Several studies of female adult populations suggest that somatization problems appear during adolescence and that they are related to behavioural problems during childhood. This study uses Cloninger's personality model to verify the link between personality traits and the beginning of somatization problems in elementary school girls. This model is based on the interaction of three dimensions: novelty seeking, harm avoidance and social reward dependence. Subjects were part of a longitudinal study of the social adjustment of children from Montreal and Val d'Or families. Evaluations of the girls' behaviour in kindergarten were used to establish personality types according to Cloninger's model. The somatization problems were assessed at age ten following interviews with mothers and girls, and ratings by mothers and teachers. The results showed that somatization problems at age ten were more likely when novelty seeking and harm avoidance were high in kindergarten. The kindergarten girls with ‘passive-aggressive’ or ‘explosive-schizoid’ personality profiles were more at risk of higher levels of somatization problems at age ten. However, Cloninger's hypothesized link between high levels of somatization problems and the ‘histrionic’ personality profile was not confirmed.
References
1.
BriquetP.Traité clinique et thérapeutique de l'hystérie, Tome 1.Paris: Baillière et fils, 1859 (réimpression 1974).
2.
FreudS.Fragment of analysis of a case of hysteria. In: StracheyJ., ed. The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud.London: Hogarth Press,1953; 7: 7–134.
3.
JanetP.The major symptoms of hysteria.New York: McMillan,1906.
4.
NemiahJ.C.Somatoform disorders. In: FreedmanA.M., KaplanH.I., SadockB.J., eds. Comprehensive textbook of psychiatry.Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins,1980; 4: 924–937.
5.
PerleyM.J., GuzeS.B.Hysteria: the stability and usefulness of clinical criteria. Quantitative study based on follow-up period of 6–8 year in 39 patients.N Engl J Med1962; 266: 421–426.
6.
WoodruffR.A., MurphyG.E., HerjanicM.The natural history of affective disorders, I. Symptoms of 72 patients at the time of index hospital admission.J Psychiatr Res1967; 5(3): 255–263.
7.
Mayer-GrossW., SlaterE., RothM.Clinical Psychiatry, third edition.Bloomington, IN: Sawnders,1969.
8.
MearesR., HorvathT.D.Acute and chronic hysteria.Br J Psychiatry1972; 121: 653–657.
9.
BianchiG.N.Patterns of hypochondriasis: a principal components analysis.Br J Psychiatry1973; 122: 541–548.
10.
GuzeS.B., WoodruffR.A., ClaytonP.J.Sex, age and the diagnostic of hysteria (Briquet's syndrome).Am J Psychiatry1973; 129: 745–748.
11.
American Psychiatric Association.Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders DSM-III-R.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1987.
12.
RobinsL.Deviant children grow up.Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins,1966.
13.
CloningerC.R., ReichT., GuzeS.B.The multifactorial model of disease transmission: III. Familial relationship between sociopathy and hysteria (Briquet's syndrome).Br J Psychiatry1975; 127: 23–32.
14.
RobinsL.N.The consequences of conduct disorder in girls. In: OlweusD., BlockJ., Radke-YarrowM., eds. Development of antisocial and prosocial behaviour: research, theories and issues.New York: Academic Press,1986.
15.
SigvardssonS., Von KnorringA.L., BohmanM.An adoption study of somatoform disorders: 1. The relationship of somatization to psychiatric disability.Arch Gen Psychiatry1984; 41: 853–859.
16.
CloningerC.R.A unified biosocial theory of personality and its rote in the development of anxiety states.Psychiatr Dev1986; 3: 167–226.
17.
De BonisM.Étude factorielle de la Symptomatologie subjective de l'anxiété.Revue de Psychologie Appliquée1968; 18: 177–187.
18.
SchallingD., CronholmB., AsberM.Ratings of psychic and somatic anxiety indicants-interrater reliability and relations to personality variables.Acta Psychiatr Scand1973; 49: 353–368.
19.
MorrisL.W., DavisM.A., HutchingsC.H.Cognitive and emotional components of anxiety: literature review and a revised worry-emotionality scale.J Educ Psychol1981; 73: 541–555.
20.
LehrerP.M., WoolfolkR.L.Self-report assessment of anxiety: somatic, cognitive and behavioral modalities.Behav Assess1982; 4: 167–177.
21.
TamarenA.J., CorneyR.M., AllenT.W.Assessment of cognitive and somatic anxiety.Behav Assess1985; 7: 197–202.
22.
WoodruffR.A., GuzeS.B., ClaytonP.J.Anxiety neurosis among psychiatric outpatients.Compr Psychiatry1972; 13: 165–170.
23.
JungC.G.Psychologische Typen. Reprinted in English: The basic writings of C. G. Jung.New York: De Laszlo ed.,1959.
24.
EysenckH.J.The biological basis of personality.Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas,1967.
25.
SmallI.F., SmallJ.G., AligV.B.Passive-aggressive personality disorder: a search for a syndrome.Am J Psychiatry1970; 126: 973–983.
26.
AchenbackT.M., ConnersC.K., QuayH.C.Replication of empirically derived syndromes as a basis for taxonomy of child/adolescent psychopathology.J Abnorm Child Psychol1989; 17: 299–323.
27.
OffordD.R.Child psychiatric disorders: prevalence and perspectives.Psychiatr Clin North Am1985; 8(4): 637–652.
28.
FriskM., TenhunenT., WidholmO.Physical problems in adolescents showing advanced or delayed physical maturation.Adolescence1966; 1: 126–140.
29.
Brooks-GunnJ., PetersonA.C.Girls at puberty: biological and psychological perspectives.New York: Plenum,1983.
30.
AroH., TaipaleV.The impact of timing of puberty on psychosomatic symptoms among fourteen- to sixteen-year-old Finnish girls.Child Dev1987; 58: 261–268.
31.
BlishenB.R., CarrollW.K., MooreC.The 1981 socioeconomic index for occupations in Canadaa.Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology1987; 24: 465–488.
32.
TremblayR.E., LoeberR., GagnonC.Disruptive boys with stable and unstable high fighting behavior patterns during junior elementary school.J Abnorm Child Psychol1991; 19: 285–300.
33.
TremblayR.E.The prediction of delinquent behavior from childhood behavior: personality theory revisited. In: McCordJ., ed. Facts, frameworks and forecasts.New-Brunswick: NJ, Transactions1992; 3: 193–230.
34.
RobinsE., O'NealP.Clinical features of hysteria in children.The Nervous Child1953; 10: 246–271.
35.
KimbleR., WilliamJ.G., AgrasS.A.A comparison of two methods of diagnosing hysteria.Am J Psychiatry1975; 132: 1197–1199.
36.
LindbergB.J., LindegardB.Studies of hysteroid personality attitude.Acta Psychiatr Scand1963; 39: 170–180.
37.
MartinR.L., CloningerC.R., GuzeS.B.Female criminality and the prediction of recidivism: a prospective six year follow-up.Arch Gen Psychiatry1978; 35: 207–214.
