Examinations of racial disparity in criminal justice Processing have commonly focused on sentencing. However, many earlier decisions affect an eventual case outcome. To adequately assess the impact of race on criminal processing it is therefore necessary to analyze presentence decision making. In particular, the power of the prosecutor has burgeoned with the advent of sentencing guidelines, mandatory minimum statutes, and so-called three-strikes laws. A total of 68 studies are analyzed for evidence supportive of the discrimination thesis that African-Americans are subjects of racial bias in criminal processing. Bail and pretrial release decisions, the decision to prosecute or to dismiss, and capital charging decisions are examined. Shortcomings of the research are noted and the consequences of these shortcomings on the race-criminal processing nexus are discussed. The article concludes with a discussion of areas for future research, including (a) the impact of legislative mandates on the race-presentencing nexus, (b) the role of race in decisions to waive dug offenders into drug courts, (c) the impact of victim race on bail and pretrial release decisions and on offenses other than sexual assault and homicide, (d) the impact of prosecutor race on presentence decision making, (e) the impact of courtroom culture or environment on presentence decision making, and (f) the effect of "outside" influences on the decisions of courtroom actors.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, K.
, & Cutshall, C. (1987). Refusing to prosecute minor offenses: The relative influence of legal and extralegal factors. Justice Quarterly, 4, 595-609.
2.
Albonetti, C.
(1986). Criminality, prosecutorial screening, and uncertainty: Toward a theory of discretionary decision making in felony case processings. Criminology, 24, 623-644.
3.
Albonetti, C.
(1987). Prosecutorial discretion: The effects of uncertainty. Law & Society Review, 21, 291-313.
4.
Albonetti, C.
(1989). Bail and judicial discretion in the District of Columbia. Sociology & Social Research, 74, 40-47.
5.
Albonetti, C.
, Hauser, R., Hagan, J., & Nagel, I. (1989). Criminal justice decision making as a stratification process: The role of race and stratification resources in pretrial release. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 5, 57-82.
6.
Applegate, A.
(1982). Prosecutorial discretion and discrimination in the decision to charge. Temple Law Quarterly, 55, 35-88.
7.
Ares, C.
, Rankin, A., & Sturz, H. (1963). The Manhattan Bail Project: An interim report on the use of pre-trial parole. New York University Law Review, 38, 67-95.
8.
Ayres, I.
, & Waldfogel, I. (1994). A market test for race discrimination in bail setting. Stanford Law Review, 46, 987-1047.
9.
Baldus, D.
, Pulaski, C., & Woodworth, G. (1983). Comparative review of death sentences: An empirical study of the Georgia experience. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 74, 661-753.
10.
Baldus, D.
, Woodworth, G., & Pulaski, C. (1990). Equal justice and the death penalty: A legal and empirical analysis. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
11.
Barnes, C.
, & Kingsnorth, R. (1996). Race, drug, and criminal sentencing: Hidden effects of the criminal law. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 39-55.
12.
Baumer, E.
, Messner, S., & Felson, R. (2000). The role of victim characteristics in the disposition of murder cases. Justice Quarterly, 17, 281-307.
13.
Beck, A.
(2000). Prisoners in 1999. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
14.
Berger, R.
, Free, M., & Searles, P. (2001). Crime, justice, and society: Criminology and the sociological imagination. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
15.
Bernstein, I.
, Cardascia, J., & Ross, C. (1979). Defendant's sex and criminal court decisions. In R. Alvarez & K. Lutterman (Eds.), Discrimination in organizations: Using social indicators to manage social change (pp. 329-354). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
16.
Bernstein, I.
, Kelly, W., & Doyle, P. (1977). Societal reaction to deviants: The case of criminal defendants. American Sociological Review, 42, 743-755.
17.
Bienen, L.
, Weiner, N., Denno, D., Allison, P., & Mills, D. (1988). The reimposition of capital punishment in New Jersey: The role of prosecutorial discretion. Rutgers Law Review, 41, 27-361.
