Hybrid bonding-fastening is an alternative joining technique that consists of simultaneous adhesive bonding and mechanical fastening of the adherends. In this paper, pertinent scientific publications are selected and reviewed in an attempt to synthesize the current knowledge on various aspects of this technique. A particular focus is maintained on its application in composite structures. Two major bonding-fastening methods, namely bonding-bolting and bonding-pinning, are identified and contrasted, and the characteristics of each are discussed. Existing gaps in the literature are identified. Finally, perspectives for future research are assessed.
Messler R. Joining of materials and structures: from pragmatic process to enabling technology. New York, NY: Butterworth-Heinemann, 2004.
2.
GodwinEMatthewsF. A review of the strength of joints in fibre-reinforced plastics. Part 1. Mechanically fastened joints. Composites1980; 11: 155–160.
3.
MatthewsFKiltyPGodwinE. A review of the strength of joints in fibre-reinforced plastics. Part 2. Adhesively bonded joints. Composites1982; 13: 29–37.
4.
AdamsRCawleyP. A review of defect types and nondestructive testing techniques for composites and bonded joints. NDT Int1988; 21: 208–222.
5.
AdamsRCawleyP. Strength predictions for lap joints, especially with composite adherends. A review. J Adhes1989; 30: 219–242.
6.
CamanhoPMatthewsF. Stress analysis and strength prediction of mechanically fastened joints in FRP: a review. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf1997; 28: 529–547.
7.
ThoppulSFineganJGibsonR. Mechanics of mechanically fastened joints in polymer-matrix composite structures a review. Compos Sci Technol2009; 69: 301–329.
8.
HuhneCZerbstAKuhlmannG. Progressive damage analysis of composite bolted joints with liquid shim layers using constant and continuous degradation models. Compos Struct2010; 92: 189–200.
9.
ZhaiYLiDWangL. An experimental study on the effect of joining interface condition on bearing response of single-lap, countersunk composite-aluminum bolted joints. Compos Struct2015; 134: 190–198.
10.
ComerADhoteJStanleyW. Thermo-mechanical fatigue analysis of liquid shim in mechanically fastened hybrid joints for aerospace applications. Compos Struct2012; 94: 2181–2187.
11.
KellyG. Quasi-static strength and fatigue life of hybrid (bonded/bolted) composite single-lap joints. Compos Struct2006; 72: 119–129.
12.
MatsuzakiRShibataMTodorokiA. Improving performance of GFRP/aluminum single lap joints using bolted/co-cured hybrid method. Compos A2008; 39: 154–163.
13.
GrahamDRezaiABakerD. The development and scalability of a high strength, damage tolerant, hybrid joining scheme for composite-metal structures. Compos A2014; 64: 11–24.
14.
International A. Standard test method for apparent shear strength of single-lap-joint adhesively bonded metal specimens by tension loading (metal-to-metal). ASTM D1002-10 2010.
15.
International A. Standard test method for strength properties of adhesives in shear by tension loading of single-lap-joint laminated assemblies. ASTM Standard D3165 2014.
16.
Hart-Smith L. Design methodology for bonded-bolted composite joints vol. 1: analysis derivations and illustrative solution. Technical Report AFWAL-TR-81-3154, McDonnel Douglas Corporation, 1982.
17.
LiGChenJYanisheskyM. Static strength of a composite butt joint configuration with different attachments. Compos Struct2012; 94: 1736–1744.
18.
Hart-SmithLMechanically-fastened joints for advanced composites phenomenological considerations and simple analyses. In: LenoeEOplingerDBurkeJ (eds). Fibrous composites in structural design (chapter 31), New York, NY: Plenum Press, 1980, pp. 543–574.
19.
Hart-SmithL. The key to designing efficient bolted composite joints. Composites1994; 25: 835–837.
20.
ChowdhuryNChiuWWangJ. Static and fatigue testing thin riveted, bonded and hybrid carbon fiber double lap joints used in aircraft structures. Compos Struct2015; 121: 315–323.
21.
ChowdhuryNWangJChiuW. Experimental and finite element studies of thin bonded and hybrid carbon fibre double lap joints used in aircraft structures. Compos B2016; 85: 233–242.
