Online trolling as a form of overt racism forces sociologists to reexamine contemporary understandings of racialization in a color-blind era. In this article, I demonstrate how men of color construct meanings about their experiences of racist hate speech, referred to as trash talk, on an online gaming platform. Analyzing semistructured interviews, I show that respondents cope with this form of racism through a process of desensitization. This strategy is mediated by respondents’ peer socialization on how to effectively manage this racism as men, and their stigmatization by others who do not view these experiences as “real” racism. Strategies to cope with racism in this domain are thus gendered in ways that encourage men of color to remain silent in the face of repeated hate speech. This study further demonstrates how individual strategies developed to navigate racism online are tied to broader, collective understandings of the meanings of race, racisms, and masculinity.
AjrouchKristine J.ReisineSusanLimSungwooSohnWoosungIsmailAmid. 2010. “Perceived Everyday Discrimination and Psychological Distress: Does Social Support Matter?” Ethnicity & Health15(4):417–34.
2.
ArendellTerry. 1997. “Reflections on the Researcher-researched Relationship: A Woman Interviewing Men.” Qualitative Sociology20(3):341–68.
3.
BallinasJorge. 2017. “Where Are You from and Why Are You Here? Microaggressions, Racialization, and Mexican College Students in a New Destination.” Sociological Inquiry87(2):385–410.
4.
BeckVictoria SimpsonBoysStephanieRoseChristopherBeckEric. 2012. “Violence against Women in Video Games: A Prequel or Sequel to Rape Myth Acceptance?” Journal of Interpersonal Violence27(15):3016–31.
5.
Behm-MorawitzElizabethMastroDana. 2009. “The Effects of the Sexualization of Female Video Game Characters on Gender Stereotyping and Female Self Concept.” Sex Roles61(11–12):808–23.
6.
BilligMichael. 2001. “Humour and Hatred: The Racist Jokes of the Ku Klux Klan.” Discourse & Society12(3):267–89.
7.
BliucAna-MariaMcGartyCraigHartleyLisaHendresDaniela Muntele. 2012. “Manipulating National Identity: The Strategic Use of Rhetoric by Supporters and Opponents of the ‘Cronulla Riots’ in Australia.” Ethnic and Racial Studies35(12):2174–94.
8.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 1997. “Rethinking racism: Toward a structural interpretation.” American Sociological Review62(3):465–80.
9.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 2006. Racism without Racists: Color-blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in the United States. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
10.
BowlegLisaBurkholderGary J.MassieJenné S.WahomeRahabTetiMichelleMalebrancheDavid J.TschannJeanne M.2013. “Racial Discrimination, Social Support, and Sexual HIV Risk among Black Heterosexual Men.” AIDS and Behavior17(1):407–18.
11.
BraunVirginiaClarkeVictoria. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology3(2):77-101.
12.
BrickellChris. 2012. “Sexuality, Power and the Sociology of the Internet.” Current Sociology60(1):28–44.
13.
BroomsDerrick R.PerryArmon R.2016. “‘It’s Simply Because We’re Black Men’: Black Men’s Experiences and Responses to the Killing of Black Men.” The Journal of Men’s Studies24(2):166–84.
14.
BuckelsErin E.TrapnellPaul D.PaulhusDelroy L.2014. “Trolls Just Want to Have Fun.” Personality and Individual Differences67:97–102.
15.
CabreraNolen L.2014a. “‘But I’m Oppressed Too’: White Male College Students Framing Racial Emotions as Facts and Recreating Racism.” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education27(6):768–84.
16.
CabreraNolen L.2014b. “Exposing Whiteness in Higher Education: White Male College Students Minimizing Racism, Claiming Victimization, and Recreating White Supremacy.” Race Ethnicity and Education17(1):30–55.
17.
CarrErika R.SzymanskiDawn M.TahaFarahWestLindsey M.KaslowNadine J.2014. “Understanding the Link between Multiple Oppressions and Depression among African American Women: The Role of Internalization.” Psychology of Women Quarterly38(2):233–45.
18.
CarverCharles S.Connor-SmithJennifer. 2010. “Personality and Coping.” Annual Review of Psychology61:679–704.
19.
CazenaveNoel A.2016. Conceptualizing Racism: Breaking the Chains of Racially Accommodating Language. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
20.
