This longitudinal study with a matched comparison group was conducted in Abitibi, an area in North-West Quebec. Its goal was to observe the impact of community support services on the quality of life of long term psychiatric patients living in a remote area. A cohort of 47 subjects, living in a small town with a comprehensive network of community support services, was compared with a similar group living in a neighbouring city with only outpatient services. The satisfaction with life domains scale developed by Andrews and Withey and adapted by Baker and Intagliata was used at four times during the study. According to the results, the subjective perception of the quality of life in the two groups is comparable, even though the objective conditions are less favorable for the group participating in the community support program. The highest ratings were given to the place of residence, the neighborhood and its commodities; the lowest ratings were given to their love life and financial situation. One can observe a stability of the measures of quality of life over time and for the two groups. The perceptions of the sample living in a remote area are much more favorable than the ones of a comparable group living in the Montreal area. These results are discussed in a double perspective: the role of community support services in the daily life of people who are having severe and persistant problems of mental health, and the interest of measures of quality of life.
References
1.
BachrachLL. Psychiatric services in rural areas: a sociological overview. Hosp Community Psychiatry1983; 34 (3): 215–226.
2.
LambR.Community psychiatry and prevention. Dans: American Psychiatric Association. Textbook of psychiatry.Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc., 1988: 1152.
3.
LangsleyDG. Community psychiatry. Dans: KaplanHI, FreemanAA, SadockBJ, eds. Comprehensive textbook of psychiatry.Baltimore MD: Williams and Wilkins, 1985; 4: 1878–1884.
4.
EyH, BernardP, BrissetC.Manuel de psychiatrie, quatrième édition. Paris: Masson, 1974.
5.
DiamondRJ, Van DykeD.Rural community support programs: the experience in three Wisconsin counties. Dans: SteinLI, TestMA, eds. The training in community living model: a decade of experience.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1985; 26: 49–57.
6.
BeyDR, ChampmanRE, KookerRA, A private practice model. Dans: TalbottJA. The chronic mentally ill: Treatment, Program, Systems. New York: Human Sciences Press, 1981: 75.
7.
CutlerDL. Volunteer support networks for chronic patients. New Dir Ment Health Serv1979; 2: 67–74.
8.
CutlerDL, MadoreE.Community family network therapy in a rural setting. Community Ment Health J1980; 16: 144–155.
9.
CutlerDL, TerwillingerW, FaulknerL, Disseminating the principles of community support program. Hosp Community Psychiatry1984; 35(1): 51–55.
10.
FairE.Community support and involvement in a rural mental health center. New Dir Ment Health Serv1981; 2: 51–59.
11.
GilesS.Appalachia's “Forgotten warriors”: outreach services for Vietnam veterans. New Dir Ment Health Serv1981; 9: 23–31.
12.
HughettBG, HonakerMJ. A rural program. Dans: TalbottJA, ed. The chronic mentally ill: treatment, program, systems.New York: Human Sciences Press, 1981.
13.
KantorLE, KauschDF, SmithLL. Development of an aftercare program in a nonmetropolitan area. Community Ment Health J1978; 14: 46–53.
14.
CormierHJ, GuimondG, VaillancourtS.Description et évaluation du programme de soutien communautaire du CLSC de Portneuf. Québec: Centre de recherche Université Laval/Robert Giffard, 1990.
15.
FieldG, YeggeL.A client outcome study of a community support demonstration project. Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal1982; 6(2): 15–22.
16.
GrunskyO, TierneyK, Anspach, . Descriptive evaluations of community support programs. International Journal of Mental Health1987; 15(4): 26–43.
17.
NadeauB.Le «case management» au carrefour de l'intervention clinique et communautaire. Santé mentale au Québec1989; 2: 51–60.
18.
CarscaddonDM, GeorgeM, WellsG.Rural community mental health consumer satisfaction and psychiatric symptoms. Community Ment Health J1990; 26(4): 309–319.
