Two hundred and fifty-four women were followed from the second trimester of pregnancy until twelve months postpartum. Of these women, twenty-eight had had a prior therapeutic abortion and 216 women had no previous abortion. During their pregnancy and the postpartum period, the women completed a series of psychological and attitudinal measures. Analysis revealed that there were no significant differences between the two groups in terms of their demographic status, their obstetric experience or attitudes towards labour and birth. The study failed to demonstrate a relationship between anxiety during pregnancy and a prior abortion, nor were there any indications of inadequate maternal functioning.
Women who had a prior abortion scored higher on the autonomy and nurturance subscales of the Personality Research Form, and had higher levels of depressive affect in the third trimester of pregnancy and in the postpartum period.
References
1.
HodgsonJ.E. ed. Abortion and sterilization. Medical and social aspects.London: Academic Press, 1981.
2.
MeikleS., RobinsonC., BrodyH.Recent changes in the emotional reactions of therapeutic abortion applicants.Can Psychiatr Assoc J1977; 22(2): 67–70.
SelbyJ.W., CalhounL.G., VogelA.V., KingH.E.Psychology and human reproduction.New York: The Free Press, 1980.
6.
NeyP.G.Infant abortion and child abuse: cause and effect. In: MallD., WattsW.F., eds. Psychological aspects of abortion.Chicago: Chicago University Publications of America, 1979.
7.
NeyP.G.Relationship between abortion and child abuse.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24(7): 610–20.
8.
WattersW.W.Mental health consequences of abortion.Can J Psychiatry1980; 25(1): 68–73.
9.
ShustermanL.R.The psychosocial factors of the abortion experience.Psychology of Women Quarterly1976; 1(1): 79–106.
10.
BelseyE.M., GreerH.S., LalS., LewisS.C., BeardR.W.Predictive factors in emotional response to abortion: King's termination study.Social Science and Medicine1977; 11: 71–82.
11.
BrewerC.Induced abortion after feeling fetal movements: its causes and emotional consequences.J Biosoc Sci1978; 10(2): 209–16.
12.
BrackenM.B.Psychosomatic aspects of abortion: implications for counselling.J Reprod Med19(5): 265–72.
13.
DavidH.P.Abortion in psychosocial perspective.New York, N.Y.: Springer Publishing, 1978.
GreerH.S., LalS., LewisS.C., BelseyE.M., BeardR.W.Psychosocial consequences of therapeutic abortion: King's termination study 111.Br J Psychiatry1976; 74: 128.
16.
WiddicombeJ., BurnhillM.S., LandyU., SusmanF., SokolR.L.Abortion: legal, medical and social perspectives.Family Community Health1979; 2: 17–28.
17.
BlombergS.Influence of maternal distress during pregnancy on complications in pregnancy and delivery.Acta Psychiatr Scand1980; 62(5): 399–404.
18.
BlombergS.Influence of maternal distess during pregnancy on postnatal development.Acta Psychiatr Scand1980; 62(5): 405–17.
19.
KumarR., RobsonK.Previous induced abortion and antenatal depression in primiparae: preliminary report of a survey of mental health in pregnancy.Psychol Med1978; 8: 711–15.
20.
DevoreN.E.The relationship between previous elective abortions and postpartum depressive reactions.JOGN Nursing1979; 4: 237–40.
21.
FloydC.C.Pregnancy after reproductive failure.Am J Nurs1981; 11: 2050–53.
22.
Figa-TalamancaI.Abortion and mental health. In: HodgsonJ.E., ed. Abortion and sterilization.London: Academic Press, 1981.
23.
BradleyC.F.The antecedents and consequences of maternal adaptation in the postpartum period. Final report to National Health and Welfare Canada. NHRDP No: 6610–1176–46.
24.
JacksonD.N.Personality research form manual.Goshen, New York: Research Psychologists Press, 1974.
25.
LubinB.L.Adjective checklist for measurement of depression.Arch Gen Psychiatry1965; 12: 57–70.
McLeanP., HakstianA.R.Efficient questionnaire discrimination between depressed and normal populations.University of British Columbia, submitted for publication.
28.
SpielbergerC.D., GorsuchR.L., LusheneR.E.STAI manual for the state-trait anxiety inventory.Palo Alto, California: Consulting Psychologists Press, 1970.
29.
WeissmanM.M., BothwellS.Assessment of social adjustment by patient self-report.Arch Gen Psychiatry1976; 33: 1111–15.
30.
EpsteinS.Anxiety, arousal and the self-concept. In: SarasonI.G., SpielbergerC.D., eds. Stress and anxiety, Vol. 3.Washington and London: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, 1976.
31.
BradleyC.F.The effects of hospital experience on postpartum feelings and attitudes of women.Dissertation Abstracts International1977; 38(1B): 347.
32.
BradleyC., WigginsS.An evaluation of a family centred maternity program.Women and Health1983; 8(1): 35–47.
33.
CareyW.B.A simplified method for measuring infant temperament.J Pediatr1970; 77: 188–94.
34.
CareyW.B.Clinical applications of infant temperament measurements.J Pediatr1972; 81: 823–8.
35.
BayleyN.Bayley scales of infant development: birth to two years.New York: Psychological Corporation, 1969.
36.
TowellM.E., Dixon-WarrenB.C.First standard perinatal records produced in B.C. B.C.Medical Journal1978; 20(10): 303–9.
37.
MillerW.R.Psychological deficit in depression.Psychol Bull1975; 82(2): 238–60.
38.
BeckA.T.The core problem in depression: the cognitive triad.Science and Psychoanalysis1970; 17: 47–55.
39.
BeckA.T.Depression: causes and treatment.Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1972.
40.
SeligmanM.E.P.Depression and learned helplessness. In: FriedmanR.J., KatzM.M., eds. The psychology of depression: contemporary theory and research.New York: Winston-Wiley, 1975.
41.
RehmL.P.Assessment of depression. In: HersenM., BellackA.S. eds. Behavioral assessment: a practical handbook.Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1981.
42.
CoganR.Comfort during prepared childbirth as a function of parity, reported by four classes of participant observers.J Psychosom Res1975; 19: 33–7.
43.
CoganR., KlopferF.The delivery of childbirth reports: an analysis of sample bias in questionnaire returns.J Psychosom Res1974; 19: 39–42.
