Math achievement in U.S. high schools is a consistent predictor of educational attainment. While emphasis on raising math achievement continues, school-level interventions often come at the expense of other subjects. Arts courses are particularly at risk of being cut, especially in schools serving lower socioeconomic status youth. Evidence suggests, however, that arts coursework is beneficial to many educational outcomes. We use data on 20,590 adolescents from the High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 to answer two research questions: (1) Does student accumulation of fine arts courses across different topic areas relate positively to math test scores in high school? (2) Does school SES differentiate this potential association? Results indicate that youth attending higher-SES schools take more art courses and taking music courses is related to higher math test scores. However, this benefit only seems to only apply to more socially advantaged student bodies. Results reveal a site of additional educational advantage for already privileged youth.
AdelmanClifford. 2006. The Toolbox Revisited: Paths to Degree Completion from High School through College. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
2.
AikensNikki L.BarbarinOscar. 2008. “Socioeconomic Differences in Reading Trajectories: The Contribution of Family, Neighborhood, and School Contexts.”Journal of Educational Psychology100(2):235–51.
3.
AlegradoAlenamieWinslerAdam. 2020. “Predictors of Taking Elective Music Courses in Middle School Among Low-SES, Ethnically Diverse Students in Miami.”Journal of Research in Music Education68(1):5–30.
AppleMichael W.1990. Ideology and Curriculum. London, England: Psychology Press.
6.
ArcherLouiseDeWittJenniferOsborneJonathanDillonJustinWillisBeatriceWongBilly. 2010. “‘Doing’ Science Versus ‘Being’ a Scientist: Examining 10/11-year Schoolchildren’s Constructions of Science through the Lens of Identity.”Science Education94(4):617–39.
7.
BakerRichard A.2012. “The Effects of High-stakes Testing Policy on Arts Education.”Arts Education Policy Review113(1):17–25.
8.
BellingerDavid B.DeCaroMarci S.RalstonPatricia A. S.. 2015. “Mindfulness, Anxiety, and High-stakes Mathematics Performance in the Laboratory and Classroom.”Consciousness and Cognition37:123–32.
9.
BequetteJames W.BequetteMarjorie Bullitt. 2012. “A Place for ART and DESIGN Education in the STEM Conversation.”Art Education; Reston65(2):40–47.
10.
BerendsMarkLucasSamuel R.PenalozaRoberto V.. 2008. “How Changes in Families and Schools Are Related to Trends in Black-white Test Scores.”Sociology of Education81(4):313–44.
11.
BeveridgeTina. 2009. “No Child Left Behind and Fine Arts Classes.”Arts Education Policy Review111(1):4–7.
12.
BlumsAngelaBelskyJayGrimmKevinChenZhe. 2017. “Building Links between Early Socioeconomic Status, Cognitive Ability, and Math and Science Achievement.”Journal of Cognition and Development18(1):16–40.
13.
BollenKenneth A.BiemerPaul P.KarrAlan F.TuellerStephenBerzofskyMarcus E.. 2016. “Are Survey Weights Needed? A Review of Diagnostic Tests in Regression Analysis.”Annual Review of Statistics and Its Application3(1):375–92.
14.
BollenKenneth A.BrandJennie E.. 2010. “A General Panel Model with Random and Fixed Effects: A Structural Equations Approach.”Social Forces89(1):1–34.
15.
BourdieuPierre. 1986. “The Forms of Capital.” Pp. 241–58 in Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, edited by RichardsonJ. G.. New York: Greenwood Press.
16.
BowenDaniel H.GreeneJay P.KisidaBrian. 2014. “Learning to Think Critically: A Visual Art Experiment.”Educational Researcher43(1):37–44.
17.
CallahanCarolyn M.2005. “Identifying Gifted Students from Underrepresented Populations.”Theory into Practice44(2):98–104.
18.
CarleAdam C.2009. “Fitting Multilevel Models in Complex Survey Data with Design Weights: Recommendations.”BMC Medical Research Methodology9(1):49.
19.
CarrollJamie M.MullerChandra. 2018. “Curricular Differentiation and Its Impact on Different Status Groups Including Immigrants and Students with Disabilities.” Pp. 251–73 in Handbook of the Sociology of Education in the 21st Century, edited by SchneiderB.. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
20.
CarrollJamie M.MullerChandraGrodskyEricWarrenJohn Robert. 2017. “Tracking Health Inequalities from High School to Midlife.”Social Forces96(2):591–628.
21.
