The relationship between electric stimulus energy and clinical response was examined in depressed patients receiving electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) under routine clinical conditions with a protocol which dichotomized the stimulus energy by patient age. There was no significant difference in the number of treatments and cumulative seizure duration between groups. The results support the observation that the stimulus energy may contribute to the therapeutic effect of ECT. Reduction of that energy in order to minimize side-effects may compromise the therapeutic effectiveness. The implications for dosage strategies in routine clinical practice are discussed.
References
1.
AveryD., WinokurG.The efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy and antidepressants in depression.Biol Psychiatry1977; 12: 507–523.
2.
Royal College of Psychiatrists.Memorandum on the use of electroconvulsive therapy.Br J Psychiatry1977; 131: 261–272.
3.
WeinerR.D.The psychiatric use of electrically induced seizures.Am J Psychiatry1978; 136: 1507–1517.
4.
FrankelF.H., BidderT.G., FinkM.Task Force Report 14: electroconvulsive therapy.Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc.,1978.
5.
PaulS.M., ExteinI., CalilH.M.Use of ECT with treatment-resistant patients at the National Institute of Mental Health.Am J Psychiatry1981; 138: 486–489.
6.
KendellR.E.The present status of electroconvulsive therapy.Br J Psychiatry1981; 139: 265–283.
7.
CrowT.J., JohnstoneE.C.Controlled trials of electroconvulsive therapy. In: Malitz S, Sackeim HA, eds. Electroconvulsive therapy: clinical and basic research issues.Ann N Y Acad Sci1986; 462: 12–29.
8.
SackeimH.A.The efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy. In: Malitz S, Sackeim HA, eds. Electroconvulsive therapy: clinical and basic research issues.Ann N Y Acad Sci1986; 462: 70–75.
9.
AveryD., LubranoA.Depression treated with imipramine and ECT: the DeCarolis study reconsidered.Am J Psychiatry1979; 136: 559–562.
10.
FinkM.Convulsive therapy: theory and practice.New York: Raven Press,1979.
11.
OttossonJ.O.Experimental studies of the mode of action of electroconvulsive therapy.Acta Psychiatr Neurol Scand (Suppl)1960; 145: 1–141.
12.
MaletzkyB.M.Seizure duration and clinical effect in electroconvulsive therapy.Compr Psychiatry1978; 19: 541–550.
13.
PriceT.R.P., MackenzieT.B., TuckerG.J.The dose-response ratio in electroconvulsive therapy: a preliminary study.Arch Gen Psychiatry1978; 35: 1131–1136.
14.
KramerB.A.Seizure parameters in depressed patients receiving electroconvulsive therapy: a pilot study.Compr Psychiatry1983; 24: 259–262.
15.
MilsteinV., SmallI.F.An afterdischarge window for ECT?Biol Psychiatry1984; 19: 1143–1148.
16.
MillerA.L., FaberR.A., HatchJ.P.Factors affecting amnesia, seizure duration and efficiency in ECT.Am J Psychiatry1985; 142: 692–696.
AndradeC., GangadharB.M., SubbakrishnaD.K.A double blind comparison of sinusoidal wave and brief-pulse electroconvulsive therapy in endogenous depression.Convulsive Ther1988; 4: 297–305.
19.
d'EliaG., OttossonJ.O., StromgrenL.S.Present practice of electroconvulsive therapy in Scandinavia.Arch Gen Psychiatry1983; 40: 577–581.
20.
Harris-BrandtsG.E., MartinB.A.Electroconvulsive therapy and the stimulus waveform.Can J Psychiatry1983; 28(6): 438–440.
21.
MartinB.A.Electroconvulsive therapy: contemporary standards of practice.Can J Psychiatry1986; 31(8): 759–771.
22.
SackeimH.A., DecinaP., KanzlerM.Effects of electrode placement on the efficacy of titrated, low-dose ECT.Am J Psychiatry1987; 144: 1449–1455.
23.
RobinA., DeTisseraS.A double blind controlled comparison of the therapeutic effects of low and high energy electroconvulsive therapies.Br J Psychiatry1982; 141: 357–366.
24.
SackeimH.A., DecinaP., ProhovnikI.Seizure threshold in electroconvulsive therapy: effects of sex, age, electrode placement, and number of treatments.Arch Gen Psychiatry1987; 44: 355–360.
25.
DevanandD.P., SackeimH.A.Case report: seizure elicitation blocked by pretreatment with lidocaine.Convulsive Ther1988; 4: 225–229.
26.
LambournJ., GillD.A controlled comparison of simulated and real ECT.Br J Psychiatry1978; 133: 514–519.
27.
MartinB.A.Electroconvulsive therapy for depression in general psychiatric practice.Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa1989; 14: 413–417.
28.
American Psychiatric Association, Task Force on ECT.The practice of ECT: recommendations for treatment, training and privileging.Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc.,1990.
29.
MartinB.A., StriglerS., BezchlibnykK.Electroconvulsive therapy and the seizure threshold.Can J Psychiatry1983; 28(6): 445–448.
30.
BeanG.J., RhodesA.E., MartinB.A.Electroconvulsive therapy: Electric stimulus variables and the convulsive response.Can J Psychiatry1991; 36(9): 630–636.
31.
MontgomeryS.A., AsbergM.A new depression scale designed to be sensitive to change.Br J Psychiatry1979; 134: 382–389.
BenbowS.M.The role of electroconvulsive therapy in the treatment of depressive illness in old age.Br J Psychiatry1989; 155: 147–152.
34.
OttosonJ.O.Electroconvulsive therapy in endogenous depression: An analysis of the influence of various factors on the efficacy of the therapy.J Ment Science1962; 103: 694–703.
35.
PriceT.R.P., McAllisterT.W.Response of depressed patients to sequential unilateral nondominant brief-pulse and bilateral sinusoidal ECT.J Clin Psychiatry1986; 47: 182–186.
36.
AndradeC., GangadharB.N., SwaminathG.Predicting the outcome of endogenous depression following electroconvulsive therapy.Convulsive Ther1988; 4: 169–174.
37.
CrowT.J., DeakinJ.F.W., JohnstoneE.C.Mechanism of action of ECT — relevance of clinical evidence: is noradrenergic failure associated with the development of depressive delusions? In: LererB., WeinerR.D., BelmakerR.H., eds. ECT: basic mechanisms.London/Paris: John Libbey,1984.
38.
RichC.L., BlackN.A.The efficacy of ECT: II. Correlation of specific treatment variables to response rate in unilateral ECT.Psychiatr Res1985; 16: 147–154.
39.
NettelbladtP.Factors influencing the number of treatments and seizure duration in ECT: drug treatment, social class.Convulsive Ther1988; 4: 160–168.
40.
SackeimH.A., DecinaP., ProhovnikI.Dosage, seizure threshold and the antidepressant efficacy of electroconvulsive therapy. In: Malitz S, Sackeim HA, eds. Electroconvulsive therapy: clinical and basic research issues.Ann N Y Acad Sci1986; 462: 398–415.
41.
SackeimH.A., DecinaP., PortnoyS.Studies of dosage, seizure threshold, and seizure duration in ECT.Biol Psychiatry1987; 22: 249–268.