18.
Bishop, D.
, & Frazier, C. (1984). The effects of gender on charge reduction. Sociological Quarterly, 25, 385-396.
19.
Bock, E.
, & Frazier, C. (1977). Official standards versus actual criteria in bond dispositions. Journal of Criminal Justice, 5, 321-328.
20.
Bowers, W.
(1983). The pervasiveness of arbitrariness and discrimination under post-Furman capital statutes. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 74, 1067-1100.
21.
Bowers, W.
, & Pierce, G. (1980). Arbitariness and discrimination under post-Furman capital statutes. Crime & Delinquency, 26, 563-635.
22.
Brown, J.
, & Langan, P. (1999). Felony sentences in the United States, 1996. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
23.
Bureau of Justice Assistance
. (1998). 1996 national survey of state sentencing structures. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
24.
Bynum, T.
(1982). Release on recognizance: Substantive or superficial reform?Criminology, 20, 67-82.
25.
Chiricos, T.
, & Bales, W. (1991). Unemployment and punishment: An empirical assessment. Criminology, 29, 701-724.
26.
Chiricos, T.
, & Crawford, C. (1995). Race and imprisonment: A contextual assessment of the evidence. In D. F. Hawkins (Ed.), Ethnicity, race, and crime: Perspectives across time and place (pp. 281-309). Albany: State University of New York Press.
27.
Cole, D.
(1999). No equal justice: Race and class in the American criminal justice system. New York: New Press.
28.
Crew, B.
(1991). Race differences in felony charging and sentencing: Toward an integration of decision-making and negotiation models. Journal of Crime & Justice, 14, 99-122.
29.
Curran, D.
(1983). Judicial discretion and defendant's sex. Criminology, 21, 41-58.
30.
Dalaker, J.
, & Proctor, B. (2000). Poverty in the United States: 1999. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
31.
Davis, A.
(1998). Prosecution and race: The power and privilege of discretion. Fordham Law Review, 67, 13-67.
32.
Death Penalty Information Center
. (2001). Race and defendants executed since 1976. Retrieved March 30,2002, from http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.orgldpicrace.html.
33.
Dorning, M.
(2000, July 24). Federal death sentences show race gap. Chicago Tribune, pp. 1, 6 (section 1).
34.
Eterno, J.
(1993, March). Ethnicity and sentencing: A study of the effect of ethnicity on sentencing of female prostitutes in New York City. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, Kansas City, MO.
35.
Ewing, J.
, & Houston, B. (1991, June 18). Inequalities in bail persist 10 years after reforms. Hartford Courant, pp. A1, A6.
36.
Farnworth, M.
, & Horan, P. (1980). Separate justice: An analysis of race differences in court processes. Social Science Research, 9, 381-399.
37.
Farrell, R.
, & Swigert, V. (1986). Adjudication in homicide: An interpretive analysis of the effects of defendant and victim social characteristics. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency, 23, 349-369.
38.
Feeley, M.
(1979). The process is the punishment: Handling cases in a lower criminal court. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
39.
Foley, L.
, & Powell, R. (1982). The discretion of prosecutors, judges, and juries in capital cases. Criminal Justice Review, 7, 16-22.
40.
Foote, C.
(1959). The bail system and equal justice. Federal Probation, 23, 43-48.
41.
Frazier, C.
, Bock, E., & Henretta, J. (1980). Pretrial release and bail decisions: The effects of legal, community, and personal variables. Criminology, 18, 162-181.
42.
Free, M., Jr.
(1996). African Americans and the criminal justice system. New York: Garland.
43.
Free, M., Jr.
(2001). Racial bias and the American criminal justice system: Race and presentencing revisited. Critical Criminology, 10, 195-223.
44.
Furman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238 (1972).
45.
Ghali, M.
