In the measurement of occupational segregation by race and gender, pairwise comparisons of employment distributions, based on the Index of Dissimilarity, are unsatisfactory. A multidimensional approach, based on Silber (1992), is adopted to analyze trends in segregation across six race/gender groups and four groups of occupations over the period 1983-92. Black males and females have integrated fastest, whereas Hispanics integrated slowest. White-collar occupations exhibited a modest pro-cyclical rate of integration, but blue-collar occupations exhibited little change. The empirical results are linked to the recent radical literature that explores the relationship between job exclusion, racial discrimination and wage differentials (Mason 1993 and Williams 1991).
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albelda, R.P.1986. Occupational Segregation by Race and Gender. Industrial and Labor Relations Review39(3): 404-411.
2.
Beller, A.H.1985. Changes in the Sex Composition of U.S. Occupations 1960-81. Journal of Human Resources20(2): 235-250.
3.
Blackburn, R.M.
, J. Jarman and J. Siltanen. 1993. The Analysis of Occupational Gender Segregation over Time and Place: Considerations of Martin J. Watts Measurement and Some New Evidence. Work, Employment and Society7(3): 335-362.
4.
Blackburn, R.M.
, J. Jarman and J. Siltanen. 1994Unhelpful Directions in the Analysis of Occupational Gender Segregation: A Reply to Watts. Work, Employment and Society8(3): 433-438.
5.
Charles, M.1992. Cross National Variation in Occupational Sex Segregation. American Sociological Review57: 482-503.
6.
Cherry, R.
and P. Mobilia. 1993. Trends in Various Dissimilarity Indexes. Review of Radical Political Economics25(3): 93-103.
7.
Cortese C.F.
, R.F. Frank and J. Cohen. 1976. Further Considerations on the Methodological Analysis of Segregation Indices. American Sociological Review41: 630-637.
8.
Deming, W.E.
and F.F. Stephan. 1940. On a Least Squares Adjustment of Sampled Frequency Table when the Expected Marginal Totals are Known. Annals of Mathematical Statistics11: 427-444.
9.
Duncan, O.D.
and B. Duncan. 1955. A Methodological Analysis of Segregation Indexes. American Sociological Review20: 210-217.
10.
Figart, D.M.
and E. Mutari. 1993. Gender Segmentation of Craft Workers by Race in the 1970's and 1980's. Review of Radical Political Economics25(2): 50-66.
11.
Fossett, M.A.
, O.G. Galle and W.R. Kelly. 1986. Racial Occupational Inequality, 1940-80: National and Regional Trends. American Sociological Review51: 421-429.
12.
Hakim, C.1992. Explaining Trends in Occupational Segregation: The Measurement, Causes, and Consequences of the Sexual Division of Labour. European Sociological Review8(2): 127-152.
13.
Hakim, C.1993a. Segregated and Integrated Occupations: A New Approach to Analysing Social Change. European Sociological Review9(3): 289-313.
14.
Hakim, C.1993b. Refocusing Research on Occupational Segregation: Reply to Watts. European Sociological Review9(3): 321-324.
15.
Jacobs, J.A.1989. Long Term Trends in Occupational Segregation by Sex. American Journal of Sociology95(1): 160-173.
16.
Jacobs, J.A.1993. Theoretical and Measurement Issues in the Study of Sex Segregation in the Workplace: Research Note. European Sociological Review9(3): 325-330.
17.
Jones, F.L.1992. Segregation Indices: an Historical and Conceptual Note. Australian and New Zealand. Journal of Sociology28(1): 105-110.
18.
Karmel, T.
and M. Maclachlan. 1988. Occupational Sex Segregation - Increasing or Decreasing. Economic Record64: 187-195.
19.
King, M.C.1992. Occupational Segregation by Race and Sex: 1940-88. Monthly Labor Review30-37.
20.
Mason, P.L.1993. Accumulation, Segmentation and the Discriminatory Process in the Market for Labor Power. Review of Radical Political Economy25(2): 1-25.
21.
Mason, P.L.1994. Race, Competition and Differential Wages. Forthcoming in the Cambridge Journal of Economics.
22.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
. 1985. The Integration of Women into the Economy. Paris: OECD
23.
Power, M.
and S. Rosenberg. 1993. Black Female Clerical Workers: Movement towards Equality with White Women?Industrial Relations32(2): 223-237.
24.
Reskin, B.F.
and C.E. Roos. 1992. Jobs, Authority and Earnings among Managers. Work and Occupations19(4): 342-365.
25.
Rubery, J.
(ed.) 1988. Women and Recession. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
26.
Shulman, S.1984. The Measurement and Interpretation of Black Wage and Occupational Gains: A Re-evaluation. Review of Black Political Economy12(1): 59-69.
27.
Shulman, S.1990. Racial Inequality and White Employment: An Interpretation and Test of the Bargaining Power Hypothesis. Review of Black Political Economy18(3): 5-20.
28.
Silber, J.1992. Occupational Segregation Indices in the Multidimensional Case: A Note. Economic Record68: 276-277.
29.
Spriggs, W.E.
and R.M. Williams. 1994. A Logit Decomposition Analysis of Occupational Segregation: Results from the 1970's and 1980's. Forthcoming Review of Economics and Statistics.
30.
U.S. Department of Labor
. Unpublished Employment Data by Gender and Race. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Washington, D.C.: GPO.
31.
Van Wagner, M.J.1993. Are Men's Jobs becoming Women's Jobs? Substitution and Segmentation in the U.S. Labor Force. Review of Radical Political Economics25(3): 75-84.
32.
Walby, S.1986. Patriarchy at Work: Patriarchal and Capitalist Relations in Employment. Cambridge: Polity Press.
33.
Watts, M.J.1992. How Should Occupational Sex Segregation be Measured?Work, Employment and Society6(3): 475-487.
34.
Watts, M.J.1993a. Some Notes on the Construction and Decomposition of (Multi-Dimensional) Segregation Indexes. Mimeo, Department of Economics, Newcastle University.
35.
Watts, M.J.1993b. Explaining Trends in Occupational Segregation: Some Comments. European Sociological Review9(3): 315-319.
36.
Watts, M.J.1994a. A Critique of Marginal Matching. Work, Employment and Society8(3): 421-431.
37.
Watts, M.J.1995a. Divergent Patterns of Gender Segregation by Occupation in the USA: 1970-92. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics17(3): 357-379.
38.
Watts, M.J.1995b. Female Employment Growth in Britain, 1979-92: Some Competing Hypotheses. Review of Political Economy7(3): 338-357.
39.
Watts, M.J.
and J. Rich. 1992. Labour Market Segmentation and the Persistence of Occupational Sex Segregation in Australia. Australian Economic Papers31(58): 58-76.
40.
Watts, M.J.
and J. Rich. 1993. Occupational Sex Segregation in Britain, 1979-89: The Persistence of Sexual Stereotyping. Cambridge Journal of Economics17(2): 159-177.
41.
Williams, R.1991. Competition, Discrimination and Differential Wage Rates: On the Continued Relevance of Marxian Theory to the Analysis of Earnings and Employment Inequality. In, New Approaches to the Economic and Social Analysis of Discrimination, R. Cornwall and P. Wunnava (eds.). New York: Praeger.