22.
FioreVAlagnaFGaltieriG. Effect of curing time on the performances of hybrid/mixed joints. Compos B2013; 45: 911–918.
23.
Di FrancoGFratiniLPastaA. Analysis of the mechanical performance of hybrid (SPR/bonded) single-lap joints between CFRP panels and aluminum blanks. Int J Adhes Adhes2013; 41: 24–32.
24.
MarannanoGZuccarelloB. Numerical experimental analysis of hybrid double lap aluminum-CFRP joints. Compos B2015; 71: 29–39.
25.
Campbell Jr FC. Manufacturing technology for aerospace structural materials. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2011.
26.
MIL Military Handbook. HDBK-17-3F: composite materials handbook, Volume 3 polymer matrix composites materials usage, design and analysis. US Department of Defense, 2002.
27.
KweonJJungJKimT. Failure of carbon composite-to-aluminum joints with combined mechanical fastening and adhesive bonding. Compos Struct2006; 75: 192–198.
28.
LinWJenM. The strength of bolted and bonded single-lapped composite joints in tension. J Compos Mater1999; 33: 640–666.
29.
JenMLinW. Innovative fracture tests of single-lapped bolted and bonded composite joints. J Reinf Plast Compos2000; 19: 1444–1473.
30.
FuMMallickP. Fatigue of hybrid (adhesive/bolted) joints in SRIM composites. Int J Adhes Adhes2001; 21: 145–159.
AllredRGuessT. Efficiency of double-lapped composite joints in bending. Composites1978; 9: 112–118.
33.
LeeYLimDChoiJ. Failure load evaluation and prediction of hybrid composite double lap joints. Compos Struct2010; 92: 2916–2926.
34.
GomezSOnoroJPecharromanJ. A simple mechanical model of a structural hybrid adhesive/riveted single lap joint. Int J Adhes Adhes2007; 27: 263–267.
35.
Baker A and Kelly D. Joining of composite structures. In: Baker A, Dutton S and Kelly D (eds.) Composite materials for aircraft structures. 2nd ed. chapter 9. Reston, VA: American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2004.
36.
da Silva LF, Dillard DA, Blackman B, et al. Testing adhesive joints: best practices. Weinheim, Germany: John Wiley & Sons, 2012.
37.
KellyG. Load transfer in hybrid (bonded/bolted) composite single-lap joints. Compos Struct2005; 69: 35–43.
38.
SadowskiTGolewskiPZarzeka-RaczkowskaE. Damage and failure processes of hybrid joints: adhesive bonded aluminum plates reinforced by rivets. Comput Mater Sci2010; 50: 1256–1262.
39.
BodjonaKLessardL. Nonlinear static analysis of a composite bonded/bolted single-lap joint using the meshfree radial point interpolation method. Compos Struct2015; 134: 1024–1035.
40.
BoisCWargnierHWahlJ. An analytical model for the strength prediction of hybrid (bolted/bonded) composite joints. Compos Struct2013; 97: 252–260.
41.
ParoissienESartorMHuetJ. Hybrid (bolted/bonded) joints applied to aeronautic parts: Analytical two-dimensional model of a single-lap joint. J Aircraft2007; 44: 573–582.
42.
BodjonaKRajuKLimG. Load sharing in single-lap bonded/bolted composite joints. Part I: Model development and validation. Compos Struct2015; 129: 268–275.
43.
PirondiAMoroniF. Clinch-bonded and rivet-bonded hybrid joints: application of damage models for simulation of forming and failure. J Adhes Sci Technol2009; 23: 1547–1574.
44.
BodjonaKLessardL. Load sharing in single-lap bonded/bolted composite joints. part ii: Global sensitivity analysis. Compos Struct2015; 129: 276–283.
45.
OskoueiRChakherlouT. Reduction in clamping force due to applied longitudinal load to aerospace structural bolted plates. Aerospace Sci Technol2009; 13: 325–330.
46.
ChakherlouTMirzajanzadehHVogwellJ. Investigation of the fatigue life and crack growth in torque tightened bolted joints. Aerospace Sci Technol2011; 15: 304–313.
