As a result of a 1990 Supreme Court of Canada decision, battered woman syndrome defense is now accepted as a legitimate extension of self-defense in Canadian courts. This defense hinges on the expert testimony that a battered woman who is accused of murder or aggravated assault suffers from the psychological sequelae of abuse and that this psychological distress contributes to her apprehension of danger and ultimately her apprehension of death during a particular battering episode. The authors present a brief overview of the history of battered woman syndrome defense, the role of the expert in assessing the applicability of this defense in any particular situation, and the pitfalls of using battered woman syndrome defense.
References
1.
Criminal Code of Canada, 34(2).
2.
EwingP.Psychological self-defense: a proposed justification for battered women who kill.Law Human Behav1990; 14(6): 579–594.
3.
GallianoG., NicholsM.Mental health professional as expert witness: psychosocial evaluation of battered women accused of homicide or assault.J Int Violence1988; 3(1): 29–41.
4.
DubinskyK.Maidenly girls or designing women? The crime of seduction in turn-of-the-century Ontario. In: IacovettaF., ValverdeM., ed. Gender conflicts: new essays in women's history.Toronto ON: University of Toronto Press,1992.
5.
Lavallee v. Regina, 55 C.C.C. 3d 97 (1990).
6.
HermanJ.L.Trauma and recovery.New York NY: Basic Books, 1992.
7.
WalkerL.The Battered Woman.New York NY: Harper and Row Publishers, 1979.
8.
WalkerL.Victimology and the psychological perspectives of battered women.Victimology1983; 8: 82–104.
9.
WalkerL.The battered woman syndrome.New York NY: Springer,1984.
10.
WalkerE., YoungP.A killing cure.New York NY: Holt, Rinehart & Winston,1986.
11.
EwingP.Battered women who kill.Toronto ON: Lexington Books,1978.
12.
BrownmillerS.Against our will: men, women and rape.London: Seeker and Warburg,1975.
13.
SchullerR., VidmarN.Battered woman syndrome evidence in the courtroom: a review of the literature.Law Human Behav1992; 16(3): 273–291.
14.
JenkinsP., DavidsonB.Battered women in the criminal justice system: an analysis of gender stereotypes.Behav Sci Law1990; 8(2): 161–170.
15.
StarkE.Framing and refraining battered women. In: BuzawaE., and BuzawaC., eds. Domestic violence: the changing criminal justice response.Westport CT: Auburn House,1991.
16.
CrockerP.The meaning of equality for battered women who kill men in self-defense.Harvard Women's Law Rev1985; 8: 121–153.
17.
EwingP.Psychological self-defense: a proposed justification for battered women who kill.Law Human Behav1990; 14(6): 579–594.
18.
CormackE.Battered woman syndrome: feminist engagement with the law.Criminology Seminar University of Toronto, 1993.
19.
SmartC.Feminism and the power of law.London: Routledge,1989.
