The survey of patient satisfaction with the mental health services provided is recommended but involves a methodological dilemma. Concerns include a definition problem, the delineation of a representative sample, the selection of a survey technique and the type of questions to be used. A literature review and the authors’ own experience with the process are presented.
The investigation of patient satisfaction while, as yet, limited in the critical information it can provide for the evaluation of services, will help pinpoint areas where the most patient dissatisfaction exists. The process can also be useful therapeutically, but patient satisfaction, although an important outcome measure, is not systematically related to other measures of treatment success. Methodological suggestions to improve the validity of the data gathered conclude the paper.
References
1.
GordonD., AlexanderD.A., DietzanJ.The psychiatric patient: a voice to be heard.Br J Psychiatry1979; 135: 115–21.
2.
HartT., BassettL.Measuring consumer satisfaction in a mental health center.Hosp Community Psychiatry1975; 26: 512–5.
3.
McPheeC.B., ZusmanJ., JossR.H.Measurement of patient satisfaction: a survey of practices in community mental health centres.Compr Psychiatry1975; 16: 399–404.
4.
KoltuvM., AhmedM.B., MeyerM.A study of outpatient satisfaction with mental health center services.Hosp Community Psychiatry1978; 29: 179–81.
5.
Sarwer-FonerG.J.On the mechanism of action of neuroleptic drugs: a theoretical psychodynamic explanation.Recent Adv Biol Psychiatry1963; 6: 217–32.
6.
Van PuttenT., MayP.R.A.Subjective response as a predictor of outcome in pharmacotherapy.Arch Gen Psychiatry1978; 35: 477–80.
7.
FreemanC.P.L., KendellR.E.ECT: I. Patients’ experiences and attitudes.Br J Psychiatry1980; 137: 8–16.
8.
ToewsJ., el-GuebalyN., LeckieA.Patients’ reactions to their commitment.Can J Psychiatry1981; 26: 251–4.
LlewelynS.P., HumeW.I.The patient's view of therapy.Br J Med Psychol1979; 52: 29–35.
11.
EisenthalS., LazareA.Evaluation of the initial interview in a walk-in clinic.The patient's perspective on a “customer approach.” J Nerv Ment Dis1976; 162: 169–76.
12.
EderD., KukulskiS.A scale for measuring patient satisfaction with hospital services.Hosp Community Psychiatry1975; 26: 15–6.
13.
SnellingE., WalkerF.Patient satisfaction with facilities at an acute admission psychiatric unit.NZ Med J1978; 87: 94–7.
14.
JansenD.G., AldrichM.W.State hospital psychiatric patients evaluate their treatment teams.Hosp Community Psychiatry1973; 24: 768–70.
15.
KastelerJ., KaneR.L., OlsenD.M., ThetfordC.Issues underlying prevalence of “doctor-shopping” behaviour.J Health Soc Behav1976; 17: 328–39.
16.
FrancisV., KorschB.M., MorrisM.J.Gaps in doctor-patient communication. Patient's response to medical advice.N Engl J Med1969; 280: 535–40.
17.
BertelsenK., HarrisM.R.Citizen participation in the development of a community mental health center.Hosp Community Psychiatry1963; 24: 553–6
18.
HoflingC.K.Consumerism: is it an appropriate term in psychiatry?Hosp Community Psychiatry1973; 24: 345.
19.
Webster's New World Dictionary. Second College Edition. Toronto: Nelson, Foster and Scott Ltd., 1970.
20.
EdwardsD.W., YarvisR.M., MuellerD.P., LangsleyD.G.Does patient satisfaction correlate with success?Hosp Community Psychiatry1978; 29: 188–90.
21.
FeeneyD.J.Jr, DrangerP.Alcoholics view group therapy process and goals.J Stud Alcohol1976; 37: 611–8.
22.
FreemanC.P.L., WeeksD., KendellR.E.ECT: II. Patients who complain.Br J Psychiatry1980; 137: 17–25.
SydiahaD., StewartA., LafaveH.G.A study of mail questionnaire technique with discharged psychiatric patients.Int J Soc Psychiatry1968; 14: 135–40.
25.
JusticeB., McBeeG.A client satisfaction survey as one element in evaluation.Community Ment Health J1978; 14: 248–52.
26.
ObitzF.W.Alcoholics’ perceptions of selected counselling techniques.Br J Addict1975; 70: 187–91.
27.
ShannonP.Coercion and compulsory hospitalization. Some patient's attitudes.Med J Aust1976; 2: 798–800.
28.
JohnsonB., AanesD.Patients’ use of a full-time patient advocate office in a state hospital.Hosp Community Psychiatry1974; 25: 445–8.
29.
AllenP.A bill of rights for citizens using outpatient mental health services. In: Lamb HR and associates. Community survival for long-term patients.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1976: 147–70.
30.
ChamberlinJ.On our own. Patient-controlled alternatives to the mental health system.New York: Hawthorn Books, Inc., 1978: 236.
31.
GilliganJ.F., WildermanR.An economical rural mental health consumer satisfaction evaluation.Community Ment Health1977; 13: 31–6.
32.
FrankR., SalzrnanK., FergusE.Correlates of consumer satisfaction with outpatient therapy assessed by postcards.Community Ment Health J1977; 13: 37–45.
33.
HarperD.W., Elliott-HarperC., WeinermanR.Patient and therapist opinions concerning psychiatric crisis.Journal of Psychiatric Treatment and Evaluation1982; 4: 239–41.
34.
EdelsonR.I., PaulG.L.Some problems in the use of “attitude” and “atmosphere” scores as indicators of staff effectiveness in institutional treatment.J Nerv Ment Dis1976; 162: 248–57.
35.
PallisD.J.Psychiatric treatment: the question of attitudes.Int J Soc Psychiatry1978; 24: 281–6.
