To review the status of current treatment of seasonal affective disorder (SAD).
Method
Treatment studies of SAD published between January 1989 and March 1995 were identified using a computerized MEDLINE literature search. Additional citations were obtained from the reference sections of these articles. Studies included in this review were selected using operational methodologic criteria.
Results
Many studies support the efficacy of bright light therapy using a fluorescent light box. The best studied protocol is >2500 lux white light for 2 hours per day, but newer protocols using 10,000 lux for 30 minutes have comparable response rates. Studies of light visors and other head-mounted devices also report similar response rates, but have not yet shown superiority over putative control conditions. There are fewer medication studies in SAD, but controlled studies suggest that fluoxetine, d-fenfluramine and propranolol are effective. Other treatments such as dawn simulation require further study. No studies of psychological treatments for SAD were found. Many studies had methodologic limitations, including brief treatment periods, small sample sizes, and lack of replication, that limit the generalizability of findings.
Conclusion
There are several well-studied, effective treatments for SAD, including light therapy and medications. However, further research must be done to demonstrate sustained treatment response over time, to clarify the intensity-response relationship of light therapy, to clarify the role of light therapy and medications, and to assess combination treatments.
References
1.
BauerM.S., DunnerD.L.Validity of seasonal pattern as a modifier for recurrent mood disorders for DSM-IV.Compr Psychiatry1993; 34: 159–170.
2.
LewyA.J., KernH.A., RosenthalN.E.Bright artificial light treatment of a manic-depressive patient with a seasonal mood cycle.Am J Psychiatry1982; 139: 1496–1498.
3.
RosenthalN.E., SackD.A., GillinJ.C.Seasonal affective disorder: a description of the syndrome and preliminary findings with light therapy.Arch Gen Psychiatry1984; 41: 72–80.
4.
LamR.W., KripkeD.F., GillinJ.C.Phototherapy for depressive disorders: a review.Can J Psychiatry1989; 34: 140–147.
5.
WehrT.A., RosenthalN.E.Seasonality and affective illness.Am J Psychiatry1989; 146: 829–839.
6.
BleharM.C., LewyA.J.Seasonal mood disorders: consensus and controversy.Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 465–494.
7.
TermanM., TermanJ.S., QuitkinF.M.Light therapy for seasonal affective disorder. A review of efficacy.Neuropsychopharmacology1989; 2: 1–22.
BrownW.A.Is light treatment a placebo?Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 527–530.
10.
EastmanC.I.What the placebo literature can tell us about light therapy for SAD.Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 495–504.
11.
StewartJ.Placebos in evaluating light therapy for seasonal affective disorder.Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 525–526.
12.
HamiltonM.Development of a rating scale for primary depressive illness.Br J Soc Clin Psych1967; 6: 278–296.
13.
RosenthalN.E., HeffernanM.M.Bulimia, carbohydrate craving, and depression: a central connection? In: WurtmanR.J., WurtmanJ.J., editors. Nutrition and the brain, volume 7.New York: Raven Press;1986.
14.
WintonF., CornT., HusonL.W.Effects of light treatment upon mood and melatonin in patients with seasonal affective disorder.Psychol Med1989; 19: 585–590.
15.
TermanJ.S., TermanM., SchlagerD.Efficacy of brief, intense light exposure for treatment of winter depression.Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 3–11.
16.
LamR.W., BuchananA., ClarkC.M.Ultraviolet versus non-ultraviolet light therapy for seasonal affective disorder.J Clin Psychiatry1991; 52: 213–216.
17.
MagnussonA., KristbjarnarsonH.Treatment of seasonal affective disorder with high-intensity light. A phototherapy study with an Icelandic group of patients.J Affect Disord1991; 21: 141–147.
18.
GrotaL.J., YerevanianB.I., GuptaK.Phototherapy for seasonal major depressive disorder: effectiveness bright light of high or low intensity.Psychiatry Res1989; 29: 29–35.
19.
EastmanC.I., LahmeycrH.W., WatellL.G.A placebo-controlled trial of light treatment for winter depression.J Affect Disord1992; 26: 211–221.
20.
BrainardG.C., SherryD., SkwererR.G.Effects of different wavelengths in seasonal affective disorder.J Affect Disord1990; 20: 209–216.
21.
OrenD.A., BrainardG.C., JohnstonS.H.Treatment of seasonal affective disorder with green light and red light.Am J Psychiatry1991; 148: 509–511.
