Until quite recently, histories of imprisonment in America have overlooked women. Prison history has also been limited geographically to institutions in the northeast, and consequently there have been few studies of western prisons. The present historical analysis deals with women who were confined in the Arizona Territorial Prison at Yuma between 1876 and 1909. It extends and expands upon Nicole Rafter's Partial Justice (1990). Specifically, it covers the experience of women imprisoned in western states and territories during the last quarter of the nineteenth century, describes the racial and ethnic diversity of the female prison population along with the accompanying social and cultural differences, and outlines the treatment that women received from male prison officials. It also develops the concept of the western "bad women" within nineteenth-century popular culture to provide further support for Rafter's claim that prisons function to control gender, race, and ethnicity as well as crime.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adamson, C.
(1983). Punishment after slavery: Southern state penal systems, 1865-1890. Social Problems, 30, 555-569.
2.
Adamson, C.
(1984). Toward a Marxian penology: Captive criminal populations as economic threats and resources. Social Problems, 31, 433-458.
3.
Alexander, R.
(1988). We are engaged as a band of sisters: Class and domesticity in the Washington Temperance Movement, 1840-1850. Journal of American History, 75, 763-785.
4.
Arizona Gazette. (1897, October 26), p. 2.
5.
Arizona Gazette. (1908, October 20), p. 3.
6.
Arizona Republican. (1890, August 24), p. 4.
7.
Arizona Republican. (1897a, November 5), p. 6.
8.
Arizona Republican. (1897b, November 19), p. 3.
9.
Arizona Republican. (1908, October 20), p. 1.
10.
Arizona Sentinel. (1897a, August 28), p. 3.
11.
Arizona Sentinel. (1897b, October 23), p. 6.
12.
Arizona Sentinel. (1902, December 17), p. 2.
13.
Arizona Sentinel. (1908, October 21), p. 3.
14.
Arizona Territorial Prison
. (1876-1909). Register and descriptive list of convicts at the Arizona Territorial Prison. Arizona Department of Library, Archives and Public Records, Phoenix.
15.
Arizona Territorial Prison
. (1895). Rules and regulations for the government and discipline of the Arizona Territorial Prison at Yuma. Arizona State Historical Society Library, Tucson.
16.
Arizona Territory
. (1867). Journals of the Fourth Legislative Assembly. Prescott, AZ: Office of the Arizona Miner.
17.
Arizona Territory
. (1877). Journals of the Ninth Legislative Assembly. Phoenix, AZ: Office of the Arizona Citizen.
18.
Arizona Territory
. (1893). Journals of the Seventeenth Legislature of Arizona. Phoenix, AZ: Herald Book and Job Office.
19.
Arizona Territory
. (1904). Biennial report of the Board of Control of Arizona for the three years ending June 30th, 1903, and June 30th, 1904. Government Documents, Hayden Library of Arizona State University, Tempe.
20.
Arizona Territory
. (1905). Acts, resolutions, and memorials of the Twenty-Third Legislative Assembly of the Territory of Arizona. Phoenix, AZ: H. H. McNeil.
21.
Arizona Territory
. (1907-1908). Biennial report of the Board of Control of Arizona, 1907-1908. Government Documents, Hayden Library of Arizona State University, Tempe.
22.
Arizona Territory
. (1909). Journals of the Twenty-Fifth Legislative Assembly of the Territory of Arizona. Phoenix, AZ: State Printers.
23.
Armitage, S.
, Banfield, T., & Jacobs, S. (1977). Black women and their communities in Colorado. Frontiers, 2, 45-51.
24.
Boehringer, C.
(1929). Mary Elizabeth Post-high priestess of Americanization. Arizona Historical Review, 2, 92-100.
25.
Boehringer, C.
(1930). Josephine Brawley Hughes-crusader, state builder. Arizona Historical Review, 2, 98-107.
26.
Brenzel, B.
(1983). Daughters of the state: A social portrait of the first reform school for girls In North America, 1856-1909. Cambridge, MA: Oxford University Press.
27.
Butler, A.
(1989). Still in chains: Black women in western prisons, 1865-1910. Western Historical Quarterly, 20, 19-35.
28.
Conley, J.
(1981). Revising conceptions about the origin of prisons: The importance of economic considerations. Social Science Quarterly, 62, 247-258.
29.
Courtwright, D.
(1982). Dark paradise: Opiate addiction in America before 1940. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
30.
de Graaf, L.
(1980). Race, sex, and region: Black women in the American west, 1850-1920. Pacific Historical Review, 49, 285-313.
31.
del Castillo, R.
(1975). La familia chicana: Social changes in the Chicano family of Los Angeles 1850-1880. Journal of Ethnic Studies, 3, 41-58.
32.
Drago, H. S.
(1969). Notorious ladies of the frontier. New York, NY: Dodd.
