Death by suicide is widely held as an undesirable outcome. Most Western countries place emphasis on patient autonomy, a concept of controversy in relation to suicide. This paper explores the tensions between patients' rights and many societies' overarching desire to prevent suicide, while clarifying the relations between mental disorders, mental capacity, and rational suicide.
Methods:
A literature search was conducted using search terms of suicide and ethics in the PubMed and LexisNexis Academic databases. Article titles and abstracts were reviewed and deemed relevant if the paper addressed topics of rational suicide, patient autonomy or rights, or responsibility for life. Further articles were found from reference lists and by suggestion from preliminary reviewers of this paper.
Results:
Suicidal behaviour in a person cannot be reliably predicted, yet various associations and organizations have developed standards of care for managing patients exhibiting suicidal behaviour. The responsibility for preventing suicide tends to be placed on the treating clinician. In cases where a person is capable of making treatment decisions—uninfluenced by any mental disorder—there is growing interest in the concept of rational suicide.
Conclusions:
There is much debate about whether suicide can ever be rational. Designating suicide as an undesirable event that should never occur raises the debate of who is responsible for one's life and runs the risk of erroneously attributing blame for suicide. While upholding patient rights of autonomy in psychiatric care is laudable, cases of suicidality warrant a delicate consideration of clinical judgment, duty of care, and legal obligations.
PrabhakarDAnziaJMBalonR, “Collateral damages”: Preparing residents for coping with patient suicide. Acad Psychiatry. 2013 May 7. doi: 10.1176/appi.ap.11060110. Epub ahead of print.
2.
ChemtobCMHamadaRSBauerGB, Patient suicide: Frequency and impact on psychiatrists. Am J Psychiatry. 1988;145:224–228.
3.
RuskinRSakinofskyIBagbyRM, Impact of patient suicide on psychiatrists and psychiatric trainees. Acad Psychiatry. 2004;28(2):104–110.
4.
WettsteinRM. Psychiatric malpractice. Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1989.
5.
BongarBMarisRWBermanAL, Outpatient standards of care and the suicidal patient. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1992;22(4):453–478.
6.
DoyalLSheatherJ.Mental health legislation should respect decision making capacity. BMJ. 2005;331:1467–1469.
7.
KhanMMMianAI. The one truly serious philosophical problem: Ethical aspects of suicide. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2010;22(3):288–293.
8.
MisharaBLWeisstubDN. Ethical and legal issues in suicide research. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2005;28(1):23–41.
9.
KantI.Second section: Transition from popular moral philosophy to the metaphysics of morals. In: AbbottJK, editor. Fundamental principles of the metaphysics of morals. New York (NY): Liberal Art Press; 1949.
10.
BluckRS, editor. Plato's Phaedo. Indianapolis (IN): Bobbs-Merrill; 1955.
11.
Singapore Penal Code. Chapter XVI: Offences affecting the human body, s309, (1871, rev ed2008).
12.
Indian Penal Code, Act 45 of 1860, Chapter XVI: Of offenses affecting the human body, s309 (1860).
13.
Parliament of Canada. Of life and death—final report. Appendix D: Chronology of major Canadian development and events [Internet].Ottawa (ON): Parliament of Canada; 1995 [cited 2013 Aug 16]. Available from: http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/sen/committee/351/euth/rep/lad-a2-e.htm.
14.
CutcliffeJRLinksPS. Whose life is it anyway? An exploration of five contemporary ethical issues that pertain to the psychiatric nursing care of the person who is suicidal: Part one. Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2008;17(4):236–245.
15.
BeauchampTChildressJ.Principles of bio-medical ethics. 7th ed.Oxford (GB): Oxford University Press; 2012.
16.
SzaszT.Fatal freedom: The ethics and politics of suicide. Westport (CT): Praeger; 1999.
17.
MeyerRGLandisERHaysJR. Law for the psychotherapist. New York (NY): Norton; 1988.
18.
TsaoCILaydeJB. A basic review of psychiatric medical malpractice law in the United States. Compr Psychiatry. 2007;48(4):309–312.
19.
PackmanWPennutoTBongarB, Legal issues of professional negligence in suicide cases. Behav Sci Law. 2004;22(5):697–713.
20.
SimonRI. Concise guide to clinical psychiatry and the law. Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1988.
21.
BongarBMarisRWBermanAL, Inpatient standards of care and the suicidal patient. Part I: General clinical formulations and legal considerations. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1993;23(3):245–256.
22.
ReesalRLamR, CANMAT Depression Working Group. Clinical guidelines for the treatment of depressive disorders. II. Principles of managment. Can J Psychiatry. 2001;46(Suppl 1):21S–28S.
23.
BlackHC. Black's law dictionary. Abridged 6th ed.St Paul (MN): West; 1979. Standard of care.
24.
RobertsonJD. Psychiatric malpractice: Liability of mental health professionals. New York (NY): Wiley; 1988.
25.
SchutzBM. Legal liability in psychotherapy. San Francisco (CA): Jossey-Bass; 1982.
26.
LitmanRE. Hospital suicides: Lawsuits and standards. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1982;12(4):212–220.
27.
MarisRW. Forensic suicidology: Litigation of suicide cases and equivocal deaths. In: BongarB, editor. Suicide: Guidelines for assessment, management and treatment. New York (NY): Oxford University Press; 1992. p 235–252.
28.
Winger v. Franciscan Medical Centre, 701N.E.2d 813. Ill. App. Ct. 3rd Dist; 1998.
29.
VandeCreekLKnappSHerzogC.Malpractice risks in the treatment of dangerous patients. Psychotherapy. 1987;24:145–153.
30.
Bellah v. Greenson. 146 Cal Rptr: 81 Cal.App.3d 614; 1978. p. 535.
