Technical, economic and environmental criteria were used to evaluate the feasibility of recycling plant nutrients in kitchen waste, human excreta and sullage from households in Phattalung (urban), Kuan Lang (peri urban) and Prik (rural) in Southern Thailand. The difference in situation and context of the three areas called for individual solutions, and for each area three sanitation systems were evaluated. However, in all three areas recycling human excreta and kitchen waste via composting latrines was found to be more environmental feasible than human excreta managed in septic tanks or sub surface trickle irrigation and kitchen waste disposed of at landfill sites or treated at composting plants. Sullage should in Kuan Lang and Prik be used directly on garden crops, but in Phattalung be treated in waste stabilisation ponds before discharge, to be environmentally feasible. The economic feasibility results varied among the three areas and among the involved stakeholders: farmers and Kuan Lang administration benefited from recycling waste, at the expense of other private users, Phattalung municipality and Prik municipality. The main cause of these conflicting interests was lack of cost recovery and public participation, which should therefore serve as the fundament of any future environmental and economic feasible sanitation system.
Al-Kloub, B., Al-Shemmeri, T. & Pearman, A. (1997) The role of weights in multi-criteria decision aid, and the ranking of water projects in Jordan. European Journal of Operational Research, 99, pp. 278-288.
2.
BAAJ (1996) Bekendtgørelse om anvendelse af affaldsprodukter til jordbrugsformål (UK: Departmental Order about Agricultural Use of Waste Products). No. 823 of 16th September, EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Miljø- og Energiministeriet, Denmark.
3.
Beccali, G., Cellura, M. & Mistretta, M. (2001) Managing municipal solid waste - Energetic and environmental comparison among different management options. International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 4, pp. 243-249.
4.
BKV (1996) Bekendtgørelse om kvalitetskrav for vandområder og krav til udledning af visse farlige stoffer til vandløb, søer eller havet (UK: Departmental Order about Quality Requirement for Water and Requirement for Discharge of certain Hazardous Compounds to Watercourses, Lakes or Sea). No. 921 of 8th October, EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Miljø- og Energiministeriet, Denmark.
5.
BSM (1999) Bekendtgørelse om Spildevandstilladelser m.v. efter Miljøbeskyttelseslovens kapitel 3 og 4 (UK: Departmental order regarding wastewater approvals etc. according to environmental protection law). No. 501 of 21st June, EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Miljø- og Energiministeriet, Denmark.
6.
Budget (2000) Official budget of Phattalung Municipality, Prik Municipality and Kuan Lang Administrative Organisation,Thailand.
7.
Cheng, S.Chan, C.W. & Huang, G.H. (2002) Using multiple criteria decision analysis for supporting decisions of solid waste management. Journal of environmental science and health part A - toxic/hazardous substances & environmental engineering, 6, pp. 975-990.
Database (1995) Fundamental Database of Village Level. The National Committee of Community Development, The Ministry of Interior, Thailand.
12.
Diaz, L.F., Savage, G.M., Eggerth, L.L. & Golueke, C.G. (1996) Solid Waste Management for Economically Developing Countries. ISWA. CalRecovery Inc.Concord, CA, United States of America.
13.
EmSong (1999), Technical Background Report, No. 26. Environmental Infrastructure in the Songkhla Lake Basin Volume I/II, VKI in association with DHI, PEMconsult A/S, COWI A/S, Prince of Songkla University, Seatec International Ltd. DANCED and Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment, Office of Environmental Policy and Planning, Thailand.
14.
ENSIC (1990), Environmental sanitation reviews no. 30, Social Aspects of Solid Waste Recovery in Asian Cities, Environmental Sanitation Information Center, Asian Institute of Technology, Bangkok, Thailand.
15.
Esrey, S.A., Gough, J., Rapaport, D., Sawyer, R., Simpson-Hébert, M., Vargas, J. & Winblad, U. (eds) (1998) Ecological sanitation. Published by Department for Natural Resources and Environment, Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency, SIDA, Stockholm, Sweden.
16.
Feachem, R.G., Bradley, D.J., Garelick, H. & Mara, D.D. (1983) Sanitation and Diesease - Health Aspects of Excreta and Wastewater Management. Published for World Bank by John Wiley and Sons.
17.
Gardner, G. (1997) Recycling Organic Waste: From Urban Pollutant to Farm Resource. Jane, A. Peterson (eds) World Watch Paper 135. Washington, DC, USA.
18.
Grimble, Robin & Chan, Man-kwun (1995) Stakeholder analysis for natural resource management in developing countries - some practical guidelines for making management more participatory and effective. Natural resources forum, 19, pp. 113-124.
19.
Hall, D.O., Barnard, G.W & Moss, P.A. (1982) Biomass for Energy in the Developing Countries. Current role, potential, problems, prospects. Pergamon Press Ltd.
20.
Hansen, T.C. (1984) Beton i henhold til DS411-84 (UK: Concrete according to DS411-84). Building Material Laboratory. Technical University of Denmark. Technical Report 146/86, Denmark.
21.
Henze, M.Somlyódy, L., Schilling, W. & Tyson, J. (1997) Sustainable Sanitation. Water Science and Technology, 20, no. 9.
22.
Hoffmann B, Baslev Nielsen, S., Ellen, M.Gabriel, S., Eilersen, A.M., Henze, M. & Mikkelsen, P.S. (2000) Assessing the sustainability of small waste-water systems - A context oriented planning approach. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 20, pp. 347-357.
23.
