This article examines two related themes: the increasingly restrictive security measures in public schools and the reluctance of the courts to protect the basic Fourth Amendment rights of students. Information from academic and journalistic sources is presented regarding the impact on students from greater police presence and restrictive school security measures, including the potential harm to the learning environment. Additionally, this article reviews recent state appellate court decisions empowering police to search students using the less protective guidelines of reasonable suspicion and the "special needs" doctrine. This article also evaluates the recent United States Supreme Court decision that permits schools to conduct suspicionless drug testing of students as a condition of participating in any extracurricular activities. The results of these disciplinary policies and search tactics can be described as the "worst of both worlds," with severe penalties for even minor student misconduct without the safeguards of the Fourth Amendment.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Addington, L. A.
(1999). Assessing the constitutionality of suspicionless searches in public schools. Criminal Law Bulletin, 35, 203-233.
2.
Advancement Project/Civil Rights Project
. (2000). Opportunities suspended: The devastating consequences of zero tolerance and school discipline policies. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
3.
A.J.M. v. State, 617 So.2d 1137 (Fla. App. I Dist. 1993).
4.
Anderson, D. C.
(1998). Curriculum, culture, and community: The challenge of school violence. Crime and Justice, 24, 317-342.
5.
Ayers, W.
(1997/1998). The criminalization of youth. Rethinking schools. Accessed July 12, 2003, from http://www.rethinkingschools.org/archive/12_02/12_02.shtml.
6.
Bailey, K. A.
(2001). Legal implications of profiling students for violence. Psychology in the Schools, 38(2), 141-155.
7.
Bates, K.
, & Hollingsworth, H. (1999, March 16). Student parking sparks clash over Fourth Amendment. Topeka Capital Journal, p. 12.
8.
Black, S.
(1999, January). Why suspension and expulsion should be your court of last resort. American School Board Journal, pp. 34-37.
9.
Board of Education of Independent School District No. 92 of Pottawatomie County v. Lindsey Earls et al., 536 U.S. 822(2002).
10.
Brady, K. P.
(2002). Zero tolerance or (in)tolerance policies? Weaponless school violence, due process, and the law of student suspensions and expulsions: An examination of Fuller v. Decatur Public School Board of Education School District. Brigham Young University Education & Law Journal, 21, 159-209.
11.
Brener, N. D.
, Simon, T. R., Krug, E. G., & Lowry, R. (1999). Recent trends in violence-related behaviors among high school students in the United States. Journal of the American Medical Association, 282(5), 440-446.
12.
Brooks, K.
, Schiraldi, V., & Ziedenberg, J. (2001). School house hype: Two years later. Justice Policy Institute/Children's Law Center. Accessed July 12, 2003, from http://www.cjcj.org/pubs/schoolhouse/shh2.html.
13.
Buffaloe, J. Y.
(1997). Note: Special needs and the Fourth Amendment. An exception poised to swallow the warrant preference rule. Harvard Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Law Review, 32, 529-562.
14.
Bureau of Justice Statistics
. (2000). Local police departments 1997. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
15.
Camara v. Municipal Court, 387 U.S. 523 (1967).
16.
Chaddock, G. R.
(1999, August 24). Safe schools at a price. Christian Science Monitor, p. 15.
17.
Chandler v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 (1997).
18.
Chiang, H.
(1997, March 20). Suit filed over drug searches: School officials use dogs to sniff students' belongings. San Francisco Chronicle, p. A16.
19.
Commonwealth v. Cass, 709 A.2d 350 (Pa. S.Ct. 1998).
20.
Commonwealth v. Dingfelt, 323 A.2d 145 (Pa. Super. 1974).
21.
Commonwealth v. J.B., 719 A.2d 1058 (Pa. Super. 1998).
22.
Cook-Sather, A.
(2002). Find out what it means to me respect: The scholarship of teaching and learning. Academic Exchange Quarterly, 6, 168-173.
23.
Devine, J.
(1995). Can metal detectors replace the panopticon?Cultural Anthropology, 10, 171-195.
