Although studies have analyzed the effects of “stand your ground” (SYG) laws on violent crime, the question of why states are more likely to take measures to allow gun violence (albeit in self-defense) in the public sphere remains understudied in the literature. Using a fixed-effects event-history analysis of a panel of longitudinal state-level data for the period 2005–2012, we expand upon recent research by testing three competing perspectives on the adoption of SYG laws: group threat, political partisanship, and crime. Despite rhetorical framing of SYG laws as a means of self-defense from predatory criminals by gun-rights organizations, we find no effect of crime on the passage of SYG laws. Nor do we find evidence for group threat. Implications of these findings and directions for future research are discussed. Instead, results support the political partisanship view, providing further evidence of the politicization of gun policy in the contemporary United States.
AlbaRichardRumbautRubenMartozKaren. 2005. “A Distorted Nation: Perceptions of Racial/Ethnic Group Sizes and Attitudes toward Immigrants and Other Minorities.” Social Forces84(2):901–19.
2.
AllisonPaul D.2005. Fixed Effects Regression MEthods for Longitudinal Data Using SAS. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.
3.
AllisonPaul D.2010. Survival Analysis Using SAS: A Practical Guide. 2nd ed.Cary, NC: SAS Institute.
4.
American Bar Association. 2014. “Preliminary Report and Recommendations of the National Task Force on Stand Your Ground Laws.” Retrieved September 13, 2017 (http://www.abajournal.com/files/GunReport.pdf).
5.
AzraelDeborahCookPhillip J.MillerMatthew. 2004. “State and Local Prevalence of Firearms Ownership: Measurement, Structure, and Trends.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology20:43–62.
6.
BarclayScottFisherShauna. 2006. “The States and the Differing Impetus for Divergent Paths on Same-sex Marriage, 1990-2001.” The Policy Studies Journal31:331–52.
7.
BarkanStevenCohnSteven. 2005. “Why Whites Favor Spending More Money to Fight Crime: The Role of Racial Prejudice.” Social Problems52(2):300–14.
8.
BerryWilliamFordingRichardRindquistEvanHansonRussellKlarnerCarl. 2010. “Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in US States: A Re-appraisal.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly10:117–35.
9.
BerryWilliamRindquistEvanFordingRichardHansonRussell. 1998. “Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in the American States, 1960-1993.” American Journal of Political Science42:327–48.
10.
BerryWilliamRindquistEvanFordingRichardHansonRussell. 2007. “The Measurement and Stability of State Citizen Ideology.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly7:111–32.
11.
BlalockHubert M.1957. “Per Cent Non-white and Discrimination in the South.” American Sociological Review22:677–82.
12.
BlumerHerbert. 1958. “Race Prejudice as a Sense of Group Position.” Pacific Sociological Review1:3–7.
13.
BoboLawrence. 1988. “Group Conflict, Prejudice, and the Paradox of Contemporary Racial Attitudes.” Pp. 85–114 in Eliminating Racism, edited by KatzP. A.TaylorD. A. New York: Plenum Press.
14.
BoboLawrenceHutchingsVincent L. 1996. “Perceptions of Racial Group Competition: Extending Blumer’s Theory of Group Position to a Multiracial Social Context.” American Sociological Review61:951–72.
15.
BousheyGraemeLuedtkeAdam. 2011. “Immigrants across the U.S. Federal Laboratory: Explaining State-level Innovation in Immigration Policy.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly11:390–414.
16.
BrunsonRod. 2007. “The Police Don’t like Black People: African American Young Men’s Accumulated Police Experience.” Criminology & Public Policy6(1):71–101.
17.
BrunsonRodMillerJody. 2005. “Young Black Men and Urban Policing in the United States.” British Journal of Criminology46(4):613–40.
18.
BucklerKevinUnneverJames. 2008. “Racial and Ethnic Perceptions of Injustice: Testing the Core Hypotheses of Comparative Conflict Theory.” Journal of Criminal Justice36(3):270–78.
19.
BurnsPeterGimpelJames G. 2000. “Economic Insecurity, Prejudicial Stereotypes, and Public Opinion on Immigration Policy.” Political Science Quarterly115:201–25.