CatterallJames S.2012. The Arts and Achievement in At-risk Youth: Findings from Four Longitudinal Studies. Research Report# 55. Washington, DC: National Endowment for the Arts.
22.
ChappellSharon VernerCahnmann-TaylorMelisa. 2013. “No Child Left with Crayons: The Imperative of Arts-based Education and Research with Language ‘Minority’ and Other Minoritized Communities.”Review of Research in Education37(1):243–68.
23.
ChenPingChantalaKim. 2014. Guidelines for Analyzing Add Health Data. Chapel Hill, NC: Carolina Population Center, University of North Carolina.
24.
ChiuMing Ming. 2010. “Effects of Inequality, Family and School on Mathematics Achievement: Country and Student Differences.”Social Forces88(4):1645–76.
25.
ClarkePaulCrawfordClaireSteeleFionaVignolesAnna. 2010. The Choice between Fixed and Random Effects Models: Some Considerations for Educational Research (DoQSS Working Paper No. 10-10). London, England: Department of Quantitative Social Science, Institute of Education, University of London.
ColeShawnPaulsonAnnaShastryGauri Kartini. 2016. “High School Curriculum and Financial Outcomes: The Impact of Mandated Personal Finance and Mathematics Courses.”Journal of Human Resources51(3):656–98.
28.
ColemanJames S.1988. “Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.”American Journal of Sociology94:S95–120.
29.
CollierPeter J.MorganDavid L.. 2008. “‘Is that Paper Really Due Today?’: Differences in First-generation and Traditional College Students’ Understandings of Faculty Expectations.”Higher Education55(4):425–46.
30.
CoulangeonPhilippe. 2018. “The Impact of Participation in Extracurricular Activities on School Achievement of French Middle School Students: Human Capital and Cultural Capital Revisited.”Social Forces97(1):55–90.
31.
CrosnoeRobertCavanaghShannonElderGlen H.. 2003. “Adolescent Friendships as Academic Resources: The Intersection of Friendship, Race, and School Disadvantage.”Sociological Perspectives46(3):331–52.
32.
CrosnoeRobertSchneiderBarbara. 2010. “Social Capital, Information, and Socioeconomic Disparities in Math Course Work.”American Journal of Education117(1):79–107.
33.
DeasyRichard J.2002. Critical Links: Learning in the Arts and Student Academic and Social Development. Washington, DC: Arts Education Partnership, One Massachusetts Ave.
34.
DeereKelli Beth. 2010. The Impact of Music Education on Academic Achievement in Reading and Math. Ann Arbor, MI: ProQuest LLC.
DettermanDouglas K.SternbergRobert J.., eds. 1993. Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition, and Instruction. Westport, CT: Ablex Publishing.
37.
DiMaggioPaul. 1982. “Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of US High School Students.”American Sociological Review47(2):189–201.
38.
DumaisSusan A.2002. “Cultural Capital, Gender, and School Success: The Role of Habitus.”Sociology of Education75(1):44–68.
39.
DupreyMichael A.PrattDaniel J.JewellDonna M.CominoleMelissa B.FritchLaura BurnsRitchieEthan A.RogersJames E.WescottJamie D.WilsonDavid H.. 2018. High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09) Base-year to Second Follow-up Data File Documentation (NCES 2018-140). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, US Department of Education.
40.
DweckCarol S.2007. “Is Math a Gift? Beliefs That Put Females at Risk.” Pp. 47–55 in Why Aren’t More Women in Science? Top Researchers Debate the Evidence, edited by CeciS. J.WilliamsW.. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
41.
EisnerElliot W.1999. “Does Experience in the Arts Boost Academic Achievement?.”The Clearing House; Washington72(3):143–49.
42.
EisnerElliot W.DayMichael D.. 2004. Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education. London, England: Routledge.
43.
EllenWinnerRGoldstein ThaliaStéphanVincent-Lancrin. 2013. Art for Art’s Sake? the Impact of Arts Education: The Impact of Arts Education. Washington, DC: OECD Publishing.
44.
ElpusKenneth. 2018. “Estimating the Effect of Music and Arts Coursework on College Admissions Outcomes.”Arts Education Policy Review119(3):111–23.
45.
ElpusKenneth. 2020. “Access to Arts Education in America: The Availability of Visual Art, Music, Dance, and Theater Courses in US High Schools.”Arts Education Policy Review123(2):50–69.
46.
EpsteinDebbieMendickHeatherMoreauMarie-Pierre. 2010. “Imagining the Mathematician: Young People Talking about Popular Representations of Maths.”Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education13(1):45–60.