24.
Devine, J.
(1996). Maximum security: The culture of violence in inner-city schools. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
25.
Dodson, R. D.
(2000). Ten years of randomized jurisprudence: Amending the special needs doctrine. South Carolina Law Review, 51, 258-289.
26.
Dohm, B.
(2001). Look out, kid, it's something you did: Zero tolerance for children. In W. Ayers, B. Dohm, & R. Ayers (Eds.), Zero tolerance: Resisting the drive for punishment in our schools (pp. 89-113). New York: New Press.
27.
D.R.C. v. State, 646 P.2d 252 (Alaska Ct. App. 1982).
28.
Dunn, M. J.
(1999). Police liaison for schools. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 68(9), 7-8.
29.
Easterbrook, M.
(1999). The classroom is becoming a police state. Psychology Today, 32(4), 52-56.
30.
Edwards, C. H.
(2001). Student violence and the moral dimensions of education. Psychology in the Schools, 38(3), 249-257.
31.
Fitzgerald, M.
(2000, April 11). Lockdown drills prepare students for guns, other emergencies. Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service. Accessed July 18, 2003, from http://web5.infotrac-college.comJwadsworth/session/805/297/63028966/sig!1.
32.
Gamer, B. A.
(1999). Black's law dictionary (7th ed.). St. Paul, MN: West Group.
33.
Gaughan, E.
, Cerio, J. D., & Myers, R. A. (2001). Lethal violence in schools: A national study. Alfred, NY: Alfred University.
34.
Gendar, A.
(1999, March 29). Detecting students frustration. New York Daily News, p. 1.
35.
Gips, M. A.
(2002). A good resource for schools?Security Management, 46(4), 18-19.
36.
Giroux, H. A.
(2001). Zero tolerance: Examples that demonstrate overzealousness to prevent violence. Tikkun, 16, 29-37.
37.
Glazer, S.
(1992). Violence in schools. CQ Researcher, 34, 785-808.
38.
Gottfredson, D. C.
(1986). An empirical test of school-based environmental and individual interventions to reduce the risk of delinquent behavior. Criminology, 24, 705-731.
39.
Gottfredson, D. C.
, Gottfredson, G. D., & Hybl, L. G. (1993). Managing adolescent behavior: A multiyear, multischool study. American Educational Research Journal, 30, 179-215.
40.
Hancock, L.
(2001). The school shootings: Why context counts. Columbia Journalism Review, 40, 76-80.
41.
Hanson, L. T.
(2002). Note: Psst! Janie's got a gun. Anonymous tips and the Fourth Amendment search and seizure rights in schools. Georgia Law Review, 37, 267-297.
42.
Hollingsworth, H.
(1999, May 19). Middle schools ban pagers-laser pointers. Topeka Capital Journal, p. 11.
43.
Howell, J. C.
(1997). Juvenile justice and youth violence. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
44.
Hyman, I. A.
, & Perone, D. C. (1998). The other side of school violence: Educator policies and practices that may contribute to student misbehavior. Journal of Social Psychology, 36, 7-27.
45.
Imbriani, J. E.
(1995). Metal detectors in public schools: A subtle sacrifice of privacy interests. Seaton Hall Constitutional Law Journal, 6, 189-219.
46.
In the Interest of Thomas B.D., 486 S.E.2d 498 (S.C. App. 1997).
47.
In the Matter of Ana E., N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 53 (N.Y. Ct. App. 2002).
48.
In the Matter of Gregory M., 627 N.E.2d 500 (N.Y. Ct. App. 1993).
49.
In the Matter of Josue T., 989 P.2d 431 (N.M. Ct. App. 1999).
50.
In Re D.D., 554 S.E.2d 346 (N.C. App. 2001).
51.
In Re Donaldson, 75 Cal. Rptr. 220 (Cal. App. 2d 1969).
52.
In Re F.B., 726 A.2d 361 (Pa. Super. 1999).
53.
In Re Thomas G., 90 Cal. Rptr. 361 (Cal. App. 11970).