20.
ButzAdam M.FixMichael P.MitchellJoshua L. 2015. “Policy Learning and the Diffusion of Stand-your-ground Laws.” Politics & Policy43:347–77.
21.
CaoLiqunCullenFrancis T.LinkBruce G. 1997. “The Social Determinants of Gun Ownership: Self-Protection in an Urban Environment.” Criminology35(4):629-58.
22.
CaravelisCyndyChiricosTedBalesWilliam. 2011. “Static and Dynamic Indicators of Minority Threat in Sentencing Outcomes: A Multi-level Analysis.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology27(4):405–25.
23.
CarlsonJennifer. 2014. “The Equalizer? Crime, Vulnerability, and Gender in Pro-gun Discourse.” Feminist Criminology9(1):59–83.
24.
CarlsonJennifer. 2016. “Moral Panic, Moral Breach: Bernhard Goetz, George Zimmerman, and Racialized News Reporting in Contested Cases of Self-defense.” Social Problems63:1–20.
25.
CarmichaelJason T.2010. “Sentencing Disparities for Juvenile Offenders Sentenced to Adult Prisons: An individual and Contextual Analysis.” Journal of Criminal Justice38:747–57.
26.
CarmichaelJason T.KentStephanie. 2014. “The Persistent Significance of Racial and Economic Inequality on the Size of Municipal Police Forces in the United States, 1980-2010.” Social Problems61:159–82.
27.
CelinskaKatarzyna. 2007. “Individualism and Collectivism in America: The Case of Gun Ownership and Attitudes toward Gun Control.” Sociological Perspectives50(2):229–47.
28.
ChamlinMitchell B.2014. “An Assessment of the Intended and Unintended Consequences of Arizona’s Self-defense, Home Protection Act.” Journal of Crime and Justice37:327–38.
29.
ChenJulie. 2013. “Is All Punishment Local? The Effects of Jurisdictional Context on Sentence Length.” Social Science Quarterly94:1372–97.
30.
ChenJulie. 2014. “In the Furtherance of Justice, Injustice, or Both? A Multilevel Analysis of Courtroom Context and the Implementation of Three Strikes.” Justice Quarterly31(2):257–86.
31.
ChengChengHoekstraMark. 2013. “Does Strengthening Self-defense Law Deter Crime or Escalate Violence? Evidence from Expansions to Castle Doctrine.” Journal of Human Resources48:821–54.
32.
ChiricosTedHoganMichaelGertzMarc. 1997. “Racial Composition of Neighborhood and Fear of Crime.” Criminology35(1):107–31.
33.
ChiricosTedStupiElizabeth K.StultsBrian J.GertzMarc. 2014. “Undocumented Immigrant Threat and Support for Social Controls.” Social Problems61(4):673–92.
34.
ChiricosTedWelchKellyGertzMarc. 2004. “Racial Typification of Crime and Support for Punitive Measures.” Criminology42(2):358–90.
35.
CitrinJackGreenDonald P.MusteChristopherWongCara. 1997. “Public Opinion toward Immigration Reform: The Role of Economic Motivations.” The Journal of Politics59:858–81.
36.
CookPhillipDonohueJohn. 2017. “Saving Lives by Regulating Guns: Evidence for Policy.” Science358(6368):1259–61.
DixonJeffrey. 2006. “The Ties That Bind and Those That Don’t: Toward Reconciling Group Threat and Contact Theories of Prejudice.” Social Forces84(4):2179–204.
39.
DowlerKenneth. 2002. “Media Influence on Attitudes towards Guns and Gun Control.” American Journal of Criminal Justice26(2):235–47.
40.
EitleDavidD’AllessioStewartStolzenbergLisa. 2002. “Racial Threat and Social Control: A Test of the Political, Economic, and Threat of Black Crime Hypotheses.” Social Forces81:557–76.
41.
EitleDavidTaylorJohn. 2008. “Are Hispanics the New Threat? Minority Group Threat and Fear of Crime in Miami-Dade County.” Social Science Research37(4):1102–15.
42.
