In this paper we compare interventions of the same group analyst in two
different groups - a traditional slow-open group of six out-patients with Eating
Disorders diagnosis (all female; age: 16-26) and a time-limited, group of eight
outpatients (different in age and sex) with organic vision disturbances. Our aim
was to see if the same group therapist adopts different therapeutic
interpretative interventions in the two groups, depending on the aims of each
group and the different patients’ diagnosis. The sessions were
recorded, transcribed and coded by the Code of Analysis of the Therapeutic Field
Style (SCAT). In the traditional group, the therapist’s intervention
style is focused more on interpretative individual interventions than the
time-limited group. Similarly, the DCA patients used more interpretative
interventions in all the therapy stages. The results show that the
Organizational Area is of great importance in the conducting of both groups.
Ablon, J.S.
and
Jones, E.E.
(1998)
‘How Expert Clinicians’ Prototypes of an Ideal
Correlate with Outcome in Psychodynamic and Cognitive-Behavior Therapy’
, Psychotherapy Research8:
71-83
.
2.
American Psychiatric Association
(1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorder (4th ed.).
Washington D.C.: Author
.
3.
Beck, A.P.
and
Lewis, C.M.
(eds) (2000) The Process of Group Psychotherapy: Systems for
Analyzing Change.
Washington D.C.: American Psychological Association
.
4.
Bednar, R.L.
and
Kaul, T.J.
(1994) ‘Experiential Group Research: Can the
Canon Fire?’, in
A.E. Bergin
and
S.L. Garfield
(eds) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change (4th
ed.), pp. 631-663.
New York: Wiley
.
5.
Burlingame, G.M.
,
MacKenzie, R.K.
and
Strauss, B.
(2003) ‘Small Group Treatment: Evidence for
Effectiveness and Mechanisms of Change’, in
M. Lambert
(ed.) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change (5th
ed.).
New York: Wiley
.
6.
Crits-Christoph, P.
(1992)
‘The Efficacy of Brief Dynamic Psychotherapy: A Meta-Analysis’
, American Journal of Psychiatry149:
151-158
.
7.
Denzin, N.K.
and
Lincoln, Y.S.
(eds) (2000) Handbook of Qualitative Research (2nd
edn).
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
8.
Di Nuovo, S., Lo Verso, G., Giannone, F. and Di Blasi, M. (eds) (1998)
Valutare le Psicoterapie. La Ricerca Italiana. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Foulkes, S.H.
(1964) Therapeutic Group Analysis.
London: Allen and Unwin
. Reprinted
London: Karnac
, 1984.
11.
Fuhriman, A.
and
Burlingame, G.M.
(1994) ‘Group Psychotherapy: Research and
Practice’, in
A. Fuhriman
and
G.M. Burlingame
(eds) Handbook of Group Psychotherapy: An Empirical and Clinical
Synthesis, pp. 3-40.
New York: Wiley
.
12.
Gillespy, J.E.
,
Wright, A.R.
,
Campbell, C.
,
Stokes, S.
and
Adinoff, B.
(2002)
‘Group Alliance and Cohesion as Predictors of Drug and Alcohol
Abuse Treatment Outcomes’
, Psychotherapy Research12:
213-229
.
13.
Greenberg, L.S.
and
Pinsof, W.M.
(eds) (1986) The Psychotherapeutic Process: A Research
Handbook.
New York: Guilford Press
.
14.
Heaton, K.J.
,
Hill, C.E.
and
Edwards, L.A.
(1995)
‘Comparing Molecular and Molar Methods of Judging Therapist Techniques’
, Psychotherapy Research5:
141-153
.
15.
Hill, C.E.
(1986) ‘An Overview of the Hill Counselor and
Client Verbal Response Modes Category System’, in
L.S. Greenberg
and
W.M. Pinsof
, (eds) The Psychotherapeutic Process: A Research Handbook, pp.
131-160.
New York: Guilford Press
.
16.
Jacobson, N.S.
and
Truax, P.
(1991)
‘Clinically Significant: A Statistical Approach to Defining
Meaningful Change in Psychotherapy Research’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology59:
12-19
.
17.
Kazdin, A.E.
, (1994) ‘Methodology, Design, and Evaluation in
Psychotherapy Research’, in
A.E. Bergin
and
S.L. Garfield
(eds) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change (4th
edn), pp. 19-71.
New York: Wiley
.
18.
Kennard, D.
,
Roberts, J.
and
Winter, D.A.
(1993) A Work Book of Group-Analytic Interventions.
London: Routledge
.
19.
Lipsey, M.W.
and
Wilson, D.B.
(1993)
‘The Efficacy of Psychological, Educational, and Behavioural
Treatment: Confirmation from Meta-Analysis’
, American Psychologist48:
1181-1209
.
20.
Lo Coco, G.
,
Di Blasi, M.
and
Giannone, F.
(2001)
‘Indicatori di Cambiamento in un Gruppo di Pazienti con Disturbi
del Comportamento Alimentare’
, Ricerca in Psicoterapia4:
49-65
.
