Ninety-one male and seventy-nine female Israeli industrial workers in similar technological settings were compared in terms of their job satisfaction and work role centrality. Female workers did not differ from men in their job satisfaction, when personal and technological factors were controlled. They had lower work role centrality, and this difference occurred predominantly for younger, unmarried, and Middle Eastern women. Both men and women tended to react similarly in their work role centrality to differences in the technological setting, but men did so more strongly. For both men and women, job satisfaction and work role centrality were correlated. For both genders, work role centrality was more responsive to personal characteristics and to technological conditions than was job satisfaction. The least satisfied and least work-centered women had no work place preference, and in this response differed from men. The findings for women concerning WRC are explained by means of a “socialization to industrial work” thesis, while findings regarding job satisfaction are situationally explained.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ACKER, J.
and D. R. VAN HOUTEN (1974) “Differential recruitment and control: the sex-structuring of organizations.”Admin. Sci. Q.19 (June): 152-163.
2.
BAKER, S. H.
(1978) “Women in blue collar and service occupations,” in A. H. Stromberg and S. Harkness (eds.) Women Working. Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield.
3.
BAR-YOSEF, R.
, A. BLOOM, and T. LEVY (1978) Role Ideology of Young Israeli Women. Jerusalem: Hebrew University, Work Research Institute.
4.
BIRCHALL, D.
and R. WILD (1977) “Job characteristics and the attitudes of female manual workers: a research note.”Human Relations30 (April): 335-342.
5.
CROWLEY, J.
, T. LEVITIN, and R. QUINN (1973) “Seven deadly half-truths about the American working woman.”Psychology Today (March): 94.
6.
DE HAAN, U. (1975) Autonomy and Technology-Limits and Optimal States. Ph.D. dissertation, Israel Institute of Technology.
7.
DUBIN, R.
and J. E. CHAMPOUX (1977) “Central life interests and job satisfaction.”Organizational Behavior and Human Performance18 (April): 366-377.
8.
DUBIN, R.
, R. A. HEDLEY, and C. TAVEGGIA (1976) “Attachment to work,” in R. Dubin (ed.) Handbook of Work, Organization and Society. Chicago: Rand McNally.
9.
HALL, R. H.
(1975) Occupations and the Social Structure. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
10.
IZRAELI, D. W.
(1979) “Sex structure of occupations.”Sociology of Work and Occupations6 (November): 404-429.
11.
KANTER, R. M.
(1976) “The impact of hierarchical structures on the work behavior of women and men.”Social Problems23 (April): 415-430.
12.
MANNHEIM, B.
(1975) “A comparative study of work centrality, job rewards and satisfaction—occupational groups in Israel.”Sociology of Work and Occupations2 (February): 79-102.
13.
MANNHEIM, B.
and A. COHEN (1978) “Multivariate analyses of factors affecting work centrality of occupational categories.”Human Relations31 (June): 525-553.
14.
MANNHEIM, B.
and J. REIN (1981) “Work centrality of different age groups and the wish to discontinue work.”Int. J. of Aging and Human Development13, 3: 221-232.
15.
MANNHEIM, B.
, R. DUBIN, and A. GOLDBERG (1976) “Worker autonomy and commitment in relation to organizational and managerial characteristics.” Progress Report, Center for Study of Man at Work, Technion. (mimeo)
16.
NUNNALLY, J. C.
(1967) Psychometric Theory. New York: McGraw-Hill.
17.
PARNES, H.
, J. SHEA, R. SPITZ, and F. ZELLER (1970) Dual Careers: A Longitudinal Study of the Labor Market Experience of Women. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
18.
PERROW, C.
(1970) Organizational Analysis. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
19.
QUINN, R.
, G. L. STAINES, and M. R. McCULLOUGH (1974) Job Satisfaction: Is There a Trend?Washington, DC: U.S. Printing Office Research and Development Monograph No. 30.
20.
RABINOWITZ, S. (1975) An examination of influence of individual difference variables and perceived job stimulation. Master's thesis, Michigan State University.
21.
RABINOWITZ, S.
and D. G. HALL (1977) “Organizational research on job involvement.”Psych. Bull.84 (March): 265-289.
22.
RABINOWITZ, S.D. G. HALL
and J. G. GOODALE (1977) “Job scope and individual differences as predictors of job involvement: independent or interactive.”Academy of Management J.20 (June): 273-281.
23.
RITZER, G.
(1972) Man and His Work: Conflict and Change. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
24.
ROSENBACH, W. E.
, R. C. DAILEY, and C. P. MORGAN (1979) “Perception of job characteristics and affective outcomes for women and men.”Sex Roles5 (June): 267-277.
25.
SAFILIOS-ROTHSCHILD, C.
(1971) “Toward the conceptualization and measurement of work commitment.”Human Relations24 (December): 489-493.
26.
SALEH, S. D.
and M. LALLJEE (1969). “Sex and job orientation.”Personnel Psychology22 (September): 465-471.
27.
SAUSER, W. J.
and C. M. YORK (1978) “Sex differences in job satisfaction: a re-examination.”Personnel Psychology31 (Fall): 537-547.
28.
SCHMITT, N.
, B. W. COYLE, J. K. WHITE, and J. RAUSCHENBERGER (1978) “Background, needs, job perceptions and job satisfaction: a causal model.”Personnel Psychology31 (Winter): 889-901.
29.
SHEPARD, J. M.
, D. I. KIM, and I. G. HOUGLAND (1979) “Effects of technology in industrialized and industrializing societies.”Sociology of Work and Occupations64 (November): 457-481.
30.
Statistical Abstract of Israel No. 29 (1978) Jerusalem: Government Printing Office.
31.
TAYLOR, J. C.
and D. C. BOWERS (1972) Survey of Organizations. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.
32.
TAVEGGIA, T. C.
and T. ZIEMBA (1978) “Linkages to work: a study of the `Central Life Interests' and `Work Attachments' of male and female workers.”J. of Vocational Behavior12 (June): 305-320.
33.
TENNE, R.
and B. MANNHEIM (1977) “The effect of the level of production technology on workers' orientation and responses to the work situation,” in M. Haug and J. Dofny (eds.) Work and Technology. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
34.
VAN MAANEN, J.
(1976) “Breaking in: socialization to work,” in R. Dubin (ed.), Handbook of Work, Organization and Societies. Chicago: Rand McNally.
35.
WANOUS, J. P.
(1974) “Individual differences and reactions to job characteristics.”J. of Applied Psychology59 (December): 616-622.
36.
WEAVER, C. N.
(1978) “Sex differences in the determinants of job satisfaction.”Academy of Management J.21 (June): 265-274.
37.
WILD, R.
(1970) “Job needs, job satisfaction and job behavior of women manual workers.”J. of Applied Psychology54 (April): 157-162.
