Mentally ill offenders are especially difficult patients to rehabilitate. Although group therapy is a universal method of treating these patients, their ability to benefit from group therapy has not been proven. The authors studied a group of patients held on Warrants of the Lieutenant Governor to assess their personality characteristics and their ability to develop group dynamics which are beneficial in other patient populations. The findings were that forensic patients have personality characteristics which preclude the development of these therapeutic dynamics.
References
1.
CleckleyH.The mask of sanity, fourth edition.St. Louis MO: C.V. Moseby,1964.
2.
HodginsS.Canadian data base: patients held on Lieutenant Governors' warrants annual report — year 1.Ottawa ON: Canadian Federal Department of Justice,1989.
3.
SmithM.Benefits of psychotherapy.Baltimore MD: Johns Hopkins University Press,1984.
4.
BorrielloJ.Group psychotherapy with acting-out patients: specific problems and techniques.Am J Psychother1979; 33(4): 275–285.
5.
YalomI.The theory and practise of group psychotherapy, second edition.New York: Basic Books,1975.
6.
KanasN.Inpatient and outpatient group therapy for schizophrenic patients.Am J Psychother1985; 39(3): 431–439.
7.
ScottD., GriffithM.The evaluation of group therapy in the treatment of schizophrenia.Small Group Behaviour1982; 13(3): 415–422.
8.
CarneyF.L.Three important factors in psychotherapy with criminal patients.Am J Psychother1973; 27(2): 220–231.
9.
CarneyF.L.Outpatient treatment of the aggressive offender.Am J Psychother1977; 31(2): 265–274.
10.
RappaportR.G.Group psychotherapy in prison.Int J Group Psychother1971; 21(4): 249–271.
11.
YochelsonS., SamenowS.E.The criminal personality.New York: Jason Aronson, 1976.
12.
MaxmenJ.S.Helping patients survive theories: the practice of an educative model.Int J Group Psychother1984; 34(3): 355–368.
13.
MaxmenJ.S.An educative model for inpatient group therapy.Int J Group Psychother1978; 28: 321–338.
14.
CarneyF.L.Some recurring therapeutic issues in group psychotherapy with criminal patients.Am J Psychother1972; 26(1): 34–41.
15.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, third edition, revised.Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc., 1987.
16.
MaxmenJ.S., HanoverN.H.Group therapy as viewed by hospitalized patients.Arch Gen Psychiatry1973; 28: 404–408.
17.
LongL., CopeC.Curative factors in male felony offender groups.Small Group Behaviour1980; 11: 389–398.
18.
MacDevittJ.W., SanislowC.Curative factors in offenders' groups.Small Group Behaviour1987; 18(1): 72–81.
19.
SteinfieldG.J., MabliJ.Perceived curative factors in group therapy by residents of a therapeutic community.Criminal Justice and Behaviour1974; 1(3): 278–288.
20.
SadoffR.L.Clinical measure of enforced group psychotherapy.Am J Psychiatry1971; 128(2): 116–119.
21.
RiceM.Violent recidivism among psychopaths and non-psychopaths treated in a therapeutic community.Research Reports, Mental Health Centre, Penetanguishene, Ontario1989; 6(1).