EriksonRobertWrightGeraldMcIverJohn. 1989. “Political Parties, Public Opinion, and State Policy in the United States.” American Political Science Review83(3):729–50.
43.
EspositoLuigiFinlayLaura. 2014. “Beyond Gun Control: Examining Neo-liberalism, Pro-gun Politics, and Gun Violence in the United States.” Theory in Action7(2):34–103.
44.
EstepKevin. 2017. “Constructing a Language Problem: Status-based Power Devaluation and the Threat of Immigrant Inclusion.” Sociological Perspectives60(3):437–58.
FilindraAlexandraKaplanNoah. 2017. “Testing Theories of Gun Policy Preferences among Blacks, Latinos, and Whites in America.” Social Science Quarterly98(2):413–28.
47.
FloresRené. 2015. “Taking the Law into Their Own Hands: Do Local Anti-immigrant Ordinances Increase Gun Sales?” Social Problems62(3):363–90.
GabbidonShaunJordanKareem. 2013. “Public Opinion on the Killing of Trayvon Martin: A Test of the Racial Gradient Thesis.” Journal of Crime & Justice36(3):283–98.
50.
GimpelJames. 1998. “Packing Heat at the Polls: Gun Ownership, Interest Group Endorsement and Voting Behavior in Gubernatorial Elections.” Social Science Quarterly79(3):634–48.
51.
GlaeserEdwardGlendonSpencer. 1998. “Who Owns Guns? Criminals, Victims, and the Culture of Violence.” American Economic Review88(2):458–62.
GrattetRyanJennessValerieCurryTheodore R. 1998. “The Homogenization and Differentiation of Hate Crime Law in the United States, 1978 to 1995: Innovation and Diffusion in the Criminalization of Bigotry.” American Sociological Review63:286–307.
54.
GreenDonald P.StrolovitchDara Z.WongJanelle S. 1998. “Defended Neighborhoods, Integration, and Racially Motivated Crime.” American Journal of Sociology104:372–403.
55.
Haider-MarkelDonaldJoslynMark. 2001. “Gun Policy, Opinion, Tragedy, and Blame Attribution: The Conditional Influence of Issue Frames.” The Journal of Politics63(2):523–33.
56.
Haider-MarkelDonaldJoslynMark. 2013. “The Politics of Causes: Mass Shootings and the Cases of the Virginia Tech and Tucson Tragedies.” Social Science Quarterly94(2):410–23.
57.
HairJoseph F.Jr.AndersonRolph E.TathamRonald L.BlackWilliam C. 1995. Multivariate Data Analysis. 3rd ed.New York: Macmillan.
58.
HallMathewKrysanMaria. 2016. “The Neighborhood Context of Latino Threat.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity3(2):218–35.
HelmsRonald. 2007. “The Impact of Political Context on Local Law Enforcement Resourcing: An Analysis of Deputy Employment Rates in US Counties.” Policing & Society17:182–206.
61.
HelmsRonaldJacobsDavid. 2002. “The Political Context of Sentencing: An Analysis of Community and Individual Determinants.” Social Forces81:577–604.
62.
HollidayWyatt. 2012. “The Answer to Criminal Aggression Is Retaliation: Stand-your-ground Laws and the Liberalization of Self-defense.” University of Toledo Law Review43:407–36.
63.
HolmesMalcolmSmithBradFrengAdrienneMuñozEd. 2008. “Minority Threat, Crime Control, and Police Resource Allocation in the Southwestern United States.” Crime & Delinquency54:128–52.
64.
JacksonPamelaCarrollLeo. 1981. “Race and the War on Crime: The Sociopolitical Determinants of Municipal Police Expenditures in 90 Non-Southern U.S. Cities.” American Sociological Review46:290–305.
65.
JacobsDavid. 1979. “Inequality and Police Strength: Conflict Theory and Coercive Control in Metropolitan Areas.” American Sociological Review44:913–25.
66.
JacobsDavidBrittDavid. 1979. “Inequality and Police Use of Deadly Force: An Empirical Assessment of a Conflict Hypothesis.” Social Problems26:403–12.
67.