Canadian Medical Protective Association. Forseeability: What is expected of a physician?Ottawa (ON): Canadian Medical Protective Association; 2009.
33.
ShneidmanES. Definition of suicide. New York (NY): Wiley-Interscience; 1985.
34.
KhuriRAkiskalH.Suicide prevention: The necessity of treating contributory psychiatric disorders. Psychiatr Clin North Am. 1983;6(1):193–207.
35.
ShneidmanES. Psychotherapy with suicidal patients. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1981;11(4):341–348.
36.
BlumenthalSJKupferDJ. Suicide over the life-cycle. Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Press; 1990.
37.
CholbiM.Tonkens on the irrationality of the suicidally mentally ill. J Appl Philos. 2009;26(1):102–106.
38.
Thomson West Staff, editors. Proximate cause, sec 436–438. 57A Am Jur 2d.St Paul (MN): Thomson West; 2004.
39.
PerrIN. Legal aspects of suicide. In: HankoffLDEinsidlerB, editors. Suicide: Theory and clinical aspects. Littleton (MA): PSG Publishing; 1979. p 91–100.
40.
LindeP.Danger to self: On the front line with an ER psychiatrist. Berkeley (CA): University of California Press; 2010.
41.
HewittJ.Schizophrenia, mental capacity, and rational suicide. Theor Med Bioeth. 2010;31(1):63–77.
42.
MahlerB.Delusions: Contemporary etiological hypotheses. Psychiatr Ann. 1992;22:260–268.
43.
CulverCMGertB.Philosophy in medicine: Conceptual and ethical issues in medicine and psychiatry. New York (NY): Oxford University Press; 1982.
44.
FrankfurtHG. Freedom of will and the concept of a person. J Philos. 1971;68(1):5–20.
45.
WerthJJrGordonJ.Rational suicide? Implications for mental health professionals. Washington (DC): Taylor Francis; 1996.
CameronS.Learning from Amy: A remarkable patient provokes anquished debate about rationality, autonomy, and the right to die. CMAJ. 1997;156(2):229–231.
48.
CameronSWatlerCLGervaisL.Lessons from Amy [letters and response]. CMAJ. 1997;157(1):13.
49.
RobinsE.The final months: A study of the lives of 134 persons who committed suicide.New York (NY): Oxford University Press; 1980.
50.
American Psychiatric Association (APA). Practice guidelines for the treatment of psychiatric disorders: Compendium. Treatment of patients with suicidal behaviours. Arlington (VA): APA; 2003.
51.
SilvermanMMBermanALBongarB, Inpatient standards of care and the suicidal patient. Part II: An integration with clinical risk management. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1994;24(2):152–169.
52.
BongarBGreaneySA. Essential clinical and legal issues when working with the suicidal patient. Death Stud. 1994;18(5):529–548.
53.
WerthJLJr., When is a mental health professional competent to assess a person's decision to hasten death?Ethics Behav. 1999;9:141–157.
54.
WerthJLJrHoldwickDJ. A primer on rational suicide and other forms of hastened death. Counsel Psychol. 2000;25(4):511–539.
55.
WerthJLJr., Mental health professionals and assisted death: Perceived ethical obligations and proposed guidelines for practice. Ethics Behav. 1999;9(2):159–183.
56.
WhiteJ.Suicide-related research in Canada: A descriptive overview. Montreal (QC): Public Health Agency of Canada; 2003.
57.
Government of Canada. Federal Framework for Suicide Prevention Act, s.c. 2012, c. 30, (Dec 14, 2012).
58.
The Joint Commission. Hospital National Patient Safety Goals.Oakbrook Terrace (IL): The Joint Commission; 2013.
59.
National Quality Forum. Serious reportable events in healthcare: 2006 update.Washington (DC): National Quality Forum; 2007.
60.
WerthJJrGordonJ.Helping at the end of life: Mental health professionals and hastened death. Innovations clinical practice: A sourcebook.Sarasota (FL): Professional Resource Press; 1998. p 385–398.
61.
ShepherdL.Asking too much: Autonomy and responsibility at the end of life. J Contemp Health Law Policy. 2009;26(1):72–81.
62.
CameronSDunnR.Touched and troubled by Amy [letters and response]. CMAJ. 1997;156(8):1116.
63.
NordenfeltL.Rationality and compulsion. Oxford (GB): Oxford University Press; 2007.
64.
VandeCreekLKnappS.Malpractice risks with suicidal patients. Psychotherapy. 1983;20:274–280.
65.
LeemanCP. Distinguishing among irrational suicide and other forms of hastened death: Implications for clinical practice. Psychosomatics. 2009;50(3):185–191.
66.
PokornyAD. Prediction of suicide in psychiatric patients: Report of a prospective study. In: ManRWBermanALMaltsbergerJT, editors. Assessment and prediction of suicide. New York (NY): Guilford Press; 1992. p 105–129.
67.
GutheilTG. Argument for the defendant-expert opinion: Death in hindsight. In: SimonRI, editor. Review of clinical psychiatry and the law. Washington (DC): American Psychiatric Association; 1990. p 335–339.
68.
VentegodtSMerrickJ.Suicide from a holistic point of view. Scientific WorldJourna1. 2005;5:759–766.
MarisRBermanAMaltsbergerJ.Summary and conclusions: What have we learned about suicide assessment and prediction? In: MarisRWBermanALMaltsbergerJT, editors. Assessment and prediction of suicide. New York (NY): Guilford Press; 1992. p 640–672.
71.
HogeSAppelbaumP.Legal issues in outpatient psychiatry. In: LazareA, editor. Outpatient psychiatry. Baltimore (MD): Williams & Wilkins; 1989. p 605–621.