33.
Faragher, J.
, & Stansell, C. (1975). Women and their families on the Overland Trail from California to Oregon, 1842-1867. Feminist Studies, 2, 160.
34.
Feinman, C.
(1984). An historical overview of the treatment of incarcerated women: Myths and realities of rehabilitation. Prison Journal, 63, 12-26.
35.
Foucault, M.
(1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. New York, NY: Vintage.
36.
Freedman, E.
(1981). Their sister's keepers: Women's prison reform in America, 1830-1930. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
37.
Freedman, E.
(1984). Sentiment and discipline: Women's prison experiences in nineteenth century America. Prologue, 16, 249-259.
38.
Garcia, M.
(1980). The chicana in American history: The women of El Paso, 1880-1920-a case study. Pacific Historical Review, 49, 315-337.
39.
Gill, M.
, & Goff, J. (1980). Joseph H. Kibbey and school segregation in Arizona. Journal of Arizona History, 21, 411-422.
40.
Graff, H.
(1977). Crime and punishment in the nineteenth century: A new look at the criminal. Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 7, 477-488.
41.
Hahn, N.
(1980). Female state prisoners in Tennessee: 1831-1979. Tennessee Historical Quarterly, 19, 485-497.
42.
Hart, P.
(1899, May-October). An Arizona episode. Cosmopolitan, 27, 673-677.
43.
Hawkins, D.
(1985). Trends in black-white imprisonment: Changing conceptions of race or changing patterns of social control?Crime and Social Justice, 24, 181-209.
44.
Hobsbawm, E.
(1959). Primitive rebels. New York, NY: W. W. Norton.
45.
Hobsbawm, E.
(1981). Bandits. New York, NY: Pantheon.
46.
Hull, P.
(1900). The Arizona Territorial Prison at Yuma. Arizona Graphic, 1, 1-3.
47.
Ignatieff, M.
(1978). A just measure of pain: The penitentiary in the Industrial Revolution. New York, NY: Pantheon.
48.
Jameson, E.
(1980). Women as workers, women as civilizers: True womanhood in the American west. Frontiers, 7, 1-8.
49.
Jeffrey, J.
(1969). Adobe and iron. La Jolla, CA: Clarendon Press.
50.
Johnson, S.
(1984). Sharing bed and board: Cohabitation and cultural differences in central Arizona mining towns. Frontiers, 7, 36-42.
51.
Jones, D.
(1970). Blood'n thunder: Virgins, villains, and violence in the dime novel western. Journal of Popular Culture, 4, 508-513.
52.
Katz, W.
(1987). The black west. Seattle, WA: Pacific Search.
53.
Knepper, P.
(1989). Southern-style punitive repression: Ethnic stratification, economic inequality, and imprisonment in territorial Arizona. Social Justice, 16, 132-149.
54.
Knepper, P. (1990). Imprisonment and society in Arizona Territory. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Arizona State University, Tempe.
55.
Lapp, R.
(1977). Blacks in gold rush California. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
56.
Lekkerkerker, E.
(1931). Reformatories for women in the U.S. Groningen, Netherlands: J. B. Wolters.
57.
Lewis, W.
(1961). The female criminal and the prisons of New York, 1825-1845. New York History, 42, 215-236.
58.
Luckingham, B.
(1989). Phoenix: A history of a southwestern metropolis. Tucson, AZ: University of Arizona Press.
59.
Madyun, G.
, & Malone, L. (1981). Black pioneers in San Diego, 1880-1920. San Diego History, 27, n.p.
60.
Mancini, M.
(1978). Race, economics, and the abandonment of convict leasing. Journal of Negro History, 63, 339-352.
61.
McAfee, W. M.
(1990a). The formation of prison-management philosophy in Oregon, 1843-1915. Oregon Historical Quarterly, 259-283.
62.
McAfee, W. M.
(1990b). A history of convict labor in California. Southern California Quarterly, 72, 19-40.
63.
McKanna, C.
(1985a). Ethnics and San Quentin prison registers: A comment on methodology. Journal of Social History, 18, 477-482.
64.
McKanna, C.
(1985b). The San Quentin prison pardon papers: A look at file no. 1808, the case of Francisco Javier Bonilla. Southern California Quarterly, 54, 187-196.
65.
McKanna, C.
(1987). The origins of San Quentin 1851-1880. California Quarterly, 76, 49-54.
66.
McKelvey, B.
(1933). Penology in the westward movement. Pacific Historical Review, 5, 418-438.
67.
McKelvey, B.
(1977). American prisons: A history of good intentions. Montclair, NJ: Patterson Smith.
68.
Melossi, D.
, & Pavarini, M. (1981). The prison and the factory: Origins of the penitentiary system. Totowa, NJ: Barnes and Noble.
69.
Miller, D.
