Roughly half of American workers report feeling underpaid. Equity and distributive justice theory and research suggests that perceived underpayment is associated with more job dissatisfaction. However, no population-based research has examined the situational factors that may protect individuals from the harmful effects of perceived underpayment. Using data from a national sample of American workers, this study examines the extent to which forms of security modify the association between perceived underpayment and job dissatisfaction. Results indicate that while perceived underpayment is associated with more job dissatisfaction, each of the following attenuates that association: job security, financial security, and employment in the public sector. This provides a novel theoretical elaboration and extension.
AdamsJ. S. (1965) Inequality in social exchange. In: BerkowitzL. (ed.) Advances in experimental social psychologyVol. 2, New York, NY: Academic Press, pp. 267–299.
2.
AlvesW. M.RossiP. H. (1978) Who should get what? Fairness judgments of the distribution of earnings. American Journal of Sociology84: 541–564.
3.
BakkerA. B.DemeroutiE. (2007) The job demands-resources model: State of the art. Journal of Managerial Psychology22(3): 309–328.
4.
BakkerA. B.DemeroutiE.EuwemaM. C. (2005) Job resources buffer the impact of job demands on burnout. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology10(2): 170–180.
5.
BegleyT. M.LeeC.HuiC. (2006) Organizational level as a moderator of the relationship between justice perceptions and work-related reactions. Journal of Organizational Behavior27: 705–721.
6.
BersoffD.CrosbyF. (1984) Job satisfaction and family status. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin10(1): 79–83.
7.
BrocknerJ.TylerT. R.Cooper-SchneiderR. (1992) The influence of prior commitment to an institution on reactions to perceived unfairness: The higher they are, the harder they fall. Administrative Science Quarterly37: 241–261.
8.
BurgardS. A.BrandJ. E.HouseJ. S. (2009) Perceived job insecurity and worker health in the United States. Social Science & Medicine69: 777–785.
9.
BygrenM. (2004) Pay reference standards and pay satisfaction: What do workers evaluate their pay against?Social Science Research33(2): 206–224.
10.
ChengT.MaunoS.LeeC. (2014) Do job control, support, and optimism help job insecure employees? A three-wave study of the buffering effects on job satisfaction, vigor, and work-family environment. Social Indicators Research118(3): 1269–1291.
11.
ClarkA. E. (1996) Job satisfaction in Britain. British Journal of Industrial Relations34(2): 189–217.
12.
ClarkA. E. (1997) Job satisfaction and gender: Why are women so happy at work?Labour Economics4: 341–372.
13.
Clark, A. E. (1998). Measures of job satisfaction: What makes a good job? Evidence from OECD countries (OECD Labour Market and Social Policy Occasional Papers, No. 34). Paris, France: OECD Publishing.
14.
ClarkA. E. (2001) What really matters in a job? Hedonic measurement using quit data. Labour Economics8: 223–242.
ClarkA. E.SenikC. (2010) Who compares to whom? The anatomy of income comparisons in Europe. The Economic Journal120(544): 573–594.
17.
Clay-WarnerJ.ReynoldsJ.RomanP. (2005) Organizational justice and job satisfaction: A test of three competing models. Social Justice Research18(4): 391–409.
18.
CoggburnJ. D. (2000) The effects of deregulation on state government personnel administration. Review of Public Personnel Administration20(4): 24–40.
19.
Cohen-CharashY.SpectorP. E. (2001) The role of justice in organizations: A meta-analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes86(2): 278–321.
20.
ColquittA. J.ConlonD. E.WessonM. J.PorterC. O. L. H.NgK. Y. (2001) Justice at the millennium: A meta-analytic review of 25 years of organizational justice research. Journal of Applied Psychology86(3): 425–445.
21.
ColquittA. J.GreenbergJ.Zapata-PhelanC. P. (2005) What is organizational justice? A historical overview. In: GreenbergJ.ColquittJ. A. (eds) Handbook of organizational justice, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp. 3–56.
22.