JacobsDavidCarmichaelJason T. 2001. “The Politics of Punishment across Time and Space: A Pooled Time-Series Analysis of Imprisonment Rates.” Social Forces80(1):61-90.
68.
JacobsDavidCarmichaelJason. 2004. “Ideology, Social Threat, and the Death Sentence: Capital Sentences across Time and Space.” Social Forces83:249–78.
69.
JacobsDavidDixonMarc. 2006. “The Politics of Labor-management Relations: Detecting the Conditions that Affect Changes in Right-to-work Laws.” Social Problems53:118–37.
70.
JacobsDavidKlebanRichard. 2003. “Political Institutions, Minorities, and Punishment: A Pooled Cross-national Analysis of Imprisonment Rates.” Social Forces82:725–55.
71.
JansenStevenNugent-BorakoveM. Elaine. 2007. Expansions to the Castle Doctrine: Implications for Policy and Practice. Alexandria, VA: National District Attorneys Association.
72.
JohnsonDevon. 2001. “Punitive Attitudes on Crime: Economic Insecurity, Racial Prejudice, or Both?” Sociological Focus34(1):33–54.
73.
JoslynMarkHaider-MarkelDonaldBraggsMichaelBilboAndrew. 2017. “Emerging Political Identities? Gun Ownership and Voting in Presidential Elections.” Social Science Quarterly98(2):382–96.
74.
KahaneLeo. 1994. “Political, Ideological and Economic Determinants of Abortion Position: An Empirical Analysis of State Legislatures and Governors.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology53:347–60.
75.
KaneRobertGustafsonJosephBruellChristopher. 2013. “Racial Encroachment and the Formal Control of Space: Minority Group-threat and Misdemeanor Arrests in Urban Communities.” Justice Quarterly30(6):957–82.
76.
KingRyan. 2007. “The Context of Minority Group Threat: Race, Institutions, and Complying with Hate Crime Law.” Law & Society Review41:189–224.
77.
KingRyanWheelockDarren. 2007. “Group Threat and Social Control: Race, Perceptions of Minorities and the Desire to Punish.” Social Forces85:1255–80.
78.
KleckGary. 1996. “Crime, Culture Conflict and Sources of Support for Gun Control: A Multi-level Application of the General Social Surveys.” American Behavioral Scientist39(4):387–404.
79.
KleckGary. 2004. “Measures of Gun Ownership Levels for Macro-level Crime and Violence Research.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency41:3–36.
80.
KleckGary. 2017. “The Impact of Gun Ownership Rates on Crime Rates: A Methodological Review of the Evidence.” Journal of Criminal Justice43(1):40–48.
KleckGaryKovandzicTomislavSaberMarkHauserWill. 2011. “The Effect of Perceived Risk and Victimization on Plans to Purchase a Gun for Self-protection.” Journal of Criminal Justice39(4):312–19.
83.
KurtzHilda. 2013. “Trayvon Martin and the Dystopian Turn in US Self-defense Doctrine.” Antipode45:248–51.
84.
LawsonTamara. 2012. “A Fresh Cut in an Old Wound—A Critical Analysis of the Trayvon Martin Killing: The Public Outcry, the Prosecutors’ Discretion, and the Stand Your Ground Law.” University of Florida Journal of Law and Public Policy23:271–310.
85.
LeeCynthia. 2012. “Making Race Salient: Trayvon Martin and Implicit Bias in a Not yet Post-racial Society.” North Carolina Law Review91:101–57.
MarkertJohn. 2010. “The Changing Face of Racial Discrimination: Hispanics as the Dominant Minority in the USA—A New Application of Power-threat Theory.” Critical Sociology36(2):307–27.
90.
MarquezTimothySchraufnagelScot. 2013. “Hispanic Population Growth and State Immigration Policy: An Analysis of Restriction (2008–12).” Publius: The Journal of Federalism43:347–67.
91.
McCammonHolly J.1995. “The Politics of Protection: State Minimum Wage and Maximum Hours Laws for Women in the United States, 1870-1930.” The Sociological Quarterly36:217–49.
92.