54.
Insley, A. C.
(2001). Comment: Suspending and expelling children from educational opportunity: Time to reevaluate zero tolerance policies. American University Law Review, 50, 1039-1077.
55.
Jacobs, T. L.
(2000). School violence: An incurable social ill that should not lead to the unconstitutional compromise of students' rights. Duquesne University Law Review, 38, 617-667.
Johnson, I. M.
(1999). School violence: The effectiveness of a school resource officer program in a southern city. Journal of Criminal Justice, 27, 173-192.
58.
Josephson Institute of Ethics
. (2001). Report card: Violence and substance abuse. Accessed July 12,2003, from http://www.josephsoninstitute.org/Survey2000/violence2000-commentary.htm.
59.
Kaplan, L. S.
, & Owings, W. A. (2000). Helping kids feel safe, valued, and competent. Education Digest, 66, 24-29.
Lavarello, C.
(2000). School based policing: Specialized training will ease liability. ASLET, 15(6), 2-6.
63.
Lawrence, R.
(1998). School crime and juvenile justice. New York: Oxford University Press.
64.
Lewis, A.
(1999). Drug testing: Can privacy interests be protected under the special needs doctrine?Brooklyn Law Review, 56, 1013-1044.
65.
Loyd, J.
(2000, May 31). Change in tactics: Police trade talk for rapid response. Christian Science Monitor, p. 2.
66.
Lush, K.
(2000). Expanding the rights of children in public schools. New England Journal on Criminal and Civil Confinement, 26, 95-117.
67.
Martinez, J. C.
(2000, August 4). School anti-violence law touted data-sharing designed to head off attacks. Denver Post, p. B12.
68.
Mayer, M. J.
, & Leone, P. E. (1999). A structural analysis of school violence and disruption: Implications for creating safer schools. Education and Treatment of Children, 23, 333-356.
69.
McIntyre, J. B.
(2000). Empowering schools to search: The effect of growing drug and violence concerns on American schools. University of illinois Law Review, 47, 1025-1052.
70.
Mello, M.
(2002). Friendly fire: Privacy vs. security after September 11. Criminal Law Bulletin, 38, 367-395.
71.
Mercer v. State, 450 S.W.2d 715 (Tex. Cir. App. 1970).
72.
Miller v. Wilkes, 172 F.3d 574 (8th Cir. 1999).
73.
Minow, M.
(1995). What ever happened to children's rights?Minnesota Law Review, 80, 267-298.
Mulqueen, C.
(1999). School resource officers more than guards. American School & University, 71, 17-19.
76.
National Center for Education Statistics
. (1998). Violence and discipline problems in U.S. public schools: 1996-97. Accessed July 18, 2003, from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid--98030.
77.
National Center for Education Statistics
. (2001). Indicators of school crime and safety, 2001. Accessed July 12, 2003, from http://nces.ed.gov/Pubs2002/crime200l/.
78.
New Jersey v. T.L.O., 469 U.S. 325 (1985).
79.
Noguera, P.
(1995). Preventing and producing violence: A critical analysis of responses to school violence. Harvard Educational Review, 65, 189-212.
80.
O'Leary, A.
(2001, April 5). In many schools police are becoming part of the curriculum. Boston Globe, pp. 3-5.
81.
Olivo, A.
(2000, August 30). Lockless lockers leave students sore and disillusioned. Los Angeles Times, p. B1.
82.
Peden, J. M.
(2001). Through a glass darkly: Educating with zero tolerance. Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy, 10, 369-398.
83.
People v. Avalos, 47 Cal. App.4th 1569 (Cal. App. 1996).
84.
People v. Dilworth, 661 N.E.2d 310 (111. 1996).
85.
People v. Pruitt, 662 N.E.2d 540 (Ill. App. 1 Dist. 1996).
86.
Peterson, J.
(2001, June 27). Santee school shootings: Shootings result in privacy tradeoffs. Los Angeles Times, p. 5.
87.
R.C.M. v. State, 660 S.W.2d 552 (Tex. App. 1983).
