A review of the literature on the efficacy of electrosleep therapy is presented. The vast majority of non-double-blind based reports are very optimistic about its effectiveness, but the inferences from the double-blind based research are much less positive. It is concluded that the efficacy of electrosleep therapy has not yet been satisfactorily demonstrated.
References
1.
AchteK., KaukoK., SeppalaK.: On electrosleep therapy.Psychiatr. Q.42: 17–27, 1968.
2.
AstrupC.: A follow-up study of electrosleep.Biol. Psychiatry8: 115–117, 1974.
3.
BanschikovV. M.: Present Status of Electrosleep in the USSR. In: Electrotherapeutic Sleep and Electroanesthesia. Eds. WagenederF. M., and SchuySt.Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam,1966.
4.
ChumakovaL. T., KirillovaZ. A.: In: Electrosleep as an Effective Treatment for Nervous and Psychological Disorders. Eds. WagenederF. M., and SchuySt.Excerpta Medica Foundation. Amsterdam, 1966.
5.
CostainR., RedfearnJ. W. T., LippoldO.C.J.: A controlled trial of the therapeutic effects of polarization of the brain in depressive illness.Br. J. Psychiatry110: 786–799, 1964.
6.
DodgeC. H.: Electrosleep, electroanesthesia, and electroneural diagnostics and therapeutics.Foreign Sci, Bull.3: 46–64, 1967.
HearstE. D., CloningerC. R., CrewsE. L., CadoretR. J.: Electrosleep therapy: a double-blind trial.Arch. Gen. Psychiatry30: 463–466, 1974.
13.
IwanovskyA.: Report of international progress in cerebral electrotherapy (electrosleep) and electroanesthesia.Foreign Sci. Bull.5: 10: 15–40, 1969.
14.
IwanovskyA., DodgeC. H.: Electrosleep and electroanesthesia — theory and clinical experience.Foreign Sci. Bull.5: 10: 15–40, 1969.
15.
KoeglerR. R., HicksS. M., RogersL., BargerJ. H.: A Preliminary Study of the Use of Electrosleep in Clinical Psychiatry in the Nervous System and Electric Currents. Edited by WulfsohmN. L., and SancesA., New York and London, Plenum Press, 1970.
16.
KulikovaE. L.: Electrosleep in the Combined Treatment of Sleep Disturbances in Patients with Neuroses and with Traumatic and Vascular Diseases of the Brain.WagenederF. M., SchuySt., NussmullerJ., Clutton-BrockJ., and WeaverB. M. Q. Eds.: Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam,1966.
17.
LippoldO. C. J., RedfearnJ. W. T.: Mental changes resulting from the passage of small direct currents through the human brain.Br. J. Psychiatry110: 768–772, 1974.
MillerE. C., MathasJ. L.: The use and effectiveness of electrosleep in the treatment of some common psychiatric problems.Am. J. Psychiatry122: 460–462, 1965.
20.
MooreJ. A., MellorC. S., StandageK. F., StrongH.: A double-blind study of electrosleep for anxiety and insomnia.Biol. Psychiatry, 10: 59–63, 1975.
21.
PattersonA. S., MilliganW. L.: Electronarcosis, a new treatment for schizophrenia.Lancet2: 198–201, 1947.
22.
RedfearnJ. W. T., LippoldO. C. J., CostainR.: A preliminary account of the clinical effects of polarizating the brain in certain psychiatric disorders.Br. J. Psychiatry110: 733–785, 1964.
23.
RosenthalS. H.: A qualitative description of electrosleep experience.Nerv. Syst. Electr. Curr.2: 153–155, 1971.
RosenthalS. H., WulfsohnN. L.: Studies of electrosleep with active and simulated treatment.Curr. Ther. Res.12: 126–130, 1970.
31.
SergeevG. V.: The Use of Electrosleep in Clinical Medicine.WagenederF. M., SchuySt., NussmullerJ., Clutton-BrockJ., and WeaverB. M. Q. Eds. Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam, 1966.
32.
SergeevG. V.: Electrosleep as a method of neurotrophic therapy of patients with hypertensive disease.Am. Heart J.66: 138–139, 1963.
33.
SorokinaE. I.: Electrosleep Therapy in Neurogenic Functional Cardiovascular Disorders.WagenederF. M., SchuySt., NussmullerJ., Clutton-BrockJ., and WeaverB. M. Q. Eds. Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam, 1966.
34.
StrausB., ElkindA., BodianC. A.: Electrical induction of sleep.Am. J. Med. Sci.248: 514–520, 1964.
35.
StudnisynaL. A.Electrosleep in the Treatment of Some Cardiovascular Diseases.WagenederF. M., SchuySt., NussmullerJ., Clutton-BrockJ., and WeaverB. M. Q., Eds. Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam, 1966.
36.
TauaevaV. A.: Treatment of Eczema and Neurodermatitis by Electrosleep.WagenederF. M., SchuySt., NussmullerJ., Clutton-BrockJ., and WeaverB. M. Q., Eds. Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam, 1966.
37.
TietzE. B., ThompsonG. M., Van HarreveldA., WiersmaC. A. G.: Electronarcosis, its application and therapeutic effect in schizophrenia.J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.103: 144–163, 1946.
38.
TomsovicM., EdwardsR. V.: Cerebral electrotherapy for tension related symptoms in alcoholics.Q. J. Stud. Alcohol.34: 1352–1355, 1973.
39.
WagenederF. M.: The application of electrosleep in people of advanced age.Am. J. Proctol.20: 351–358, 1969.
40.
WagenederF. M., SchuySt.: Electrotherapeutic Sleep and Electroanesthesia. Proceedings of the First International Symposium, Graz, Austria. Amsterdam, Excerpta Medica, September, 1966.
41.
WagenederF. M., SchuySt.: Electrotherapeutic Sleep and Electroanesthesia. Proceedings of the Sound International Symposium, Graz, Austria. Amsterdam, Excerpta Medica, September, 1970.
42.
WagenederF. M., St. SchuyF., KissT. I., SchollH.: Electrosleep Therapy in the Treatment of Insomnia.Excerpta Medica Foundation, Amsterdam, 1966.
43.
WagenederF. M., IwanovskyA., DodgeC. H.: Electrosleep (cerebral electrotherapy) and electroanesthesia — The international effort at evaluation.Foreign Sci. Bull.5: 1–104, 1969.
44.
WeissM. F.: The treatment of insomnia through the use of electrosleep: and EEG study.J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.157: 108–120, 1973.
45.
WilliamsR. L., WebbW. B.: Sleep Therapy, Springfield, Illinois, Charles C. Thomas, 1966.