, & Chesney-Lind, M. (1986). Gender bias and the criminal justice system: An empirical investigation. Sociology & Social Research, 70, 164-171.
46.
Hagan, J.
(1974). Extra-legal attributes and criminal sentencing: An assessment of a sociological viewpoint. Law & Society Review, 8, 357-383.
47.
Holmes, M.
, & Daudistel, H. (1984). Ethnicity and justice in the southwest: The sentencing of Anglo, black, and Mexican origin defendants. Social Science Quarterly, 65, 265-277.
48.
Holmes, M.
, Daudistel, H., & Farrell, R. (1987). Determinants of charge reductions and final dispositions in cases of burglary and robbery. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency, 24, 233-254.
49.
Holmes, M.
, Hosch, H., Daudistel, H., Perez, D., & Graves, J. (1996). Ethnicity, legal resources, and felony dispositions in two southwestern jurisdictions. Justice Quarterly, 13, 11-30.
50.
Horney, J.
, & Spohn, C. (1996). The influence of blame and believability factors on the processing of simple versus aggravated rape cases. Criminology, 34, 135-162.
51.
Humphrey, J.
, & Fogarty, T. (1987). Race and plea bargained outcomes: A research note. Social Forces, 66, 176-182.
52.
Jackson, P.
(1986). Black visibility, city size, and social control. Sociological Quarterly, 27, 185-203.
53.
Jackson, P.
, & Carroll, L. (1981). Race and the war on crime: The sociopolitical determinants of municipal police expenditures in 90 non-southern U.S. cities. American Sociological Review, 46, 290-305.
54.
Jacoby, J.
, & Paternoster, R. (1982). Sentencing disparity and jury packing: Further challenges to the death penalty. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 73, 379-387.
55.
Juszkiewicz, J.
(1993, March). More evidence of racial and ethnic disparity in criminal justice outcomes: Is it more evidence of racial and ethnic bias? Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, Kansas City, MO.
56.
Keil, T.
, & Vito, G. (1989). Race, homicide severity, and application of the death penalty: A consideration of the Barnett scale. Criminology, 27, 511-535.
57.
Keil, T.
, & Vito, G. (1990). Race and the death penalty in Kentucky murder trials: An analysis of post-Gregg outcomes. Justice Quarterly, 7, 189-207.
58.
Keil, T.
, & Vito, G. (1995). Race and the death penalty in Kentucky murder trials: 1976-1991. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 20, 17-36.
59.
Kempf, K.
, & Austin, R. (1986). Older and more recent evidence on racial discrimination in sentencing. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2, 29-48.
60.
Kingsnorth, R.
, Lopez, J., Wentworth, J., & Cummings, D. (1998). Adult sexual assault: The role of racial/ethnic composition in prosecution and sentencing. Journal of Criminal Justice, 26, 359-371.
61.
Kleck, G.
(1981). Racial discrimination in criminal sentencing: A critical evaluation of the evidence with additional evidence on the death penalty. American Sociological Review, 46, 783-805.
62.
Kramer, J.
, & Steffensmeir, D. (1993). Race and imprisonment decisions. Sociological Quarterly, 34, 357-376.
63.
Kruttschnitt, C.
(1984). Sex and criminal court dispositions: The unresolved controversy. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency, 21, 213-232.
64.
LaFree, G.
(1980). The effect of sexual stratification by race on official reactions to rape. American Sociological Review, 45, 842-854.
65.
Landes, W.
(1974). Legality and reality: Some evidence on criminal procedure. Journal of Legal Studies, 3, 287-337.
66.
Lizotte, A.
(1978). Extra-legal factors in Chicago's criminal courts: Testing the conflict model of criminal justice. Social Problems, 25, 564-580.
67.
Lynch, M.
(1990). Racial bias and criminal justice: Definitional and methodological issues. In B. MacLean & D. Milovanovic (Eds.), Racism, empiricism, and criminal justice (pp. 35-42). Vancouver, Canada: Collective Press.
68.
