To critically assess the scientific evidence for associating creativity with mental illness.
Method:
MEDLINE and secondary literature searches identified 29 studies and 34 review articles on creativity and mental illness. All studies were critically evaluated. Reviews were also assessed.
Results:
Of 29 studies that evaluated possible associations between creativity and mental illness, 15 found no evidence to link creativity and mental illness, 9 found positive evidence, and 5 had unclear findings. Most studies used flawed methodologies with weak (case series or case control) designs. There were no randomized or prospective cohort studies. Adequate criteria for determining causal association were not met. In 34 selective reviews, despite mixed evidence, many authors asserted that creativity and mental illness were positively or causally associated.
Conclusions:
There is limited scientific evidence to associate creativity with mental illness. Despite this, many authors promoted a connection. Explanations for this contradiction are explored, and social and research implications are discussed.
BeckerG. The mad genius controversy. London: Sage Publications; 1978.
2.
RichardsR. Relationships between creativity and psychopathology: An evaluation and interpretation of the evidence. Genetic Psychology Monographs1981;103:261–324.
3.
StorrA. The dynamics of creation. New York: Atheneum; 1985.
4.
AndreasenNGlickI. Bipolar affective disorder and creativity: Implications and clinical management. Compr Psychiatry1988;29:207–17.
5.
JamisonK. Manic-depressive illness, creativity and leadership. In: GoodwinFJamisonK, editors. Manic-depressive illness. New York: Oxford University Press; 1990. p 332–67.
6.
RothenbergA. Creativity and madness. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 1990.
7.
LudwigA. Reflections on creativity and madness. Am J Psychother1989;43:4–14.
8.
LudwigA. Culture and creativity. Am J Psychother1992;46:454–69.
9.
LudwigA. The price of greatness. New York: The Guilford Press; 1995.
10.
WeisbergR. Creativity: Beyond the myth of genius. New York: Freeman and Company; 1993.
11.
FoucaultM. Madness and civilization. Toronto: Random House; 1965.
12.
CheslerP. Women and madness. New York: Avon Books; 1973.
13.
PenfoldSWalkerG. Women and the psychiatric paradox. Montreal: Eden Press; 1983.
14.
SzaszT. The myth of mental illness. Revised edition. New York: Harper and Row; 1974.
15.
SassL. Madness and modernism. Boston: Harvard University Press; 1992.
16.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-III). 3rd ed.Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1980.
17.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-III-R).3rd ed. Revised.Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1987.
18.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-IV). 4th ed.Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1994.
19.
JamisonK. Touched with fire. Toronto: Maxwell MacMillan Canada; 1993.
20.
JamisonK. Manic-depressive illness and creativity. Sci Am1995;Feb:62–7.
21.
CharbonneauL. Some calm for an unquiet mind. The Medical Post1995 Nov 7:65.
22.
GutinJ. Mental illness: Going over the creative edge. The Globe and Mail1996 Dec 7;Sect D:6.
23.
CampbellM. Not always on the level. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1988.
24.
StyronW. Darkness visible: A memoir of madness. New York: Vintage Books; 1990.
25.
MilletK. The loony-bin trip. New York: Simon and Schuster; 1990.
26.
MaysJ. In the jaws of the black dogs: A memoir of depression. Toronto: Viking Press; 1995.
27.
JamisonK. An unquiet mind. New York: Alfred A. Knopf; 1995.
28.
TermanLCoxCOdenMBurksBJensenD. Genetic studies of genius (Volumes 1–5). Stanford: Stanford University Press; 1925–1959.
29.
EllisH. A study of British genius. New York: Houghton Mifflin; 1926.
30.
NicolsonH. The health of authors. Lancet1947;2:709–14.
31.
JudaA. The relationship between highest mental capacity and psychic abnormalities. Am J Psychiatry1949;106:296–307.
32.
DrevdahlJCattellR. Personality and creativity in artists and writers. J Clin Psychol1958;14:107–12.
33.
GoertzelVGoertzelM. Cradles of eminence. Boston: Little, Brown; 1962.
34.
TorranceE. Rewarding creative behavior: Experiments in classroom creativity. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall; 1965.
35.
MacKinnonD. Personality and the realization of creative potential. Am Psychol1965;20:273–81.
36.
NoreikKOdegardO. Psychoses in Norwegians with a background of higher education. Br J Psychiatry1966;112:34–55.
37.
BarronF. Creative writers. In: AlbertR, editor. Genius and eminence. 2nd ed.New York: Pergamon Press; 1992. p 315–24.
38.
McNeilT. Prebirth and postbirth influence on the relationship between creative ability and recorded mental illness. J Pers1971;39:391–406.
39.
MartindaleC. Father's absence, psychopathology, and poetic eminence. Psychol Rep1972;31:843–7.
40.
LucasCStringerP. Interaction in university selection, mental health and academic performance. Br J Psychiatry1972;120:189–95.
41.
