Restitution as a social practice can simultaneously have a punitive effect and add to a person’s criminal justice debt load, while maintaining a reparative and therefore restorative component. We use principles of restorative justice to assess restitution as a concept and a practice, drawing on data from a survey experiment administered to a nationally representative sample (n = 433). We find that the common and strongly preferred conception of restitution is “direct,” entailing a convicted person compensating a victim for quantifiable loss. Evidence from Victim Compensation Funds (VCFs) in all 50 states demonstrate the widespread use of “indirect” restitution, through which funds from various sources are distributed to qualifying victims. Broader trends in criminal justice policy related to the centering of the victim and a managerial approach to punishment help explain our findings. We conclude that the divergence between common conception and widespread practice indicates a need for a revised notion of restitution.
American Civil Liberties Union of Washington and Columbia Legal Services. 2014. “Modern-day Debtors’ Prisons: The Ways Court-imposed Debts Punish People for Being Poor.” Retrieved October 26, 2020 (https://www.aclu-wa.org/docs/modern-day-debtors-prisons-washington).
8.
BannonAliciaNagrechaMitaliDillerRebekah. 2010. “Criminal Justice Debt: A Barrier to Reentry.” New York: Brennan Center for Justice.
9.
BeckettKatherineHarrisAlexes. 2011. “On Cash and Conviction: Monetary Sanctions as Misguided Policy.” Criminology & Public Policy10(3):505–507.
10.
BeckettKatherineHarrisAlexesEvansHeather. 2008. The Assessment and Consequences of Legal Financial Obligations in Washington State. Olympia, WA: Washington State Minority and Justice Commission.
11.
BeckettKatherineMurakawaNaomi. 2012. “Mapping the Shadow Carceral State: Toward an Institutionally Capacious Approach to Punishment.” Theoretical Criminology16(2):221–244
12.
BonczarThomas P.2003. “Prevalence of Imprisonment in the U.S. Population, 1974-2001.” Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
13.
BuhrmesterMichaelKwangTracyGoslingSamuel D.2011. “Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, Yet High-quality, Data?” Perspectives on Psychological Science6(1):3–5.
14.
CarlsmithKevin M.DarleyJohn M.RobinsonPaul H.2002. “Why Do We Punish? Deterence and Just Deserts as Motives for Punishment.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology83(2):284–299.
DalyKathleen. 2016. “What Is Restorative Justice? Fresh Answers to a Vexed Question.” Victims & Offenders11(1):9–29.
18.
DickmanMatthew. 2009. “Should Crime Pay? A Critical Assessment of the Mandatory Victims Restitution Act of 1996.” California Law Review97(6):1687–718. Retrieved March 10, 2020 (www.jstor.org/stable/20677922).
19.
EberhardtJennifer L.GoffPhillip AtibaPurdieValerie J.DaviesPaul G.2004. “Seeing Black: Race, Crime, and Visual Processing.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology87(6):876–93.
20.
EvansDouglas. 2014. “Compensating Victims of Crime.” New York: Research & Evaluation Center, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, City University of New York.
21.
FeeleyMalcolm MJonathanSimon. 1992. “The New Penology: Notes On The Emerging Strategy of Corrections and its Implications.” Criminology30(4):449–474.
GarlandDavid. 1991. “Sociological Perspectives on Punishment.” Crime and Justice14:115–165.
24.
GarlandDavid, eds. 2001. Mass Imprisonment: Social Causes and Consequences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
25.
GarlandDavid. 2018. “Theoretical Advances and Problems in the Sociology of Punishment.” Punishment & Society20(1):8–33.
26.
GilliamFranklin D.Jr.IyengarShanto. 2000. “Prime Suspects: The Influence of Local Television News on the Viewing Public.” American Journal of Political Science44:560–73.
27.
GilliamFranklin D.Jr.IyengarShantoSimonAdamWrightOliver. 1996. “Crime in Black and White: The Violent, Scary World of Local News.” Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics1(3):6–23.
28.
GrometDena MDarleyJohn M.2009 “Retributive and Restorative Justice: Importance of Crime Severity and Shared Identity in People’s Justice Responses.” Australian Journal of Psychology61(1):50–57.
HarrisAlexes. 2016. A Pound of Flesh: Monetary Sanctions as Punishment for the Poor. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
31.
HarrisAlexesEvansHeatherBeckettKatherine. 2011. “Courtesy Stigma and Monetary Sanctions: Toward a Socio-cultural Theory of Punishment.” American Sociological Review76(2):234–64.
HartH. L. A.1968. Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
35.
HaynesStacy Hoskins. 2011. “The Effects of Victim-related Contextual Factors on the Criminal Justice System.” Crime & Delinquency57:298–328.
36.
HaynesStacy HoskinsCaresAlison C.RubackR. Barry. 2014. “Juvenile Economic Sanctions: An Analysis of Their Imposition, Payment, and Effect on Recidivism.” Criminology & Public Policy13:31–60.
37.
