Explanations for the difficulty faced by unions in their attempts to organize workers in high-tech firms in the Sunbelt are examined. We located our discussion within the theoretical debate regarding the decline of unions in the United States. Our focus is on 125 workers in two high-tech firms in a large Texas city. Based on survey data, personal interviews, and field observations, we describe the work and nonwork experiences of employees as they relate to the unionization process. We argue for a multicausal explanation for the lack of unionization. An authoritarian work environment, disorganized work lives, and an antiunion political climate combine to make unionization an unlikely alternative for these workers, despite the fact that they are not inherently antiunion in their attitudes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ARONOWITZ, S.
(1983) Working Class Hero. New York: Pilgrim Press.
2.
BECKER, B. E.
and R. U. MILLER. (1981) “Patterns and determinants of union growth in the hospital industry.”J. of Labor Research2: 309-328.
3.
BELL, D.
(1972) “Labor in the post-industrial society.”Dissent19: 163-189.
4.
BELL, D.
(1973) The Coming of Post-Industrial Society. New York: Basic Books.
5.
BLAUNER, R.
(1964) Alienation and Freedom. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
6.
CHALYKOFF, H.
and P. CAPPELLI (1986) “Union avoidance: management's new industrial relations strategy.”Monthly Labor Rev.190: 45-46.
7.
COOKE, W.
(1985) “The rising toll of discrimination against union activists.”Industrial Relations24: 421-441.
8.
CORNFIELD, D. B.
(1986) “Declining union membership in the post-World War II era: the United Furniture Workers of America, 1939-1982.”Amer. J. of Soc.91: 1112-1153.
9.
DELANEY, J.
(1981) “Union success in hospital representation elections.”Industrial Relations20: 149-161.
10.
EDWARDS, R.et al.
(eds.) (1986) Unions in Crisis and Beyond. Dover, MA: Auburn House
11.
FIORITO, J.
and C. GREER (1982) “Determinants of U.S. unionism: past research and future needs.”Industrial Relations23: 1-32.
12.
FREEMAN, R.
(1985) “Why are unions faring poorly in NLRB representation elections?” in T. Kochan (ed.) Challenges & Choices Facing American Labor. Cambridge: MIT Press.
13.
FREEMAN, R.
and J. MEDOFF (1984) What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
14.
FUENTES, A.
and B. EHRENREICH (1983) Women in the Global Factory. Boston: South End Press.
15.
GETMAN, J.
, G. STEPHEN, B. GOLDBERG, and J. B. HERMAN (1976) Union Representation Elections: Law and Reality. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
16.
GOLDFIELD, M.
(1982) “The decline of organized labor: NLRB union certification election results.”Politics and Society11: 167-209.
17.
GOLDFIELD, M.
(1984) “The causes of U.S. trade union decline and their future prospects.”Research in Pol. Economy7: 81-159.
18.
GOODMAN, R.
(1979) The Last Entrepreneurs. Boston: South End Press.
19.
GREER, C. R.
and J. C. SHEARER (1981) “Foreign ownership effects on NLRB representation elections.”J. of Int. Business Studies3: 9-23.
20.
GUNDERSON, M.
and N. M. MELTZ (1986) “Canadian unions achieve strong gains in membership.”Monthly Labor Rev.190: 48-49.
21.
HENEMAN, H.
and M. SANDAVER (1983) “Predicting the outcome of union certification election: a review of the literature.”Industrial and Labor Relations Rev.36: 537-559.
22.
HILLS, S. M.
(1985) “Attitudes of union and non-union male workers toward union representation.”Industrial and Labor Relations Rev.38: 179-194.
23.
HIRSCH, B.
(1980) “The determinants of unionization. An analysis of interarea differences.”Industrial and Labor Relations Rev.33: 147-161.
24.
HODSON, R.
(1985) “Working in `high-tech': research issues and opportunities for the industrial sociologist.”Soc. Q.26: 351-364.
25.
HUNT, J. C.
and R. A. WHITE (1983) “The effects of right-to-work legislation on union outcomes: additional evidence.”J. of Labor Research4: 47-75.
26.
HUXLEY, C.
, D. KETTLER, and J. STRUTHERS (1986) “Is Canada's experience `especially instructive'?” pp. 113-132 in S. M. Lipset (ed.) Unions in Transition. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies.
27.
JURIS, H.
and M. ROOMKIN (1980) “The shrinking perimeter: unions and collective bargaining in manufacturing,” in H. A. Juris and M. Roomkin (eds.) The Shrinking Perimeter. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
28.
KOCHAN, T.
(1979) “How American workers view labor unions.”Monthly Labor Rev.192 (April): 23-31.
29.
KOCHAN, T.
(1980) “Industrial relations research: an agenda for the 1980s.”Monthly Labor Rev.103 (September): 20-25.
30.
KORNHAUSER, R.
(1961) “Some social determinants and consequences of union membership.”Labor History2: 30-61.
31.
KUTTNER, B.
(1984) “Can labor lead?”New Republic (March 12).
32.
LAWLER, J.