ChenSiyu. 2016. “Negotiating Masculinities through the Game of Distinction—A Case Study of MOBA Gamers at a Chinese University.” Asian Anthropology15(3):242–59.
21.
ChessShiraShawAdrienne. 2015. “A Conspiracy of Fishes, or, How We Learned to Stop Worrying about #GamerGate and Embrace Hegemonic Masculinity.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media59(1):208–20.
22.
ChoiKyung-HeeHanChong-sukPaulJayAyalaGeorge. 2011. “Strategies for Managing Racism and Homophobia among U.S. Ethnic and Racial Minority Men Who Have Sex with Men.” AIDS Education and Prevention23(2):145–58.
23.
ChooHae YeonFerreeMyra Marx. 2010. “Practicing Intersectionality in Sociological Research: A Critical Analysis of Inclusions, Interactions, and Institutions in the Study of Inequalities.” Sociological Theory28(2):129–49.
24.
ColesTony. 2009. “Negotiating the Field of Masculinity: The Production and Reproduction of Multiple Dominant Masculinities.” Men and Masculinities12(1):30–44.
25.
CollinsPatricia HillBilgeSirma. 2016. Intersectionality. Malden, MA: John Wiley.
26.
ConmyBenTenenbaumGershonEklundRobertRoehrigAlysia. 2013. “Trash Talk in a Competitive Setting: Impact on Self-efficacy and Affect.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology43(5):1002–14.
27.
ConsalvoMia. 2009. “There is No Magic Circle.” Games and Culture4(4):408–17.
28.
CooperShauna M.GuthrieBarbara J.BrownCharityMetzgerIsha. 2011. “Daily Hassles and African American Adolescent Females’ Psychological Functioning: Direct and Interactive Associations with Gender Role Orientation.” Sex Roles65(5–6):397–409.
29.
CooperShauna M.BrownCharityMetzgerIshaClintonYvetteGuthrieBarbara. 2013. “Racial Discrimination and African American Adolescents’ Adjustment: Gender Variation in Family and Community Social Support, Promotive and Protective Factors.” Journal of Child and Family Studies22(1):15–29.
30.
CoteAmanda C.2017. “‘I Can Defend Myself’: Women’s Strategies for Coping with Harassment While Gaming Online.” Games and Culture12(2):136–55.
31.
CourtenayWill H. 2000. “Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-being: A Theory of Gender and Health.” Social Science & Medicine50(10):1385–1401.
32.
CreswellJohn W.MillerDana L.2000. “Determining Validity in Qualitative Inquiry.” Theory into Practice39(3):124-130.
33.
CruzAngela Gracia B.SeoYuriRexMathew. 2018. “Trolling in Online Communities: A Practice-based Theoretical Perspective.” The Information Society34(1):15–26.
34.
DanielsJessie. 2013. “Race and Racism in Internet Studies: A Review and Critique.” New Media & Society15(5):695–719.
35.
DavisDon E.DeBlaereCirleenHookJoshua N.BurnetteJeniVan TongerenDaryl R.RiceKenneth G.WorthingtonEverett L.Jr.2015. “Intergroup Forgiveness of Race-related Offenses.” Journal of Counseling Psychology62(3):402–12.
36.
De GroveCédricFrederikCourtoisLooyJan Van. 2015. “How to Be a Gamer! Exploring Personal and Social Indicators of Gamer Identity.” Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication20(3):346–61.
37.
DwyerSonya CorbinBuckleJennifer L.2009. “The Space Between: On Being an Insider-outsider in Qualitative Research.” International Journal of Qualitative Methods8(1):54–63.
38.
EmbrickDavid G.HenricksKasey. 2013. “Discursive colorlines at work: How epithets and stereotypes are racially unequal.” Symbolic Interaction36(2):197–215.
39.
EmbrickDavid G.HenricksKasey. 2015. “Two-faced-isms: Racism at Work and How Race Discourse Shapes Classtalk and Gendertalk.” Language Sciences52:165–75.
40.
EngelhardtChristopher R.BartholowBruce D.KerrGeoffrey T.BushmanBrad J.2011. “This Is Your Brain on Violent Video Games: Neural Desensitization to Violence Predicts Increased Aggression Following Violent Video Game Exposure.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology47(5):1033–36.
