Fifty patients released by the Review Panel are compared with a matched group of 50 patients discharged by the attending physician at one and at two years after separation from hospital. The two groups did not differ with respect to readmission rate or time spent in the community. At two years the physician-discharged patients were functioning better than the Panel-discharged patients in two of the seven areas of functioning; in the other five areas of functioning the adjustment of the two groups did not differ.
The implications of these findings for the operation of the Review Panel and for the timely discharge of involuntary patients by attending physicians is discussed.
References
1.
GrayJ., ClarkA., HigenbottamJ., LedwidgeB., ParedesJ.Review panels for involuntary patients: which patients apply?Can J Psychiatry1985; 30: 573–576.
2.
HigenbottamJ., LedwidgeB., ParedesJ., HansenM., KoganC., LambertL.Variables affecting the decision making of a review panel.Can J Psychiatry1985; 30: 577–581.
3.
QuinseyV.L., WarnefordA., PruesseM., LinkN.Released Oak Ridge patients: a follow-up study of review board discharges.Br J Criminol1975; 15: 264–270.
4.
TuckmanJ., LavellM.Psychiatric patients discharged with or against medical advice.J Clin Psychol1962; 18: 177–180.
5.
SchorerC.E.Defiance and healing.Compr Psychiatry1965; 6: 184–190.
6.
ScheerN., BartonG.M.A comparison of patients discharged against medical advice with a matched control group.Am J Psychiatry1974; 131: 1217–1220.
FabrickA.L., RuffinW.C., DenmanS.B.Characteristics of patients discharged against medical advice.Mental Hygiene1968; 52: 124–128.
9.
WitherstyD.J.Patient responsibility and the AMA discharge: a one-year follow-up study.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134: 1442–1444.
10.
HarmonH.H.Modern factor analysis. Second edition.Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1967.
11.
AnthonyW., CohenM., VitaloR.The measurement of rehabilitation outcome.Schizophr Bull1978; 4: 365–383.
12.
CaffeyE.M., GalbrechtC.R., KlettC.J.Brief hospitalization and aftercare in the treatment of schizophrenia.Arch Gen Psychiatry1971; 24: 81–86.
13.
GlickI.D., HargreavesW.A., RaskinM., KutnerS.J.Short versus long hospitalization: a prospective controlled study: 11. Results for schizophrenic patients.Am J Psychiatry1975; 132: 385–390.
14.
HerzM.I., EndicottJ., SpitzerR.L.Brief hospitalization: a two year follow-up.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134: 502–507.
15.
LehmanA.F., WardN.C., LinnL.S.Chronic mental patients: the quality of life issue.Am J Psychiatry1982; 139: 1271–1282.
16.
SingerJ.E., GrobM.C.Patients discharged against medical advice: a follow-up study.Massachusetts Journal of Mental Health1974; 5: 57–67.