47.
EvansGary W.2004. “The Environment of Childhood Poverty.”American Psychologist59(2):77–92.
48.
FarkasGeorgeGrobeRobert P.SheehanDanielShuanYuan. 1990. “Cultural Resources and School Success: Gender, Ethnicity, and Poverty Groups within an Urban School District.”American Sociological Review55(1):127–42.
49.
FroilandJohn MarkDavisonMark L.. 2016. “The Longitudinal Influences of Peers, Parents, Motivation, and Mathematics Course-taking on High School Math Achievement.”Learning and Individual Differences50:252–59.
50.
GaertnerMatthew N.KimJeongeunDesJardinsStephen L.McClartyKatie Larsen. 2014. “Preparing Students for College and Careers: The Causal Role of Algebra II.”Research in Higher Education55(2):143–65.
51.
GibsonAdrian.2016. “Students’ Perceptions of High School Band Programs, Their Marching Bands, and Factors That Lead to Intended Enrollment in These Ensembles.”Middle and Secondary Education dissertations, Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA.
52.
GonzalezHeather B.KuenziJeffrey J.. 2012. “Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Education: A Primer.” Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress (https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/R42642.pdf).
53.
GorskiKarlyn J.2021. “In School for After School: The Relationship Between Extracurricular Participation and School Engagement.”Sociological Forum36(1):248–70.
54.
HamblenKaren A.1993. “Theories and Research That Support Art Instruction for Instrumental Outcomes.”Theory into Practice32(4):191.
55.
HanSiqi. 2020. “Reproducing the Working Class? Incongruence between the Valuation of Social-emotional Skills in School and in the Labor Market.”Sociological Perspectives64:467–487.
56.
HanselmanPaulFielJeremy E.. 2017. “School Opportunity Hoarding? Racial Segregation and Access to High Growth Schools.”Social Forces95(3):1077–1104.
57.
HarlandJohnKinderKayLordPippaStottAlisonSchagenIanHaynesJoCusworthLindaWhiteRichardPaolaRiana. 2000. Arts Education in Secondary Schools: Effects and Effectiveness. Slough, England: NFER.
58.
HeiligJulian VasquezColeHeatherAguilarAngélica. 2010. “From Dewey to No Child Left Behind: The Evolution and Devolution of Public Arts Education.”Arts Education Policy Review111(4):136–45.
59.
HetlandLoisWinnerEllen. 2001. “The Arts and Academic Achievement: What the Evidence Shows.”Arts Education Policy Review102(5):3.
60.
HetlandLoisWinnerEllen. 2004. “Cognitive Transfer from Arts Education to Nonarts Outcomes: Research Evidence and Policy Implications.” Pp. 135–62 in Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education. London, England: Routledge.
61.
HetlandLoisWinnerEllenVeenemaShirleySheridanKimberly M.. 2015. Studio Thinking 2: the Real Benefits of Visual Arts Education. 2nd ed.New York: Teachers College Press.
62.
HolochwostSteven J.PropperCathi B.WolfDennie PalmerWilloughbyMichael T.FisherKelly R.KolaczJacekVolpeVanessa V.JaffeeSara R.. 2017. “Music Education, Academic Achievement, and Executive Functions.”Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts11(2):147–66.
63.
IngelsStevenPrattDanielHergetDeborahBryanMichaelFritchLauraOttemRandolphRogersJamesWilsonDavid. 2015. High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09) 2013 Update and High School Transcripts Data File Documentation. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
64.
IngelsSteven J.PrattDaniel J.HergetDeborah R.BurnsLaura J.DeverJill A.OttemRandolphRogersJames E.JinYingLeinwandSteve. 2011. High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09): Base-year Data File Documentation. NCES 2011-328. Waschington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
65.
IngelsSteven J.PrattDaniel J.HergetDeborah R.DeverJill A.FritchLaura B.OttemRandolphRogersJames E.KitmittoSamiLeinwandSteve. 2013. High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09) Base Year to First Follow-up Data File Documentation (NCES 2014-361). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, US Department of Education.
66.
JackAnthony Abraham. 2014. “Culture Shock Revisited: The Social and Cultural Contingencies to Class Marginality.”Sociological Forum29(2):453–75.
67.
JenningsJackRentnerDiane Stark. 2006. “Ten Big Effects of the No Child Left Behind Act on Public Schools.”Phi Delta Kappan88(2):110–13.
