Fifty outpatients in a ‘schizophrenia clinic’ were examined, and sixteen were found to be suffering from periodic affective disorders. Nine of these were given lithium carbonate, and eight responded well. Case histories illustrate three separate reasons for incorrect diagnosis. Examination of extensive old clinical notes of five of these patients suggests that the problems of diagnosis which have been described in the literature in the past, continue to represent obstacles to correct diagnosis. Suggestions for improvement are offered.
References
1.
AbramsR., TaylorM.A., GaztanagaP.: Manic-depressive illness and paranoid schizophrenia.Arch. Gen. Psychiatry,31: 640–642, 1974.
2.
BaastrupP.C., PoulsenJ.C., SchouM., ThomsenK., AmdiserA.: Prophylactic lithium: Double-blind discontinuation in manic-depressive and recurrent depressive disorders.Lancet, 2: 326–330, 1970.
3.
CarpenterT.Jr., StraussJ.S., MulehS.: Are there pathognomonic symptoms in schizophrenia?Arch. Gen. Psychiatry,28: 847–852, 1973.
4.
ClaghornJ.L., Kinross-WrightJ.: Reduction in hospitalization of schizophrenics.Am. J. Psychiatry,128: 344–347, 1971.
El-GuebalyN.: Manic-depressive psychosis and drug abuse.Can. Psychiatr. Assoc. J.,20: 595–598, 1975.
7.
KendellR.E., CooperJ.E., GourlayA.J., CopelandJ.R.M., SharpeL., GurlandB.J.: Diagnostic criteria of American and British psychiatrists.Arch. Gen. Psychiatry,25: 123–130, 1971.
8.
OllenrenshawD.P.: The classification of the functional psychoses.Br. J. Psychiatry,122: 517–530, 1973.
9.
QuitkinF.M., KleinD.F.: Follow-up of treatment failure. Psychosis and character disorder.Am. J. Psychiatry,124: 499–505, 1967.
10.
SchorerC.E.: Mistakes in the diagnosis of schizophrenia.Am. J. Psychiatry,124: 1057–1062, 1968.
11.
ShopsinB., GershonS., ThompsonH., CollinsP.: Psychoactive drugs in mania.Arch. Gen. Psychiatry,32: 34–42, 1975.
12.
SimonR.J., FleissJ.L., GurlandB.J., StillerP.R., SharpeL.: Depression and schizophrenia in hospitalized black and white mental patients.Arch. Gen. Psychiatry,28: 509–512, 1973.
13.
TimburyG.C., MowbrayR.M.: The diagnosis of schizophrenia by Scottish psychiatrists.Br. J. Psychiatry,110: 174–180, 1964.
14.
Van PuttenT., SandersD.G.: Lithium in treatment failures.J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.,161: 255–264, 1975.