Maguire, K.
, & Pastore, A. (1999). Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics—1998. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
69.
Mann, C. R.
(1984). Race and sentencing of female felons: A field study. International Study of Women's Studies, 7, 160-172.
70.
Mann, C. R.
(1993). Unequal justice. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
71.
McCleskey v. Kemp, 481 U.S. 279 (1987).
72.
Murphy, E.
(1984). Application of the death penalty in Cook County. Illinois Bar Journal, 93, 90-95.
73.
Myers, M.
(1982). Common law in action: The prosecution of felonies and misdemeanors. Sociological Inquiry, 52, 1-15.
74.
Myers, M.
, & Hagan, J. (1979). Private and public trouble: Prosecutors and the allocation of court resources. Social Problems, 26, 439-451.
75.
Myrdal, G.
(1944). An American dilemma: The Negro problem and modern democracy. New York: Harper.
76.
Nagel, I.
(1983). The legal/extra-legal controversy: Judicial decisions in pretrial release. Law & Society Review, 17, 481-515.
77.
Nagel, I.
, Cardascia, J., & Ross, C. (1982). Sex differences in the processing of criminal defendants. In D. K. Weisberg (Ed.), Women and the law: A social historical perspective (Vol. 1, pp. 259-282). Cambridge, MA: Schenkman.
78.
Nagel, S.
, & Weitzman, L. (1979). Women as litigants. In F. Adler & R. Simon (Eds.), The criminology of deviant women (pp. 264-272). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
79.
Nakell, B.
, & Hardy, K. (1987). The arbitrariness of the death penalty. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
80.
Pallesen, T.
(1991, June 3). Bias accused in supervised jail releases: Whites freed more often among suspects who can't afford bail. Palm Beach Post, p. Al.
81.
Pastore, A.
, & Maguire, K. (2000). Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics 1999. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
82.
Paternoster, R.
(1983). Race of victim and location of crime: The decision to seek the death penalty in South Carolina. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 74, 754-785.
83.
Paternoster, R.
(1984). Prosecutorial discretion in requesting the death penalty: A case of victim-based racial discrimination. Law & Society Review, 18, 437-478.
84.
Paternoster, R.
, & Kazyaka, A. (1988). The administration of the death penalty in South Carolina: Experiences over the first few years. South Carolina Law Review, 39, 245-411.
85.
Patterson, E.
, & Lynch, M. (1991). Bias in formalized bail procedures. In M. Lynch & E. Patterson (Eds.), Race and criminal justice (pp. 36-53). Albany, NY: Harrow & Heston.
86.
Petee, T.
(1994). Recommended for release on recognizance: Factors affecting pretrial release recommendations. Journal of Social Psychology, 134, 375-382.
87.
Petersilia, I.
(1983). Racial disparities in the criminal justice system. Santa Monica, CA: Rand.
88.
Pokorak, J.
(1998). Probing the capital prosecutor's perspective: Race of the discretionary actors. Cornell Law Review, 83, 1811-1820.
89.
Pratt, T.
(1998). Race and sentencing: A meta-analysis of conflicting empirical research results. Journal of Criminal Justice, 26, 513-523.
90.
Radelet, M.
(1981). Racial characteristics and the imposition of the death penalty. American Sociological Review, 46, 918-927.
91.
Rankin, A.
(1964). The effect of pretrial detention. New York University Law Review, 39, 641-655.
92.
Rauma, D.
(1984). Going for the gold: Prosecutorial decision making in cases of wife assault. Social Science Research, 13, 321-351.
93.
Rohrlich, T.
, & Tulsky, F. (1996, December 3). Not all L.A. murder cases are equal. Los Angeles Times, pp.A1, A14-A15.
94.
Schmitt, C.
(1991, December 8). Plea bargaining favors whites as blacks, Hispanics pay price. San Jose Mercury News, p. 1A.
95.
Snell, T.
(1999). Capital punishment 1998. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
96.
