Experimental Study and Simple Failure Analysis of Stitched J-Stiffened Composite Shear Panels

Abstract

Two fuselage type, stitched composite shear panels with J-shape stiffeners manufactured through the process of Resin Transfer Molding technique were tested. Through the diagonal tension tests, it was found that failure of each panel occurred at approximately 3.5 times its initial buckling load, indicating significant diagonal tension strength. Neither of the panels failed by stiffener “pop-off,” showing that the stitching helps to inhibit this failure mode. No other damage or delamination of the panel was visible as well.

The newly developed generalized Yeh-Stratton (Y-S) failure criterion was used to evaluate the failure of these composite panels. Compared with several other failure criteria, the calculated failure loads are quite close to experimental results and all are conservative. The Y-S criterion is the most conservative for this case.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Madan

R. C.

1989. “The Influence of Low Velocity Impact on Composite Structures,” ASTM Third Symposium on Composite Materials: Fatigue and Fracture, Orlando, FL, Nov. 6–9.

2. Kim

C. H.

Yen

H.-Y.

. 1994. “Development of a New Yielding Criterion: The Yeh-Stratton Criterion,” Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 47(4):569–582.

3. Yeh

H.-Y.

Kim

C. H.

. 1994. “The Yeh-Stratton Criterion for Composite Materials,” Journal of Composite Materials, 38(10):926–939.

Davis

R. C.

1980. “Stress Analysis and Buckling of J-Stiffened Graphite-Epoxy Panel,” NASA Technical Paper 1607, NASA Scientific and Technical Information Office.

Agarwal

B. L.

1980. “Postbuckling Behavior of Composite Shear Webs,” AIAA Paper 80-0689.

Hart-Smith

L. J.

1990. “A Strain Based Maximum Shear Stress Failure Criteria for Fibrous Composites,” 31st AIAA/ASME/AHS/ASC Structures. Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, Long Beach, CA, April 2–4.

7. Yeh

H.-Y

Yeh

H. L.

. 1989. “Stress Concentration of the Composite Material Used by X-29A Forward-Swept Wine Aircraft Under Various Temperature Levels,” Composite Structures 5, New York.

Jones

R. M.

1975. Mechanics of Composite Materials, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, New York.

9. Yeh

H.-Y.

Chen

V. L.

. 1993. “Structural Instability Behavior and Material Failure of J-Stiffened Composite Fuselage Panels,” Final Project Report, NSF Grant No. MSS-9213705. Dec.