22.
StewartK.T., GaddyJ.R., ByrneB.Effects of green or white light for treatment of seasonal depression.Psychiatry Res1991; 38: 261–270.
23.
BielskiR.J., MayorJ., RiceJ.Phototherapy with broad spectrum white fluorescent light: a comparative study.Psychiatry Res1992; 43: 167–175.
24.
LamR.W., BuchananA., MadorJ.A.et al. The effects of ultraviolet-A wavelengths in light therapy for seasonal depression.J Affect Disord1992; 24: 237–243.
25.
DoghramjiK., GaddyJ.R., StewartK.T.2- versus 4-hour evening phototherapy of seasonal affective disorder.J Nerv Ment Dis1990; 178: 257–260.
26.
AveryD., KhanA., DagerS.Is morning light exposure superior to evening light in treating seasonal affective disorder?Psychopharmacol Bull1990; 26: 521–524.
27.
SackR.L., LewyA.J., WhiteD.M.Morning versus evening light treatment for winter depression. Evidence that the therapeutic effects of light are mediated by circadian phase shifts [published erratum appears in Arch Gen Psychiatry 1992;49:650].Arch Gen Psychiatry1990; 47: 343–351.
28.
AveryD.H., KhanA., DagerS.R.Morning or evening bright light treatment of winter depression?The significance of hypersomnia. Biol Psychiatry1991; 29: 117–126.
29.
Wirz-JusticeA., GrawP., KrauchiK.Light therapy in seasonal affective disorder is independent of time of day or circadian phase.Arch Gen Psychiatry1993; 50: 929–937.
30.
LaterB., SachsG.S., LabbateL.A.Phototherapy for seasonal affective disorder: a blind comparison of three different schedules.Am J Psychiatry1994; 151: 1081–1083.
31.
TermanM., TermanJ.S.Light therapy for winter depression. In: HolickM.F., KligmanA.M., editors. Biological effects of light.New York NY: de Gruyter and Co.;1992.
32.
StewartK.T., GaddyJ.R., BensonD.M.Treatment of winter depression with a portable, head-mounted phototherapy device.Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry1990; 14: 569–578.
33.
JoffeR.T., MoulD.E., LamR.W.Light visor treatment for seasonal affective disorder: a multicenter study.Psychiatry Res1993; 46: 29–39.
34.
RosenthalN.E., MoulD.E., HelleksonC.J.A multicenter study of the light visor for seasonal affective disorder: no difference in efficacy found between two different intensities.Neuropsychopharmacology1993; 8: 151–160.
35.
TeicherM.H., GlodC.A., OrenD.A.The phototherapy visor: there is more to it than meets the eye.Am J Psychiatry. Forthcoming.
36.
LevittA.J., JoffeR.T., KingE.Dim versus bright red (light-emitting diode) light in the treatment of seasonal affective disorder.Acta Psychiatr Scand1994; 89: 341–345.
37.
LevittA.J., JoffeR.T., MoulD.E.Side effects of light therapy in seasonal affective disorder.Am J Psychiatry1993; 150: 650–652.
38.
LabbateL.A., LaferB., ThibaultA.Side effects induced by bright light treatment for seasonal affective disorder.J Clin Psychiatry1994; 55: 189–191.
39.
KasperS., RogersS.L., MaddenP.A.The effects of phototherapy in the general population.J Affect Disord1990; 18: 211–219.
40.
BauerM.S., KurtzJ.W., RubinL.B.Mood and behavioral effects of four-week light treatment in winter depressives and controls.J Psychiatr Res1994; 28: 135–145.
41.
SchwitzerJ., NeudorferC., BlechaH.G.Mania as a side effect of phototherapy.Biol Psychiatry1990; 28: 532–534.
KripkeD.F.Timing of phototherapy and occurrence of mania [letter].Biol Psychiatry1991; 29: 1156–1157.
44.
ChanP.K., LamR.W., PerryK.F.Mania precipitated by light therapy for patients with SAD [letter].J Clin Psychiatry1994; 55: 454.
45.
TermanM., RemeC.E., RaffertyB.Bright light therapy for winter depression: potential ocular effects and theoretical implications.Photochem Photobiol1990; 51: 781–792.
46.
GormanC.P., WyseP.H., DemjenS.Ophthalmological profile of 71 SAD patients: a significant correlation between myopia and SAD [abstract]. Abstracts of the 5th Annual Meeting of the Society for Light Treatment and Biological Rhythms; 1993; 8.