ColquittA. J.ScottB. A.RodellJ. B.LongD. M.Zapata-PhelanC. P.ConlonD. E.WessonM. J. (2013) Justice at the millennium, a decade later: A meta-analytic test of social exchange and affect-based perspectives. Journal of Applied Psychology98: 199–236.
23.
CopelandC. (2006) Employment-based retirement plan participation: Geographic differences and trends, 2005. EBRI Issue Brief299: 1–32.
24.
CornfieldD. B.FletcherB. (2001) The U.S labor movement: Toward a sociology of labor revitalization. In: BergI.KallebergA. L. (eds) Sourcebook of labor markets: Evolving structures and processes, New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, pp. 61–82.
25.
CropanzanoR.SteinJ. H.NadisicT. (2011) Social justice and the experience of emotion, New York, NY: Routledge.
26.
DemeroutiE.BakkerA. B. (2011) The job-demands resources model: Challenges for future research. SA Journal of Industrial Psychology37(2): 1–9.
27.
DemeroutiE.BakkerA. B.NachreinerF.SchaufeliW. B. (2001) The job demands-resources model of burnout. Journal of Applied Psychology86(3): 499–512.
28.
De WitteH.NäswallK. K. (2003) 'Objective' vs. 'subjective' Consequences of temporary work for job satisfaction and organizational commitment in four European countries. Economic and Industrial Democracy24(2): 149–188.
29.
Families and Work Institute (2008) National study of the changing workforce, New York, NY: Families and Work Institute.
30.
FaragherE. B.CassM.CooperC. L. (2005) The relationship between job satisfaction and health: A meta-analysis. Occupational and Environmental Medicine62(1): 105–112.
31.
Farber, H. S. (2005). Union membership in the United States: The divergence between the public and private sectors (Working Paper No. 503). Princeton, NJ: Industrial Relations Section, Princeton University.
32.
Farber, H. S. (2009). Job loss and the decline in job security in the United States (Working Paper No. 520). Princeton, NJ: Industrial Relations Section, Princeton University.
33.
FerrieJ. E.ShipleyM. J.NewmanK.StansfeldS. A.MarmotM. (2005) Self-reported job insecurity and health in the Whitehall II study: Potential explanations of the relationship. Social Science & Medicine60: 1593–1602.
34.
FordM. T. (2014) Perceived unfairness at work, social and personal resources, and resting blood pressure. Stress and Health30(1): 12–22.
35.
FordM. T.HuangJ. (2014) The health consequences of organizational injustice: Why do they exist and what can be done? In: LekaS.SinclairR. R. (eds) Contemporary occupational health psychology: Global perspectives on research and practiceVol. 3, West Sussex, England: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, pp. 35–50.
36.
FoxS.SpectorP. E.MilesD. (2001) Counterproductive work behavior (CWB) in response to job stressors and organizational justice: Some mediator and moderator tests for autonomy and emotions. Journal of Vocational Behavior59: 291–309.
37.
FrankS. A.LewisG. B. (2004) Government employees: Working hard or hardly working?American Review of Public Administration34(1): 36–51.
38.
FriedY.SlowikL. H.ShperlingZ.FranzC.Ben-DavidH. A.AvitalN.YeverechyahuU. (2003) The moderating effect of job security on the relation between role clarity and job performance: A longitudinal field study. Human Relations56(7): 787–805.
39.
FronstinP. (2006) Sources of health insurance and characteristics of the uninsured: Analysis of the March 2006 Current Population Survey. EBRI Issue Brief298: 1–30.
40.
FullertonA. S.WallaceM. (2007) Traversing the flexible turn: US workers’ perceptions of job security, 1977–2002. Social Science Research36: 201–222.
41.
GlavinP. (2013) The impact of job insecurity and job degradation on the sense of personal control. Work and Occupations40(2): 115–142.
42.
GlavinP.SchiemanS. (2014) Control in the face of uncertainty: Is job insecurity a challenge to the mental health benefits of control beliefs?Social Psychology Quarterly77(4): 319–343.
43.
GreenR.ForbisR.GoldenA.NelsonS. L.RobinsonJ. (2006) On the ethics of at-will employment in the public sector. Public Integrity8(4): 305–327.
