How (non)discriminatory are the Institute of Group Analysis and group analysis? An institutional ethnography study

Abstract

The current political, social and economic landscape in psychotherapy is permeated by neoliberalism and requirements for diversity and equality. Nevertheless, racism occurred in the Institute of Group Analysis (IGA). Using Institutional Ethnography, this study examined whether non-discrimination of clients, students and group analysts is nowadays a lived actuality. Unfortunately, a disjuncture between claims of non-discrimination and lived experiences was identified. Unconscious prejudices, hidden discrimination and neoliberalist affiliations perpetuate white discriminatory practices. Marginalized clients, students and group analysts remain outsiders, even though the PPP Working Group has made some positive changes. I suggested that documents should be revised, contemporary theory be included in diversity seminars and diversity frameworks be researched.

Keywords

discrimination group analysis capitalism institutional ethnography IGA

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiyegbusi

(2021a) The white mirror: Face to face with racism in group analysis part 1. Mainly practice. Group Analysis 54(3). Available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0533316421992438.

Aiyegbusi

(2021b) The White Mirror: Face to Face with Racism in Group Analysis Part 2. Mainly Theory. Group Analysis 54(3). Available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0533316421992315.

Arday

(2018) Understanding Mental Health: What Are the Issues for Black and Ethnic Minority Students at University? Social Science 7: 196–223.

Azu Okeke

(1993) Conflict in the Search for an Individual Self as Opposed to a Traditional Group Self. A Consequence of Undertaking Group Analytic Training. Group Analysis 26: 261–68.

Azu Okeke

(2003) Response to Lecture by Dick Blackwell. Group Analysis 36(4): 465–76.

Bacha

Einhorn

Lieberman

(2021) ‘If you prick me, do I not bleed?’ Antisemitism, racism and group analysis—some thoughts. Group Analysis 54(3): 1–14.

Benjamin

Tucker

(2021) We’ve all got skin in the game: National Diversity Working Group: Power, Privilege and Position. Group Analysis 54(3): 1–23. Available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0533316421992315.

Bhambra

Holmwood

(2018) Colonialism, Postcolonialism and the Liberal Welfare State. New Political Economy 23(5): 574–87.

Blackwell

(1994) The Emergence of Racism in Group Analysis. Group Analysis 27(2): 197–210.

10.

Blackwell

(2002) Out of their class. Class, Colonialization and Resistance in Analytic Psychotherapy and Group Analysis. Group Analysis 35(3): 367–80.

11.

Blackwell

(2003) Colonialism and Globalisation. A Group Analytic Perspective. Group Analysis 36(4): 445–62.

12.

Blackwell

(2015) Group Analysis, Racism and Youth and Community Work Training: A Response to David Woodger’s Article. Group Analysis 48(1): 90–7.

13.

Blackwell

(2018) Cultural Transition, Negation and the Social Unconscious. Group Analysis 51(3): 304–14.

14.

Blackwell

(2020) The impenetrable wall of whiteness. A response to Guilaine Kinouani. Group Analysis 53(1): 92–101.

15.

Blackwell

(2021) A history of the struggle against racism in the social unconscious of group analysis. Group Analysis 54(3): 1–17. Available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0533316421992315.

16.

Boas

Gans-Morse (2009) Neoliberalism. From new liberal Philosophy to Anti-Liberal Slogan. St. Comp. Int. Dev 44: 137–161.

17.

Campbell

(2000) Research on Health Care Experiences of People with Disabilities. Exploring the Social Organization of Service Delivery. Research in Social Science and Disability 1: 131–154.

18.

Campbell

(2001) Textual Accounts, Ruling Action: The Intersection of Knowledge and Power in the Routine Conduct of Community Nursing Work. Studies in Cultures, Organizations and Societies 7: 231–50.

19.

Campbell

Gregor

(2002) Mapping Social Relations. A Primer in Doing Institutional Ethnography. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

20.

Collins English Dictionary (2018) 13th Edition. Glasgow: Harper Collins Publishers. Available at: https://www.collinsdictionary.com. [Accessed on 2nd July].

21.

Cudd

(2015) Is capitalism good for women? Journal of Business Ethics 127(4): 761–70.

22.

Dalal

(1993) ‘Race’ and Racism. An attempt to organize difference. Group Analysis 26: 277–93.

23.

Dalal

(2006) Racism. Processes of Detachment, Dehumanization and Hatred. The Psychoanalytic Quarterly 75(1):131–61.

24.

Dalal

(2012) Thought Paralysis. The Virtues of Discrimination. London: Karnac.

25.

Dalal

(2016) Group Analysis in the Tie of Austerity. Neoliberalism, Managerialism and Evidence-Based Research. Group Analysis 50(1): 35–54.

26.

DeVault

McCoy

(2002) Institutional Ethnography. Using Interviews to Investigate Ruling Relations. In: Gubrium Holstein (eds) Handbook of Interview Research: Context and Method. Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage, pp. 751–76.

27.

Deveau

(2008) Examining the Institutional Ethnographer’s Toolkit. Socialist 4(2):1–19.

28.

Ferron

(1991) The Black and White Group. Group Analysis 24(2): 201–10.

29.

Gonggrijp

(1993) Black and White. Median and Large Groups. Group Analysis 26(3): 63–5.

30.