HaynesStacy HoskinsCaresAlison C.RubackR. Barry. 2015. “Reducing the Harm of Criminal Victimization: The Role of Restitution.” Violence and Victims30(3):450–69.
HurwitzJonPeffleyMark. 2005. “Playing the Race Card in the Post-Willie Horton Era: The Impact of Racialized Code Words on Support for Punitive Crime Policy.” Public Opinion Quarterly69(1):99–112.
40.
JohnstoneGerryVan NessDaniel W.2006. “The Meaning of Restorative Justice.” Pp. 5–23 in Handbook of Restorative Justice, edited by JohnstoneGerryVan NessDaniel W.Cullompton, England: Willan.
41.
LollarCortney E.2014. “What Is Criminal Restitution.” Iowa Law Review100:93–154.
42.
MacaulayStewart. 1959. “Restitution in Context.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review107(8):1133–1148.
43.
MarshallTony. 1996. “The Evolution of Restorative Justice in Britain.” European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research4(4):21–43.
44.
MartinKarin. 2018. “Monetary Myopia: An Examination of Institutional Response to Revenue from Monetary Sanctions for Misdemeanors.” Criminal Justice Policy Review29(6–7):630–62.
45.
MartinKarinSykesBryanShannonSarahEdwardsFrankHarrisAlexes. 2018. “Monetary Sanctions: Legal Financial Obligations in US Systems of Justice.” Annual Review of Criminology1:471–95.
46.
MasseyCalvin. 1987. “The Excessive Fines Clause and Punitive Damages: Some Lessons from History.” Vanderbilt Law Review40:1233–76.
47.
McColdPaul. 2000. “Toward a Holistic Vision of Restorative Juvenile Justice: A Reply to the Maximalist Model.” Contemporary Justice Review3(4):357–414.
48.
National Association of VOCA Assistance Administrators (NAVAA)2017. “Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) Crime Victims Fund” Briefing Background.
49.
O’HaraErin A.2005. “Victim Participation in the Criminal Process.” Journal of Law and Policy13(1):229–247.
50.
OkimotoTyler G.WenzelMichaelFeatherN. T.2009. “Beyond Retribution: Conceptualizing Restorative Justice and Exploring its Determinants.” Social Justice Research22(1):156–80.
51.
PeerEyalVosgerauJoachimAcquistiAlessandro. 2014. “Reputation as a Sufficient Condition for Data Quality on Amazon Mechanical Turk.” Behavior Research Methods46:1023–31.
52.
PeffleyMarkHurwitzJon. 2007. “Persuasion and Resistance: Race and the Death Penalty in America.” American Journal of Political Science51(4):996–1012.
53.
PollockFrederickMaitlandFrederic William. 1968. The History of English Law before the Time of Edward I. Reissued with a New Introduction and Select Bibliography by SFC Milsom. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
RoachKent. 2000. “Changing Punishment at the Turn of the Century: Restorative Justice on the Rise.” Canadian Journal of Criminology42(3):249–80.
56.
RoemerJohn E.1998. Theories of Distributive Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
57.
RosenmerkelSeanDuroseMatthewFaroleDonald. 2009. “Felony Sentences in State Courts, 2006: Statistical Tables.” NCJ 226846. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice.
58.
RubackR. BarryKnothLauren K.GladfelterAndrew S.LantzBrendan. 2018. “Restitution Payment and Recidivism: An Experimental Analysis.” Criminology & Public Policy17:789–813.
59.
RubackR. BarryRuthGretchenShafferJennifer. 2005. “Assessing the Impact of Statutory Change: A Statewide Multilevel Analysis of Restitution Orders in Pennsylvania.” Crime & Delinquency51(3):318–42.
60.
SalasMarioCiolfiAngela. 2017. “Driven by Dollars: A State-by-state Analysis of Driver’s License Suspension Laws for Failure to Pay Court Debt.” Charlottesville, VA: Legal Aid Justice Center.
61.
SarnoffSusan. 2014. “Restitution: Exploring Disparities and Potentials.” Criminology & Public Policy13:437–40.
62.
ShankDaniel B.2016. “Using Crowdsourcing Websites for Sociological Research: The Case of Amazon Mechanical Turk.” The American Sociologist47(1):47–55.
63.
ShannonSarah K. S.UggenChristopherSchnittkerJasonThompsonMelissaWakefieldSaraMassogliaMichael. 2017. “The Growth, Scope, and Spatial Distribution of People with Felony Records in the United States, 1948-2010.” Demography54:1795–818. doi:10.1007/s13524-017-0611-1.
Van NessDaniel W.Heetderks StrongKaren. 2014. Restoring Justice: An Introduction to Restorative Justice. London: Routledge.
68.
VidmarN.MillerD.T., 1980. “Socialpsychological Processes Underlying Attitudes toward Legal Punishment.” Law and Society Review14(3):565–602.
69.
ZehrHoward. 1990. Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press.
70.
ZehrHoward. 2002. The Little Book of Restorative Justice. Intercourse, PA: Good Books.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
