Despite the scientific evidence that long stays in mental hospitals are clinically deleterious, inhumane and probably not cost-effective, this practice still occurs in most Western countries. The continued use of long stay beds in mental hospitals is a policy decided by many authorities, including psychiatrists. Alternatives to the mental hospital exist and may limit the use of hospital beds through comprehensive community care that also includes proper residential provisions. Alternatives may also decrease, but not impede the tendency to chronicity in some patients, who become long term users of these community services. Italy passed a law in 1978 prohibiting admissions to mental hospitals and encouraging the development of community care. In South Verona, Italy, the policy has been properly implemented and evaluated. Data from the case register and intensive studies of a cohort of patients will be used to show that long stay hospitalization can be discontinued while meeting the needs of the most severely handicapped patients. Implications of South Verona's experience for future training of psychiatrists will also be discussed.
References
1.
BrownGW, BoneM, DalisonB.Schizophrenia and social care.London: Oxford University Press,1966.
2.
ToothGC, BrookeEMTrends in the mental hospital population and their effect on future planning.Lancet1961; i: 710–713.
3.
LafaveHG, GrunbergFLa fin de l'Asile.Information Psychiatrique1974; 50(5): 525–535.
4.
AhmedPI, PlogSCState mental hospital, what happens when they close.New York: Plenum Press,1976.
5.
WingJKLong-term community care: experience in a London borough. Psychological Medicine Monograph Supplement 2.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1982.
6.
BachrachLLThe future of the state mental hospital.Hosp Community Psychiatry1986; 37: 467–474.
7.
LesageAD, LamontagneYVers une redéfinition de la psychiatrie communautaire au Québec.Can J Psychiatry1984; 29(6): 485–489.
HafnerH, an der HeidenWEffectiveness and cost of community care for schizophrenic patients.Hosp Community Psychiatry1989; 40: 59–63.
19.
WingJK, BrownGWInstitutionalism and schizophrenia.London: Cambridge University Press,1970.
20.
GoldbergDCost-effectiveness studies in the treatment of schizophrenia: a review.Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol1991; 26: 139–142.
21.
SerbanGNew trends of psychiatry in the community.Cambridge MA: Ballinger,1977.
22.
TansellaM, De SalviaD, WilliamsPThe Italian psychiatric reform: some quantitative evidence.Social Psychiatry1987; 2: 37–48.
23.
de GirolamoGItalian psychiatry and reform law: a review of the international literature.Int J Soc Psychiatry1989; 35: 21–37.
24.
de GirolamoG, TumminelloGLa réforme dans le paysage international.L'information psychiatrique1989; 7: 727–743.
25.
TansellaM, WilliamsPThe Italian experience and its implications.Psychol Med1987; 17: 283–289.
26.
BolliniP, ReichM, MuscettolaGRevision of the Italian psychiatric reform: north/south differences and future strategies.Soc Sci Med1988; 12: 1327–1335.
27.
FrisancoRThe quality of psychiatric care since the reform law: the “CENSIS survey.”Int J Soc Psychiatry1989; 35: 81–89.
28.
CrepetPA transition period in psychiatric care in Italy ten years after the reform.Br J Psychiatry1990; 156: 27–36.
29.
De SalviaD, TrifilettiCIntroduzione A. Rapporte sull’ Assistenza Psichiatrica in Otto Aree di Registre della Gran Bretagna (1976–1981) Edizione italiana.Nuova Unità Sanitaria, Numero Monografico, Poggibonsi: Lalli Editore,1986.
30.
JablenskyA, HendersonJReport on a visit to the South-Verona community psychiatric service. WHO Assignment Report.Copenhagen and Geneva: WHO,1983.
31.
LesageADSociological factors affecting clinical caseload in Italian good practice areas.Int J Soc Psychiatry1989; 35(1): 54–61.
32.
TansellaM, BalestrieriM, MeneghelliG.Trends in the provision of psychiatric care 1979–1988. In: TansellaM ed. Community-based psychiatry: long-term patterns of care in South-Verona. Psychological Medicine Monograph Supplement 19. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991: 5–16.
33.
BalestrieriM, MiccioloR, TansellaMLong-stay and long-term psychiatric patients in an area with a community-based system of care. A register follow-up study.Int J Soc Psychiatry1987; 33: 251–262.
34.
BalestrieriMIl Registre dei Casi per il Monitoraggio e la Valutazione dei Servizi Psichiatrici. Died Anni (1979–1988) di Psichiatria Territoriale a Verona-sud. Rivista Sperimentale di Freniatria 114, Monograph Supplement, No. 1, 1990.
35.
Berti CeroniG, MarangoniCLa nuova lungodegenza: rassegna della letteratura e presentazione di una ricerca su Bologna Ovest.Rivista Sperimentale di Freniatria1988; 112: 883–903.
36.
GibbonsJL, JenningsC, WingJKPsychiatric care in eight register areas.Statistics from eight psychiatric case registers in Great Britain. 1976–1981. Mimeo of Southampton Psychiatric Case Register, Knowle Hospital, Fareham, Hants, P017, UK, 1984.
37.
TansellaMCommunity-based psychiatry: long-term patterns of care in South-Verona. Psychological Medicine Monograph Supplement 19.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1991.
38.
MignolliG, FaccincaniC, PlattSPsychopathology and social performance in a cohort of patients with schizophrenic psychoses. A 7–year follow-up study. In: TansellaM ed. Community-based psychiatry: long-term patterns of care in South-Verona. Psychological Medicine Monograph Supplement 19.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991: 17–26.
39.
LesageAD, TrapaniV, TansellaMExcess mortality by natural causes of Italian schizophrenic patients.Eur Arch Psychiatry Neurol Sci1990; 239: 361–365.
40.
LesageAD, MignolliG, FaccincaniC.Standardized assessment of the needs for care in a cohort of patients with schizophrenic psychoses. In: TansellaM ed. Community-based psychiatry: long-term patterns of care in South-Verona. Psychological Medicine Monograph Supplement 19,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991: 27–34.
41.
HirshSRPsychiatric beds and resources: factors influencing bed use and service planning.Royal College of Psychiatrists, London: Gaskell,1988.
42.
HydeC, BridgesK, GoldbergD.The evaluation of a hostel ward. A controlled study using modified cost-benefit analysis.Br J Psychiatry1987; 151: 805–812.
43.
GaretyP, MorrisIAnew unit for long-stay psychiatric patients: organization, attitudes and quality of care.Psychol Med1984; 14: 183–192.
44.
GoldbergDP, BridgesK, CooperW.Douglas house: a new type of hostel ward for chronic psychotic patients.Br J Psychiatry1985; 147: 383–388.
45.
SteinLT, FactorRM, DiamondRJTraining psychiatrists in the treatment of chronically disabled patients. In: MyersonAT, FineT eds. Psychiatric disability: clinical, administrative, and legal aspects, 1983.
46.
BurtiL, MosherLRTraining psychiatrists in the community: a report of the Italian experience.Am J Psychiatry1986; 143: 1580–1584.
