While the mentally disordered defendant has garnered notable attention recently, little empirical research has been conducted in this area. In an attempt to fill this void, the research effort reported here examines prosecutorial and judicial decisions concerning this type of defendant. Emphasis is placed on the postures (punitive or therapeu tic) assumed by these court officials and the impact of various factors on these postures. Data were gathered on all adult criminal defendants identified as mentally disordered by the Milwaukee, Wisconsin Mental Health Screening Unit from 1981 through 1983. The results clearly indicate that criminal justice officials are at least as interested in therapy as they are in punishment. Furthermore, the findings suggest that the court views these defendants as inappropriate subjects for criminal sanctioning but under certain conditions mandates treatment for individuals who likely would not be subject to such involuntary treatment under civil law.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abramson, M.F.
(1972). The criminalization of mentally disordered behav ior: Possible side-effect of a new mental health law. Hospital and Commu nity Psychiatry, 23(4), 101-113.
2.
Bittner, E.
(1967). Police discretion in emergency apprehension of mentally ill persons. Social Problems, 14(3), 278-283.
3.
Blair, J.
(1973). Where have all the patients gone?Human Behavior, 14(2), 17-23.
4.
Bonovitz, J.C.
& Bonovitz, J.S. (1981). Diversion of the mentally ill into the criminal justice system: The police intervention perspective. American Journal of Psychiatry, 138, 973-976.
5.
Bonovitz, J.C.
& Guy, E. (1979). Impact of restrictive civil commitment pro cedures on a prison psychiatric service. American Journal of Psychiatry, 136, 1045-1048.
6.
Cocozza, J.J.
, Melick, M.E., & Steadman, H.J. (1978). Trends in violent crime among ex-mental patients. Criminology, 16, 317-334.
7.
Coie, J.S.
, Constanzo, P.R., & Cox, G. (1975). Behavioral determinants of mental illness concerns: A comparison of 'gatekeeper professions.' Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 43, 626-636.
8.
Dickey, W.
(1980). Incompetency and the nondangerous mentally ill client. Criminal Law Bulletin, 16, 22-27.
9.
Geller, J.L.
& Lister, E.D. (1978). The process of criminal commitment for pretrial psychiatric examination: An evaluation. American Journal of Psy chiatry, 135, 53-60.
10.
Goffman, E.
(1963). Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
11.
Heininger, B.L.
(1982). Incompetency to stand trial: As status, as label, and as potential source of sentencing disparity. Journal of Criminal Justice, 10, 191-198.
12.
Hochstedler, E.
(In press). Twice cursed? The mentally disordered criminal defendant. Criminal Justice and Behavior.
13.
Hochstedler, E.
(1984). Criminal prosecution of the mentally disordered. Law and Society Review, 20, 279-283.
14.
Matthews, A.R.
(1970). Observations on police policy and procedures for emergency detention of the mentally ill. Journal of Criminology, Criminal Law, and Police Science, 61, 283-287.
15.
McGarry, A.L.
(1973). Competency to stand trial and mental illness. Wash ington, DC: National Institute of Mental Health.
16.
Monahan, J.Caldiera, C.
, & Friedlander, H.D. (1980). Police and the men tally ill: A comparison of committed and arrested persons. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 2, 509-518.
17.
Roesch, R.
& Golding, S.L. (1979). Treatment and disposition of defendants found incompetent to stand trial: A review and a proposal. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 2, 349-370.
18.
Rubin, L.C.
& Mills, M.J. (1983). Behavioral precipitant to civil commit ment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 140, 5-12.
19.
Scheurman, L.
& Korbin, S. (1984). Exposure of community mental health clients to the criminal justice system: Client/criminal or patient/prisoner. In L. Teplin (Ed.), Mental health and criminal justice (pp. 87-118). Bev erly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
20.
Sheridan, E.P.
& Teplin, L.A. (1981). Police-referred psychiatric emergen cies: Advantages of community treatment. Journal of Community Psy chology, 9, 140-147.
21.
Steadman, H.J.
(1979). Beating a rap? Defendants found incompetent to stand trial. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
22.
Steadman, H.J.
& Cocozza, J.J. (1974). Careers of the criminally insane. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
23.
Steadman, H.J.
, Cocozza, I.J., & Melick, M.E. (1978). Explaining the in creased arrest rate among mental patients: The changing clientele of state hospitals. American Journal of Psychiatry, 135, 816-820.
24.
Steadman, H.J.
, Monahan, J., Duffee, B., Hartstone, E., & Robbins, P.C. (November, 1983). The impact of state mental hospital deinstitutional ization on United States prison populations, 1968-1978. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Denver, CO.
25.
Steadman, H.J.
& Ribner, S. (1978). Changing perceptions of the mental health needs of inmates in local jails. American Journal of Psychiatry, 137, 1115-1116.
26.
Steadman, H.J.Vanderwyst, D.
, & Ribner, S. (1978). Comparing arrest rates of mental patients and criminal offenders. American Journal of Psy chiatry, 135, 1218-1220.
27.
Suffet, F.
(1966). Bail setting: A study of courtroom interaction. Crime and Delinquency, 12, 318-331.
28.
Tate v. Short, 401 U.S. 395 (1971).
29.
Teplin, L.A.
(1983). The criminalization of the mentally ill: Speculation in search of data. Psychological Bulletin, 94(1), 54-62.
30.
Teplin, L.A.
, Filstead, W., Hefter, G., & Sheridan, E.P. (1980). Police in volvement with the psychiatric emergency patient. Psychiatric Annals, 10(5), 202-202.