McClellanChandlerTekinErdal. 2017. “Stand Your Ground Laws, Homicides, and Injuries,”Journal of Human Resources52(3): 621–653.
93.
MearsDanielStewartEric. 2010. “Interracial Contact and Fear of Crime.” Journal of Criminal Justice38(1):34–41.
94.
MedoffMarshal. 2002. “The Determinants and Impact of State Abortion Restrictions.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology61:481–93.
95.
MegaleElizabeth. 2010. “Deadly Combinations: How Self-defense Laws Pairing Immunity with a Presumption of Fear Allow Criminals to Get Away with Murder.” American Journal of Trial Advocacy34:105–34.
96.
MetzlJonathanMacLeishKenneth. 2015. “Mental Illness, Mass-shootings and the Politics of American Firearms.” American Journal of Public Health105(2):240–49.
97.
MichalowskiRaymond. 2013. “Ethnic Cleansing, American Style: SB 1070, Nativism and the Contradictions of Neo-liberal Globalization.” Journal of Crime and Justice36(2):171–93.
98.
MillerDarrell A. H.2009. “Guns as Smut: Defending the Home Bound Second Amendment.” Columbia Law Review109(6):1278–356.
NeterJohnWassermanWilliamKutnerMichael H. 1989. Applied Linear Regression Models. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
101.
O’BrienKerryForrestWalterLynottDermotDalyMichael. 2013. “Racism, Gun Ownership and Gun Control: Biased Attitudes in US Whites May Influence Policy Decisions.” PLoS ONE8(10):e77552. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0077552.
PattenRyanThomasMatthewWadaJames. 2013. “Packing Heat: Attitudes regarding Concealed Weapons on College Campuses.” American Journal of Criminal Justice38(4):551–69.
107.
Pearson-MerkowitzShannaDykeJoshua. 2017. “Crime and Partisanship: How Party ID Muddles Reality, Perception, and Policy Attitudes on Crime and Guns.” Social Science Quarterly98(2):443–54.
PickettJustin. 2016. “On the Social Foundations for Crimmigration: Latino Threat and Support for Expanded Police Powers.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology32(1):103–32.
111.
PickettJustinChiricosTedGoldenKristinGertzMarc. 2012. “Reconsidering the Relationship between Perceived Neighborhood Composition and Whites’ Perception of Victimization Risk: Do Racial Stereotypes Matter.” Criminology50(1):145–86.
QuillianLincoln. 1995. “Prejudice as a Response to Perceived Group Threat: Population Composition and Anti-immigrant and Racial Prejudice in Europe.” American Sociological Review60:586–611.
114.
QuillianLincolnPagerDevah. 2001. “Black Neighbors, Higher Crime? The Role of Racial Stereotypes in Evaluations of Neighborhood Crime.” American Journal of Sociology107(3):717–67.
115.
ReichGaryBarthJay. 2017. “Planting in Fertile Soil: The National Rifle Association and State Firearms Legislation.” Social Science Quarterly98(2):485–99.
116.
RenLingZhangYanZhaoJihong Solomon. 2012. “The Deterrent Effect of the Castle Doctrine Law on Burglary in Texas: A Tale of Outcomes in Houston and Dallas.” Crime and Delinquency61:1127–51.
117.
RichCamille Gear. 2014. “Angela Harris and the Racial Politics of Masculinity: Trayvon Martin, George Zimmerman, and the Dilemmas of Desiring Whiteness.” California Law Review102:1027–52.
RomeroLuisZarrughAmina. 2018. “Islamophobia and the Making of Latinos/as into Terrorist Threats.” Ethnic and Racial Studies31(12):2235–54.
120.
SchildkrautDeborah J.2001. “Official-English and the States: Influences on Declaring English the Official Language in the United States.” Political Research Quarterly54(2):445–57.
121.
ShapiraHarel. 2013. Waiting for Jose: Minutemen’s Pursuit of America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
122.
ShinHeejuLealDavidEllisonChristopher. 2015. “Does Anti-Hispanic Bias Motivate Opposition to Non-English Languages?” Sociological Inquiry85(3):375–406.
123.