Sorensen, J.
, & Wallace, D. (1995). Capital punishment in Missouri: Examining the issue of race. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 13, 61-80.
97.
Sorensen, J.
, & Wallace, D. (1999). Prosecutorial discretion in seeking death: An analysis of racial disparity in the pretrial stages of case processing in a midwestern county. Justice Quarterly, 16, 559-578.
98.
Spears, J.
, & Spohn, C. (1997). The effect of evidence factors and victim characteristics on prosecutors' charging decisions in sexual assault cases. Justice Quarterly, 14, 501-524.
99.
Spohn, C.
(1990a). Decision making in sexual assault cases: Do black and female judges make a difference?Women & Criminal Justice, 2, 83-105.
100.
Spohn, C.
(1990b). The sentencing decisions of black and white judges: Expected and unexpected similarities. Law & Society Review, 24, 1197-1216.
101.
Spohn, C.
(2000). Thirty years of sentencing reform: The quest for a racially-neutral sentencing process. In U.S. Department of Justice (Ed.), NIJ Criminal Justice 2000 (Vol. 3, pp. 427-501). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
102.
Spohn, C.
, Gruhl, J., & Welch, S. (1987). The impact of the ethnicity and gender of defendants on the decision to reject or dismiss felony charges. Criminology, 25, 175-191.
103.
Spohn, C.
, & Holleran, D. (2000). The imprisonment penalty paid by young, unemployed black, and Hispanic male offenders. Criminology, 38, 281-306.
104.
Spohn, C.
, & Holleran, D. (2001). Prosecuting sexual assault: A comparison of charging decisions in sexual assault cases involving strangers, acquaintances, and intimate partners. Justice Quarterly, 18, 651-688.
105.
Spohn, C.
, & Horney, J. (1993). Rape law reform and the effect of victim characteristics on case processing. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 9, 383-409.
106.
Spohn, C.
, & Spears, J. (1996). The effect of offender and victim characteristics on sexual assault case processing decisions. Justice Quarterly, 13, 649-679.
107.
Steury, E.
, & Frank, N. (1990). Gender bias and pretrial release: More pieces of the puzzle. Journal of Criminal Justice, 18, 417-432.
108.
Stryker, R.
, Nagel, I., & Hagan, J. (1983). Methodological issues in court research: Pretrial release decisions for federal defendants. Sociological Methods & Research, 11, 469-500.
109.
U.S. General Accounting Office
. (1990). Death penalty sentencing: Research indicates pattern of racial disparities. Washington, DC: U.S. General Accounting Office.
110.
Uhlman, T.
(1978). Black elite decision making: The case of trial judges. American Journal of Political Science, 22, 884-895.
111.
Unnever, J.
(1982). Direct and organizational discrimination in the sentencing of drug offenders. Social Problems, 30, 212-225.
112.
Vito, G.
, & Keil, T. (1988). Capital sentencing in Kentucky: An analysis of the factors influencing decision making in the post-Gregg period. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 79, 483-503.
113.
Walker, S.
, Spohn, C., & DeLone, M. (1996). The color of justice: Race, ethnicity, and crime in America. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
114.
Walker, T.
, & Barrow, D. (1985). The diversification of the federal bench: Policy and process ramifications. Journal of Politics, 47, 596-617.
115.
Weitzer, R.
(1996). Racial discrimination in the criminal justice system: Findings and problems in the literature. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 309-322.
116.
Welch, S.
, Gruhl, J., & Spohn, C. (1984). Dismissal, conviction, and incarceration of Hispanic defendants: A comparison with Anglos and blacks. Social Science Quarterly, 65, 257-263.
117.
Wilbanks, W.
(1987). The myth of a racist criminal justice system. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
118.
Wriggens, J.
(1995). Rape, racism, and the law. In P. Searles & R. Berger (Eds.), Rape and society (pp. 215-222). Boulder, CO: Westview.