19.
ChuCC, SallackHS, KleinHE. Differences in symptomatology and social adjustment between urban and rural schizophrenics. Soc Psychiatry1986; 21: 10–14.
20.
DaviesMA, BrometEJ, SchulzSC, Community adjustment of chronic schizophrenic patients in urban and rural settings. Hosp Community Psychiatry1989; 40(8): 824–830.
21.
MuellerD.The current status of urban-rural difference in psychiatric disorder. J Nerv Ment Dis1981; 169: 18–27.
22.
CorinE, BibeauG, MartinJC, Comprendre pour soigner autrement. Montréal QC: Les Presses de l'Université de Montréal, 1991.
23.
Commission Administrative Régionale des Services en Santé Mentale. Bases théoriques du modèle d'intervention communautaire en santé mentale en Abitibi-Témiscamingue.Rouyn QC: Conseil régional de la Santé et des Services sociaux, 1985.
24.
GlaçonC, CharronR.Annales de la psychiatrie en Abitibi-Témiscamingue. Transitions1988; 25: 21–34.
25.
RenaudC, MercierC, TempierR.Perception par les équipes soignantes de l'approche communautaire en psychiatrie. Revue canadienne de santé mentale communautaire,1991; 11(1): 65–82.
26.
CloutierM.Clinique externe et services connexes. Transitions1988; 25: 35–46.
27.
RannouJ, FournierL, PalinL, Programme de réinsertion progressive au travail pour personnes handicapées psychiques. Transitions1988; 25: 47–60.
28.
RannouJ, LauzonS, DenisR, Présentation du groupe Soleil de Malartic Inc. Transitions1988; 25: 61–70.
29.
CharronR, Proresol, une charte et un outil, seulement? Transitions1988; 25: 71–80.
30.
EndicottJ, SpitzerRL, FleissJL, The global assessment scale: a procedure for measuring overall severity of psychiatric disturbance. Arch Gen Psychiatry1976; 33: 766–771.
31.
FilionJ.Une échelle de niveau fonctionnel. Santé mentale au Québec1987; 12(2): 180–181.
32.
ChengST. Subjective quality of life in the planning and evaluation of programs. Evaluation and Program Planning1988; 11: 123–134.
33.
LehmanAF. The well-being of chronic mental patients. Assessing their quality of life. Arch Gen Psychiatry1983; 40: 369–373.
34.
MercierC, FilionJ.La qualité de la vie: perspectives théoriques et empiriques. Santé mentale au Québec1987; 2: 135–143.
35.
WolfeJC, SchulbergHC. The design and evaluation of future mental health systems. Dans: StahlerGJ et TashWR eds. Innovative approaches to mental health evaluation, 1982: 3–22.
36.
BakerF, IntagliataJ.Quality of life in the evaluation of community support systems. Evaluation and Program Planning1982; 5: 69–79.
37.
AndrewsFM, WitheySB. Social indicators of well-being.New York: Plenum Press, 1976.
38.
KammanR, FarvyM, HarbisonP.The analysis and measurement of happiness as a sense of well-being. Social Indicators Research1983; 15: 91–115.
39.
HorleyJ, LittleBR. Affective and cognitive components of global subjective well-being measures. Social Indicators Research1985; 17: 189–197.
40.
LarsenRJ, DienerD, EmmonsRA. An evaluation of subjective well-being measures. Social Indicators Research1985; 17: 1–17.
41.
MercierC, RenaudC, DesbiensF, La contribution des services à la qualité de la vie des patients psychiatriques dans la communauté. Rapport présenté au Programme de subventions nationales au Bien-être social. Verdun QC: Unité de recherche psychosociale, Centre de recherche de l'hôpital Douglas, 1990.
42.
NajmanJM, LevineS.Evaluating the impact of medical care and technologies on the quality of life: a review and critique. Soc Sci Med1981; 15: 107–115.