Erguner-TekinalpBengu. 2009. “Daily Experiences of Racism and Forgiving Historical Offenses: An African American Experience.” International Journal of Human and Social Sciences4(1):1–9.
FaulknerNicholasBliucAna-Maria. 2016. “‘It’s Okay to Be Racist’: Moral Disengagement in Online Discussions of Racist Incidents in Australia.” Ethnic and Racial Studies39(14):2545–63.
45.
FeaginJoe R.2013. The White Racial Frame: Centuries of Racial Framing and Counter-framing. New York: Routledge.
46.
FlerasAugie. 2016. “Theorizing Micro-aggressions as Racism 3.0: Shifting the Discourse.” Canadian Ethnic Studies48(2):1–19.
47.
GoodmanPhilip. 2014. “Race in California’s Prison Fire Camps for Men: Prison Politics, Space, and the Racialization of Everyday Life.” American Journal of Sociology120(2):352–94.
48.
GrayKishonna L.2011. Deviant Bodies Resisting Online: Examining the Intersecting Realities of Women of Color in Xbox Live. PhD dissertation, Department of Justice Studies, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ.
49.
GrayKishonna L.2012. “Deviant Bodies, Stigmatized Identities, and Racist Acts: Examining the Experiences of African-American Gamers in Xbox Live.” New Review of Hypermedia and Multimedia18(4):261–76.
50.
GrayKishonna L.2014. Race, Gender, and Deviance in Xbox Live: Theoretical Perspectives from the Virtual Margins. Oxford, England: Elsevier.
51.
GrayKishonna L.2016. “‘They’re Just Too Urban’: Black Gamers Streaming on Twitch.” Pp. 355–68 in Digital Sociologies, edited by DanielsJessieGregoryKarenCottomTressie M.Bristol, England: University of Bristol.
52.
GrayKishonna L.2018. “Gaming Out Online: Black Lesbian Identity Development and Community Building in Xbox Live.” Journal of Lesbian Studies22:282–96.
53.
GrayKishonna L.BuyukozturkBertanHillZachary G.2017. “Blurring the Boundaries: Using Gamergate to Examine ‘Real’ and Symbolic Violence against Women in Contemporary Gaming Culture.” Sociology Compass11(3):e12458.
54.
HammondWizdom Powell. 2012. “Taking it Like a Man: Masculine Role Norms as Moderators of the Racial Discrimination–depressive Symptoms Association among African American Men.” American Journal of Public Health102(2):232–41.
55.
HammondWizdom PowellBanksKira HudsonMattisJacqueline S.2006. “Masculinity Ideology and Forgiveness of Racial Discrimination among African American Men: Direct and Interactive Relationships.” Sex Roles55(9–10):679–92.
56.
HardakerClaire. 2010. “Trolling in Asynchronous Computer-mediated Communication: From User Discussions to Academic Definitions.” Journal of Politeness Research6:215–42.
57.
HarrellShelly P.2000. “A Multidimensional Conceptualization of Racism-related Stress: Implications for the Well-being of People of Color.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry70(1):42–57.
58.
HillJane H.2008. The Everyday Language of White Racism. Chichester, England: John Wiley.
59.
HoltThomas C.1995. “Marking: Race, Race-making, and the Writing of History.” The American Historical Review100(1):1–20.
60.
HudsonDarrell L.NeighborsHarold W.GeronimusArline T.JacksonJames S.2016. “Racial Discrimination, John Henryism, and Depression among African Americans.” Journal of Black Psychology42(3):221–43.
61.
HurtadoAídaSinhaMrinal. 2008. “More than Men: Latino Feminist Masculinities and Intersectionality.” Sex Roles59(6):337–49.
62.
JacksonBrandon A.2018. “Beyond the Cool Pose: Black Men and Emotion Management Strategies.” Sociology Compass12:e12569.
63.
JacksonBrandon A.WingfieldAdia Harvey. 2013. “Getting Angry to Get Ahead: Black College Men, Emotional Performance, and Encouraging Respectable Masculinity.” Symbolic Interaction36(3):275–92.
64.
JakupcakMatthewSaltersKristalynGratzKim L.RoemerLizabeth. 2003. “Masculinity and Emotionality: An Investigation of Men’s Primary and Secondary Emotional Responding.” Sex Roles49(3):111–20.
