The moral values of contemporary society present a turmoil of pluralistic, often confusing values. In the face of these, what should be the proper attitude of the physician towards the suicidal patient? Should he (she) support the patient's autonomous right to make such a decision independently, or should he use his professional influence to try to sustain the patient's life? This paper discusses the social and religious roots of today's medical dilemma and tries to help the health professional to avoid the pitfalls of simplistic solutions which do not take account of clinical experience.
References
1.
ClareA.W.In defence of compulsory psychiatric intervention.Lancet1978; ii: 1197–1198.
2.
ChodoffP.Involuntary hospitalization of the mentally ill as a moral issue.Am J Psychiatry1984; 141: 384–389.
3.
HoffmasterC.B., SwartG.T.Suicide: philosophical, legal, theological and medical issues: introductory remarks.Can J Psychiatry1986; 31 (2).
4.
MaxmenJ.S., TuckerG.J.No exit: the persistently suicidal patient.Compr Psychiatry1973; 14: 71–79.
5.
BestE.E.Suicide: ethical and moral issues from a theological perspective.Can J Psychiatry1986; 31 (2).
6.
DurkheimE.Suicide: a study in sociology. Transl: Spaulding JA and Simpson G.New York: The Free Press,1951.
7.
AquinasT.Whether it is lawful to kill oneself. Reprinted from Summa Theologica. In: BeauchampT.L., PerlinS., eds. Ethical issues in death and dying.Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1978.
8.
RosenG.History in the study of suicide.Psychol Med1971; 1: 267–285.
9.
HabgoodJ.S.Euthanasia — a Christian view.Roy Soc Health J1974; 94: 124–126.
10.
SchwynE.Ethical norms of suicide prevention and crisis intervention.Ment Health Soc1976; 3: 142–147.
11.
Al-NajjarY.Suicide and Islamic law.Ment Health Soc1976; 3: 137–141.
12.
CohenH.Suicide in Jewish legal and religious tradition.Ment Health Soc1976; 3: 129–136.
GillonR.Autonomy and the principle of respect for autonomy.Br Med J1985; 290: 1806–1808.
15.
PellegrinoE.D.Medical ethics, education, and the physician's image.JAMA1976; 235: 1043–1044.
16.
BeauchampT.L., ChildressJ.F.The principle of autonomy. In: Principles of biomedical ethics.New York: Oxford University Press,1979.
17.
PickeringG.Doctor-patient relationship: the impact of recent changes in medicine and society.Acta Med Scand1978; 204: 339–343.
18.
PickeringG.Therapeutics: art or science.JAMA1979; 242: 649–653.
19.
RatnerH.The physician's obligation: society versus person.Linacre Quart1978; 45: 106–110.
20.
EngelG.L.The care of the patient: art or science.Johns Hopkins Med J1977; 140: 222–232.
21.
KassL.R.Ethical dilemmas in the care of the ill. 1.What is the physician's service? JAMA1980; 244: 1811–1816.
22.
KassL.R.Ethical dilemmas in the care of the ill. II.What is the patient's good? JAMA1980; 244: 1946–1949.
23.
KetchumS.A., PierceC.Rights and responsibilities.J Med Philos1981; 6: 271–279.
24.
LaddJ.Medical ethics: who knows best.Lancet1980; ii: 1127–1129.
25.
LaddJ.The distinction between rights and responsibilities: a defense.Linacre Quart1982; 49: 121–142.
26.
LockwoodM.Rights.J Med Ethics1981; 7: 150–152.
27.
BowieN.E. “Role” as a moral concept in health care.J Med Philos1982; 7: 57–63.
28.
PerryC.Rights and responsibilities in medical ethics.Linacre Quart1982; 49: 111–120.
29.
NarvesonJ.Moral philosophy and suicide.Can J Psychiatry1986; 31 (2).
30.
NarvesonJ.Self-ownership and the ethics of suicide.Suicide Life Threat Behav1983; 13: 240–253.
31.
SzaszT.S.The ethics of suicide. In: WeirR.F., ed. Ethical issues in death and dying.New York: Columbia University Press, 1977.
32.
SzaszT.S.The ethics of suicide. In: BeauchampT.L., PerlinS., eds. Ethical issues in death and dying.Englewood-Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1978.
33.
ShneidmanE.S.Suicide among the gifted. In: Suicidology: contemporary developments.New York: Grune and Stratton,1976.
34.
PellegrinoE.D.Toward a reconstruction of medical morality: the primacy of the act of profession and the fact of illness.J Med Philos1979; 4: 32–56.
35.
AckermanT.F.Why doctors should intervene.Hastings Cent Rep1982; 12: 14–17.
36.
BeckA.T.Depression: causes and treatment.Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press, 1972.
37.
BeckA.T., RushA.J., ShawB.F., EmeryG.Cognitive therapy of depression.New York: The Guilford Press,1979.
38.
BrandtR.B.The morality and rationality of suicide. In: BeauchampT.L., PerlinS., eds. Ethical issues in death and dying.Englewood-Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1978.
39.
MottoJ.A.Clinical implications of moral theory regarding suicide.Suicide Life Threat Behav1983; 13: 304–312.
40.
BraffD.L., GlickI.D., GriffinP.Thought disorder and depression in psychiatric patients.Compr Psychiatry1983; 24: 57–64.
41.
SilbermanE.K., WeingartnerH., PostR.M.Thinking disorder in depression: logic and strategy in an abstract reasoning task.Arch Gen Psychiatry1983; 40: 775–780.
RobinsE., MurphyG.E., WilkinsonR.H., GassnerS., KayesJ.Some clinical considerations in the prevention of suicide based on a study of 134 successful suicides.Am J Public Health1959; 49: 888–899.
44.
RobinsE.The final months: a study of the lives of 134 persons who committed suicide.New York: Oxford University Press,1981.
45.
MilesC.P.Conditions predisposing to suicide: a review.J Nerv Ment Dis1977; 164: 231–246.
46.
MurphyG.K.Cancer and the coroner.JAMA1977; 237: 786–788.
47.
PettyF., NoyesR.Jr.Depression secondary to cancer.Biol Psychiatry1981; 16: 1203–1220.
48.
SakinofskyI.Depression and suicide in the disabled. In: BishopD.S., ed. Behavioral problems and the disabled.Malabar, Fla.: Robert E. Krieger, 1984.
49.
SakinofskyI.The family doctor and the prevention of suicide.Can Fam Physician1982; 28: 1606–1610.
50.
JacksonD.L., YoungnerS.Patient autonomy and “death with dignity”: some clinical caveats.N Engl J Med1979; 301: 404–408.
51.
BarracloughB.M.A medical approach to suicide prevention.Soc Sci Med1972; 6: 661–671.
52.
HeydD., BlochS.The ethics of suicide. In: BlochS., ChodoffP., eds. Psychiatric ethics.New York: Oxford University Press, 1981.
53.
ShneidmanE.S.Preventing suicide. In: WeirR.F., ed. Ethical issues in death and dying.New York: Columbia University Press, 1977.
54.
WhitehornJ.C.A working concept of maturity of personality.Am J Psychiatry1962; 119: 197–202.
