This paper explores some of the similarities and differences between hysteria and hypochondriasis and suggests that voice disorders are a prototype of disorders which reflect the intricate interplay of emotional, cognitive and physiological functions. Speech production requires the involvement of various systems of the body, including the central nervous system, respiratory and vocal systems. Voice disorders can take many different forms and can be caused by a variety of factors. A review of the relevant literature is presented along with a clinical case record of a woman with hysterical dysarthria.
References
1.
RamaniS.V., QuesneyL.F., OlsonD.Diagnosis of hysterical seizures in epileptic patients.Am J Psychiatry1980; 137: 705–709.
2.
SapirS., AronsonA.E.Coexisting psychogenic and neurogenic dysphonia: a source of diagnostic confusion.Br J Disord Commun1987; 22: 73–80.
3.
HartmanD.E., DailyW.W., MorinK.N.A case of superior laryngeal nerve paresis and psychogenic dysphonia.J Speech Hear Disord1989; 54(4): 526–529.
4.
FreudS.Fragment of an analysis of a case of hysteria.London: Hogarth Press,1953.
5.
AlexanderF.Psychosomatic medicine: its principles and applications.New York: W.W. Norton and Company,1950.
6.
McCueE.C., McCueP.A.Hynposis in the elucidation of hysterical aphonia: a case report.Am J Clin Hypn1988; 30: 178–182.
7.
ChertokL.Psychoanalysis and hypnosis theory: comments on five case histories.Am J Clin Hypn1983; 25(4): 109–224.
8.
SmithM.S.Acute psychogenic Stridor in an adolescent athlete treated with hypnosis.Australian Journal of Clinical Hypnotherapy and Hypnosis1984; 5(2): 61–63.
9.
HorsleyI.A.Hypnosis and self-hypnosis in the treatment of psychogenic dysphonia: a case report.Am J Clin Hypn1982; 24: 277–283.
10.
ButcherP., EliasA.Raven R, et al. Psychogenic voice disorder unresponsive to speech therapy: Psychological characteristics and cognitive-behaviour therapy.Br J Disord Commun1987; 22: 81–92.
11.
MacLeodC., HemsleyD.R.Visual feedback of vocal intensity in the treatment of hysterical aphonia.J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry1985; 16: 347–353.
12.
BigenzahnW., HoflerH.Therapy of psychogenic aphonias using endolaryngeal faradization.Larygol-Rhinol-Otol-Stuttg1986; 65: 659–661.
13.
LalK.K.A case of functional dysphonia.Indian Journal of Clinical Psychology1983; 10: 367–378.
14.
EliasA.Speech therapy for psychogenic voice disorder: A survey of current practice and training.Br J Disord Commun1989; 24(1): 61–76.
15.
HammarbergB.Pitch and quality characteristics of mutational voice disorders before and after therapy.Folia Phoniatrica1987; 39(4): 204–216.
16.
KhubalkarR.An approach to hysterical aphonia (a case report).Indian Journal of Clinical Psychology1983; 10: 113–114.
17.
KitzingP.The therapy of disturbed voice function.Folia Phonitrica1983; 35: 40–65.
18.
SamoliuboverE.G.Neuropsychic disorders in functional dysphonias Zh.Nevropatol Psikhiatr1988; 88(3): 104–108.
19.
RoyA.Hysteria: a case note study.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24(2): 157–160.
20.
ThorpeL.U., KeeganD.L., VeemanG.A.Conversion mutism: case report and discussion.Can J Psychiatry1985; 30(1): 71–73.
21.
GinsbergB.I., WallackJ.J., SrainJ.J.Defining the psychiatric role in spastic dysphonia.Gen Hosp Psychiatry1988; 10: 132–137.
22.
FroeseA.P., SimsP.Functional dysphonia in adolescence: two case reports.Can J Psychiatry1987; 32(5): 389–392.
23.
KoufmanJ.A., BlalockP.D.Vocal fatigue and dysphonia in the professional voice user: Bogart-Bacall syndrome.Laryngoscope1988; 98: 493–498.
24.
KinzlJ., BieblRauchegger H.Functional aphonia: a conversion symptom as defensive mechanism against anxiety.Psychother-Psychosom1988; 49: 31–36.
25.
KinzlJ.Functional aphonia: psychosomatic aspects of diagnosis and therapy.Folia Phoniatr Basel1988; 40(3): 131–137.
26.
KinzlJ., BieblW., RaucheggerH.Functional aphonia - a conversion symptom as a defence against fear.Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol1988; 38(9–10): 347–351.
27.
HouseA.D., AndrewsH.B.Life events and difficulties preceding the onset of functional dysphonia.J Psychosom Res1988; 32: 311–319.
28.
FreidlW., EggerJ., FriedrichG.Personality and coping with stress in patients with functional dysphonia.Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol1989; 39(8): 300–305.