SchouM. Artistic productivity and lithium prophylaxis in manic-depressive illness. Br J Psychiatry1979;135:97–103.
42.
JamisonK. Mood disorders and patterns of creativity in British writers and artists. Psychiatry1989;52:125–34.
43.
LudwigA. Alcohol input and creative output. British Journal of Addiction1990;85:953–63.
44.
LudwigA. Creative achievement and psychopathology: Comparison among professions. Am J Psychother1992;46:330–56.
45.
SchildkrautJHirshfeldAMurphyJ. Mind and mood in modern art, II: Depressive disorders, spirituality, and early deaths in the abstract expressionist artists of the New York school. Am J Psychiatry1994;151:482–8.
46.
PostF. Creativity and psychopathology: A study of 291 world-famous men. Br J Psychiatry1994;165:22–34.
47.
PostF. Verbal creativity, depression and alcoholism. Br J Psychiatry1996;168:545–55.
48.
AndreasenNCanterA. The creative writer: Psychiatric symptoms and family history. Compr Psychiatry1974;15:123–31.
49.
AndreasenNPowersP. Creativity and psychosis: An examination of conceptual style. Arch Gen Psychiatry1975;32:70–3.
50.
AndreasenN. Creativity and mental illness: Prevalence rates in writers and their first-degree relatives. Am J Psychiatry1987;144:1288–92.
51.
LudwigA. Mental illness and creative activity in female writers. Am J Psychiatry1994;151:1650–6.
52.
RothenbergA. Psychopathology and creative cognition. Arch Gen Psychiatry1983;40:937–42.
53.
KarlssonJ. Academic achievement of psychotic and alcoholic patients. Hereditas1983;99:69–72.
54.
AkiskalHAkiskalK. Reassessing the prevalence of bipolar disorders: Clinical significance and artistic creativity. Psychiatry and Psychobiology1988;3(Suppl):29S–36S.
55.
RichardsRKinneyDLundeIBenetMMerzelA. Creativity in manic-depressives, cyclothymes, their normal relatives, and control subjects. J Abnorm Psychol1988;97:281–8.
56.
FunkJChessareJWeaverMExleyA. Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, creativity, and the effects of methylphenidate. Pediatrics1993;91:816–9.
57.
RoeA. Personal problems and science. In: TaylorCBarronF, editors. Scientific creativity: Its recognition and development. New York: Wiley; 1963. p 132–8.
58.
GrantV. Great abnormals. New York: Hawthorn Books; 1968.
59.
SlaterE. The problems of pathography. Acta Psychiatr Scand1970; (219 Suppl):209S–215S.
60.
AndreasenN. James Joyce: A portrait of the artist as a schizoid. JAMA1973;224:67–71.
61.
GoodwinD. The muse and the martini. JAMA1973;224:35–8.
62.
TrethowanW. Music and mental disorder. In: CritchleyMHensonR, editors. Music and the brain. Illinois: Charles Thomas; 1977. p 398–432.
63.
AndreasenN. Creativity and psychiatric illness. Psychiatric Annals1978;8:113–9.
64.
PrentkyR. Creativity and psychopathology. New York: Praeger; 1980.
65.
DeLongGAldershofA. Association of special abilities with juvenile manic-depressive illness. In: Programs and Abstracts. Twelfth Annual Meeting of the Child Neurology Society; 1983 Oct 13–15; Williamsburg, VA. Ann Neurol1983;14:362.
66.
HoldenC. Manic depression and creativity. Science1986;233:725.
67.
KinneyDRichardsR. Creativity and manic depressive illness. Science1986;234:528.
68.
HareE. Creativity and mental illness. BMJ1987;295:1587–9.
69.
KesselN. Genius and mental disorder: A history of ideas concerning their conjunction. In: MurrayP, editor. Genius: The history of an idea. New York: Basil Blackwell; 1989. p 196–212.
WhybrowP. Of the muse and moods mundane. Am J Psychiatry1994;151:477–9.
79.
SackettDHaynesBTugwellP. Clinical epidemiology: A basic science for clinical medicine. Toronto: Little, Brown and Company; 1985.
80.
OxmanAGuyattG. Guidelines for reading literature reviews. Canadian Medical Association Journal1988;138:697–703.
81.
JamesW. The varieties of religious experience. New York: Collier Books; 1961.
82.
LowryM. Under the volcano. Markham: Penguin Books Canada; 1985.
83.
[Anonymous]. Eddie Vedder. People Magazine1993 Dec 27:93.
84.
JamisonKGernerRHammenCPadeskyC. Clouds and silver linings: Positive experiences associated with primary affective disorders. Am J Psychiatry1980;137:198–202.
85.
SontagS. Illness as metaphor and AIDS and its metaphors. Toronto: Doubleday; 1990.
86.
KuhnT. The structure of scientific revolutions. 2nd ed.Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1970.
87.
EardleyC. Artists are tougher than other people. The New York Times1994 May 6;SectA:15.
