the performance of a fortnightly collection of household waste separated into compostables, recyclates and refuse in the south of England. Resources Conservation and Recycling31: 265–284.
100.
XiaYDeshpandeSBonatesT (2016) Effectiveness of social marketing interventions to promote physical activity. Journal of Physical Activity and Health13: 1263–1274.
101.
YehMAJewellRDThomasVL (2017) The stigma of mental illness: Using segmentation for social change. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing36: 97–116.
102.
ZhuB (2016) Consumer’s motivation, opportunities and abilities for sustainable consumption: A case in China. Sustainability Management Forum24: 337–352.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
