Evaluation of regional psychiatric services is essential for effective and economical planning and requires a complete and accurate source of data about individuals in the system. Routinely collected statistics describe only events, and cannot link data about individuals over time. This is possible with record linkage systems (or case registers) which are systematic standardized data collections about individuals’ contacts with specified facilities over time. Such data bases have a wide range of clinical, epidemiological and administrative functions. The confidentiality of such systems is of paramount importance and is maintained by several safeguards. There are numerous technical considerations in establishing and operating record linkage systems. A wide variety of studies have been produced from systems around the world. An ongoing collection of linked data is required for many types of research and particularly for service evaluation. In times of cost constraints and diminishing resources, it is essential to deliver psychiatric services in the most effective and cost efficient manner possible.
References
1.
EastwoodM.R., MeierH.M.R., WooghC.W.Information systems in psychiatry.Psychol Med1978; 8: 181–184.
2.
BrookeE.M.A cohort study of patients first admitted to mental hospitals in 1954 and 1955. GRO Studies on Medical Population Subjects No 18, HMSO, 1963.
3.
FriedmanI.R.A., LundsteadtS., Von MeringO., HinkoE.N.Systematic underestimation in reported mental hospital readmission rates.Am J Psychiatry1964; 121: 148.
4.
WooghC.M., MeierH.M.R., EastwoodM.R.Psychiatric hospitalization in Ontario: the revolving door in perspective.Can Med Assoc J1977; 116: 876.
5.
BaldwinJ.A.Linked record medical information systems.Proc R Soc Lond (Biol)1973; 184: 403–420.
6.
AchesonE.D.Medical record linkage.London: Oxford University Press, 1967.
7.
BahnA.K.Psychiatric case register conference 1962.Public Health Reports1962; 77(12): 1071–1076.
8.
BrotherstonJ.H.F.In: Acheson ED, ed. Record linkage in medicine.Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins, 1968.
9.
RichmanA.In: Hare EH, Wing JK, eds. Psychiatric epidemiological proceedings of the international symposium.London: Oxford University Press, 1970.
10.
SainsburyP., KreitmanN.Methods of psychiatric research.London: Oxford University Press, 1975.
11.
GoldbergI.D., AllinG.Unduplicated counts of persons receiving care in psychiatric facilities in Monroe County, New York. Mental Health Statistical Note No 158, National Institute of Mental Health Survey & Reports Branch, 1981.
12.
AchesonE.D., EvansJ.G.The Oxford record linkage study: review of the methods with some preliminary results.Royal Society of Medicine1964; 57: 269–274.
13.
BaldwinJ.A., InnesG., MillarW.M., SharpG.A.A psychiatric case register in north-east Scotland.Br J Prev Soc Med1965; 19: 38–42.
14.
FryersT.Accumulating long-stay in-patients in Salford: monitoring further progress.Psychol Med1979; 9: 567–572.
15.
MarinoniA., TorreE., AllegriG., ComelliM.Lomest psychiatric case register: the statistical context required for planning.Acta Psychiatr Scand1983; 67: 109–117.
16.
BennettE.M., TruteB. eds. Mental health information systems: problems and prospects.New York & Toronto: Edwin Mellon Press, 1983.
17.
WagnerG., NewcombeH.B.Record linkage its methodology and application in medical data processing.Methods Inf Med1970; 9 (2): 121–138.
18.
GardnerE.A., MilesH.C., IkerH.P., RomanoJ.A cumulative register of psychiatric services in a community.Am J Public Health1963; 53: 1269–1277.
19.
LiptzinB., BabigianH.M.Ten years experience with a cumulative psychiatric patient register.Methods Inf Med1972; 11 (4): 238–242.
20.
MilesH.C., GardnerE.A., BodianC., RomanoJ.A cumulative survey of all psychiatric experience in Monroe County, N.Y.Psychiatr Q1964; 38: 458–487.
21.
NottP.N.Psychiatric illness following childbirth in Southampton: a case register study.Psychol Med1982; 12: 557–561.
22.
RoghmannK.J., BabigianH.M., GoldbergI.D., ZastownyT.R.The increasing number of children using psychiatric services: analysis of a cumulative psychiatric case register.Pediatrics1982; 70 (5) 790–801.
23.
WalshD., O'HareA., BlakeB., HalpennyJ.V., O'BrienP.The treated prevalence of mental illness in the republic of Ireland — the three county case register study.Psychol Med1980; 10: 465–470.
