The history of civil commitment procedures is reviewed, with an analysis of the origins of commitment authority. Views contrary to involuntary hospitalization are presented. The author argues for the retention of these procedures, with an emphasis upon the parens patriae approach.
References
1.
Developments in the law: civil commitment of the mentally ill.Harvard Law Review1974; 87: 1190–1406.
2.
RosenG.Madness in society — chapters in the historical sociology of mental illness.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1968: 21–138.
3.
FoucaultM.Madness and civilization — a history of insanity in the age of reason. Translated by Richard Howard.New York: Pantheon Books, 1965.
4.
JonesK.A history of the mental health services.London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1972.
5.
Theobald SirH.S.The law relating to lunacy.London: Stevens and Sons Ltd., 1924.
6.
ConollyJ.The construction and government of lunatic asylums and hospitals for the insane. First published in 1847. Reprinted with an introduction by Richard Hunter and Ida Macalpine. London: Dawsons of Pall Mall, 1968.
7.
RajAnand. Involuntary civil commitment in Ontario: the need to curtail the abuses of psychiatry.Canadian Bar Review1979; 57: 250–80.
8.
ChadoffP.The case for involuntary hospitalization of the mentally ill.Am J Psychiatry1967; 133(5): 496–501.
9.
EnnisB.J.Prisoners of psychiatry — mental patients, psychiatrist and the law.New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovitch Inc., 1972.
10.
LeppmannP.K.Involuntary committal: a medico-socio-legal problem.Legal Medical Quarterly1978; 2(2): 276–7.
11.
MillerK.S.Managing madness — the case against civil commitment.New York: The Free Press, 1976.
12.
RozovskyL.Civil commitment of the mentally ill.Dimensions in Health Service1978; Nov.: 37–8.
13.
SharpeG.The Ontario mental health act, 1978: a legal perspective.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24(6): 517–9.
14.
SzaszT.S.Ideology and insanity — essays on the psychiatric dehumanization of man. Anchor Books, New York: Doubleday and Co., 1970.
15.
ToewsJ.. Commitment of the mentally ill — current issues.Can J Psychiatry1980: 25(8): 611–8.
WeisstubD.N.The theoretical relationship between law and psychiatry. In: DavidN.Weistubb, ed. Law and psychiatry — proceedings of an international symposium.Toronto: Pergamon Press, 1978.
18.
Civil commitment of the mentally ill: theories and procedures.Harvard Law Review1966; 79: 1288–98.
19.
MillerA.The Ontario mental health act, 1978: a comment on its application.Can J Psychiatry1979; 24(6): 515–6.
DandurandY.Criminality is not a mental health problem.Canada's Mental Health1977; 25(2): 18–20.
24.
PfohlS.J.Predicting dangerousness — the social construction of psychiatric reality.Lexington Books, Toronto: D.C. Health and Company, 1978.
25.
PfohlS.J.From whom will we be protected? comparative approaches to the assessment of dangerousness.International Journal of Law and Psychiatry1979; 2: 55–78.
26.
McCormickW.O.Involuntary commitment in Ontario: some barriers to the provision of proper care.Can Med Assoc J1981; 124: 715–7.
27.
PageS.Civil commitment: operational definition of new criteria.Can J Psychiatry1981; 26(6): 419–20.
28.
MechanicD.Mental health and social policy, ed. 2. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1980, Chap. 12.
29.
StoneA.Mental health and the law: a system in transition.NIMH, Rockville, Maryland, 1975.
30.
Mind's evidence to the royal commission on the NHS with regard to services for mentally ill people (1978). Cited in Gostin, Larry O. The merger of incompetency and certification: the illustration of unauthorized medical contact in the psychiatric context.International Journal of Law and Psychiatry1979; (2): 127–67.
31.
MorseS.A preference for liberty: the case against involuntary commitment of the mentally disordered. Presented at the sixth International Symposium on law and psychiatry. Charlottesville, VA., June 1981. In press.
32.
PageS.Power, professionals and arguments against civil commitment.Professional Psychology1975; Nov.: 381–93.
33.
CameronD.Tim Crawford meets the mind police.Saturday Night1972; Nov.: 15–20.
34.
MillJ.S.On liberty (Introductory Chapter). In: ChambersRobert, KingCarlyle ed. A book of essays.Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1963.
35.
CooperD.Psychiatry and anti-psychiatry.London: Tavistock, 1967.
36.
LaingR.D.The politics of experience.London: Penguin, 1967.
37.
SzaszT.The myth of mental illness: foundations of a theory of personal conduct.New York: Harper and Row, 1961.
38.
ScheffT.J.Schizophrenia as ideology.Schizophr Bull1970; 2: 15–9. Reprinted in: Phil Brown, ed. Radical Psychology. New York: Harper and Row, 1973.
SzaszT.The myth of mental illness.Am Psychol1960; 15: 113–8. Reprinted in: Phil Broiwn, ed. Radical Psychology. New York: Harper and Row, 1973.
41.
Warren CarolA.B.Involuntary commitment for mental disorder: the application of California's Lanterman-Petris-Short act.Law and Society1977; Spring: 629–49.
42.
MonahanJ.Empirical analysis of civil commitment: critique and comment.Law and Society1977; Spring: 619–28.
43.
StoneA.A.Comment.Am J Psychiatry1978; 1: 61–3.
44.
SchifferM.Mental disorder and the criminal trial process.Toronto: Butterworth and Co., 1978.
45.
HarveyD.A.Cameron. The law of habeas corpus in Canada.Toronto: Butterworth, 1974.
46.
AbramsonM.F.The criminalization of mentally disordered behavior: possible side-effect of a new mental health law.Hosp Community Psychiatry1972; 23(4): 101–5.
47.
From back wards to back streets.A documentary for television, produced by WNET — t.v., Channel 13, 365 West 58th Street, New York, N.Y.
48.
StoneA.A.Recent mental health litigation: a critical perspective.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134(3): 273–8.
49.
HidayV.A.Reformed commitment procedures: an empirical study in the courtroom.Law and Society1977; Spring: 651–66.
50.
JonesK.The limitations of the legal approach to mental health.International Journal of Law and Psychiatry1980; 3: 1–15.
51.
GostinL.O.The merger of incompetency and certification: the illustration of unauthorized medical contact in the psychiatric context, internationalJournal of Law and Psychiatry1969; 2: 127–67.
52.
MeiselA.. Toward a model of the legal doctrine of informed consent.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134(3): 285–9.
53.
RothL.H.. Tests of incompetency to consent to treatment.Am J Psychiatry1977; 134(3): 279–84.
54.
ToewsJ.. Patients’ reactions to their commitment.Can J Psychiatry1981; 26(4): 251–4.
55.
RileyR., RichmanA.Involuntary hospitalization to mental and psychiatric hospitals and to psychiatric units of general hospitals, Canada, 1970–1978. Presented at annual meeting of the Canadian Psychiatric Association, September 23, 1981.
