This paper considers the impact of a state medical insurance system on the structure of psychiatric services. The tendency of the upper socioeconomic classes to use private practitioners, and the lower classes to use public clinics, is examined before and after the imposition of the medical insurance system in Quebec in 1970. Data from one public clinic reveal a significant rise in the socioeconomic status of patients after Medicare. Alternative interpretations for the change in the clinic population are explored.
References
1.
BadgleyR.F., HetheringtonR.W., MathewsV.L.: The impact of Medicare in Wheatville.Can J Public Health58: 101–107, 1967.
2.
BeckR.G.: Economic class and access to physician services under public medical care insurance.Int J Health Serv3: 341–355, 1973.
3.
CampbellD.T., StanleyJ.C.: Experimental and Quasi-experimental Designs for Research.Chicago: Rand McNally, 1966.
4.
EatonW.W., SteinS.: “A simple psychiatric case register: Some problems with comprehensive data collection and a solution for the General Hospital”. Submitted for publication, 1974.
5.
EllenbergerH.F.: The Discovery of the Unconscious: The history and evolution of dynamic psychiatry.New York: Basic Books, 1970.
6.
EnterlineP.E., McDonaldJ.C., McDonaldA.: Effects of “free” medical care on medical practice — the Quebec experience.N Engl J Med288: 1152–1155, 1973.
7.
FoucaultM.: Madness and Civilization, A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason.New York: Random House, 1973.
8.
HollingsheadA.B., RedlichF.C.: Social Class and Mental Illness.New York: Wiley & Son, 1958.
9.
HornstraR.K., UdellB.: Use of psychiatric services and insurance coverage.Hosp Community Psychiatry24: 90–93, 1973.
10.
KohnR., RadivsS.: Two roads to health care: U.S. and Canadian policies, 1945–1975.Med Care12: 189–196, 1974.
11.
McDonaldA.D., McDonaldJ.C., SteinmetzN., EnterlineP.E., SalterV.: Physician service in Montreal before Universal Health Insurance.Med. Care11: 269–285, 1973.
12.
ParisJ.: Psychiatric practice in Canada pre-and post-Medicare.Can Med Assoc J109: 469–472, 1973.
13.
ReedL.S., MyersE.S., SchneidermandelP.L.: Health Insurance and Psychiatric Care: Utilization and Cost.Washington, D.C: American Psychiatric Association,1972.
14.
ScharfsteinA., TaubeC.A., GoldbergI.: Private psychiatry and accountability: A response to the APA Task Force Report on private practice.Am J Psychiatry132: 43–51, 1975.