21.
Lorentzen, S.
(2000)
‘Assessment of Change after Long-Term Psychoanalytic Group Treatment’
, Group-Analysis33(3):
373-396
.
22.
Luborsky, L.
and
Barber, J.P.
(1993) ‘Benefits of Adherence to Psychotherapy
Manuals, and Where to get Them’, in
N.E. Miller
,
L. Luborsky
,
J.P. Barber
and
J.P. Docherty
(eds) Psychodynamic Treatment Research, pp.
211-226.
New York: Basic Books
.
23.
Luborsky, L.
,
Singer, B.
and
Luborsky, L.
(1975)
‘Comparative Studies of Psychotherapies’
, Archives of General Psychiatry32:
995-1008
.
24.
MacKenzie, R.
(1997) Introduction to Time Limited Group
Psychotherapy.
Washington D.C.: American Psychiatric Press
.
25.
McNeilly, C.L.
and
Howard, K.I.
(1991)
‘The Therapeutic Procedures Inventory: Psychometric Properties
and Relationship to Phase of Treatment’
, Journal of Psychotherapy Integration1:
223-234
.
26.
McRoberts, C.
,
Burlingame, G.M.
and
Matthew, J.H.
(1998)
‘Comparative Efficacy of Individual and Group Psychotherapy: A
Meta-Analytic Perspective’
, Group Dynamics: Theory, Research and Practice2:
101-117
.
27.
Orlinsky, D.E.
,
Grawe, K.
and
Parks, B.K.
(1994) ‘Process and Outcome in
Psychotherapy’, in
A.E. Bergin
and
S.L. Garfield
(eds) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change (4th
edn), pp. 270-376.
New York: Wiley
.
28.
Piper, W.E.
and
Joyce, A.S.
(1996)
‘A Consideration of Factors Influencing the Utilization of
Time-Limited, Short-Term Group’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy46(3):
311-328
.
29.
Pontalti, C. and Pontalti, I. (1998) ‘Lo Studio del Processo in
Psicoterapia: Un’ Analisi dei Setting Multipersonali. Il Codice delle
Emozioni Espresse e il Codice degli Interventi del Terapeuta’, in S. Di
Nuovo, G. Lo Verso, F. Giannone and M. Di Blasi (eds) Valutare le Psicoterapie.
La Ricerca Italiana, pp. 191-7. Milano: Franco Angeli.
30.
Pontalti, I.
,
Azzara, C.
and
Cappello, S.
(1997b)
‘An Experimental Research in Family Group Analytic Psychotherapy’
, New Trends in Experimental and Clinical Psychiatry13(4):
217-220
.
31.
Pontalti, I.
,
Pontalti, C.
,
Annunziata, M.
,
Azzara, C.
,
Calindro, R.
,
Cannarsa, F.
,
Cappello, S.
,
Fiore, D.
,
Lo vallo, M.T.
,
Milasi, R.
,
Pacelli, M.
,
Porcari, F.
and
Ruggiero, F.S.
(1997a) ‘SCAT Manual for Rating Group-Analytic
Process’. Unpublished manuscript.
Catholic University of Rome, Italy
.
32.
Roth, A.
and
Fonagy, P.
(eds) (1996) What Works for Whom? A Critical Review of
Psychotherapy Research.
New York: Guilford Press
.
33.
Sandahl, C.
,
Lindgren, A.
and
Herlitz, K.
(2000)
‘Does the Group Conductor Make a Difference? Citation Patterns in
Group-Analytically and Cognitive Behaviourally-Oriented Therapy Groups’
, Group Analysis33(3):
333-351
.
34.
Stiles, W.B.
(1992) Describing Talk: A Taxonomy of Verbal Response
Modes.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
35.
Svartberg, M.
and
Stiles, T.C.
(1994)
‘Therapeutic Alliance, Therapist Competence and Client Change in
Short-Term Anxiety-Provoking Psychotherapy’
, Psychotherapy Research4:
20-33
.
36.
Trijsburg, R.W.
,
Frederiks, G.C.F.J.
,
Gorlee, M.
,
Klouwer, E.
,
Den Hollander, A.M.
and
Duivenvoorden, H.J.
(2002)
‘Development of the Comprehensive Psychotherapeutic Interventions
Rating Scale (CPIRS)’
, Psychotherapy Research12:
287-317
.
37.
Waltz, J.
,
Addis, M.E.
,
Koerner, K.
and
Jacobson, N.S.
(1993)
‘Testing the Integrity of a Psychotherapy Protocol: Assessment of
Adherence and Competence’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology61:
620-630
.
38.
Wiser, S.
and
Goldfried, M.R.
(1998)
‘Therapist Interventions and Client Emotional Experiencing in
Expert Psychodynamic-Interpersonal and Cognitive-Behavioral Therapies’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology66:
634-640
.
39.
Yalom, I.D.
(1995) The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy
(4th edn).
New York: Basic Books
.