(1982). Cross-cultural marriages in the southwest: The New Mexico experience 1846-1900. New Mexico Historical Review, 57, 187-201.
70.
Montejano, D.
(1987). Anglos and Mexicans in the making of Texas, 1836-1986. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
71.
Myres, S.
(1983). Women in the west. In M. P. Malone (Ed.), Historians and the American west. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
72.
The Oasis. (1897, November 20), p. 2.
73.
Pisciotta, A.
(1983). Race, sex, and rehabilitation: A study of differential treatment in the juvenile reformatory. Crime and Delinquency, 29, 254-270.
74.
Rafter, N.
(1985). Gender, prisons, and prison history. Social Science History, 9, 233-247.
75.
Rafter, N.
(1990). Partial justice: Women, prisons, and social control. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
76.
Roberts, V.
(1982). Heroines on the Arizona frontier: The first Anglo-American women. Journal of Arizona History, 23, 11-34.
77.
Roberts, V.
(1985). The women was too tough. Journal of Arizona History, 26, 395-414.
78.
Rothman, D.
(1971). The discovery of the asylum: Social order and disorder in the new republic. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
79.
Savage, W.
(1976). Blacks in the west. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
80.
Schlissel, L.
(1977). Women's diaries on the western frontier. American Studies, 18, 85-90.
81.
Schwartz, J.
(1970). The wild west show: Everything genuine. Journal of Popular Culture, 3, 656-666.
82.
Sellin, T.
(1976). Slavery and the penal system. New York, NY: Elsevier.
83.
Smith, B.
(1989). Female admissions and parolees in the western House of Refuge in the 1880s: An historical example of community corrections. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 26, 36-66.
84.
Smith, N.
(1979). Mexican stereotypes on fictional battlefields or dime novel romances of the Mexican War. Journal of Popular Culture, 13, 526-540.
85.
Spierenburg, P.
(1987). From Amsterdam to Auburn: An exploration of the rise of the prison in seventeenth-century Holland and nineteenth-century America. Journal of Social History, 20, 439-461.
86.
Stoeltje, B.
(1975). "A helpmate for man indeed": The image of the frontier woman. Journal of American Folklore, 83, 38-40.
87.
Stojkovic, S.
, Pope, C., & Feyerherm, W. (1987). Confinement patterns in the Milwaukee County House of Correction: 1907-1965. Journal of Criminal Justice, 15, 301-316.
88.
Trulio, B.
(1973). Anglo-American attitudes toward New Mexican women. Journal of the West, 12, 229-239.
89.
U.S. Bureau of the Census
. (1872). Compendium of the ninth census. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
90.
U.S. Bureau of the Census
. (1883). Compendium of the tenth census. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
91.
U.S. Bureau of the Census
. (1913). Thirteenth census of the United States. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
92.
U.S. Congress
(1853). Congressional Globe. 32 Congress, 2 session.
93.
U.S. Congress
. (1855). Congressional Globe. 33 Congress, 2 session.
94.
U.S. Congress
. (1867-1868). Congressional Globe. 39 Congress, 2 session.
95.
U.S. Congress
. (1874). House Executive Document7. 43 Congress, 2 session, serial 1638.
96.
U.S. Congress
. (1888a). House Executive Document 224. 50Congress, 1 session, serial 2560.
97.
U.S. Congress
. (1888b). House Executive Document 257. 50 Congress, 1 session, serial 2560.
98.
U.S. Congress
. (1888c). House Executive Document 268. 50 Congress, 1 session, serial 2560.
99.
U.S. Department of the Interior
. (1897). Report of the Governor of Arizona to the Secretary of the Interior. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
100.
U.S. Department of the Interior
. (1903). Report of the Governor of Arizona to the Secretary of the Interior. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
101.
U.S. Department of the Interior
. (1904). Report of the Governor of Arizona to the Secretary of the Interior. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
102.
Underwood, J.
(1985). Western women and true womanhood: Culture and symbol in history and literature. Great Plains Quarterly, 5, 93-107.
103.
Vonada, D.
(1990). Annie Oakley was more than "a crack shot in petticoats." Smithsonian, 21, 131-148.
104.
Waite, R.
(1985). Necessary to isolate the female prisoners: Women convicts and the women's yard at the Idaho penitentiary. Idaho Yesterdays, 29, 2-12.
105.
Welter, B.
(1966). The cult of true womanhood: 1820-1860. American Quarterly, 28, 151-174.
106.
Whiteside, H. O.
(1978). The drug habit in nineteenth century Colorado. Colorado Magazine, 55, 60-74.
107.
Wilson, C.
(1976). Racial reservations: Indians and blacks in American magazines, 1865-1900. Journal of Popular Culture, 10, 65-80.
108.
Zatz, M.
(1987). The changing forms of racial/ethnic biases in sentencing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 24, 69-92.
