To explore relevant literature about sexual abuse allegations arising in child custody disputes.
Method
A literature review of false allegations is given and the contribution of gender bias to this issue is discussed. The role a child psychiatrist may play in such cases is outlined.
Results
Contrary to much popular and professional opinion, sexual abuse allegations are found in only 2% of child custody disputes, and, of these, 8% to 16.5% are false. While false allegations arise for a variety of reasons, the word “false” can imply both erroneous and deceitful activities. This ambiguity, along with gender bias, may lead to disbelief of, and blame towards, parents who report sexual abuse in the context of a dispute about custody or access.
Conclusion
The child psychiatrist who testifies in such custody disputes should have caution, humility, and an open mind both in the courtroom and in dealing with other professionals working in this area.
References
1.
BenedekE.P., SchetkyD.H.Allegations of sexual abuse in child custody and visitation disputes. In: Emerging issues in child psychiatry and the law.SchetkyD.H., BenedekE.P., eds. New York: Brunner/Mazel; 1985: 145–156.
2.
GreenA.H.True and false allegations of sexual abuse in child custody disputes.J Am Acad Child Psychiatry1986; 5: 49–456.
3.
GardnerR.A.The parental alienation syndrome and the differentiation between fabricated and genuine child sexual abuse.Cresskil, NJ: Creative Therapeutics,1987.
4.
Child abuse used to win custody feuds.Toronto: Globe and Mail, January 1987.
5.
CorwinD.L., BerlinerL., GoodmanG.Child sexual abuse and custody disputes: no easy answers.J Interpers Violence1987; 2: 91–105.
6.
TheonnesN., TjadenP.G.The extent, nature, and validity of sexual abuse allegations in custody/visitation disputes.Child Abuse and Negl1990; 14: 151–163.
7.
McIntoshJ.A., PrinzR.J.The incidence of alleged sexual abuse in 603 family court cases.Law and Human Behaviour1993; 17: 95–101.
8.
JonesD.P.H., McGrawJ.M.Reliable and fictitious accounts of sexual abuse to children.J Interpers Violence1987; 2: 27–45.
9.
HladyL.J., GunterE.J.Alleged child abuse in custody and access disputes.Child Abuse Negl1990; 14: 591–593.
10.
McGrawJ.M., SmithH.A.Child sexual abuse allegations amidst divorce and custody proceedings: refining the validation process.J Child Sexual Abuse1992; 1: 49–62.
11.
BernetW.False statements and the differential diagnosis of abuse allegations.J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry1993; 32: 903–910.
12.
EltermanM.F., EhrenbergM.F.Sexual abuse allegations in child custody disputes.Int J Law Psychiatry1991; 14: 269–286.
13.
GreenA.H.Factors contributing to false allegations of child sexual abuse in custody disputes.Child Youth Services1991; 15: 177–189.
14.
QuinnK.M.The credibility of children's allegations of sexual abuse.Behav Sci Law1988; 6: 181–199.
15.
YatesA., MustyT.Preschool children's erroneous allegations of sexual molestation.Am J Psychiatry1988; 45: 989–992.
16.
MianM., WehrspannW., Klajner-DiamondH.Review of 125 children 6 years of age and under who were sexually abused.Child Abuse and Negl1986; 10: 223–229.
17.
FallerK.C.Possible explanations for child sexual abuse allegations in divorce.Am J Orthopsychiat1991; 61: 86–91.
18.
FinkelhorD., HotalingG., LewisI.A.Sexual abuse in a national survey of adult men and women: prevalence characteristics and risk factors.Child Abuse Negl1990; 14: 19–28.
19.
AndersonJ., MartinJ., MullenP.Prevalence of childhood sexual abuse experiences in a community sample of women.J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry1993; 32: 911–919.
20.
BrodzinskyD.M.On the use and misuse of psychological testing in child custody evaluations.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice1993; 24: 213–219.
21.
CrossT.P., SaxeL.A critique of the validity of polygraph testing in child sexual abuse cases.J Child Sexual Abuse1992; 1: 19–33.
22.
EarlsC.M.Clinical issues in the psychological assessment of child molesters. In: The sexual abuse of children: clinical issues.O'DonohueW., GeerJ.H., editors. Hillsdale NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1992: 232–255.
23.
HornerT.M., GuyerM.J., KalterN.M.Clinical expertise and the assessment of child sexual abuse.J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry1993; 32: 925–931.
24.
ZarbL.H.Allegations of childhood sexual abuse in custody and access disputes: what care is in the best interests of the child?Can J Fam Law1994; 12: 90–114.
25.
Bolocof skyD.N.Use and abuse of mental health experts in child custody determinations.Behav Sci Law1989; 7: 197–213.
26.
KarpmanB.The sexual psychopath.J Criminal Law Criminol1951; 42: 184–198.
27.
HaysH.R.The dangerous sex: the myth of feminine evil.New York: Putnam;1964.
28.
SchudsonC.B.Antagonistic parents in family courts: false allegations or false assumptions about true allegations of child sexual abuse?J Child Sexual Abuse1992; 1: 113–116.
29.
Report of the Law Society of British Columbia Gender Bias Committee.Gender equality in the justice system.The Law Society of British Columbia, 1992; 1: 1–6.
30.
Report of the Law Society of British Columbia Gender Bias Committee.Gender equality in the justice system.The Law Society of British Columbia, 1992; 2: 5–49.
31.
TaylorG.In whose best interests? A working report on women's experience in custody and access disputes. Vancouver BC, 1992.
32.
YatesA.Discussion of clinical expertise and the assessment of child sexual abuse.J Am Acad Child Psychiatry1993; 32: 931–933.
33.
CaplanP.J., WilsonJ.Assessing the child custody assessors.Review of Family Law1990; 27(3d): 121–134.
34.
AdamsC.B.Examining questionable child sexual abuse allegations in their environmental and psychodynamic contexts.J Child Sexual Abuse1994; 3: 21–50.
35.
WeissmanH.N.Forensic psychological examination of the child witness in cases of alleged sexual abuse.Am J Orthopsychiat1991; 61: 48–58.
36.
YuilleJ.C.The systematic assessment of children's testimony.Can J Psychol1988; 29: 247–262.
37.
BalaN.Children, psychiatrists and the courts: understanding the ambivalence of the legal profession. Part II - Applied principles.Can J Psychiatry1994; 39: 31–539.
38.
JonesD.P.H., SeigA.Child sexual abuse allegations in custody or visitation disputes: a report of 20 cases. In: Sexual abuse allegations in custody and visitation cases.NicholsonE.B., BulkelyJ., editors. American Bar Association1988: 22–36.
