Academics strive for citations, but there has been little work done to identify the determinants of citations, primarily due to a lack of usable data. This paper uses new data to confirm the intuition that reputation, documented research, collaboration, and signalling are important. However, the results shed new light on (and refute) some widely held conceptions about the effects of self-citation, author experience, editor biases, and gender equality.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Economic Association. Directory of Members, 1974–85.
2.
ArchibaldRobertB.DavidH. Finifter. “Multivariate Citations Functions and Journal Rankings”. Eastern Economic Journal. Vol. 16 (2), 1990. p 151–158.
3.
→ BaumolWilliamJ.“On Taxation and the Control of Externalities”. American Economic Review. Vol 62 (3), 1972. p. 307–322.
4.
→ BrownLawrenceD.JohnC. Gardner. “Using Citation Analysis to Assess the Impact of Journals and Articles on Contemporary Accounting Research”. Journal of Accounting Research. Vol 23 (1), 1985. p. 84–109.
5.
→ DiamondArthurM.Jr.“What is a citation worth?”Journal of Human Resources. Vol 21 (2), 1986. p. 200–215.
6.
GoffBrianL.WilliamF. ShughartIIIRobertD. TollisonStephenB. Pociask. “The Incentive to Cite”. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics. Vol 143 (3), 1987. p. 467–476.
7.
→ GordonMichaelE.JuliaE. Purvis. “Journal Publication Records as a Measure of Research Performance in Industrial Relations”. Industrial and Labor Relations Review. Vol 45 (1), 1991. p. 194–201.
8.
→ GrilichesZvi. “Issues in assessing the contribution of research and development to productivity growth”. Bell Journal of Economics. Vol 10 (1), 1979. p. 92–116.
9.
HeckLouisJeanPeterA. Zaleski. “Trends in Economic Journal Literature 1969–89”. Atlantic Economic Journal. Vol. 19 (4), 1991. p. 27–32.
10.
HsiaoCheng. Analysis of Panel Data. Cambridge University Press, 1986.
11.
→ JaffeAdamB.“Technological Opportunity and Spillovers of R + D: Evidence from Firms' Patents, Profits and Market Value”. American Economic Review. Vol 76 (5), 1986. p. 984–1001.
12.
→ JaffeAdamB.“Real Effects of Academic Research”. American Economic Review. Vol 79 (5), 1989. p. 957–970.
13.
→ JaffeAdamB.TrajtenbergManuelHendersonRebecca. “Geographic Localization of Knowledge Spillovers as evidenced by Patent Citations”. Quarterly Journal of Economics. Vol 108 (3), 1993. p. 577–598.
14.
→ LabandDavidN.“Is there value-added from the review process in economics? Preliminary evidence from authors”. Quarterly Journal of Economics. Vol 105 (2), 1990. p. 341–352.
15.
→ LabandDavidN.MichaelJ. Piette. “Favouritism versus Search for Good Papers: Empirical Evidence Regarding the Behavior of Journal Editors”. Journal of Political Economy. Vol 102 (1), 1994. p. 194–203.
16.
LabandDavidN.JohnP. Sophocleus. “The Determinants of Article Popularity: Preliminary Results”. Atlantic Economic Journal. Vol 13 (4), 1985. p. 80.
17.
→ LevinSharonG.PaulaE. Stephen. “Researcl Productivity over the Life Cycle: Evidence for Academic Scientists”. American Economic Review. Vol 81 (1), 1991. p. 114–132.
18.
→ LiebowitzS. J.“Copying and Indirect Appropriability: Photocopying of Journals”. Journal of Political Economy. Vol 93 (5), 1985. p. 945–957.
19.
→ LiebowitzS. J.PalmerJ. P., “Assessing the Relative Impacts of Economics Journals”. Journal of Economic Literature. Vol 22 (1), 1984. p. 77–88.
20.
→ LovellMichaelC.“The Production of Economic Literature: An Economic Interpretation”. Journal of Economic Literature. Vol 11 (1), 1973. p. 27–55.
21.
→ McDowellJohnMelvinMichael. “The Determinants of Co-Authorship: An Analysis of the Economics Literature”. Review of Economics and Statistics. Vol 65 (1), 1983. p 155–160.
22.
→ QuandtRichardE.“Some Quantitative Aspects of the Economic Journal Literature”. Journal of Political Economy. Vol 84 (4), 1976. p. 741–755.
23.
→ SauerRaymondD.“Estimates of the Returns to Quality and Coauthorship in Economic Academia”. Journal of Political Economy. Vol 96 (4), 1988, p. 855–866.
24.
StrathmanJamesG.“Analysis of Theoretical, Methodological and Empirical Research in the Journal of Regional Science”. Journal of Regional Science. Vol 32 (4), 1992. p. 501–509.
25.
→ TrajtenbergManuel. “A penny for your quotes: Patent citations and the value of innovations”. Rand Journal of Economics. Vol 21 (1), 1990. p. 172–187.
