In this study a cohort of 1722 patients first admitted to all three psychiatric facilities in a small urban area were followed for up to seven years. Seventy-nine percent had non-psychotic diagnoses. Of the total cohort, 7%(n=120) were readmitted more than three times — these patients were more likely to be male, young and unemployed, but of similar education level to age-sex matched single admission controls. Fifty three per cent (n=49) of this group were not psychotic (most were alcholics or personality disorders) and again were more likely to be males, young and unemployed than age-sex matched non-psychotic single admission controls.
Efforts to further evaluate the characteristics of the multiplyreadmitted cohort were thwarted for a number of reasons. Information about individuals within a system are essential for further epidemiological study but require a better data base and prospective monitoring of patient careers.
References
1.
MartinB.A., KedwardH.B., EastwoodM.R.Hospitalization for mental illness: evaluation of admission trends from 1941 to 1971.Can Med Assoc J1976; 115: 322–325.
2.
D'ArcyC., FritzW.A mental health system in transition: profiles of change.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24: 121–131.
3.
Ontario Department of Health, Mental Health Division: Preface to the Annual Report, 1951.
4.
RichmanA.Advances in therapeutics and diagnosis: persisting problems in care.Annals Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada1983; 16 (5): 431–436.
5.
BrookeE.M.A cohort study of patients first admitted to mental hospitals in 1954 and 1955.G. R. O. Studies on medical population subjects No. 18, H. M. S. O., 1963.
6.
FriedmanI.R.A., LundsteadtS., Von MeringO., HinkoE.N.Systematic underestimation in reported mental hospital readmission rates.Am J Psychiatry1964; 121: 148–152.
WooghC.M., MeierH.M.R., EastwoodM.R.Psychiatric hospitalization in Ontario. The revolving door in perspective.Can Med Assoc J1977; 116: 876–881.
9.
KramerM.Applications of mental health statistics.W. H. O., Geneva, 1969.
10.
KrupinskiJ., StollerA.Changing patterns of psychiatric hospitalization in the past fifty years: a cohort study.Aust NZJ Psychiatry1975; 9: 231–239.
11.
FosterF.R.Cohort study of first admissions, Special Report No. 27. Mental Hospitals Admissions and Release Data, National Health Statistics Centre, Wellington, New Zealand,1969.
12.
EastwoodM.R., MeierH.M.R., WooghC.M., KedwardH.B.Comparative cohort studies of first admissions to psychiatric hospitals. Paper presented at the Canadian Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting, Quebec City, 1976.
13.
FranklinJ.L., KittredgeL.D., ThrasherJ.H.A Survey of factors related to mental hospital readmissions.Hosp Community Psychiatry1975; 26 (11): 749–756.
14.
TalbottJ.A.Stopping the revolving door - a study of readmissions to a State Hospital.Psychiatr Q1974; 48: 159–168.
15.
RosenblattA., MayerJ.E.The recidivism of mental patients: a review of past studies.Am J Orthopsychiatry1974; 44 (5): 697–706.
16.
VoineskosG., DenaultS.Recurrent psychiatric hospitalization.Can Med Assoc J1978; 118: 247–250.
17.
GoffmanE.Asylums: essays on the social situation of mental patients and other inmates.New York: Doubleday,1961.
18.
GruenbergE.M., KasiusR.V., HuxleyM.Objective appraisal of deterioration in a group of long-stay hospital patients.Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly1962; 40: 90–100.
19.
BartonR.Institutional Neurosis.Bristol: John Wright, 1966.
20.
WingJ.K., BrownG.W.Institutionalism and schizophrenia.London: Cambridge University Press, 1970.
21.
KedwardH.B., EastwoodM.R., AllodiF., DuckworthG.S.The evaluation of chronic psychiatric care.Can Med Assoc J1974; 110: 519–523.
22.
MurphyH.B.M., PenneB., LuchineD.Foster homes - new back wards?Canadian Mental Health1972; 20, supplement 71.
23.
DeckerJ.B., StubblebineJ.M.Crisis intervention and prevention of psychiatric disability: a follow-up study.Am J Psychiatry1972; 129 (6): 725–729.
24.
SheridanE.P., TeplinL.A.Recidivism in difficult patients: differences between community mental health center and State Hospital admissions.Am J Psychiatry1981; 138 (5): 688–690.
25.
SeltzerM.L. In: Kaplan, Freedman and Sadock, eds. Comprehensive textbook of psychiatry (3rd ed.) Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1980.
26.
GellerM.P.The ‘revolving door’: a trap or a lifestyle?Hosp Community Psychiatry1982; 33 (5): 388–389.
27.
PasamanickB., ScarpittiF.R., DinitzS.Schizophrenics in the community: an experimental study in the prevention of hospitalization.New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts,1967.