47.
ChenH. The static and fatigue strength of bolted joints in composites with hygrothermal cycling. Compos Struct2001; 52: 295–306.
48.
CrewsJShivakumarK. An equation for bolt clamp-up relaxation in transient environments. J Compos, Technol Res1982; 4: 132–135.
49.
Paroissien E. Contribution aux assemblages hybrides (boulonneés/collées). PhD Thesis, Université Toulouse III – Paul Sabattier, France, 2006.
50.
da SilvaLFRodriguesTFigueiredoM. Effect of adhesive type and thickness on the lap shear strength. J Adhes2006; 82: 1091–1115.
51.
Lehman G and Hawley A. Joint and attachment investigation volume 1. Technical discussion and summary. Technical Report AFFDL-TR-69-43, United States Air Force, 1969.
52.
GrayPOHigginsRMcCarthyC. Effect of thickness and laminate taper on the stiffness, strength and secondary bending of single-lap, single-bolt countersunk composite joints. Compos Struct2014; 107: 315–324.
53.
GrayPOHigginsRMcCarthyC. Effects of laminate thickness, tapering and missing fasteners on the mechanical behaviour of single-lap, multi-bolt, countersunk composite joints. Compos Struct2014; 107: 219–230.
54.
ImanakaMHaragaKNishikawaT. Fatigue strength of adhesive/rivet combined lap joints. J Adhes2006; 49: 197–209.
55.
EsmaeiliFChakherlouTNZehsazM. Investigation of bolt clamping force on the fatigue life of double lap simple bolted and hybrid (bolted/bonded) joints via experimental and numerical analysis. Eng Failure Anal2014; 45: 406–420.
56.
Hoang-NgocCParoissienE. Simulation of single-lap bonded and hybrid (bolted/bonded) joints with flexible adhesive. Int J Adhes Adhes2010; 30: 117–129.
57.
EsmaeiliFZehsazMChakherlouT. Investigation the effect of tightening toque on the fatigue strength of double lap simple bolted and hybrid (bolted-bonded) joints using volumetric method. Mater Des2014; 63: 349–359.
58.
CartiéDDDellAnnoGPoulinE. 3d reinforcement of stiffener-to-skin t-joints by z-pinning and tufting. Eng Fracture Mech2006; 73: 2532–2540.
59.
TaoYJiaoGWangB. Effect of z-pins’ diameter, spacing and overlap length on connecting performance of CMC single lap joint. Acta Mech Solida Sinica2008; 21: 461–471.
60.
ParkYBLeeBHKweonJH. The strength of composite bonded t-joints transversely reinforced by carbon pins. Compos Struct2012; 94: 625–634.
61.
KohTFeihSMouritzA. Strengthening mechanics of thin and thick composite t-joints reinforced with z-pins. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manufac2012; 43: 1308–1317.
62.
BianchiFKohTZhangX. Finite element modelling of z-pinned composite t-joints. Compos Sci Technol2012; 73: 48–56.
63.
HeimbsSNogueiraAHombergsmeierE. Failure behaviour of composite t-joints with novel metallic arrow-pin reinforcement. Compos Struct2014; 110: 16–28.
64.
MouritzA. Structural properties of z-pinned carbon-epoxy t-joints in hot-wet environment. J Compos Mater2014; 48: 2905–2914.
65.
Koh T, Isa M, Chang P, et al. Improving the structural properties and damage tolerance of bonded composite joints using z-pins. J Compos Mater 2012; 46: 3255–3265.
66.
AllegriGZhangX. On the delamination and debond suppression in structural joints by z-fibre pinning. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manufac2007; 38: 1107–1115.
67.
ParkesPButlerRMeyerJ. Static strength of metal-composite joints with penetrative reinforcement. Compos Struct2014; 118: 250–256.
68.
Parkes PN, Butler R and Almond DP. Fatigue of metal-composite joints with penetrative reinforcement. In: Proceedings of 54th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC structures, structural dynamics and materials conference, Boston, USA, 8–11 April 2013.
69.
UcsnikSScheererMZarembaS. Experimental investigation of a novel hybrid metal-composite joining technology. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manufac2010; 41: 369–374.