44.
HaysS. W.SowaJ. E. (2007) Changes in state civil service systems: In: BowmanJ. S.WestJ. P. (eds) American public service: Radical reform and the merit system, Boca Raton, FL: Taylor & Francis, pp. 3–21.
45.
HegtvedtK. A. (2006) Justice frameworks. In: BurkeP. J. (ed.) Contemporary social psychological theories, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 46–69.
46.
HegtvedtK. A.ParrisC. (2014) Emotions in justice processes. In: StetsJ.TurnerJ. (eds) Handbook of the sociology of emotionsVol. 2, New York, NY: Springer, pp. 103–125.
47.
HenryP. J. (2011) The role of group-based status in job satisfaction: Workplace respect matters more for the stigmatized. Social Justice Research24: 231–238.
48.
HomansG. C. (1961) Social behavior: Its elementary forms, New York, NY: Harcourt, Brace & World.
JassoG.RossiP. H. (1978) Distributive justice and earned income. American Sociological Review42: 639–651.
51.
JudgeT. A.BonoJ. E. (2001) Relationship of core self-evaluation traits – self-esteem, generalized self-efficacy, locus of control, and emotional stability – with job satisfaction and job performance: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology86(1): 80–92.
52.
JudgeT. A.PiccoloR. F.PodsakoffN. P.ShawJ. C.RichB. L. (2010) The relationship between pay and job satisfaction: A meta-analysis of the literature. Journal of Vocational Behavior77: 157–167.
53.
JudgeT. A.ThoresenC. J.BonoJ. E.PattonG. K. (2001) The job satisfaction-job performance relationship: A qualitative and quantitative review. Psychological Bulletin127(3): 376–407.
54.
Kalleberg, A. L. (2011). Good jobs, bad jobs: The rise of polarized and precarious employment systems in the United States, 1970s--2000s. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
55.
KallebergA. L.MarsdenP. V. (2013) Changing work values in the United States, 1973–2006. Social Science Research42(2): 255–270.
56.
KarlK. A.SuttonC. L. (1998) Job values in today’s workforce: A comparison of public and private sector employees. Public Personnel Management27(4): 515–527.
57.
KaustoJ.EloA.-L.LipponenJ.ElovainioM. (2005) Moderating effects of job insecurity in the relationships between procedural justice and employee well-being: Gender differences. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology14(4): 431–452.
58.
LepkowskiJ. M. (1988) Telephone sampling methods in the United States. In: GrovesR. (ed.) Telephone survey methodology, New York, NY: John Wiley, pp. 73–98.
59.
LewisG. B.FrankS. A. (2002) Who wants to work for the government?Public Administration Review62(4): 395–404.
60.
LindE. A.Van den BosK. (2002) When fairness works: Toward a general theory of uncertainty management. Research in Organizational Behavior24: 181–223.
61.
LipponenJ.OlkkonenM.-E.MyyryL. (2004) Personal value orientation as a moderator in the relationships between perceived organizational justice and its hypothesized consequences. Social Justice Research17(3): 275–292.
62.
LuechingerS.MeierS.StutzerA. (2010) Why does unemployment hurt the employed? Evidence from the life satisfaction gap between the public and the private sector. Journal of Human Resources45(4): 998–1045.
63.
MaslowA. H. (1943) A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review50(4): 370–396.
64.
MaslowA. H. (1954) Motivation and personality, New York, NY: Harper.
65.
MirowskyJ. (2013) Analyzing associations between mental health and social circumstances. In: AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.BiermanA. (eds) Handbook of the sociology of mental health, 2nd ed. New York, NY: Springer, pp. 143–165.
66.
MirowskyJ.RossC. E. (2003) Social causes of psychological distress, 2nd ed. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
67.
PearlinL. I. (1983) Role strains and personal stress. In: KaplanH. B. (ed.) Psychosocial stress: Trends in theory and research, New York, NY: Academic Press, pp. 3–31.
68.
PearlinL. I.MenaghanE. G.LiebermanM. A.MullanJ. T. (1981) The stress process. Journal of Health and Social Behavior22(4): 337–356.