ShipanCharles R.VoldenCraig. 2006. “Bottom-up Policy Federalism: The Spread of Antismoking Laws from U.S. Cities to States.” American Journal of Political Science50:825–43.
124.
SiegelMichaelNegussieYamrotVantureSarahPleskunasJaneRossCraig S.KingCharlesIII. 2014. “The Relationship between Gun Ownership and Stranger and Nonstranger Firearm Homicide Rates in the United States, 1981-2010.” American Journal of Public Health104:1912–19.
SouleSarah. 2004. “Going to the Chapel? Same-sex Marriage Bans in the United States, 1973-2000.” Social Problems51:453–77.
127.
SouleSarahEarlJennifer. 2001. “The Enactment of State-level Hate Crime in the United States: Intrastate and Interstate Factors.” Sociological Perspectives44:281–305.
128.
SpohnCassiaHolleranDavid. 2000. “The Imprisonment Penalty Paid by Young, Unemployed Black and Hispanic Male Offenders.” Criminology38(1):281–306.
129.
SteffensmeirDarrellDemuthStephen. 2001. “Ethnicity and Judges’ Sentencing Decisions: Hispanic-Black-White Comparisons.” Criminology39(1):145–78.
130.
SteilJustinVasiIon. 2014. “The New Immigration Contestation: Social Movements and Local Immigration Policy Making in the United States, 2000-2011.” American Journal of Sociology119(4):1104–55.
131.
StewartEricMartinezRamiroBaumerEricGertzMarc. 2015. “The Social Context of Latino Threat and Punitive-Latino Sentiment.” Social Problems62(1):68–92.
132.
SukJeannie. 2008. “The True Woman: Scenes from the Law of Self-defense.” Harvard Journal of Law & Gender31:237–75.
133.
TaylorMarylee. 1998. “How White Attitudes Vary with the Racial Composition of the Local Populations: Numbers Count.” American Sociological Review63(4):512–35.
TolnayStewart E.BeckE. M.MasseyJames L. 1989. “The Power Threat Hypothesis and Black Lynching: ‘Wither’ the Evidence?” Social Forces67:634–41.
136.
UnneverJamesCullenFrancis. 2007. “The Racial Divide in Support for the Death Penalty: Does White Racism Matter?” Social Forces85:1281–301.
137.
ValentinoNicholas A.SearsDavid O. 2005. “Old Times There Are Not Forgotten: Race and Partisan Realignment in the Contemporary South.” American Journal of Political Science49(3):672–88.
138.
VizzardWilliam. 2015. “The Current and Future State of Gun Policy in the United States.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology104(4):879–904.
139.
WaldmanMichael. 2014. The Second Amendment: A Biography. New York: Simon & Schuster.
WangXia. 2012. “Undocumented Immigrants as Perceived Criminal Threat: A Test of the Minority Threat Perspective.” Criminology50(3):743–76.
142.
WardMatthew. 2017. “Opportunity, Resources, and Threat: Explaining Local Nativist Organizing in the United States.” Sociological Perspective60(3):459–78.
143.
WebsterDanielKrifasiC. K.VernickJ. S. 2014. “The Effect of the Repeal of Missouri’s Handgun Purchaser Licensing Law on Homicides.” Journal of Urban Health91:293–302.
WelchKelly. 2007. “Black Criminal Stereotypes and Racial Profiling.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice23(3):276–88.
146.
WelchKellyPayneAllisonChiricosTedGertzMarc. 2011. “The Typification of Hispanics as Criminals and Support for Punitive Crime Control Policies.” Social Science Research40(3):822–40.
147.
WoodsJoshuaMarciniakAgnieszka. 2016. “The Effects of Perceived Threat, Political Orientation, and Framing on Public Reactions to Punitive Immigration Law Enforcement Practices.” Sociology of Race & Ethnicity3(2):202–17.
148.
YoungDavid. 1985. “Perceptions of Crime, Racial Attitudes, and Firearms Ownership.” Social Forces64(2):473–86.
149.
ZingherJoshua N.2014. “The Ideological and Electoral Determinants of Laws Targeting Undocumented Migrants in the U.S. States.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly14:90–117.
