This research analyses retrospectively a population of 24 psychotic patients, hospitalized in a maximum security institution for the criminality insane and who have committed or attempted to commit murder.
The main focus is on finding the clinical elements which are associated with increased homicidal risk, in the short term.
With that aim in mind, nine patients that were in contact with a mental health professional, during the month preceding the homicide, were studied more specifically. It seems that in addition to the elements usually described in the literature, the association of depressive and paranoid features in the psychotic is a risk factor for homicide in the short term.
References
1.
GuzeS.Criminality and psychiatric disorders.New York: Oxford University Press1976; 35–36.
2.
HafnerH., BokerW.Crimes of violence by mentally abnormal offenders.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1973.
3.
MonahanJ.The clinical prediction of violent behaviour; Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office,1981.
4.
SteadmanH., CocozzaJ., MelickM.A.Explaining the increased arrest rate among mental patients: the changing clientele of state hospitals; Am J Psychiatry1978; 135: 816–820.
5.
TaylorP.J., GunnJ.Risk of violence among psychotic men.Br Med J1984; 288: 1945–1949.
6.
EastN.Medical aspects of crime (369). In: WolfgangM.E., ed. Patterns in criminal homicide.Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, PennsylvaniaUniversity Press, 1958.
7.
HindelangM.Race and involvement in crimes.Am Soc Rev1978; 43: 93–109.
8.
MonahanJ.Predicting violent behavior: an assessment of clinical techniques.Beverly Hills, Ca: Sage Publications,1981; 104–118 et 133.
9.
PritchardD.Stable predictors of recidivism, J Su Abstract Service1977; 7: 72.
10.
RevitchE., SchlesingerL.B.The organic toxic and paranoid homicides. In: ThomasC., ed Psychopathology of homicide.Springfield, Illinois.1981.
11.
SteadmanH.A new look at recidivism among patuxent inmates; Bull Am Acad Law Psychiatry1977; 5: 200–209.
12.
HardingT.W.Le médecin face à la dangerosité.Rev méd Suisse Romande1985; 105; 23–31.
13.
AddadM., BenezechM.Schizophrénie et délinquance.Enquête médico-sociale chez 116 psychotiques, dont 83 délinquants, hospitalisés en centres hospitaliers spécialisés; Ann Méd Psychol1977; 1(1): 1–33.
GoodM.I.Primary affective disorder, aggression, and criminality: a review clinical study.Arch Gen Psychiatry1978; 35(8): 954–960.
19.
BoscredonJ.Homicides et maladies mentales. Étude de 93 observations d'homicides ou de tentatives à partir de la population d'un hôpital psychiatrique de 1835 à 1973. Dans: Mémoire de certificat d'études relatives à l'expertise psychiatrique et médico-psychologique judiciaire.Paris: Université René Descartes,1975–1977 V.
20.
CormierB., AuglikerC.C.J., BoyerR.The psychodynamics of homicide in a specific relationship.Rev Can Criminol1971; 13(1): 1–8.
QuinseyV.L., BoydB.A.An assessment of the characteristics and dangerousness of patients held on warrants of the Lieutenant-governor.Crime and Justice,1977; 4: 268–274.
23.
WolfgangM.E.Victim precipitated criminal homicide.Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science.1957; 48: 1–11.
24.
MillaudF.Homicide et patient psychotique.Communication au congrès francophone Droit et Santé mentale. Lyon, 9, 10 et 11 juin 1986.
25.
BellD.S., ChampionR.A.Deviancy, delinquency and drug use.Br J Psychiatry1979; 134: 269–276.
26.
LangevinR., PaitickD., OrchardB.The role of alcohol, drugs, suicide attempts and situational strains in homicide committed by offenders seen for psychiatric assessment; Acta Psychiat Scand1982; 66: 229–242.
27.
CyrM., HodginsS., ElyseeR.Étude de relance auprès d'hommes traités en milieu psychiatrique sécuritaire: description des antécédents et du séjour cible. In: Cahier de recherche de l'Institut Philippe-Pinel de Montréal, Québec. 1985; 11.
28.
HodginsS., HebertJ.Une étude de relance auprès de malades mentaux ayant commis des actes criminels; Rev Can Psychiatrie1984; 29: 669–675.
29.
WernerP.D., RoseT.L., YesavageJ.A.Psychiatrists' judgements of dangerousness in patients on an acute care unit.Am J Psychiatry1984; 141: 263–266.
30.
BinderR., McNielD.E.Victims and families of violent psychiatric patients.Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law1986; 14(2): 131–139.
31.
GreenlandL.Evaluation of violence and dangerous behavior associated with mental illness.Seminars in Psychiatry1971; III: 345–356.
32.
WestD.J.Murder followed by suicide.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1966.
33.
Bach-Y-RitaG., LionJ.R., ClimentC.E.Episodic dyscontrol: a study of 130 violent patients.Am J Psychiatry1971; 127: 1473–1478.
34.
MalmquistC.P.Premonitory signs of homicidal aggression in males.Am J Psychiatry1971; 128: 461–465.
35.
YoonS.H., KanG.S.H., LeeJ.N.Homicide in schizophrenics.Neuropsychiatry (Séoul, Korea)1973; 12: 189–210.
36.
FrodiA., MacauleyJ., ThorneP.Are women always less aggressive than men? A review of the experimental literature.Psychol Bull,1977; 84: 634–660.
37.
MontandonC., HardingT.The reliability of dangerousness assessments; Brit J Psychiatry, 1984; 144: 149–155.