24.
WilkinsonD.G.The suicide rate in schizophrenia.Br J Psychiatry1982; 140: 138–141.
25.
WooghC.M.Patterns of care for psychiatric outpatients. Presented at the 66th annual meeting of the Ontario Psychiatric Association, Toronto, 1986.
26.
BabigianH.M.The impact of community mental health centers on the utilization of services.Arch Gen Psychiatry1977; 34: 385–394.
27.
BeebeG.Record linkage systems — Canada vs the United States.Am J Public Health1980; 70 (12): 1246–1248.
28.
CooperB., MorganH.G.Epidemiological psychiatry.Springfield, Ill: Charles C Thomas,1973.
29.
WykesT., WingJ.A ward in a house: accommodation for ‘new’ long-stay patients.Acta Psychiatr Scand1982; 65: 315–330.
30.
SpitzerR.L., EndicottJ., RobinsE.Research diagnostic criteria: rationale and reliability.Arch Gen Psychiatry1978; 36: 773–782.
31.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, Third edition, Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association, 1980.
32.
Epidemiological methods in the study of chronic diseases.,Technical report series No 365.Expert committee on health statistics Geneva: World Health Organization, 1967.
33.
Government of Ontario.The mental health act, 1979.
34.
LipscombC.F.Confidentiality and automated health data systems.Can J Psychiatry1980; 25: 595–597.
35.
BaldwinJ.A., LeffJ., WingJ.K.Confidentiality of psychiatric data in medical information systems.Br J Psychiatry1976; 128: 417–427.
36.
MartinB.A., EastwoodM.R.The confidentiality of medical records — the right to privacy versus the public interest.Can J Psychiatry1980; 25: 492–495.
37.
WooghC.M.Record linkage systems for service evaluation using a record linkage system. Presented at the 35th annual meeting, Canadian Psychiatric Association, Quebec City, 1985.
38.
PhillipsW., GorwitzK., BahnA.Electronic maintenance of case registers.Public Health Reports1962; 77 (6): 503–510.
39.
WooffK., FreemanH.L., FryersT.Psychiatric service use in Salford.Br J Psychiatry1983; 142: 588–597.
40.
ReidS.Personal communication.Strong Memorial Hospital, University of Rochester, Rochester NY: 1983.
41.
HoleD.J., ClarkeJ.A., HawthorneV.M., MurdochR.M.Cohort follow-up using computer linkage with routinely collected data.J Chronic Dis1981; 34 (6): 291–297.
42.
HoweG.R., LindsayJ.A generalized iterative record linkage computer system for use in medical follow-up studies.Computers and Biomedical Research1981; 14: 327–340.
43.
SmithM., NewcombeH.Automated follow-up facilities in Canada for monitoring delayed health effects.Am J Public Health1980; 70 (12): 1261–1268.
44.
SmithM., SilinsJ.Generalized iterative record linkage system. Proceedings of the American Statistical Association Social Statistics Section, 1981.
45.
DupontA., VidebechT., WeekeA.A cumulative national psychiatric register: its structure and application.Acta Psychiatr Scand1974; 50: 161–173.
46.
FryersT.Psychiatric inpatients from an urban community 1968–72.Br Med J1973; 14: 76–80.
47.
GoodmanA.B., RahavM., PopperM., GinathY., PearlE.The reliability of psychiatric diagnosis in Israel's psychiatric case register.Acta Psychiatr Scand1984; 69: 397.
48.
KastrupM.Characteristics of a nationwide cohort of psychiatric patients — with special reference to the elderly and the chronically admitted.Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl 319,1985; 71: 107–115.
Horn tenG.H.M.M., GielR.The feasibility of cost-benefit studies of mental health care. An attempt with a Dutch case register.Acta Psychiatr Scand1984; 69: 80–87.
51.
HafnerH., KlugJ.The impact of an expanding community mental health service on patterns of bed usage: evaluation of a four-year period of implementation.Psychol Med1982; 12: 177–190.
52.
TorreE., MarinoniA.Register studies: data from areas in northern Italy.Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl 316, 1985; 87–94.
53.
GibbonsJ., JenningsC., WingJ.K.Psychiatric care in eight register areas.Report from eight psychiatric case registers in Great Britain,1984.
54.
WingJ.K.Collaboration between psychiatric case registers.The Bulletin of the RC of P1984; 8 (5): 87.