68.
JimenezLauraSargradScott. 2018. A Well-rounded Education: Rethinking What Is Expected of High Schools. Washington, DC: Center for American Progress.
69.
KaufmanJasonGablerJay. 2004. “Cultural Capital and the Extracurricular Activities of Girls and Boys in the College Attainment Process.”Poetics32(2):145–68.
70.
KariukiPatrick N.HumphreySteven G.. 2006.“The Effects of Drama on the Performance of At-Risk Elementary Math Students.”Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, November 10, Birmingham, AL.
71.
KimJeongeunKimJiyunDesJardinsStephen L.McCallBrian P.. 2015. “Completing Algebra II in High School: Does It Increase College Access and Success?.”The Journal of Higher Education86(4):628–62.
72.
KinneyDaryl W.ForsytheJere L.. 2005. “The Effects of the Arts IMPACT Curriculum upon Student Performance on the Ohio Fourth-Grade Proficiency Test.” Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education (164):35–48.
73.
KisidaBrianBowenDaniel H.GreeneJay P.. 2016. “Measuring Critical Thinking: Results from an Art Museum Field Trip Experiment.”Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness9:171–87.
74.
KleinDaniel. 2018. MIMRGNS: Stata Module to Run Margins after Mi Estimate. Newton, MA: Boston College.
75.
KozolJonathan. 2012. Savage Inequalities: Children in America’s Schools. New York: Crown.
76.
LareauAnnette. 1987. “Social Class Differences in Family-school Relationships: The Importance of Cultural Capital.”Sociology of Education60(2):73–85.
77.
LareauAnnette. 2000. Home Advantage: Social Class and Parental Intervention in Elementary Education. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
78.
LareauAnnetteWeiningerElliot B.. 2003. “Cultural Capital in Educational Research: A Critical Assessment.”Theory and Society32(5):567–606.
79.
LeeJihyunStankovLazar. 2018. “Non-cognitive Predictors of Academic Achievement: Evidence from TIMSS and PISA.”Learning and Individual Differences65:50–64.
80.
LlerasChristy. 2008. “Race, Racial Concentration, and the Dynamics of Educational Inequality Across Urban and Suburban Schools.”American Educational Research Journal45(4):886–912.
81.
LongMark C.CongerDylanIatarolaPatrice. 2012. “Effects of High School Course-taking on Secondary and Postsecondary Success.”American Educational Research Journal49(2):285–322.
82.
LudwigMeredith J.BoyleAndreaLindsayJim. 2017.“Review of Evidence: Arts Integration Research through the Lens of the Every Student Succeeds Act. Washington, DC: American Institutes for Research.
83.
MaloneyErin A.BeilockSian L.. 2012. “Math Anxiety: Who Has It, Why It Develops, and How to Guard against It.”Trends in Cognitive Sciences16(8):404–406.
84.
MathisWilliam J.TrujilloTina M.. 2016. Lessons from NCLB for the Every Student Succeeds Act. Washington, DC: National Education Policy Center.
McPeckJohn E.2016. Critical Thinking and Education. London, England: Routledge.
87.
MeanwellEmilySwandoJulie. 2013. “Who Deserves Good Schools? Cultural Categories of Worth and School Finance Reform.”Sociological Perspectives56(4):495–522.
88.
MendickHeather. 2005. “A Beautiful Myth? The Gendering of Being/Doing ‘Good at Maths.’”Gender and Education17(2):203–19.
89.
MickelsonRoslynGierschJasonStearnsElizabethMollerStephanie. 2013. “How (and Why) NCLB Failed to Close the Achievement Gap: Evidence from North Carolina, 1998-2004.”The Bridge: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Legal & Social Policy3(1).
90.
MickelsonRoslyn ArlinBottiaMartha CeciliaLambertRichard. 2013. “Effects of School Racial Composition on K-12 Mathematics Outcomes: A Metaregression Analysis.”Review of Educational Research83(1):121–58.
91.
MortonKarismaRiegle-CrumbCatherine. 2020. “Is School Racial/Ethnic Composition Associated with Content Coverage in Algebra?”Educational Researcher49(6):441–47.
92.
National Governors Association. 2010. Common Core State Standards. Washington, DC: National Governors Association.
93.
NeelyStephen R.VaqueraElizabeth. 2017. “Making It Count: Breadth and Intensity of Extracurricular Engagement and High School Dropout.”Sociological Perspectives60(6):1039–62.