Harvey

(2007) Neoliberalism as creative destruction. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 10: 22–44.

31.

Hodgetts

Radley

Chamberlain

Hodgetts

(2007) Health Inequalities and Homelessness Considering Material, Spatial and Relational Dimensions. Journal of Health Psychology 12(5): 709–25.

32.

Iacobucci

(2016) Fines for breaching NHS performance targets are counterproductive. BMJ 352: i1844.

33.

IGA (2020) National Diversity Statement. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

34.

IGA (2020–21) Diploma in Supervision. Using the group as a medium of supervision. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

35.

IGA (2020–21) Handbook for the Foundation Course. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

36.

IGA (2020–21) Handbook for Group Practice. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

37.

IGA (2020–21) Handbook for the Qualifying Course. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

38.

IGA (2021) Annual Report 2021. Available at: www.groupanalysis.org.

39.

Johnson

(2013) The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. A Framework for Ethical and Inclusive Practice? Ethics and Social Welfare 7(3): 218–31.

40.

Kent

(2020) Scapegoating and the ‘angry black woman’. Group Analysis 53(1): 1–18.

41.

Kearney

Corman

Hart

Johnston

Gormley

(2019) Why institutional ethnography? Why now? Institutional ethnography in health professions education. Medical Education 8: 17–24.

42.

Kinouani

(2019) Difference, whiteness and the group analytic matrix: An integrated formulation. Group Analysis 53(1): 60–74.

43.

Kinouani

(2020) Silencing, power and racial trauma in groups. Group Analysis 53(2): 145–61.

44.

Leong

(2013) Racial Capitalism. Harvard Law Review 126(8): 2151–226.

45.

Lyndon

(1992) The Black and White Group. A Group-analytic Contribution to Race Relations? Group Analysis 25: 117–20.

46.

Mączyńska

Pysz

(2015) Classical liberalism, neoliberalism and ordoliberalism. Journal of Social Market Economy 1(2): 17–39.

47.

Malachowski

Skorobohacz

Stasiulis

(2017) Institutional ethnography as a method of inquiry: A scoping review. Qualitative Sociology Review 13(4): 121–84.

48.

Marx

(1976) Capital. A Critique of Political Economy. Volume 1. Translated by Ben

Fowkes

. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

49.

McManus

Bebbington

Jenkins

Brugha

(eds) (2016) Mental health and wellbeing in England: Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey 2014. Leeds: NHS Digital.

50.

IGA (2020) National Diversity Statement www.groupanalysis.org. Available at: https://members.groupanalysis.org/MembersStudentsAreas/MembersArea/IGABlackLivesMatterstatement.aspx

51.

IGA (2021) Annual Report www.groupanalysis.org

52.

Nayak

(2021) Black feminist intersectionality is vital to group analysis: Can group analysis allow outsider ideas in? Group Analysis. Available at: DOI: 10.1177/0533316421997767.

53.

Office for National Statistics (2018) London: Stationary Office.

54.

Rex

(1973) Race, Colonialism and the City. London: Routledge.

55.

Scott

(2006) The Political Economy of Capitalism. Harvard Business School Working Paper. 03-037. Available at: https://www.hbs.edu/ris/Publication%20Files/07-037.pdf. [Accessed on 20th July].

56.

Smith

(1987) The Everyday World as Problematic. A Feminist Sociology. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

57.

Smith

(1990) The Conceptual Practices of Power. A Feminist Sociology of Knowledge. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

58.

Smith

(1996) The Relations of Ruling: A Feminist Inquiry. Studies in Cultural Organization and Society 2: 171–90.

59.

Smith

(1999) Writing the Social: Critique, Theory, and Investigations. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

60.

Smith

(2003) Making Sense of What People Do. A Sociological Perspective. Journal of Occupational Science 10(1): 61–4.

61.

Smith

(2005) Institutional Ethnography. A Sociology for People. Lanham, MD: Alta Mira Press.

62.

Smith

(2006) Introduction. In: Smith

(ed.) Institutional Ethnography as Practice. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 1–11.

63.

Smith

(2007) Making Change from Below. Journal of the Society for Socialist Studies 3(2): 7–30.

64.

Stevenson

(2020) Psychodynamic intersectionality and the positionality of the group analyst. The tension between analytical neutrality and intersubjectivity. Group Analysis 53(4): 498–514.

65.

The Human Rights Act ( 1998) 2021 Available at: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/42/schedule/1 [Accessed on 9th August].

66.

The Equality Act (2010) London: The Stationer Office Ltd.

67.

The Ethics Code of Professional Conduct (2014) London: Institute of Group Analysis.

68.

The UKCP Code of Ethics and Professional Practice (2019) London: UKPC. Available at: https://www.psychotherapy.org.uk/media/bkjdm33f/ukcp-code-of-ethics-and-professional-practice-2019.pdf. [Accessed on 10th July 2021].

69.

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (2006) United Nations. Available at: www.un/org/disabilities.asp?id=150. [Accessed on 10th July].

70.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948). United Nations. Available at: http://www.un.org/Overview/rights.html. [Accessed on 2nd July 2021].

71.

Travers

(1996) The Social Organization of Nutritional Inequities. Social Science and Medicine 43(4): 543–53.

72.

Voyatzaki

(2006) On the History of EGATIN. Group Analysis 39(1): 108–20.