47.
GallinP.F., TermanM., RemeC.E.Ophthalmologic examination of patients with seasonal affective disorder, before and after bright light therapy.Am J Ophthalmology1995: 119: 202–210.
RosenthalN.E.Diagnosis and treatment of seasonal affective disorder.J Am Med Assoc1993; 270: 2717–2720.
52.
LamR.W.Seasonal affective disorder: emerging from the dark.Can J Diagnosis1994; 11: 53–64.
53.
RosenthalN.E., JacobsenF.M., SackD.A.Atenolol in seasonal affective disorder: a test of the melatonin hypothesis.Am J Psychiatry1988; 45: 52–56.
54.
SchlagerD.S.Early-morning administration of short-acting beta blockers for treatment of winter depression.Am J Psychiatry1994; 151: 1383–1385.
55.
OrenD.A., MoulD.E., SchwartzP.J.A controlled trial of levodopa plus carbidopa in the treatment of winter seasonal affective disorder: a test of the dopamine hypothesis.J Clin Psychopharmacol1994; 14: 196–200.
56.
O'RourkeD.A., WurtmanJ.J., BrzezinskiA.Serotonin implicated in etiology of seasonal affective disorder.Psychopharmacol Bull1987; 23: 358–359.
57.
O'RourkeD., WurtmanJ.J., WurtmanR.J.Treatment of seasonal depression with d-fenfluramine.J Clin Psychiatry1989; 50: 343–347.
58.
LingjaerdeO., Reichborn-KjennerudT., HaggagA.Treatment of winter depression in Norway. II. A comparison of the selective monoamine oxidase A inhibitor moclobemide and placebo.Acta Psychiatr Scand1993; 88: 372–380.
59.
LamR.W., GormanC.P., MichalonM.A multi-centre, placebo-controlled study of fluoxetine in seasonal affective disorder.Am J Psychiatry. Forthcoming.
DilsaverS.C., JaeckleR.S.Winter depression responds to an open trial of tranylcypromine.J Clin Psychiatry1990; 51: 326–329.
62.
DilsaverS.C., QamarA.B., Del MedicoV.J.The efficacy of bupropion in winter depression: results of an open trial.J Clin Psychiatry1992; 53: 252–255.
63.
McGrathR.E., BuckwaldB., ResnickE.V.The effect of L-tryptophan on seasonal affective disorder.J Clin Psychiatry1990; 51: 162–163.
64.
Wirz-JusticeA., van der VeldeP., BucherA.Comparison of light treatment with citalopram in winter depression: a longitudinal single case study.Int Clin Psychopharmacol1992; 7: 109–116.
65.
RuhrmannS., KasperS., HawellekB.Effects of fluoxetine versus bright light in the treatment of seasonal affective disorder.Arch Gen Psychiatry. Forthcoming.
66.
TermanM., SchlagerD., FairhurstS.Dawn and dusk simulation as a therapeutic intervention.Biol Psychiatry1989; 25: 966–970.
67.
TermanM., SchlagerD.Twilight therapeutics, winter depression, melatonin, and sleep. In: MontplaisirJ., GodboutR., editors. Sleep and biological rhythms.New York NY: Oxford University Press;1990.
68.
AveryD., BolteM.A., MilletM.Bright dawn simulation compared with bright morning light in the treatment of winter depression.Acta Psychiatr Scand1992; 85: 430–434.
69.
AveryD.H., BolteM.A., DagerS.R.Dawn simulation treatment of winter depression: a controlled study.Am J Psychiatry1993; 150: 113–117.
70.
AveryD.H., BolteM.A., WolfsonJ.K.Dawn simulation compared with a dim red signal in the treatment of winter depression.Biol Psychiatry1994; 36: 181–188.
71.
AveryD.H., BolteM.A., CohenS.Gradual versus rapid dawn simulation treatment of winter depression.J Clin Psychiatry1992; 53: 359–363.
72.
TermanM., TermanJ.S.Treatment of seasonal affective disorder with a high-output negative ionizer.J Alt Compl Med1995; 1: 87–92.
73.
BrainardG.C., GaddyJ.R., BarkerF.M.Mechanisms in the eye that mediate the biological and therapeutic effects of light in humans. In: WetterbergL., editor. Light and biological rhythms in man.New York NY: Pergamon Press;1993.
