Although depression frequently occurs in multiple sclerosis (MS), an association with cerebral pathology is unclear. This sets MS apart from other common neurological disorders. The reasons for this are explored.
Method
The literature on depression and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is reviewed and methodological issues are critically evaluated.
Results
Failure to demonstrate cerebral correlates of depression is in part a function of poor study design. However, the diffuse nature of cerebral demyelination creates difficulties in image analysis peculiar to MS.
Conclusions
More research using valid psychiatric assessment procedures, high field strength MRI and automated lesion detection is needed to resolve the issue. It is premature to reject psychosocial causes at this stage.
References
1.
MindenS.L., SchifferR.B.Affective disorders in multiple sclerosis. Review and recommendations for clinical research.Arch Neurol1990; 47: 98–104.
2.
CharcotJ.M.Lectures on the diseases of the nervous system delivered at La Salpetriere.London UK: New Sydenham Society;1887.
3.
YoungI.R., HallA.S., PallisC.A.Nuclear magnetic resonance imaging of the brain in multiple sclerosis.Lancet1981; 2: 1063–1066.
4.
RobinsonR.G., KubosK.L., StarrL.B.Mood disorders in stroke patients: importance of lesion location.Brain1984; 107: 81–93.
5.
MaybergH.S., StarksteinS.E., SadzotB.Selective hypometabolism in the inferior frontal lobe in depressed patients with Parkinson's disease.Ann Neurol1990; 28: 57–64.
6.
MaybergH.S., StarksteinS.E., PeyserC.E.Paralimbic frontal lobe hypometabolism in depression associated with Huntington's disease.Neurology1992; 42: 1791–1797.
7.
HonerW.G., HurwitzT., LiD.K.Temporal lobe involvement in multiple sclerosis patients with psychiatric disorders.Arch Neurol1987; 44: 187–190.
8.
ReischiesF.M., BaumK., BrauH.Cerebral magnetic resonance imaging findings in multiple sclerosis. Relation to disturbance of affect, drive and cognition.Arch Neurol1988; 45: 1114–1116.
9.
FeinsteinA., RonM., ThompsonA.A serial study of psychometric and magnetic resonance imaging changes in multiple sclerosis.Brain1993; 116: 569–602.
10.
RabinsP.V., BrooksB.R., O'DonnellP.Structural brain correlates of emotional disorder in multiple sclerosis.Brain1986; 109: 585–597.
11.
DalosN.P., RabinsP.V., BrooksB.R.Disease activity and emotional state in multiple sclerosis.Ann Neurol1983; 13: 573–577.
12.
SchifferR.B., CaineE.D., BamfordK.A.Depressive episodes in patients with multiple sclerosis.Am J Psychiatry1983; 140: 1498–1500.
13.
SchifferP.B., BabigianH.M.Behavioral disturbance in multiple sclerosis, temporal lobe epilepsy and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: an epidemiologic study.Arch Neurol1984; 41: 1067–1069.
14.
WhitlockF.A., SiskindM.M.Depression as a major symptom of multiple sclerosis.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry1980; 43: 861–865.
15.
SurridgeD.An investigation into some aspects of multiple sclerosis.Br J Psychiatry1969; 115: 749–764.
16.
HuberS.J., PaulsenG.W., ShuttleworthE.C.Magnetic resonance imaging correlates of dementia in multiple sclerosis.Arch Neurol1987; 44: 732–736.
17.
LogsdailS.J., CallananM.M., RonM.A.Psychiatric morbidity in patients with clinically isolated lesions of the type seen in multiple sclerosis.Psychol Med1988; 18: 355–364.
18.
AnzolaG.P., BevilacquaL., CappaS.F.Neuropsychological assessment in patients with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis and mild functional impairment: correlation with magnetic resonance imaging.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry1990; 53: 142–145.
19.
RonM.A., LogsdallS.J.Psychiatric morbidity in multiple sclerosis: a clinical and MRI study.Psychol Med1989; 19: 887–895.
20.
FeinsteinA., YoulB., RonM.Acute optic neuritis: a cognitive and magnetic resonance imaging study.Brain1992a; 115: 1403–1415.
21.
FeinsteinA., KartsounisL.D., MillerD.H.Clinically isolated lesions of the type seen in multiple sclerosis: a cognitive, psychiatric and MRI follow-up study.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry1992b; 55: 869–876.
SkeggK., CorwinP.A., SkeggD.C.G.How often is multiple sclerosis mistaken for a psychiatric disorder?Psychol Med1989; 18: 733–736.
26.
OrmerodI.E.C., MillerD.H., McDonaldW.I.The role of NIR imaging in the assessment of multiple sclerosis and isolated neurological lesions.Brain1987; 110: 1579–1616.
27.
FrancisD.A., CompstonD.A.S., BatchelorJ.R.A reassessment of the risk of multiple sclerosis developing in patients with optic neuritis after extended follow-up.J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry1987; 50: 758–765.
ThompsonA.J., KermodeA., MacManusD.G.Patterns of disease activity in multiple sclerosis: a clinical and magnetic resonance imaging study.Br Med J1991; 300: 631–634.
30.
KurtzkeJ.F.Rating neurologic impairment in multiple sclerosis: an expanded disability scale.Neurology1983; 33: 1444–1452.