65.
JamesCarl E.2012. “Students ‘at Risk’ Stereotypes and the Schooling of Black Boys.” Urban Education47(2):464–94.
66.
JosephNicole M.MitchellViesca, KaraBiancoMargarita. 2016. “Black Female Adolescents and Racism in Schools: Experiences in a Colorblind Society.” The High School Journal100(1):4–25.
67.
KaiserCheryl R.MillerCarol T.2001. “Stop Complaining! The Social Costs of Making Attributions to Discrimination.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27(2):254–63.
68.
KendallLori. 1999. “Nerd Nation: Images of Nerds in US Popular Culture.” International Journal of Cultural Studies2(2):260–83.
69.
KendallLori. 2000. “‘Oh No! I’m a Nerd!’ Hegemonic Masculinity on an Online Forum.” Gender & Society14(2):256–74.
70.
KimIsokSpencerMichael S.2011. “Heavy Drinking, Perceived Discrimination, and Immigration Status among Filipino Americans.” Substance Use & Misuse46(10):1256–64.
71.
KimuraAya. 2008. “Discrimination, Group Identity, and Mental Health: a Comparative Study of African Americans, Caribbean Americans, and European Americans.” PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Akron, Akron, OH.
72.
LeonardDavid. 2003. “‘Live in Your World, Play in Ours’: Race, Video Games, and Consuming the Other.” SIMILE: Studies in Media & Information Literacy Education3(4):1–9.
73.
LewisAmanda E.2003. “Everyday Race-making: Navigating Racial Boundaries in Schools.” American Behavioral Scientist47(3):283–305.
74.
LewisJioni A.MendenhallRubyHarwoodStacy A.HunttMargaret Browne. 2013. “Coping with Gendered Racial Microaggressions among Black Women College Students.” Journal of African American Studies17(1):51–73.
75.
LewisTené T.TroxelWendy M.KravitzHoward M.BrombergerJoyce T.MatthewsKaren A.HallMartica H.2013. “Chronic Exposure to Everyday Discrimination and Sleep in a Multiethnic Sample of Middle-aged Women.” Health Psychology32(7):810–19.
76.
LiangChristopher T. H.AlvarezAlvin N.JuangLinda P.LiangMandy X.2007. “The Role of Coping in the Relationship between Perceived Racism and Racism-related Stress for Asian Americans: Gender Differences.” Journal of Counseling Psychology54(2):132–41.
77.
LiangChristopher T. H.SalcedoJimeMillerHolly A.2011. “Perceived Racism, Masculinity Ideologies, and Gender Role Conflict among Latino Men.” Psychology of Men & Masculinity12(3):201–15.
78.
LoweSusana MingOkuboYukiReillyMichael F.2012. “A Qualitative Inquiry into Racism, Trauma, and Coping: Implications for Supporting Victims of Racism.” Professional Psychology: Research and Practice43(3):190–98.
79.
ManciniChristina, Daniel P.StewartMears, Eric A.BeaverKevin M.PickettJustin T.2015. “Whites’ Perceptions about Black Criminality: A Closer Look at the Contact Hypothesis.” Crime & Delinquency61(7): 996-1022.
80.
MantillaKarla. 2013. “Gendertrolling: Misogyny Adapts to New Media.” Feminist Studies39(2):563–70.
81.
MartinotSteve. 2010. The Machinery of Whiteness: Studies in the Structure of Racialization. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
82.
MesserschmidtJames W.2013. Crime as Structured Action: Doing Masculinities, Race, Class, Sexuality, and Crime. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
MorseJanice M.1994. “Designing Qualitative Research.” Pp. 220–35 in Handbook of Qualitative Inquiry, edited by DenzinNorman K.LincolnYvonna S.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
NaplesNancy A.1996. “A Feminist Revisiting of the Insider/Outsider Debate: The ‘Outsider Phenomenon’ in Rural Iowa.” Qualitative Sociology19(1):83–106.
87.
O’ConnorLisa A.WeinsteinBenjaminStylianouAmanda M.2017. “Supporting Young Men of Color as Survivors of Crime and Violence.” Social Work62(1):83–85.
88.