Johnston, A.E. & Syers, J.K. (1996) Nutrient Management for Sustainable Crop Production in Asia. Proceedings of an International Conference held in Bali, Indonesia, 9-12 December 1996. Organized by: The World Phosphate Institute (IMPHOS) and AARD-CSAR in collaboration with IFA/FADINAP, PPI, ACIAR, IBSRAM and Academia Sinica, Indonesia.
24.
KSOJG (1996) Kemiske Stoffers Opførsel i Jord og Grundvand: Bind I, II.. Projekt om jord og grundvand (UK: Behaviour of Chemical Compounds in Soil and Groundwater. Project regarding Soil and Groundwater), EPA, Miljøstyrelsen. Miljø- og Energiministeriet. Denmark.
25.
Lee Feed Mill (2001) Public Co., Ltd.65 Mu 2, Huay Ta Chang, Khoa Yoi, Phetchaburi 76140, tel. (032) 446-562-9, fax (032) 446-560, Thailand.
26.
Malmqvist, Per-Arne (1997) Ecological sanitation in Sweden - Evaluations‘ in Ecological alternatives in sanitation. Proceedings from SIDA Sanitation Workshop, Balingsholm, Sweden6-9 August 1997. Publications on Water Resources: No. 9. Department for Natural Resources and the Environment, Sweden.
27.
Marks, L. A., Dunn, E. G., Keller, J. M. & Godsey, L. D. (1995) Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) Using Fuzzy Logic: An Innovative Approach to Sustainable Agriculture. Proceedings of ISUMA-NAFIPS, pp. 503-508.
28.
MP (1997) Miljøprojekt nr. 351. Hygiejniske aspekter ved behandling og genanvendelse af organisk affald (UK: Hygienic aspects at treatment and recycling of organic material). EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Miljø- og Energiministeriet, Denmark.
Oron, G., DeMalach, Y., Hoffman, Z., Keren, Y., Hartman, H. & Plazner, N. (1991) Wastewater disposal by sub-surface trickle irrigation. Water Science and Technology, 23, pp. 2149-2158.
31.
Pakawan Chufamanee, personal communication (2002) Head of Water Resources, Energy and Minerals Sub-Division, Office of Environmental Policy and Planning, Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment, October, Thailand.
32.
Pike, E.B. (1979) Salmonellae in Sewerage Sludges. A survey of sewage works in England and Wales. In Treatment and Use of Sewage Sludge, Proceedings of the 1st European Symposium. Cadarache, 13-15, D. Alexandre & H. Ott (eds), Commission of the European Communities, pp. 189-200.
33.
Pillay, T.V.R. (1992) Aquaculture and the Environment. Fishing News Books. A Division of Blackwell Scientific Publications Ltd.Cambridge, United Kingdom.
34.
Polprasert, C. (1996) Organic waste recycling: technology and management. 2nd edition. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.Chichester, United Kingdom.
35.
Polprasert, C, Yang, P.Y., Kongsricharoern, N. & Kanjanaprapin, W. (1994) Productive utilization of pig farm wastes: a case study for developing countries. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 11, pp. 245-259.
Sawhill, R.B. & Ferguson, B.K. (1998) The Potential for recycling municipal sewage sludge as substrate for wetland creation. Landscape and Urban Planning, 42, pp. 123-134.
38.
Schouw, N.L., Tjell, J.C., Mosbæk, H. & Danteravanich, S. (2002a) Availability and quality of solid waste and wastewater in Southern Thailand and its potential use as fertiliser. Waste Management and Research, 20, pp. 332-340.
39.
Schouw, N.L., Danteravanich, S., Mosbaek, H. & Tjell, J.C. (2002b) Composition of Human Excreta - a case study from Southern Thailand. The Science of the Total Environment, 286, pp. 155-166.
40.
Schouw, N.L, Bravo, A. & Tjell, J.C. (2002c) Social and institutional feasibility of recycling plant nutrients in waste in Southern Thailand. Manuscript submitted October 2002 to Waste Management & Research.
41.
SPDDWT (2000) Study Project and Detail Design of Wasterwater Treatment Muang Phattalung, Progress Report. S.D.Con. Cooperation Co. Ltd. Thailand.
42.
Stubsgaard, A. (2001) Hygienic Aspects of solid fractions of wastewater. In Piet Lens, Grietje Zeeman and Gatze Lettinga (eds) Decentralised Sanitation and Reuse, DESAR, concepts, systems and implementation. Integrated Environmental Technology Series, The Netherlands.
43.
SVLV (1997) Sundhedsmæssig Vurdering af Luftforurening fra Vejtrafik. (UK: Health Assessment of Airpollution from Traffic). Project no. 352. EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Miljø- og Energiministeriet, Denmark.
44.
TCCPC (2001) Thai Central Chemical Public Company Ltd. 180-184 Metro Building, Rajawonges Rd., Bangkok 10100, Thailand.
Tiwari, D.N, Loof, R. & Paudyal, G.N. (1999) Environmental-economic decision-making in lowland irrigated agriculture using multi-criteria analysis techniques. Agricultural Systems, 60, pp. 99-112.
47.
TSPP (1995) Thailand Sewerage Prioritization Project. Seatec International Ltd. Office of Environmental Policy and Planning. Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment. September, Bangkok, Thailand.
48.
Udomsinroj, K. (1999) Environmental Technology Management, p. 68. ISBN 974-530-146-9, Thailand.
49.
UMIP (1998) Udvikling af miljøvenlige industriprodukter (UK: Development of environmental industrial products). LCV-system. Version 2.11 Beta. Unit processes. Developed by OLSY A/S and IPU, Technical University of Denmark, for Danish EPA, Miljøstyrelsen, Kontoret for Renere Teknologi og Produkter, Denmark.