69.
PetersB. G. (2001) The future of governing, Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
70.
ProbstT. M. (2003) Development and validation of the job security index and the job security satisfaction scale: A classical test theory and IRT approach. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology76: 451–467.
71.
PudrovskaT.SchiemanS.PearlinL. I.NguyenK. (2005) The sense of mastery as a mediator and moderator in the association between economic hardship and health in late life. Journal of Aging and Health17(5): 634–660.
72.
RobbinsJ. M.FordM. T.TetrickL. E. (2012) Perceived unfairness and employee health: A meta-analytic integration. Journal of Applied Psychology97(2): 235–272.
73.
RossC. E.ReskinB. F. (1992) Education, control at work, and job satisfaction. Social Science Research21: 134–148.
74.
RossC. E.WuC.-L. (1995) The links between education and health. American Sociological Review60(5): 719–745.
75.
RoxburghS. (1999) Exploring the work and family relationship: Gender differences in the influence of parenthood and social support on job satisfaction. Journal of Family Issues20(6): 771–788.
SandbergJ. G.HarperJ. M.HillE.J.MillerR. B.YorgasonJ. B.DayR. D. (2013) “What happens at home does not necessarily stay at home”: The relationship of observed negative couple interaction with physical health, mental health, and work satisfaction. Journal of Marriage and Family75: 808–821.
78.
SchaufeliW. B.BakkerA. B. (2004) Job demands, job resources, and their relationship with burnout and engagement: A multi-sample study. Journal of Organizational Behavior25(3): 293–315.
79.
SchaufeliW. B.TarisT. W. (2014) A critical review of the job demands-resources model: Implications for improving work and health. In: BauerG. F.HämmigO. (eds) Bridging occupational, organizational and public health: A transdisciplinary approach, Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer, pp. 43–68.
80.
SchiemanS. (2010) Socioeconomic status and beliefs about God’s influence in everyday life. Sociology of Religion71(1): 25–51.
81.
SchiemanS.MilkieM. A.GlavinP. (2009) When work interferes with life: Work-nonwork interference and the influence of work-related demands and resources. American Sociological Review74: 966–987.
82.
SchiemanS.ReidS. (2008) Job authority and interpersonal conflict in the workplace. Work and Occupations35: 296–326.
83.
SchiemanS.ReidS. (2009) Job authority and health: Unraveling the competing suppression and explanatory influences. Social Science & Medicine69: 1616–1624.
84.
Schunck, R., Sauer, C., & Valet, P. (2015). Unfair pay and health: The effects of perceived injustice of earnings on physical health. European Sociological Review, 31(6), 655--666.
SpectorP. E. (1997) Job satisfaction: Application, assessment, causes, and consequences, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
87.
SverkeM.HellgrenJ.NäswallK. (2002) No security: A meta-analysis and review of job insecurity and its consequences. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology7(3): 242–264.
Van den BosK.LindE. A. (2002) Uncertainty management by means of fairness judgments. In: ZannaM. P. (ed.) Advances in experimental social psychologyVol. 34, San Diego, CA: Academic Press, pp. 1–60.
90.
WaksbergJ. (1978) Sampling methods for random digit dialing. Journal of the American Statistical Association73: 40–46.
91.
WalsterE.BerscheidE.WalsterG.W. (1973) New directions in equity research. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology25(2): 151–176.
92.
WanousJ. P.ReichersA. E.HudyM. J. (1997) Overall job satisfaction: How good are single-item measures?Journal of Applied Psychology82(2): 247–252.
93.
WilliamsR. (2006) Generalized ordered logit/partial proportional odds models for ordinal dependent variables. The Stata Journal6(1): 58–82.
94.
WheatonB. (1999a) Social stress. In: AneshenselC.PhelanJ. C. (eds) Handbook of the sociology of mental health, New York, NY: Kluwer, Academic/Plenum Publishers, pp. 277–300.
95.
WheatonB. (1999b) The nature of stressors. In: HorwitzA. V.ScheidT. L. (eds) A handbook for the study of mental health, New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, pp. 176–197.