70.
SmithFWyldeG. Comeld – an innovation in composite to metal joining. Welding and Cutting2005; 4: 182–182.
71.
StelzerSUcsnikSPinterG. Fatigue behaviour of composite-composite joints reinforced with cold metal transfer welded pins. Int J Fatigue2015; 81: 37–47.
72.
TuWWenPHoggP. Optimisation of the protrusion geometry in comeld joints. Compos Sci Technol2011; 71: 868–876.
73.
ZhangHWenWCuiH. Study on the strength prediction model of comeld composites joints. Compos Part B: Eng2012; 43: 3310–3317.
74.
TuWWenPGuildF. Multi-region mesh free method for comeld joints. Comput Mater Sci2010; 48: 481–489.
75.
Chang P, Mouritz AP and Cox BN. Elevated temperature properties of pinned composite lap joints. J Composite Mater 2008; 42: 741–769.
76.
PegorinFPingkarawatKDaynesS. Influence of z-pin length on the delamination fracture toughness and fatigue resistance of pinned composites. Compos Part B: Eng2015; 78: 298–307.
77.
KohTFeihSMouritzA. Experimental determination of the structural properties and strengthening mechanisms of z-pinned composite t-joints. Compos Struct2011; 93: 2222–2230.
78.
AllegriGYasaeeMPartridgeI. A novel model of delamination bridging via z-pins in composite laminates. Int J Solids Struct2014; 51: 3314–3332.
79.
NanayakkaraAFeihSMouritzA. Improving the fracture resistance of sandwich composite t-joints by z-pinning. Compos Struct2013; 96: 207–215.
80.
SonHGParkYBKweonJH. Fatigue behaviour of metal pin-reinforced composite single-lap joints in a hygrothermal environment. Compos Struct2014; 108: 151–160.
81.
KoMGKweonJHChoiJH. Fatigue characteristics of jagged pin-reinforced composite single-lap joints in hygrothermal environments. Compos Struct2015; 119: 59–66.
82.
MouritzA. Review of z-pinned composite laminates. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manufac2007; 38: 2383–2397.
83.
BianchiFZhangX. A cohesive zone model for predicting delamination suppression in z-pinned laminates. Compos Sci Technol2011; 71: 1898–1907.
84.
ZgoulMCrocombeA. Numerical modelling of lap joints bonded with a rate-dependent adhesive. Int J Adhes Adhes2004; 24: 355–366.
85.
YuXCrocombeARichardsonG. Material modelling for rate-dependent adhesives. Int J Adhes Adhes2001; 21: 197–210.
86.
DebAMalvadeIBiswasP. An experimental and analytical study of the mechanical behaviour of adhesively bonded joints for variable extension rates and temperatures. Int J Adhes Adhes2008; 28: 1–15.
87.
ClarkeJL. Structural design of polymer composites: Eurocomp design code and background document, Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2003.
88.
ByrdLWBirmanV. Effectiveness of z-pins in preventing delamination of co-cured composite joints on the example of a double cantilever test. Compos Part B: Eng2006; 37: 365–378.
89.
Paroissien E, Hoang-Ngoc C, Bhugaloo H, et al. Improving the fatigue life of aeronautical single-lap bolted joints thanks to the hybrid (bolted/bonded) joining technology. In Bos M (ed) ICAF 2009, bridging the gap between theory and operational practice: Proceedings of the 25th symposium of the international committee on aeronautical fatigue. ICAF, Rotterdam: Springer Netherlands, pp. 475–492.
90.
VolkersenO. Die nietkraftverteilung in zugbeanspruchten nietverbindungen mit konstanten laschenquerschnitten. Luftfahrtforschung1938; 15: 41–47.
91.
GolandMReissnerE. The stresses in cemented joints. J Appl Mech1944; 66: 17–27.
92.
BarutAMadenciE. Analysis of bolted-bonded composite single-lap joints under combined in-plane and transverse loading. Compos Struct2009; 88: 579–594.
93.
MouritzAKohT. Re-evaluation of mode I bridging traction modelling for z-pinned laminates based on experimental analysis. Compos Part B: Eng2014; 56: 797–807.