88.
Reed, C.
, & Strahan, D. B. (1995). Gentle discipline in violent times. Journal for a Just & Caring Education, 3, 320-335.
89.
Richey, W.
(1998, August 12). Latest hot school gear: Photo IDs. Christian Science Monitor, p. 1.
90.
Rosenberg, I. M.
(2000). The Supreme Court, the Fourth Amendment, and the public schools: An ominous mixture. Criminal Law Bulletin, 36, 360-372.
91.
Rosenzweig, E. M.
(2002). Comment: Please don't tell. The question of confidentiality in student disciplinary records under FERPA and the Crime Awareness and Campus Security Act. Emory Law Journal, 51, 447-481.
92.
Sanchez, J. M.
(1992). Expelling the Fourth Amendment from American schools: Students' rights six years afterT.L.O. Journal of Law & Education, 21, 381-413.
93.
Santillanes, V.
(1997, May 29). APS bans sagging clothes. Albuquerque Journal, p. Al.
94.
Schiraldi, V.
(1999, December 6). Perception isn't reality when it comes to teen violence. Houston Chronicle, p. A25.
95.
Schreck, M.
(1993). The Fourth Amendment in the public schools: Issues for the 1990s and beyond. Urban Lawyer, 25, 117-157.
96.
Silva, P.
, & Macklin, R. A. (2002). Standards of mind and heart: Creating the good high school. New York: Teachers College Press.
97.
Simpson, K.
(2001, April 15). Columbine effect: Fear over reality. Denver Post, p. 5.
98.
Skiba, R. J.
, & Peterson, R. L. (2000). School discipline at a crossroads: From zero tolerance to early response. Exceptional Child, 66, 335-346.
99.
Smith, D.
(1999, September 11). Student protest in walkout at Fremont High. Los Angeles Times, p. B1.
100.
State v. Angelia D.B., 564 N.W.2d 682 (Wis. 1997).
101.
State v. Barrett, 683 So.2d 331 (La. App. 1 Cir. 1996).
102.
State v. D.S., 685 So.2d 41 (Fla. App. 3 Dist. 1996).
103.
State v. J.A., 679 So.2d 316 (Fla. App. 3 Dist. 1996).
104.
State v. N.G.B., 806 So.2d 567 (Fla. App. 2 Dist. 2002).
105.
State v. Serna, 860 P.2d 1320 (Ariz. App. 1993).
106.
State v. Tywayne H., 933 P.2d 251 (N.M. Ct. App. 1997).
107.
Teachers across the nation are offered homicide insurance
. (2001). Correctional educational bulletin. Accessed July 19, 2003, from http://www.lexis-nexis.com/universe.document?_m=b24b9d25832c2f43070b38a401d361a5.
108.
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, 393 U.S. 503 (1969).
109.
Todd v. Rush County Schools, 133 F.3d 984 (7th Cir. 1998).
110.
Vail, K.
(1997, April). Should juvenile records be open to schools?American School Board Journal, pp. 40-41.
111.
Vanderpool, T.
(1999, June 7). Drug dogs: Deterrent or invasion of student rights?Christian Science Monitor, p.2.
112.
Vaughn, M. S.
, & del Carmen, R. V. (1997). The Fourth Amendment as a tool of actuarial justice: The "special needs" exception to the warrant and probable cause requirements. Crime & Delinquency, 43, 78-103.
113.
Vernonia School District 47J v. Acton, 515 U.S. 646 (1995).
114.
Watkins, D. W.
, & Hooks, J. S. (2000). The legal aspects of school violence: Balancing school safety with students' rights. Mississippi Law Journal, 69, 641-713.
115.
Weber v. Oakridge School District, 56 P.3d 504 (Or. App. 2002).
116.
Winter, G.
(2003, May 17). Study finds no sign that testing deters students' drug use. New York Times, pp. A1, A12.
117.
Zirkel, P. A.
(2000). Counterpoint: Are the public schools detectably safe?Journal of Law & Education, 29, 193-195.