(1982) “Labor-management consultants in union organizing campaigns: do they make a difference?” pp. 274-280 in Proceedings of the 34th annual winter meeting, Industrial Relations Research Assn., December 28-30, 1981, Washington, DC. Madison, WI: IRRA.
33.
LELOUARN, J.-Y.
(1979) “Predicting union vote from worker attitudes and perceptions,” pp. 72-82 in Proceedings of the Industrial Relations Research Assn. Madison, WI: IRRA.
34.
LIPSET, S. R.
(1986) “North American labor movements: a comparative perspective,” pp. 421-454 in S. M. Lipset (ed.) Unions in Transition. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies.
35.
MELTZ, N. M.
(1985) “Labor movements in Canada and the United States,” in T. Kochan (ed.) Challenges and Choices Facing American Labor. Cambridge: MIT Press.
36.
PERSONICK, V. A.
(1983) “The job outlook through 1995: industry output and employment projections.”Monthly Labor Rev.106 (11): 24-36.
37.
PRESTON, L. E.
(1980) “The manufacturing environment in the 1980s,” pp. 3-34 in H. Juris and M. Roomkin (eds.) The Shrinking Perimeter. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
38.
REES, A.
(1980) “The size of union membership in manufacturing in the 1980s,” pp. 43-54 in H. Juris and M. Roomkin (eds.) The Shrinking Perimeter. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
39.
RICHIE, R. W.
, D. E. HECKER, and J. U. Burgan (1983) “High technology today and tomorrow.”Monthly Labor Rev.106 (11): 50-58.
40.
RIDDELL, C.
(1985) “Canadian labour relations: an overview,” in C. Riddell (ed.) Canadian Labour Relations. Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press.
41.
ROBERTS, B. C.
(1984) “Recent trends in collective bargaining in the United Kingdom.”Int. Labour Rev.123: 287-306.
42.
ROGERS, E. M.
and J. K. LARSEN. (1984) Silicon Valley Fever. New York: Basic Books.
43.
ROOMKIN, M.
and H. A. JURIS (1979) “Unions in the traditional sectors: the mid-life passage of the labor movement,” pp. 249-259 in Proceedings of the Industrial Relations Research Assn. Madison, WI: IRRA.
44.
ROSE, J. B.
and G. N. CHAISON (1985) “The state of the unions: United States and Canada.”J. of Labour Research6: 97-112.
45.
ROSENSTEIN, J.
and J. L. FRENCH (1985) “Attitudes toward unionization in an employeeowned firm in the Southwest.”Work and Occupations12: 464-478.
46.
RUBERY, J.
(1986) “Trade unions in the 1980s: the case of the United Kingdom,” in R. Edwardset al. (eds.) Unions in Crisis and Beyond. Dover, MA: Auburn House.
47.
SANDAVER, M.
and H. HENEMAN (1981) “Union growth through the election process.”Industrial Relations20: 109-116.
48.
SCHRIESHEIM, C. A.
(1978) “Job satisfaction, attitudes toward unions, and voting in a union representation election.”J. of Applied Psychology63: 548-552.
49.
SCHULMAN, M. D.
, R. ZINGRAFF, and L. REIF (1985) “Race, gender class consciousness and union support: an analysis of southern textile workers.”Sociological Q.26: 187-204.
50.
SEEBER, R. L. (1981) “A model of individual demand for unionism.” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Illinois.
51.
SEEBER, R.
and W. COOKE (1983) “The decline in union success in NLRB representation elections.”Industrial Relations22: 34-44.
52.
SIEGEL, L.
(1981) “Delicate bonds: the global semiconductor industry.”Pacific Research XI#1.
53.
SIMPSON, R. L.
(1981) “Labor force integration and southern U.S. textile unionism.”Research in the Sociology of Work1: 381-401.
54.
SOSKICE, D.
(1984) “Industrial relations and the British economy, 1979-1983.”Industrial Relations23: 306-321.
55.
SVENSSON, L.
(1986) “Class struggle in a welfare state in crisis: from radicalism to neoliberalism in Sweden,” in R. Edwardset al. (eds.) Unions in Crisis and Beyond. Dover, MA: Auburn House.
56.
TABB, W. K.
(1983) “Urban development and regional restructuring, an overview,” in L. Sawyers and W. K. Tabb (eds.) Sunbelt/Snowbelt. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
57.
TAUSKY, K.
(1984) Work and Society. Itasca, IL: F. E. Peacock.
58.
TROST, C.
(1986, December 2) “More family issues surface at bargaining tables as women show increasing interest in unions.”Wall Street J.
59.
TROY, L.
(1986) “The rise and fall of American trade unions: the labor movement From FDR to RR,” pp. 75-112 in S. M. Lipset (ed.) Unions in Transition. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies.
60.
WEILER, P.
(1983) “Promises to keep.”Harvard Law Rev.96: 1769-1827.
61.
WERTHEIMER, B. M.
(1977) We Were There: The Story of Working Women in America. New York: Pantheon Books.
62.
WRENN, R.
(1985) “The decline of American labor.”Socialist Rev. (July-October): 89-117.