NowickiJacqueline M.2018. K-12 Education: Public High Schools with More Students in Poverty and Smaller Schools Provide Fewer Academic Offerings to Prepare for College. Report to the Ranking Member, Committee on Education and the Workforce, House of Representatives. GAO-19-8. Washington, DC: US Government Accountability Office.
96.
Parsad. 2012. Arts Education in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools: 1999-2000 And 2009-10. Collingdale, PA: DIANE Publishing.
97.
ParsadBasmatSpiegelmanMaura. 2012. Arts Education in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools: 1999-2000 and 2009-10. NCES 2012-014. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
98.
Rabe-HeskethSophiaAndersSkrondal. 2007. Multilevel Modeling of Complex Survey Data. Marina Del Rey, CA: West Coast Stata.
99.
RabkinNickHedbergEric Christopher. 2011. Arts Education in America: What the Declines Mean for Arts Participation. Based on the 2008 Survey of Public Participation in the Arts. Research Report# 52. Washington, DC: National Endowment for the Arts.
100.
RattanAneetaGoodCatherineDweckCarol S.. 2012. “‘It’s Ok Not Everyone Can Be Good at Math’: Instructors with an Entity Theory Comfort (and Demotivate) Students.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology48(3):731–37.
101.
RikoonSamuelFinnBridgidJacksonTeresaInglesePatricia. 2018. “Crosscutting Literature on STEAM Ecosystems, Expectancy Value Theory, and Social Emotional Learning: A Metadata Synthesis.”ETS Research Report Series2018:1–15.
102.
RoseHeatherBettsJulian R.. 2004. “The Effect of High School Courses on Earnings.”The Review of Economics and Statistics86(2):497–513.
103.
SabolF. Robert. 2013. “Seismic Shifts in the Education Landscape: What Do They Mean for Arts Education and Arts Education Policy?.”Arts Education Policy Review114(1):33–45.
104.
ScherzZahavaOrenMiri. 2006. “How to Change Students’ Images of Science and Technology.”Science Education90(6):965–85.
105.
SchillerKathryn S.MullerChandra. 2003. “Raising the Bar and Equity? Effects of State High School Graduation Requirements and Accountability Policies on Students’ Mathematics Course Taking.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis25(3):299–318.
106.
SchneiderBarbaraSwansonChristopher B.Riegle-CrumbCatherine. 1997. “Opportunities For Learning: Course Sequences and Positional Advantages.”Social Psychology of Education2(1):25–53.
SingleyMark K.AndersonJohn Robert. 1989. The Transfer of Cognitive Skill. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
109.
SmythTheoni Soublis. 2008. “Who Is No Child Left Behind Leaving Behind?”The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas81(3):133–37.
110.
SpringJoel H.1989. The Sorting Machine Revisited: National Educational Policy Since 1945. Updated ed. New York: Longman.
111.
StankovLazarMoronySuzanneLeeYim Ping. 2014. “Confidence: The Best Non-cognitive Predictor of Academic Achievement?.”Educational Psychology34(1):9–28.
112.
StapletonLaura M.KangYoonjeong. 2016. “Design Effects of Multilevel Estimates from National Probability Samples.”Sociological Methods & Research47:430–57.
113.
TeachmanJay D.PaaschKathleenCarverKaren. 1997. “Social Capital and the Generation of Human Capital.”Social Forces75(4):1343–59.
114.
ThomasKathleenSinghPriyankaKlopfensteinKristin. 2015. “Arts Education and the High School Dropout Problem.”Journal of Cultural Economics39(4):327–39.
115.
US Department of Education. 2017. “Science, Technology, Engineering and Math: Education for Global Leadership.” Retrieved December 4 (https://www.ed.gov/stem).
116.
WatanabeMaika. 2008. “Tracking in the Era of High Stakes State Accountability Reform: Case Studies of Classroom Instruction in North Carolina.”Teachers College Record110(3):489–534.
117.
WestBrady T.2016. Fitting Weighted Multilevel Models to Complex Sample Survey Data in SAS: A Case Study. Ann Arbor, MI: Michigan SAS Users Group.
118.
WhiteIan R.RoystonPatrickWoodAngela M.. 2011. “Multiple Imputation using Chained Equations: Issues and Guidance for Practice.”Statistics in Medicine30(4):377–99.
119.
WoodsChenoa S.ParkTobyHuShoupingJonesTamara Betrand. 2018. “How High School Coursework Predicts Introductory College-level Course Success.”Community College Review46(2):176–96.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
