Effects of Friction,Geometry,and Fixture Compliance on the Perceived Toughness from Three-and Four-Point Bend End-Notched Flexure Tests

Abstract

Linear and nonlinear finite element analyses are used to examine the effects of friction, test geometry, and fixture compliance on the perceived toughness as obtained from threeand four-point bend end-notched flexure tests. To this end, a newly developed ‘direct energy balance approach’ is used to obtain the ‘true’ energy release rate for any given specimen, test geometry, and coefficient of friction. Finite element analyses are also used in a simulated compliance calibration technique, which is combined with experimental results from fixture compliance tests to obtain a perceived toughness, i.e., the value that would be obtained by experiment. By varying the different parameters, the individual and combined effects of friction, test geometry, and fixture compliance on the ratio of the perceived to true toughness is obtained. The approach is applied to two graphite/epoxy materials for which toughnesses by the three(3ENF) and four-point bend end-notched flexure (4ENF) tests are obtained experimentally for a range of geometries. These experiments produced larger perceived mode II toughnesses, GIIc, by the 4ENF than the 3ENF test, and GIIc values from the 4ENF test were observed to decrease with increasing outer span length. The finite element simulations were shown to accurately recreate the perceived values of GIIc obtained from these tests. Moreover, the finite element simulations indicate that the true toughness values are essentially constant for a given material. These findings are used to make some general recommendations for choosing 3ENF and 4ENF specimen and test geometries, as well as to discuss the relative advantages and disadvantages of the 3ENF and 4ENF test methods.

Keywords

delamination mode II nonlinear finite element energy balance energy release rate

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Martin, R. H. and Davidson, B. D. (1999). Mode II Fracture Toughness Evaluation using a Four Point Bend End Notched Flexure Test , Plastics, Rubber and Composites, 28(8): 401–406 .

Martin, R. H. , Elms, T. and Bowron, S. (1998). Characterization of Mode II Delamination using the 4ENF, In: Proceedings of the 4th European Conference on Composite Materials: Testing and Standardization, Institute of Materials, London , pp. 161–170.

Davidson, B. D. , Sun, X. and Vinciquerra, A. J. (2004). Influences of Friction, Geometric Nonlinearity and Fixture Compliance on Three and Four Point Bend End Notched Flexure Test Results, Composites Science and Technology (submitted).

Davies, P. (1999). Summary of Results from Second VAMAS Mode II Round Robin Test Exercise Using the 4ENF Specimen, IFREMER Report.

Schuecker, C. and Davidson, B. D. (2000). Effect of Friction on the Perceived Mode II Delamination Toughness from Three and Four-Point Bend End Notched Flexure Tests, In: Grant, P. and Rousseau, C. Q. (eds), Composite Structures: Theory and Practice, ASTM STP 1383, pp. 334–344, American Society for Testing and Materials .

Davidson, B. D. , Altonen, C. S. and Polaha, J. J. (1996). Effect of Stacking Sequence on Delamination Toughness and Delamination Growth Behavior in Composite End-Notched Flexure Specimens, In: Deo, R. B. and Saff, C. R. (eds), Composite Materials: Testing and Design, ASTM STP 1274, Vol. 12, pp. 393–413, American Society for Testing and Materials .

Kageyama, K. , Kimpara, I. , Suzuki, T. , Ohsawa, I. , Kanai, M. and Tsuno, H. (1999). Effects of Test Conditions on Mode II Interlaminar Fracture Toughness of Four-Point ENF Specimens, In: Proceedings of ICCM 12, Paris, France .

Schuecker, C. and Davidson, B. D. (2000). Evaluation of the Accuracy of the Four-Point Bend End-Notched Flexure Test for Mode II Delamination Toughness Determination , Composites Science and Technology, 60: 2137–2146 .

Vinciquerra, A. J. and Davidson, B. D. (2002). Effect of Crack Length Measurement Technique and Data Reduction Procedures on the Perceived Toughness from Four-Point Bend End-Notched Flexure Tests , Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites, 23(10): 1051–1062 .

10.

Sun, X. and Davidson, B. D. (2004). A Direct Energy Balance Approach for Determining Energy Release Rates in Three and Four Point Bend End Notched Flexure , International Journal of Fracture (submitted).

11.

Griffith, A. A. (1920). The Phenomena of Rupture and Flow in Solids , Philosophical Transactions, Series A 221: 163–198 .

12.

Rybicki, E. F. and Kanninen, M. F. (1977). A Finite Element Calculation of Stress Intensity Factors by a Modified Crack Closure Integral , Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 9: 931–938 .

13.

Mall, S. and Kochhar, N. K. (1986). Finite Element Analysis of End-Notched Flexure Specimens , Journal of Composites Technology & Research, 8(2): 54–57 .

14.

Sun, X. and Davidson, B. D. (2004). Numerical Evaluation of the Influence of Friction and Geometric Nonlinearity on Three and Four Point End Notched Flexure Test Results, Engineering Fracture Mechanics (submitted).

15.

Pieracci, A. , Davidson, B. D. and Sundararaman, V. (1998). Nonlinear Analysis of Homogenous, Symmetrically Delaminated Single Leg Bending Specimens , Journal of Composites Technology and Research, 20(3): 170–178 .

16.

Davidson, B. D. , Fariello, P. L. , Hudson, R. C. and Sundararaman, V. (1997). Accuracy Assessment of the Singular Field-Based Mode Mix Decomposition Procedure for the Prediction of Delamination, In: Hooper, S. J. (ed.), Composite Materials: Testing and Design, ASTM STP 1242, Vol. 13, pp. 109–128, American Society for Testing and Materials .

17.

Davidson, B. D. , Bialaszewski, R. D. and Sainath, S. S. (2004). A Non-Classical, Energy Release Rate Based Approach for Predicting Delamination Growth in Graphite Reinforced Laminated Polymeric Composites, Composites Science and Technology (To Appear).

18.

Robinson, P. (2001). A Concept for Experimentally Evaluating the Effect of Friction in the 4-ENF Interlaminar Toughness Test , International Journal of Fracture, 110: 37–42 .