OhHansYangLawrence H.AnglinDeidre M.DeVylderJordan E.2014. “Perceived Discrimination and Psychotic Experiences across Multiple Ethnic Groups in the United States.” Schizophrenia Research157(1):259–65.
89.
OjedaLizetteLiangChristopher T. H.2014. “Ethnocultural and Gendered Determinants of Coping among Mexican American Adolescent Men.” Psychology of Men & Masculinity15(3):296–304.
90.
OmiMichaelWinantHoward. 2014. Racial Formation in the United States. New York: Routledge.
91.
OrnelasIndia J.AmellJimTranAnh N.RoysterMichaelArmstrong-BrownJanelleEngEugenia. 2009. “Understanding African American Men’s Perceptions of Racism, Male Gender Socialization, and Social Capital through Photovoice.” Qualitative Health Research19(4):552–65.
92.
OrtizStephanie M.2018. “The meanings of racist and sexist trash talk for men of color: A cultural sociological approach to studying gaming culture.” New Media & Society. published electronically. doi:1461444818814252.
93.
ParsonsChad. 2007. “The Halo Effect: Hegemonic Masculinity in Online Gaming.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, August 11, New York.
94.
PiccaLeslie H.FeaginJoe R.2007. Two-faced Racism: Whites in the Backstage and Frontstage. New York: Routledge.
95.
PowellWizdomBanksKira HudsonMattisJacqueline S.2017. “Buried Hatchets, Marked Locations: Forgiveness, Everyday Racial Discrimination, and African American Men’s Depressive Symptomatology.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry87:646–62. doi:10.1037/ort0000210.
96.
RaineyDavid W.GranitoVincent. 2010. “Normative Rules for Trash Talk among College Athletes: An Exploratory Study.” Journal of Sport Behavior33(3):276–94.
97.
RiosVictor M.2011. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York: New York University Press.
98.
RollockDavidLuiP. Priscilla. 2016. “Do Spouses Matter? Discrimination, Social Support, and Psychological Distress among Asian Americans.” Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology22(1):47–57.
99.
SaboSamanthaShawSusanIngramMaiaTeufel-ShoneNicoletteCarvajalScottde ZapienJill GuernseyRosalesCeciliaRedondoFlorGarciaGinaRubio-GoldsmithRaquel. 2014. “Everyday Violence, Structural Racism and Mistreatment at the US–Mexico Border.” Social Science & Medicine109:66–74.
100.
SalterAnastasiaBlodgettBridget. 2012. “Hypermasculinity & Dickwolves: The Contentious Role of Women in the New Gaming Public.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media56(3):401–16.
101.
SanfilippoMadelynYangShengnanFichmanPnina. 2017. “Trolling Here, There, and Everywhere: Perceptions of Trolling Behaviors in Context.” Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology68(10):2313–27.
102.
SapersteinAliyaPennerAndrew M.LightRyan. 2013. “Racial Formation in Perspective: Connecting Individuals, Institutions, and Power Relations.” Annual Review of Sociology39:359–78.
103.
ShawAdrienne. 2012. “Do You Identify as a Gamer? Gender, Race, Sexuality, and Gamer Identity.” New Media & Society14(1):28–44.
104.
SmithWilliam A.MustaffaJalil BishopJonesChantal M.CurryTommy J.AllenWalter R.2016. “‘You Make me Wanna Holler and Throw up Both My Hands!’ Campus Culture, Black Misandric Microaggressions, and Racial Battle Fatigue.” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education29(9):1189–1209.
105.
SmithWilliam A.AllenWalter R.DanleyLynette L.2007. “‘Assume the Position . . . You Fit the Description’: Psychosocial Experiences and Racial Battle Fatigue among African American Male College Students.” American Behavioral Scientist51(4):551–78.
106.
SwimJanet K.HyersLauri L.CohenLaurie L.FitzgeraldDavita C.BylsmaWayne H.2003. “African American College Students’ Experiences with Everyday Racism: Characteristics of and Responses to These Incidents.” Journal of Black Psychology29(1):38–67.
107.
TwineFrance W.2004. “A white side of black Britain: The concept of racial literacy.” Ethnic and Racial Studies27(6): 878–907.
108.
TwineFrance W.2010. A White Side of Black Britain: Interracial Intimacy and Racial Literacy. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
